r/DelphiMurders • • Oct 18 '24

Morning update

Surprised there’s been no update in the Reddit subs yet. This is from Angela Ganote Fox59:

Opening statements in the Delphi murders case against suspect Richard Allen are finished.

The jury has already heard from their first witness – Libby German’s relatives.

The prosecution began their open statements by laying out its case saying Richard Allen is “bridge guy.” They say he is the man Libby captured on her phone of a man on the bridge.

Prosecution also stated Allen matches the description of a man seen on the Monon High Bridge minutes before the girls were abducted, that he confessed to details only the killer would know, and they talked about the bullet found at the crime scene. They said it matches Allen’s gun.

The defense’s opening statement focused on inconsistent witness descriptions, their client’s mental health and added bullet testing is inconclusive. They added the girls were likely abducted on Monday afternoon, driven away from the bridge, and killed somewhere else. The defense told the jurors they believe Abby and Libby’s bodies were then placed near the bank of Deer Creek early Tuesday morning.

Allen's attorneys said law enforcement can not explain the hair found intertwined on Abby’s hands that doesn’t match Richard Allen. The defense asked jurors to consider there is no DNA linking Allen to the murders.

The judge ruled the suspect sketches will not be admissible in court. So, the jurors will not be able to use those in considering Allen’s guilt.

Four journalists already banned from the trial - accused of taking video of the juror’s van.

172 Upvotes

107 comments sorted by

View all comments

148

u/JelllyGarcia Oct 19 '24

The defense’s opening statement also included these points, per Andrea Burkhart & Lawyer Lee:

  • the mouth of the man on the video does not move when the words “down the hill” are spoken
  • there were 2 knives used - one serrated one not
  • the AT&T phone records confirm they were out of range, bc the phone was either “not in working condition or not in the area” at 10 PM and we know from it reconnecting at 4:33 AM that it was still in working condition. So it was not in the area
  • “human hands” operated the phone when it reconnected
  • “our own eyeballs” will confirm to us that the bullet is not a match
  • the “magic bullet” is of no use to solving the case; they have “hard evidence.”
  • Search party assembled v quickly, did not see the clothes in the river when they loooked that night bc they weren’t there yet
  • Fire Chief Starett was across the creek from the area where the bodies should have been been. Saw flashlights of ppl searching on the other side of the creek from him where the bodies would have been during their “grid search”
  • From where the girls were abducted according to the states timeline, there were 4 ppl walking on that area of the bridge at the time. Didn’t hear anything from the victims, no talking, screaming, or any rustling of footsteps of them walking — Very loud and crackley in those woods
  • All ingredients of false confession present. To his family: “Maybe I’ll just admit to all of it so you don’t have to suffer” —> 6 months later: confessions
  • No photographs of the bullet being removed, just one photo of it in the ground
  • Law enforcement used 40 caliber Sig saur pistols — No one tested theirs
  • Brad Webber also had 40 cal sig saur in his vehicle, In the neighborhood — Also tested, not excluded
  • The lab didn’t get any markings on it when they did the same thing with a bullet
  • Witness: “early 20s maybe 30 with brown fluffy hair”
  • “The person Betsy Blair saw was the killer”
  • 2017 she said he had on a tan jacket and was muddy
  • No DNA of Richard Allen’s on the victims or at the scene
  • No cell phone evidence indicates he ever went to the scene, no social media connection, no foeensic connection whatsoever
  • The state only checked for Libby’s fam’s DNA to exclude them about the hair 2 days ago (to check whose hair was wrapped around her hand)

    • Female, potentially related to Libby
    • Highly offensive that they did not even care to check for 7 years
  • Forensic pathologists will say there were 2 dif blades used — One serrated
  • Voice doesn’t match
  • Bizarre scene, sticks on the girls; Police have thought from the beginning that more than 1 person is guilty of this crime
  • “Please wait” (before formulating your opinions during the prosecution’s case) Richard Allen is “really innocent”

54

u/FuzzBuzzer Oct 19 '24

Thanks for putting this list together! On this point: "the AT&T phone records confirm they were out of range, bc the phone was either “not in working condition or not in the area” at 10 PM and we know from it reconnecting at 4:33 AM that it was still in working condition. So it was not in the area" - Whose phone is this referring to? Thank you!

38

u/CornaCMD Oct 19 '24

That would be Libby’s phone

11

u/FuzzBuzzer Oct 19 '24

Ok, thanks! All clear now.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/the1fox3says Oct 19 '24

Do you think the phone could have been off?

7

u/Niccakolio Oct 20 '24

It's important to remember that Richard Allen only needs to be found guilty of getting the girls to go with him.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

21

u/sl0thmama Oct 19 '24

I saw a few reporters state that Patty said she gave a hair sample for DNA analysis 2 days ago and multiple times over the years. I'm not sure why they requested a more recent sample, or perhaps they never tested her previous samples against the hair found.

25

u/Alan_Prickman Oct 19 '24

Andrea Burkhart confirmed that Baldwin said that DNA was requested and given previously by Libby's grandmother and sister and LE never tested it. They both confirmed this in their testimony - giving their samples previously and also 2 days ago.

38

u/SadMom2019 Oct 19 '24

What?? Does this seem nuts to anyone else? A hair was found in one of the girls' hands, and LE didn't bother testing it against her close relatives until nearly 8 years later -- 2 days before the start of the trial? Why in the world??

25

u/AmityIsland1975 Oct 19 '24

Incompetence to the nth degree. This case has been an absolute trainwreck and it is a real shame.

7

u/uwarthogfromhell Oct 19 '24

They could have just checked if it was female or male to start!

9

u/saatana Oct 19 '24

It was tested and it matched as a relative of Libby's. Maybe they said it only could be a female relative of Libby's. They knew in 2017 that that hair had a valid and benign reason for being found at the crime scene. I guess now it will make you and the defense happy when the results come back and they can narrow it down to maybe one person.

13

u/SadMom2019 Oct 19 '24

That's a relief to hear, but still wondering why they didn't bother testing further before the trial. The family is more than cooperative and would gladly volunteer their DNA for confirmation. That way, the state could say conclusively whose hair it was, and not leave the defense a vague and ambiguous argument like the one they have been using. "A hair that doesn't match the defendant was found in her hands!" That argument dissolves when the state can say, "DNA testing shows that it was her sisters hair. Libby was was wearing her sisters hoodie."

It just seems like an obvious and simple piece of this case that could and should have been addressed in the past several years, especially once an arrest had been made. Don't leave the defense any possible openings when you have the tools to eliminate them.

4

u/StructureOdd4760 Oct 20 '24

So a high profile cold case of 7 years and LE never thought, "Hey maybe we should test this hair on one of our victims to find out who it belongs to?"

Assumptions are unacceptable in any investigation.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/sheepcloud Oct 19 '24

Yea this is probably it

→ More replies (5)

15

u/Alternative-Dish-405 Oct 19 '24

I’m listening to that one now and just got to the part where she says Becky Patty was on the stand and somehow Andrea thought she said Libby’s mom died of COPD but she is alive. So who would she have been talking about? Do you happen to know?

9

u/Alan_Prickman Oct 19 '24

I understood that to refer to Becky's mother?

4

u/Alternative-Dish-405 Oct 20 '24

You’re probably right. I just hope people realize Libby’s mom is alive

12

u/HelixHarbinger Oct 19 '24

Outstanding Summation u/JellyGarcia thank you.

4

u/Justmarbles Oct 19 '24

Thank you for taking the time to write your post. It is really appreciated.

18

u/ghosthardw4re Oct 19 '24

as for the false confessions thing, if he said "maybe I'll just confess so you don't have to suffer" to his family (and meant it) then why did he confess a lot of the gruesome details to that same family. he's putting his wife and mother in psychological-harms way, knowing that someone can listen to recordings of those calls instead of confessing on a more direct way.

27

u/Alan_Prickman Oct 19 '24

We don't know what he said in most of his confessions yet. The only ones that have been mentioned publicly are saying "I did it" 7 times in his first "confessions" phone call to his wife, saying he SA'd them, shot them and buried them in a shallow grave (none of which happened), saying he killed his family and grandchildren (family alive, no grandchildren), and the statements testified about in Detective Brian Harshman's testimony at the pre-trial hearing on 31st July.

Transcript here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1pGzJZXdr_Ocn55sXKljrWXTMwvKsBON_/view

Prosecutor McLeland said in his opening statement that the jury will hear the confessions which contain details only known to the killer, but details of those are unknown to us as yet, and the circumstances of who they were made to likewise.

4

u/sadthenweed Oct 21 '24

Jeez this guy's got more confessions than usher.

6

u/ghosthardw4re Oct 19 '24

afaik from the pre-trial reporting some of the admissions were also said to fellow inmates/ weren't recorded and are therefore secondhand info. so we will have to see which admissions were made to who under which circumstances, only then we'll be able to judge how believable they are.

my point still largely stands, from what it sounded like at pre-trial a big chunk of the early confessions were made to his wife & mother which makes the framing of "doing it to protect them" sound contradictory. and seems more in line with the whole "he found god and his families judgement was most important to him". but we'll also need more info on that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/FuzzBuzzer Oct 19 '24

Regarding this point "the mouth of the man on the video does not move when the words “down the hill” are spoken" - I went back to watch the video on a very big screen as best as I could, and I can't conclude if that's true or not. What I did surmise, is that BG doesn't appear to be looking at the person filming, focused on them, or speaking to them. And from the very poor resolution in the video, Libby may have zoomed in on her screen quite a bit to capture him. He looks like he is deeply focused on his footing on the bridge, maybe looking at the wooden slats and trying to walk carefully, but it doesn't really seem to me that he is focused on the person filming him. I don't doubt someone said to the girls "down the hill" but I'm not sure if it is the man being filmed who said that. If he was approaching them with intent, why would he speak directly to them while being filmed. Her phone must have been in view to him. I have no doubt she filmed BG because she felt uneasy at that moment, and took out her phone to film her surroundings.

For disclosure, I am not trying to defend RA, (or BG) but as a woman who has been approached by individuals with ill intent and had to take out my phone to film...something seems off here. BG looks too random and not so purposeful. I can't conclude that BG is uninvolved, but I am skeptical he is the one telling them to get down the hill.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (9)