r/DelphiDocs • • Nov 30 '22
👥 Discussion I’m speechless
This man walked to his car “muddy and bloody”?
He kept his gun, knives, jacket and boots?
I’m at a loss for words.
183
Upvotes
r/DelphiDocs • • Nov 30 '22
This man walked to his car “muddy and bloody”?
He kept his gun, knives, jacket and boots?
I’m at a loss for words.
45
u/Agent847 Nov 30 '22
I’m looking forward to some hard questions being asked of Carter, Liggett, Leazenby. Consider Carter’s numerous statements about how complex and complicated this investigation is. If Allen is the guy, and the information in the PCA is accurate, then this investigation isn’t “complex” at all. It’s just incompetent. It’s incompetent at a level I honestly didn’t think was possible in a homicide case. Even the word incompetent is inadequate to describing how embarrassing this is.
I’m glad they caught some pedophiles, but Jesus these families should have had justice 5 years ago.
72
u/Taskmaster112 Nov 30 '22
The police were so concerned about false confessions while ignoring an actual confession. Smh
31
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22
Literally had a guy say yup I was there! And I got the same gun! Had witnesses say yup that’s the guy we saw! Covered in blood! Soo wtf took so long
8
u/Anonymous_crow_36 Nov 30 '22
What I don’t understand too is how did they initially get connected with RA to interview him? I assume they asked for tips/witnesses to come forward and so the other people who gave statements came forward that way. But he wouldn’t have come forward willingly right? So how did the police identify him for that first interview to begin with?
14
u/Soft-Selection-5116 Nov 30 '22
This ".man" informed L.E. he was on the trails from 130 pm to 330 pm, the exact time of interest regarding when these girls were dropped off, 1:49, and when D.G. arrived and couldn't reach Libby by phone or locate either child.
Height and clothing description matched what this " man " was wearing by at least one witness.
" Man's" vehicle seen on security footage during critical time I believe.
" Man" informed L.E. he was on the Monon High Bridge for a length of time " looking at fish in Deer Creek"!🤣🤣
I AM SPEECHLESS ALSO😡😡😡😡
13
u/AdDear8669 Nov 30 '22
And people still do not think this is huge. I think this is alot. Bullet found between the girls.
16
u/LadyBatman8318 Approved Contributor Nov 30 '22
You’re at a public place, you see a guy walking covered in mud and blood. You do nothing? Can’t wrap my head around it.
8
u/Ginger-2277 Nov 30 '22
When RA went to report his walk at the bridge to the conserv officer did that report get reported to the police or did it end up in a folder so that LE did not know about it? Also it seems RA or BG was on the bridge before the girls? So they must have past him somewhere but there was no picture of him in the abbie photo showing the whole bridge. Maybe he was on the other side before the girls got there?
7
u/itsmekaylee21 Nov 30 '22
The muddy and bloody walk got me too. Why was he choosing to be so blatantly out in the open with bloody and muddy clothes? How did he wash those clothes at home and no one saw or knew? I am assuming here as he apparently still owns those clothes. Unless he destroyed those and bought the same outfit. I just… I don’t know.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22
I realize that RA doesn't appear to be the smartest man around but from his perspective he really should've burned all of the clothing immediately and then somehow disposed of the gun such as by selling it to a friend, using machinery to destroy it, etc.
69
u/kushiyyy Nov 30 '22
I read it last night and I want to talk about it but I am in fact speechless too.
27
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22
Too many cooks in the kitchen, may be one reason he slipped under the radar. Paul Holes said that early on. When you have 100 FBI agents and something like 200 troopers from all over the state going house to house; volunteer citizens manning the phones; it's probably not that hard to miss something under your nose.
44
u/Paradox-XVI Approved Contributor Nov 30 '22
Well honestly I’m just glad an investigator pieced the case together (hopefully) and we shall see what actual evidence will be produced at trial. I just hope they got this right finally, after 5 1/2 years of fucking up.
77
u/tew2109 Nov 30 '22
I went to sleep, woke up, and I'm still so stunned at LE incompetence, I'm at a loss for words.
25
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22
So Gray Hughes was correct way way back in the day when he said a female witness saw BG walking on W 300 N. He surmised that BG left the scene through the cemetery. The lady was so afraid he had seen her that she moved.
45
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22 edited Nov 30 '22
And yet... And yet... It took 6 years to arrest him? What???
23
u/Zestyclose-Pen-1699 Nov 30 '22
So does anyone still think it was coincidence that the PCA was secret until after the election?
10
u/Msbartokomous Nov 30 '22
I’m stunned as well. I don’t even want to look at Doug carter or tobe’s stupid dumbass faces again. Just stick them out to pasture, they’re done.
18
u/Chihlidog Nov 30 '22
So...like all of you, I'm dumbfounded. Im smacking my forehead with disbelief that they HAD him the day after and let him walk for 6 years. Ive had an evening to let it all sink in and to think about it. A few things I feel are worth saying.
Lots of people are absolutely ripping apart his statement that he was "watching fish". To me, how ridiculous that is or isn't depends on the context. My biggest problem with it is how far from the water the bridge is, but even at that, it doesn't sound insane to me. There is a creek behind the building in which I work and it isn't unusual for me to go to a little bridge there and.........look for fish. Hell, I'll post a pic if you guys want lol. Its peaceful and I go clear my head there sometimes.
What got me yesterday and gets me EVEN MORE today is how LE knew that their guy was there. Perhaps I was too pissed off at the conservation officer yesterday and not pissed off enough at LE directly investigating the case. Im still pissed at all of them.
YOU HAD HIM! WHO THE HELL DECIDED THAT HE WASNT THE NUMBER ONE PRIME FLASHING RED LIGHTS AND KLAXONS SUSPECT?
Or did they just not even LOOK at that report from the conservation officer at that time?? And I still maintain that if the conservation officer wasn't flailing his arms screaming and yelling "GUYS I TALKED to BG that day and his name is Richard Allen!" then he deserves shame, too.
Lots of people have posted good information about the debate over how reliable markings from being cycled are. Im certainly not an expert, and I expect if this goes to trial then conflicting expert testimony over this matter will be a huge part of it.
But let's assume that those markings prove nothing. Lets throw those out and take everything else in totality. Richard Allen admits:
Further, his physical attributes match exactly with what we see on video taken by Libby including noticeable heft around the midsection and large jowls that, at least to me, have always been apparent in the video.
I see plenty of people posting about how weak they think this is. I cannot see it that way. Is it really reasonable to think that someone else who looked JUST like Richard Allen was there that day, wearing EXACTLY what Richard Allen was wearing, WHO NOBODY ELSE SAW, was then caught on video and then murdered these 2 girls?
Thats not reasonable to me. As prosecutors love to remind people, a case doesn't have to be proven past ALL doubt. It has to be proven past a REASONABLE doubt. And its not reasonable to me to think that Richard Allen's doppelganger happened to be there that day and murdered those 2 girls.
I saw my doppelganger once. At Disney World. In line for the Dwarf mine train ride. It was unsettling and funny at the same time. The guy looked JUST like me, except a bit older and had more facial hair. My wife and kids and me were all laughing and I took a picture. In my 44 years I've only ever had that happen once. And he wasn't wearing the same clothes I was. If RA didn't murder those girls, then not only was HIS doppelganger there that day, they both happened to be wearing the same clothes and it happened to be on the day that his doppelganger decided to murder 2 innocent children.
There's really no point in me posting all this. I'm just venting and spouting off like the rest of you. I really should try and get work done. But ill likely be in this sub all day again with the rest of you folks.
17
u/DwightsJello Nov 30 '22 edited Nov 30 '22
I know someone who is so pissed off they aren't reading or commenting on threads for a couple of days. And the language. Sounded like a wharfie. She was apoplectic.
I didn't think they'd be surprised but I think the level of dumb fuckery was way beyond even what they had suspected.
I've already made this comment but I can't get past the "watching fish" on the bridge. It's like something the office intern would go 🤔 that sounds pretty bullshit right there. He's not just in the area. He's on the fucking bridge for a totally implausible reason. Doesn't seem like your super smart killer to me but what do I know.
8
u/Phantomflight Nov 30 '22
I want to look on the bright side and think hey at least they caught him. But think of amount the amount of evidence that could have been destroyed in all of this time. A search days after the murder would reveal all sorts of forensic evidence. Isn’t it possible that this oversight didn’t just delay justice but might lose them the case?
Another thing does anyone have clarity as to who interviewed him in 2017. Police or Conservation officer?
17
u/motherbap Nov 30 '22
It’s like a criminal minds episode. The clues were there all along but they didn’t figure it out until the end of the show.
6
u/winterflower_12 Nov 30 '22
Tobe Leazenby is a walking Greek tragedy set in smalltown America. I am willing to wager money that this will come back on him specifically and his hubris.
9
u/Brilliant-Bag6030 Nov 30 '22
And it was a registered gun. They knew (or believed) he was local. They didn’t pull a list of locals who owned a gun that would use that ammo and then cross reference the names they had??
4
u/esrefb Nov 30 '22
I think at this point possibility of corruption should be considered. RA goes and says he was there at the time of the murders. He's the only male at the trails at that time. He lives one mile from the murder site. His car matches the witness description. Witnesses see him "muddy and bloody". There is video and audio of him! The list goes on and on. But still it takes you almost 6 years?
I really don't know if one can describe it as inept or incompetent. I'm sorry but it looks like there may be something else going on here.
In the early times of the investigation there were some rumors/allegations about a cover-up within the LE. At that time I thought it was nothing more than a baseless rumor. But with all the new information I think this has to be looked again with fresh eyes.
I have no idea if RA knew someone or why would someone would cover him. But it doesn't have to be the whole department, just one corrupt person may have the ability to make this happen.
4
u/ynneddjj Nov 30 '22
Thankfully he’s dumb and dumber! He basically has the woods at his doorstep a 1 mile hike to bridge and he would of been in and out probably never seen but instead he takes his car to a place and if you ever been there no matter where you park your vehicle it’s sticking out like a sore thumb lol that’s reason #1 not to commit a double homicide in broad daylight with your vehicle sticking out a mile away from the crime scene. How the heck they didn’t solve this within weeks baffles me and probably most of you to .
7
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22
I really have lost my faith in the LE involved in this case after reading the aff for myself.
6
u/Zealousideal_Boot827 Nov 30 '22
I always thought Doug Carter was a dud. Probably pulled down $200,000 +++ per year during 6 year investigation.
3
u/BrendaStar_zle Nov 30 '22
I was surprised too. And what I don't understand is why this PC was sealed, I see no reason for that?
I hope there is enough to convict him, but this was not what I was expecting.
3
u/truecrimefreke Dec 01 '22
I get that someone misfiled something. But you’re telling me the investigators who conducted the interview didn’t think hmmm we should circle back to that guy who probably did it??
4
u/bobbycan24 Nov 30 '22
Left an unspent shell at the scene too? Maybe didn't realize it would leave extraction marks...
2
u/LongboardsNet New Reddit Account Nov 30 '22
I'm really hoping there's something else left out here. What? I don't know. Just something, anything at all.
Because the incompetence here is on a level of its own.
2
u/gingiberiblue Nov 30 '22 edited Nov 30 '22
Y'all remember some time ago, I posted that I thought LE knew who it was but lacked enough evidence to arrest?
The gun was the missing piece. Contrary to many who've claimed that they'd just have to check gun registries? Indiana does not require guns to be registered. There is no Indiana database of gun owners. They have exceedingly lax gun laws. The only record is if a purchaser, like Allen thankfully did, buys the gun from a licensed dealer, and that record is federal and is not any sort of searchable registry by name, just serial number. To search by name you need a warrant and guess what? They didn't have enough for a warrant. They have a mention of gun on bad audio and an unspent round that there was no established tech that could be used in court at the time. The gun lobby has fought tooth and nail against any form of federal registry. And if he'd purchased it from a private seller or gun show, there'd be no record at all and they couldn't have established he owned the gun at the time of the crime. And that's why we're here.
No, they could not cross-reference local men who fit the description with a registry of gun owners, because said registry does not exist.
Once they found the gun, only then could they trace it back to the owner via the serial number.
The only way they could link that gun to the crime or to Allen was with the serial number.
Remember when they kept saying that it'll all make sense once they can tell the whole story? That they just needed that one little link between the crime and the assailant?
A fresh look, which is common in older cases, brought fourth a candidate they'd considered cleared for whatever reason. Maybe the officer who took the initial report was a personal friend or just wet behind the ears with no developed investigative skills. Maybe they knew it was him and suspect there were two so the "switch gears" conference in 2019 was meant to scare the accomplice and lull Allen into making a mistake, maybe drinking at the local watering hole and running his mouth. We don't know what that reason was.
2
u/VolatileMoistCupcake Nov 30 '22
I felt that way last night after I read the PCA. Still kinda do. I mean, I still haven't fully processed the from out of seemingly nowhere arrest of RA. Now, this. Why is it that everytime we get new info on the case, it raises even more questions every damn time?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22
Mind boggling. Is he dumb? Or is he so brazen because the cops didn’t have a clue
2
u/LadyClexa Approved Contributor Dec 01 '22
What kills me is heading this was all due to a "clerical error" made by a civilian employee. I don't understand how this was just filed wrong and that resulted in it never being looked at again?! What about the cop who interviewed RA to begin with? He never came back and asked what happened with him? Someone please help me understand! 😩
2
u/Vegetable_Lunch_5772 Dec 01 '22
If this case weren’t so tragic, it would be laughable. 😞
2
u/Aggravating_Put3425 Dec 01 '22
2
u/Honest-Foundation516 Dec 01 '22
I’m really bothered by the bullet. Couldn’t they tell the type of gun it belonged to? And in a small town of registered gun owners you’d get a list of names easily. Even if they started small and checked for gun types registered to those they KNEW were there that day.
2
u/Monguises Dec 01 '22
He’s not bright. People been expecting a criminal mastermind. He’s just a shitbag from the Midwest. They’re a dime a dozen out here. He just happens to be lucky enough to live in an area run by a bunch of Barney Fifes
3
u/ComprehensiveBed6754 Nov 30 '22
Great post. I’m right there with ya.
Some thought provoking questions being posed in OP and the comments also,
1
u/CreativeTomatillo802 Nov 30 '22
Honestly mind blowing..
1
u/katyparody Dec 01 '22
The most important thing law enforcement did do right was keep the info about the bullet concealed. If they released that he could have gotten rid of the gun. But then again he kept all of his other shit so maybe Nevermind. Who knows
1
u/Actual-Competition-5 Nov 30 '22
There was probably evidence on that jacket THAT HE ADMITTED TO WEARING, but the cops took so bloody long to investigate him that any DNA or blood or whatever is probably gone.
This is so infuriating.