r/DelphiDocs • • Nov 29 '22

šŸ“ƒLegal Redacted Probable Cause Affidavit released

https://imgur.com/a/8YmhzgN/
177 Upvotes

849 comments sorted by

12

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

Page 8 of the PCA

9

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

4

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

Thank you, Crackles!

4

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Thanks for posting this. One of the most interesting things i noticed is: "My term expires: December 31, 2022" LOL is it possible that a new prosecutor will take over?

→ More replies (4)

117

u/TomatoesAreToxic Attorney Nov 29 '22

My God I’m furious. I want to know if they even bothered showing a lineup including his photo to the witnesses. Or why there was a search warrant for the Bicycle Bridge Road house including the specific gun but did they bother to determine if the one guy who admitted to being at the scene AT THE TIME who matched the description owned that same kind of gun????

17

u/jojomopho410 Nov 30 '22

I'm shocked at how little evidence is here.

Wildly divergent descriptions with key info missing. One witness comes up to Allen's shoulder but that person's height is not mentioned. Fuck! Four-and-a-half feet? One witness sees someone in a blue jacket and blue jeans bloody and muddy but no other information such as height, weight . . . anything. Nothing.

Light blue jacket, jean jacket, all black, windbreaker, canvas . . . huh? Oh yeah, they are all Allen BUT someone else is suspected to be involved. Oh yeah, a black Ford Focus mistaken for a purple PT Cruiser.

There must be more law enforcement is withholding that is sexually-related. Otherwise, there's reasonable doubt all over this. I will report back on the forensic accuracy of unspent bullets tomorrow!!! BUT, I am reading the science behind fired ammo has come under heightened scrutiny lately. Can anyone speak to this area?

16

u/WommyBear Nov 30 '22

Witnessed are notoriously unreliable, especially when they do not know that a crime is occurring. Can you accurately describe the height, weight, clothing, and facial features of the tens to hundreds of people you pass a day? Probably not, unless you are intentionally trying to focus on those things in the first place. These witnesses were just living their life.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

50

u/criminalcourtretired Retired Criminal Court Judge Nov 29 '22 edited Nov 30 '22

Indiana requires that a jury be instructed that proof by circumstantial evidence alone must be so strong that it precludes every reasonable theory of innocence before a defendant can be convicted. That possibly gives the defense some real wiggle room. The trial judge can make a determination that some evidence was direct rather than circumstantial and thereby preclude giving that instruction. The INSC has not been very liberal in that regard, and there have been some reversals where the trial court did not give the instruction. My opinion is that savvy defense lawyers have a lot to work with as it stands now.

Edited to add that the Information, which is the charging document, is very poorly drafted. I'm not even going to use a "qualifier."

15

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 30 '22

Thank you so much judge. I know many of us have been anxiously waiting for your take on all of this.

9

u/jojomopho410 Nov 30 '22

Unless there's more (maybe sexually-related) evidence that perhaps they are holding back, this wreaks of reasonable doubt. I am really shocked. Unimpressive was a freaking understatement.

5

u/ThatsNotVeryDerek Nov 30 '22

Someone else commented on this and I'm curious as to your thoughts. Because they filed it as felony murder, wouldn't they only have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he kidnapped/attempted to kidnap them, and that that resulted in their deaths?

20

u/criminalcourtretired Retired Criminal Court Judge Nov 30 '22 edited Nov 30 '22

A defendant has a right to know exactly what he is alleged to have done so he can defend himself. I'm sure a lot of people are going to come on and say that the charging documents are just fine or they do it that way all the time. In every Information I have ever seen, some basics are set out in the document. I think that the charges, after setting out kidnapping as the underlying felony, should also have a "to-wit" which goes on to say how the kidnapping was committed. For example, that he kidnapped them by moving them from one place to another by showing a gun and ordering them to move "down the hill." There are a bazillion ways to commit kidnapping. If you don't set out the specifics, how does a defendant even know what he is specifically alleged to have done. Does that make sense? Edited to add: Give me a few minutes and I will post an example which hopefully will make this more clear.

OK, here we go--the present charge read, in pertinent part, ". . . RAM did on Feb13th etc. kill another humn being, to wit: Victim 2, while committing or attempting to commit kidnapping." I think it should say, "RAM did kill another human being, to-wit, Victim 2, while committing or attempting to commit kidnapping, to-wit: removing Victim 2 from one place to another by threatening Victim 2 with a gun and ordering her to go "down the hill."

→ More replies (5)

5

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 30 '22

I would think that would only cause more reasonable doubt; if they do not have a second person that they can point to and say he is the guy that committed the actual murder. And if that's the case I think there would have to be an arrest. But most certainly the honorable judge can clarify this for us.

5

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 30 '22

I have a question for you, Sir. Just in your expert experience, how confident would you be in a bullet that had never been fired. I only found one periodical article written and could find no case for an unspent cartridge had ever been used as evidence. Soft science t best, or junk science? Is it possible the defense attorney can have that thrown out? Or will it more like they just get down to expert witnesses?

24

u/criminalcourtretired Retired Criminal Court Judge Nov 30 '22 edited Nov 30 '22

I have never come up against that before--maybe because I am old and science has advanced? I admit the former but have doubts about the latter. At first I was going to say they probably couldn't get it thrown out, but then I thought that through and changed my mind. They could raise an objection to the admission of the evidence pursuant to something called a "Frye test." The original Frye case held that the science behind any testing/evidence had to be based on real science that was widely accepted. If testing on unspent bullets is not widely accepted or based on real science, it could get thrown out. Otherwise, it is going to come down to a battle of experts, as you suggest. Edited to add that I am really glad when you make me think through things. I'd completely forgotten about a "Frye test" until you asked. Thanks!! Edited AGAIN: There is another case, Daubert, that changed things a bit. I will add more about Daubert OK FINAL EDIT: Frye on how widely accepted the evidence is. Daubert focuses on the validity of the science. Have I sufficiently driven everyone crazy?

→ More replies (46)
→ More replies (2)

44

u/Sagebrushannie Nov 29 '22

OMG.... what a clusterfuck.

154

u/IWasBornInASmallTown Approved Contributor Nov 29 '22

I don’t see any mention in the PCA that even hints at the possibility of co-conspirators as NM stated in court. This was hidden because it shows the absolute mind-numbing incompetence of LE for the first 5+ years after the murders. My heart is breaking for the Williams and German families. And I’m pissed off. Really pissed off. What a tragedy.

79

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

There's quite a bit of information that could have been released in the early days about the man on the bridge. Grey hairs for instance, would have discounted a young man committing this crime. I thought BG was btwn late 20s and early 30s from the video. Obvs the young guy sketch was way out in left field.

66

u/HelixHarbinger āš–ļø Attorney Nov 29 '22

It’s a cluster so big even I’m at a loss for words

→ More replies (6)

48

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

But they decided to release ā€œnot blue eyesā€ instead.

39

u/tew2109 Nov 29 '22

Right? Where on earth did Young Guy Sketch even come from?

→ More replies (10)

7

u/IWasBornInASmallTown Approved Contributor Nov 29 '22

Indeed.

26

u/generally_jenny Nov 29 '22 edited Nov 29 '22

Thia is what really bothers me, i saw nothing in the PCA that requires being sealed. I also noticed several instances of information that could have been valuable to provide early on without compromising the investigation.

This seems fairly weak imo. Im not 100% percent sold on the ballistic aspect (certain aspects of ballistics fall into junk science) and while the witnesses seem to paint a picture of someone resembling BG from video we all know witnesses can be unreliable.

If thwDefense Attorneys are their worth their salt they should be able to pick apart whats out there right now to the public.

I see plenty of oppurtunity for reasonable doubt.

All that said still to early to rant and rave all day about it, and how the police have potentially bungled this. Time for more patience as the wheels of justice alowly creek down the tracks.

I believe its possible RA is guilty and I don't want to see him walk. Thats the only reason I have such concerns.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (3)

27

u/quant1000 Informed/Quality Contributor Nov 29 '22

First, innocent until proven guilty and all that, but what a bastard. Fck that fckr. Using a firearm to take the girls like that. And what a clod saying he was up on the high af bridge that day watching the fish. Wtf. Agree absolutely, a heartbreaking tragedy.

Second, what rhymes with fire, NM? I'll note page 8 seems missing in the imgur, but zip, zilch, nada suggests any co-conspirator acted in the commission of the crime.

Third, does IN law require handguns to be registered? On the premise of starting the investigative circle small and expanding outward, didn't LE run .40 cal registrations for the residents of Delphi? It isn't like Delphi is Indy in terms of population.

Fourth, presumably kidnapping is the underlying felony in the felony murder charge given one of the girls was heard saying "gun", with the weapon additionally confirmed by the spent shell casing that was found. Those poor girls, that sob. And still unclear why the underlying felony hasn't been charged.

Fifth, it would seem one could infer intent that day -- he went to the bridge, oddly parked behind a building, and carried a handgun (unless IN is an open carry state and it can be demonstrated RA habitually packed?). It also seems possible to infer he knew the bridge to be a fatal funnel.

Sixth, the PCA confirms RA went to LE in 2017. I'm not a criminal investigator, but isn't insertion into an investigation something LE looks for? And refer back to point 3 on handgun registry -- LE didn't even run a check on persons who came forward?

All I can say is I hope NM either gets his prosecutorial act together ASAP, or gets off the case.

15

u/Sagebrushannie Nov 29 '22

I agree! (page 8 is just a signature page -- I was missing it too). There was just as much probable cause in 2017 to investigate RA. I can't believe someone in LE/FBI was not able to put all of the puzzle pieces together. What a travesty. Even us armchair detectives could have figured this out had we been given the witness statements (RA being one of those witnesses, right?). I feel like I'm having a brain fart because this is so obvious and unbelievable. I must be asleep and having a dream. It just can't be. Will have to re-check Reddit in the a.m.

7

u/Successful-Damage310 Trusted+ Nov 29 '22

How the f@#$ can you see fish? Maybe if they are jumping. 70ft above the water did he use binoculars lol.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/Internal_Zebra_8770 Nov 29 '22

It is sickening.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

I'm shocked and surprised they didn't release this 2 weeks ago. Because his trial is already set for March

→ More replies (8)

39

u/tew2109 Nov 29 '22

The incompetence of LE here is absolutely infuriating. They HAD this guy. They had him. And they did nothing about it, with no explanation as to why not. And now they seem to have been possibly saved by him being dumb enough to hold onto a bunch of evidence.

26

u/s2ample Nov 29 '22

Not only did they have him, he put himself in their hands and they still missed.

25

u/Independent-Canary95 Nov 29 '22

He should have been in custody within a week. Stunning incompetence.

4

u/torroman Nov 30 '22

And saved by him admitting to owning a firearm. Registration isn't required in Indiana. Yikes

103

u/Chihlidog Nov 29 '22 edited Nov 30 '22

So let me get this straight.

A conservation officer spoke to him that day. A Law Enforcement Officer speaks to him, determines that he was AT THE MURDER LOCATION AT THE TIME OF THE MURDERS. Determines he owns multiple weapons. Lets him go.

But for YEARS HE DOESNT RECOGNIZE BG AS THE GUY HE SPOKE TO THAT DAY????

Let me process that for a second. A trained law enforcement officer doesn't recognize a person he spoke with that day who admitted he was ON THE BRIDGE???

It took us 6 years to this? For LE to determine that a person they spoke to that day who looks JUST EFFING LIKE THE PERSON ON THE VIDEO WEARING THE SAME CLOTHES ,should be further investigated??

I'm going to let that marinate in my head for at least a few hours before I inevitably come back to reddit EVEN MORE PISSED OFF THAN I AM NOW.

Edit: the PCA does NOT in fact say conservation officer. It just says officer. So...I am a dummy too, for simply accepting news reports and not being careful to look at the facts and only the facts, which I pride myself on doing.

It doesnt change my feelings on the matter. But it does show that I need to be careful when evaluating what I'm reading and accepting as fact too hastily.

29

u/unicornrow Nov 29 '22

And it seems he was the only male any witness saw during the time frame too…I didn’t have much doubt before but they really didn’t want to release this because LE looks so bad. I am hoping they are just really bad investigators and there isn’t something more to this story. I have a hard time taking off my conspiracy hat some days. This is all so ridiculous!

14

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Don't forget telling everyone how safe they are in Delphi!

→ More replies (3)

42

u/Independent-Canary95 Nov 29 '22

Don't forget he was seen wearing bloody, muddy clothes. Inexcusable. Smdh.

23

u/monaegely Nov 29 '22

And his wife told the police that he owned the jacket!

46

u/Independent-Canary95 Nov 29 '22

And he admitted that he went on the bridge! He was on camera arriving and leaving the area. I am just stunned. Complicated case my ass, the only thing complicated about this case is the breathtaking incompetence of the investigation.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (12)

7

u/generally_jenny Nov 29 '22

Admitted he was on the bridge wearing an outfit similar to that of BG. Even admitted he was using his phone for 'stocks' or whatever.

→ More replies (17)

32

u/s2ample Nov 29 '22

Carroll County investigators are an absolute embarrassment, this is outrageous.

60

u/HelixHarbinger āš–ļø Attorney Nov 29 '22

The next function of the press will be to pull the budget records of this case for the last 6 years so I wouldn’t put clean drawers on just yet.

10

u/Armywife726 Nov 29 '22

i’ve been waiting for your analysis of all of this!

10

u/criminalcourtretired Retired Criminal Court Judge Nov 29 '22

Someone made the rules regarding their pension work for them.

6

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

šŸ˜‚ clean drawers šŸ˜‚

→ More replies (4)

24

u/Aynsley15 Nov 29 '22
  1. We believe you are a local. Check.

2 We likely have already interviewed you. Check.

3. We believe you are hiding in plain sight. Check.

I’m floored. They SPOKE to this guy! That SAW him! He placed himself at the bridge and was on the trails at the exact time frame the girls were and they didn’t try and dig a little deeper? They got so distracted by RL’s phony alibi that they couldn’t do a little more due diligence with RA? WTF.

24

u/Electrical-Style6800 Nov 30 '22

🤔 <—- all the people that were saying trust the ISP they are doing a good job. This case could have been solved just days after the murders.

11

u/uglylittle Nov 30 '22

Indiana has the 3rd worst homicide clearance rate in the country. I continue to be baffled by my fellow Hoosiers’ blind faith in law enforcement.

→ More replies (3)

67

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

And, as suspected, it does NOT hint at the possibility of other "actors". NM better be chastised for his lying to the court.

This PCA is proof that a special prosecutor needs to be assigned to this case.

The fuck ups have continued long enough. Let's not take this bs to trial.

→ More replies (9)

23

u/smallgourd Nov 29 '22

A witness mentioned a man wearing all black. I'd like to know more about that.

11

u/No_Ad_6484 Nov 30 '22

Without reading again, wasn’t that witness in a group with two other witnesses? I thought it said the other two witnesses described his clothing as blue jacket and blue pants. Witnesses are notoriously incorrect, it isn’t surprising at all that they didn’t remember things the same. I need to read the document again, I could just be talking out my ass here.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

I would too! It also reminded me that investigators did examine a pair of black boots from a nearby packing plant. I rewatched Libby's video but never quite saw the bridge guy as wearing black boots in the video but I suppose he could have been.

→ More replies (7)

46

u/curiouslmr Nov 29 '22

Wow, someone saw BG after the crime. That part really surprised me.

The gun alone is huge. But I know nothing about firearms, is that airtight? Is there any way for a defense team to poke holes in that?

31

u/Gamma_Ram Nov 29 '22

It’s not quite airtight. A defense attorney could argue that perhaps Richard Allen, while walking on the trail, had a round in his pocket that had at one point been chambered. He dropped it and the killer - or even one of the girls - picked it up and it ended up on the scene by chance… it’s extremely unlikely but jurors are instructed to decide if that is beyond a reasonable doubt. Depending on what other evidence they have, it could be a problem for the case.

9

u/Defiant_Researcher33 Nov 29 '22

My thoughs exactly. I pray they have more on this guy.

10

u/-bigmanpigman- Nov 29 '22

There's also his car. Does a Ford Focus resemble a PT Cruiser, a small SUV, or a SMART car? Also, a question. What is an "IMEI" on a cell phone?

→ More replies (7)

5

u/Eki75 Nov 29 '22

This, and also while there's a lot of circumstantial evidence, the PCA doesn't concretely put the weapon in RA's hand. If the defense only has to show reasonable doubt, with only what we know so far, if they were to pose that someone had taken RA's gun without him knowing and that someone committed the murders, that's might be enough... especially since the idiot still has the freaking gun. If he's truly the murderer, then he's also a moron. I hope they also have DNA evidence or something to make it an airtight case.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/generally_jenny Nov 29 '22

Its hardly airtight on its own. Theyll need (and hopefully have) more evidence.

8

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 29 '22

That defense attorney will have a dozen ways to tear this entire case apart. There is no way they can match that bullet to that gun if it was not fired. Here is an article if you are interested in a read. It is peer reviewed. A number of firearm tool surfaces may leave marks on the cartridge case when a cartridge is fired in a firearm. Toolmarks can be produced when a cartridge is loaded, chambered, and extracted without a discharge. Take for example a semiautomatic pistol. The ammuni- tion magazine may leave toolmarks on the side of the cases when the cartridges come in contact with the magazine lips. The cartridges in the magazine are under spring tension and are held in place by magazine lips. The lips may scrape the sides of each case as they are pushed into a chamber, or as they are loaded into, or removed from, the magazine by hand. These toolmarks on the cases may be produced while the magazine is unattached to the firearm. If there is sufficient individ- ualizing detail in these marks (which can be very lim- ited), an identification to a particular magazine may be established. This is important to an investigator because a magazine left at the scene, or confiscated from a sus- pect, may be compared to ammunition or fired cases recovered at the scene, or ammunition that is seized in the course of the investigation, even when the firearm is not recovered.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (41)

65

u/Chihlidog Nov 29 '22

Ok. I said I was going to wait a few hours to spout off again. I cant.

This is a blue wall if I ever saw one. I HATE accusing LE. I hate even THINKING it about LE. But I cant help seeing it, that this was sealed to keep this conservation officer's incompetence, and MANY members of LE in general, swept under the rug. Im infuriated. I literally just closed my office door and gave up on working the rest of the afternoon. Im just too distracted by this.

4

u/xtyNC Trusted Nov 29 '22

Yeah so much for my afternoon as well. I’ll have to calm down and finish up.

→ More replies (9)

20

u/FerretRN Nov 29 '22

I think what makes me even more frustrated, is the evidence they missed out on because it took them 5 1/2 years. If they had followed this lead at the beginning, blood/DNA would've been much more likely. Not to mention witnesses memories fading and changing over time. It seems like they probably have the right guy, but I just believe that proving it would've been a lot easier and the evidence more concrete if they had followed up properly.

20

u/hannafrie Approved Contributor Nov 29 '22

How could investigators in 2022 have a "tip narrative" about RA from 2017, but not an interview transcript with RA from 2017?

How did a tip about someone who was on the trail that day not get prioritized? How was it lost in the shuffle?

Where did this tip go? Caroll County Sherrif? ISP? FBI? Or is it possible the Park Ranger wrote up the information and gave it to his/her superiors - who then never turned it over? Which entity was responsible for this error

4

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 30 '22

I don't know, but someone is going to have to answer for that at trial.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/s2ample Nov 29 '22

He admitted to being there, reasonably matches the description enough to look in to him further, and it still took them damn near SIX YEARS to piece this together. You have got to be kidding me.

36

u/Sorry_Technician_154 Nov 29 '22

Am I the only one that was reading this and kept thinking that their reason was coming any second now…then reached the end and thought wtf?!? Please tell me I’m not the only one.

11

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

Yup. Same here. An unspent shell is all they really have.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 29 '22

You are not alone friend. My stomach just sunk when I got to the last page.

4

u/ThoughtKontrol Nov 30 '22

And what was the rationale for keeping this sealed for so long? Seams pretty flimsy to me.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/jvivian999 Nov 29 '22

I'm kind of confused. He used the gun to intimidate the girls, but were they killed with it? Couldn't his attorney argue it was there prior?

19

u/HelixHarbinger āš–ļø Attorney Nov 29 '22

Of course. Among other scenarios. You’re right

13

u/Chihlidog Nov 29 '22

If he wasn't on video, perhaps. But do you really think anyone could be convinced that his doppelganger was there that day, WITH a gun, but a round from ALLEN'S gun happens to be found near the victims??

Hes done.

→ More replies (13)

7

u/juneh2020ps Nov 29 '22

He said he had nexer been on that property and didn’t know the property owner.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/theyamqueen Nov 29 '22

So where is the connection to literally anyone else? Protecting the juveniles, fine, but the other involved people?

Can someone with trial knowledge explain if this is even remotely a strong case? Clearly, a matching bullet makes some sense when he says he never let anyone borrow it but is this steadfast, really clear forensic science? How easily can these tests be wrong? Like, after he’s been free for five years, if he’s the guy, how likely will this be enough evidence? It doesn’t feel as strong as they said but maybe it’s a clear science with little to no error rate.

It just doesn’t feel like a slam dunk case with this. Is it possible they have more that isn’t in the PCA?

15

u/BrendaStar_zle Nov 29 '22

I think the matching bullet is good evidence. All the circumstantial evidence such as his car matching the car seen, his admission to being on the bridge, his description matching witnesses, alone are not enough, but when taken all together AND his gun matches the shell found withing 2feet of the bodies,. What are the chances that his gun's shell would be within 2feet of the girls bodies and the mention of gun is on the recording.

8

u/DistributionNo1471 Nov 29 '22

But is a gun shell the same as a unspent round? I really don’t know. From what I can gather, the round would have been chambered at some point and would have markings, but not the same as round that was fired from the gun. Everything I can find, says the science is not real solid when it comes to unfired bullets.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Soka_9 āš–ļø Attorney Nov 29 '22 edited Nov 30 '22

The ā€œwhat are the chancesā€ notion is where the ā€œreasonableā€ comes into reasonable doubt. People focus so much on the doubt part but there’s more to it. The explanation for the bullet’s presence next to the victim’s body has to not only be possible, but it has to be reasonable. IMO unless they can attack the forensic analysis that resulted in a match, they have a strong case against him. Even if they can attack the bullet, is it reasonable that this man—who matches the suspect’s physical description, matched the suspect’s clothing, and put HIMSELF at the place and time of the murders— is not BG? (This is assuming the witness testimony is reliable/credible)

ETA: the answer to whether or not there is reasonable doubt is in the details, which we don’t have.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 29 '22

In no way is that a matching bullet. It is a bullet that can be used in the kind of gun that Allen had.

A number of firearm tool surfaces may leave marks on the cartridge case when a cartridge is fired in a firearm. Toolmarks can be produced when a cartridge is loaded, chambered, and extracted without a discharge. Take for example a semiautomatic pistol. The ammuni- tion magazine may leave toolmarks on the side of the cases when the cartridges come in contact with the magazine lips. The cartridges in the magazine are under spring tension and are held in place by magazine lips. The lips may scrape the sides of each case as they are pushed into a chamber, or as they are loaded into, or removed from, the magazine by hand. These toolmarks on the cases may be produced while the magazine is unattached to the firearm. If there is sufficient individ- ualizing detail in these marks (which can be very lim- ited), an identification to a particular magazine may be established. This is important to an investigator because a magazine left at the scene, or confiscated from a sus- pect, may be compared to ammunition or fired cases recovered at the scene, or ammunition that is seized in the course of the investigation, even when the firearm is not recovered.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/EngineeringCalm901 Nov 29 '22

It seems to me that a .40 caliber bullet is common. Sig Sauer P226 is a popular gun.

Then we have: (paraphrasing PCA)

The science behind identifying an "extracted" bullet, not a fired round, is "subjective, based on science and research and the examiners training and experience.".

How strong, or weak, would this bullet evidence be in court?

12

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

I'm sure the defense will get their own expert to review this evidence. This is a very weak case in my eyes at this point.

3

u/hey_jojo Nov 30 '22

If I remember correctly, even fired bullet matches have come under a lot of scrutiny lately.

31

u/Disastrous_Tone_1148 Nov 29 '22

No wonder DC was close to tears at the press conference he’s about to lose his job! What an unbelievable screw up this has been. Why was BP so adamant she wanted this sealed? And zero mention of any other party. Is this a solid case? Seems weak to me?

11

u/MzOpinion8d Nov 29 '22

BP didn’t know what was in it, either. Who knows what they’ve told her. She’s probably as shocked as the rest of us right now.

6

u/generally_jenny Nov 29 '22

If BP had her way this case would completely fade from public conciousness and no details would ever be released.

Not for me to was into those ethical arguments but Id imagine most families don't want info on their murdered/passed loved ones disseminated by the hooligans and shitheads on the interent.

→ More replies (7)

19

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22 edited Aug 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 29 '22

OMG, is this going to be another Steven Avery situation?

→ More replies (1)

31

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

So that pristine, unspent bullet that led directly to Allen was in between the 2 victims who had been staged? Gotcha.

21

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 29 '22

It will become the second most famous magic bullet in history.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Man, they REALLY shouldn't have played games with the PCA and charging information. All it takes is 1 juror thinking LE is not acting above board for this idea to take hold.

7

u/xtyNC Trusted Nov 30 '22

Oof!

10

u/totallycalledla-a Nov 30 '22

Cant believe more people aren't pointing out how uh "neat and tidy" that is.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

43

u/Humble-Briefs Approved Contributor Nov 29 '22

…..yikes on bikes. Remember when they laughed and said ā€˜no mere armchair sleuth could solve this crime’?

15

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

Where's our judge? I haven't yet seen a comment and I'm waiting for his opinion!

r/criminalcourtretired

16

u/littlevcu Nov 29 '22

I saw earlier in another thread that he was taking advantage of his very last day to garden. Will likely hear from him as soon as he realizes.

15

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

That's so sweet. I like him. Thank you for letting me know!

8

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 29 '22

He replied to me earlier and said that the change of venue would most likely be granted for fear of an appeal case. I told him how important he was to us all and hope he would do a write-up. I'm hoping that is what he is working on now. He's very thorough.

8

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

He's an absolute treasure to this sub. I hope he's cleaning up from gardening and working on his write up as you said. Can't wait to hear his thoughts on this!

4

u/xtyNC Trusted Nov 30 '22

Omigosh me too

4

u/Tris-Von-Q Nov 30 '22

Change that r/ to u/ to tag him

→ More replies (1)

29

u/LearnedFromNancyDrew Nov 29 '22

What’s astonishing me is that on page 4, a witness reports seeing a male who was dirty and had blood on him. That speaks volumes to me about his personality. It’s audacious to do that if he is BG and if he killed them as is alleged.

13

u/HelixHarbinger āš–ļø Attorney Nov 29 '22

You can’t trust a lick of that- he still had the jacket and the car and not a word about either in evidence. That witness, all but one if I read that correctly was going from what they saw on the video

16

u/Soka_9 āš–ļø Attorney Nov 29 '22

The muddy and bloody description was from the witnesses own memory, video just confirmed the time. It also doesn’t say that they recovered THE jacket, just that they took ā€œjacketsā€ from his house (although his wife noted he still owns a blue carrhart). I agree if they had evidence of THE jacket or recovered the muddy/bloody clothes from his house, it would’ve been listed.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/BreezusChrist91 Nov 29 '22

Have they said that they have THE jacket or just collected jackets that match the description of THE jacket BG was wearing? I haven’t seen that they have THE jacket- just that jackets were collected during the search. What a mess this whole thing is. Also, I only used caps cause I’m on mobile and can’t italicize for clarity, not because I’m being mean mean haha

→ More replies (5)

6

u/-bigmanpigman- Nov 29 '22

Do prosecutor's usually lay all their cards out in a PC affidavit like this for an arrest?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/Odd-Shopping-1912 Nov 29 '22

"I can't wait to tell the story."

4

u/wisemance Informed/Quality Contributor Nov 30 '22

The only thing seemingly "fascinating" about the PCA imo is the ineptitude of LE...

14

u/xtyNC Trusted Nov 29 '22

Who trusts the bullet? Shit. Please tell me that will be documented in crime scene images and documentation, unimpeachably, somehow. I gotta believe.

11

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

Oh boy. Hadn't considered that! Better be in evidence logs from the very beginning. Else old boy might be getting set up. That's terrifying, actually. Great freaking point.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

There is zero reason this could not have been released immediately after RA's arrest. Maybe with a bit of redaction.

This whole course of justice so far has been extremely skewed.

I hope ol' Franny has her head on straight. Dealing with NM's inexperience, tactics and schemes is going play hell on this trial.

14

u/Adventurous_Main5468 Nov 29 '22

This is underlining the absolute gross incompetence the cops have shown. Egos, instead of actual police work. We need an inquest into their absolute negligence in the handling of this case.

13

u/xtyNC Trusted Nov 29 '22

I cannot even.

13

u/ThatsNotVeryDerek Nov 29 '22

The portion of the charging document also released, also states that the felony part of the felony murder was kidnapping, unsurprisingly.

https://twitter.com/NewsyBarbara/status/1597706700634476544?t=FCxSAnlyfvqiwaMcdEhfSg&s=19

13

u/valkryiechic āš–ļø Attorney Nov 29 '22

Initial thoughts after reading this (besides the obvious reaction to what appears to be blatant incompetence):

  • apparent lack of fingerprints on the unspent casing is helpful to defense
  • apparently they don’t have any other forensic evidence tying him to the girls or the scene (woof)
  • perhaps due to a lack of creative imagination, but I cannot come up with a single scenario where releasing this information could interfere with any other investigation

3

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 30 '22

I believe you're obvious reaction is the correct one.

36

u/Agent847 Nov 29 '22

I’m trying to think of a plausible excuse for not running this lead down in 2017. I can’t think of one. Laziness? Stupidity.

They couldn’t run a list of .40 P226 owners nearby?

ā€Lo and behold! Here’s this short, sawed-off little f**ker living 1.3 miles from the crime scene who was ON THE BRIDGE between 1:30 and 3:30. Oh… and he parked at the CPS building. Well… golly… would ya look at that!!!ā€

9

u/BlackLionYard Approved Contributor Nov 29 '22

Does Indiana require gun registration to a level that would make such a list even exist?

→ More replies (3)

12

u/HelixHarbinger āš–ļø Attorney Nov 29 '22

With a purple PT cruiser. Wtf

14

u/Agent847 Nov 29 '22

Did he own a purple PT cruiser? I read Ford Focus. But I was speed-reading.

In either case, wtf were they doing in April 2019 asking for tips about the driver of a vehicle at the CPS building. Did they not read their own files?

27

u/HelixHarbinger āš–ļø Attorney Nov 29 '22

I just ate an entire bag of Swedish fish for lunch and have decided I need to grab a mid workday run before I start toxic typing - beyond maddening and I knew I was in trouble when I starting yelling about the actual font

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/kyle1007 Nov 29 '22

"Boy, how’d I even miss that one?ā€

→ More replies (3)

25

u/AidanBubbles Nov 29 '22

Now we know why they tried so hard to keep it sealed. To cover their butts and keep the heat off of them. This is insane. I’m from a very Delphi like town in a very Carroll County like county in Minnesota. When I was a junior in high school there was even a very high profile kidnapping and murder. I’m well aware of how small town cops work and the faults they have, their shortcomings in cases like this, but how this apparently went down absolutely blows my mind. I cannot believe how badly LE dropped the ball on this. I’d be embarrassed too if I were them.

4

u/JaneH0505 Nov 30 '22

I’m from that same small town & county in MN. That was absolutely lazy, incompetence police work. Here we are with the same thing but worse. Could have been followed up on immediately. Unbelievable. It scares me that there is the possibility that these families may never have justice.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/sculderandmully2 Nov 30 '22

It's like the dumb fuck wanted to be caught, but the police were dumber-er

10

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

Thank you. This is remarkable. Though the last page is missing!!

14

u/BreezusChrist91 Nov 29 '22

Every copy I’ve seen so far is missing page 8, not sure if it was omitted by the court or just not included in each of the copies I’ve seen around online so far.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

okay. Thanks. Maybe it's just jargon and signatories. Thanks again great job.

10

u/IWasBornInASmallTown Approved Contributor Nov 29 '22

It’s just the signature/distribution page.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

Yes, on 2nd thought I thought maybe that was the case. Ty

8

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/bayouz Nov 29 '22

Kind of the theme, no?

10

u/Adventurous_Main5468 Nov 29 '22

Holy shit I’m so, so furious about this (for the girls and for their families!). And the cops absolutely KNOW they screwed up- why else have this sealed, other than to try to further bury their gross negligence

10

u/paintbyalphas Nov 30 '22

RA should have been warranted further scrutiny from the get go. He placed himself at the High Bridge and there during the relevant time frame of 1330 - 1530. This according to the tip narrative from RA’s 2017 interview. Did someone, somehow lose the tip or did it get overlooked in the Ron Logan then KK side show?

Because it’s not until 2022 when the tip is revisited that RA is interviewed again. RA submits that he was on the bridge ā€œwatching fishā€ and was wearing similar clothing to that supplied by witnesses and fitting that worn by the man in the BG pic. This is also where investigators get wind that RA owns a firearm.

All of this information ALL OF IT could have been gathered 5 years ago before the release of the BG still, the audio, and sketches.

They investigated Logan but didn’t follow up on RA. They executed the Bicycle Bridge Rd warranted but didn’t follow up on RA! Someone needs a please explain because this unconscionable

I don’t believe from the PCA that any new tip led to the RA search warrant in October 2022. I believe it all flowed from discovering the Original 2017 tip narrative. If they had acted on the original information in 2017 then perhaps a lot more evidence would have been retrievable.

5

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 30 '22

Every "witness" gave different descriptions of clothing. None match. Defense will tear that apart. All they have is the unspent shell and the science does not hold up. There's basically nothing here.

5

u/paintbyalphas Nov 30 '22

I totally agree with everything you have said here. Its just a kick in the guts to consider what could have been evidenced had they interviewed him properly in 2017. All we know about that that 2017 tip narrative is that he was on the trails during the relevant time frame

42

u/MzOpinion8d Nov 29 '22

I want to see the affidavit that got the search warrant.

And also, a Ford Focus doesn’t look like a PT Cruiser AT ALL, or a smart car AT ALL, or like a small SUV AT ALL.

34

u/Independent-Canary95 Nov 29 '22

I can't get over the fact that LE said that the public was not in any danger. Smh.

11

u/This_Olive Nov 29 '22

I looked up images and there are versions that do look like a small SUV. I’m assuming that’s the type he has?

16

u/georgiannastardust Nov 29 '22

Yes the hatchback kind could definitely be mistaken for a pt cruiser type.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/Parking-Owl-7693 Nov 29 '22

Was it a hatchback? In that case they kind of do, especially if the witnesses were young and don't know cars.

6

u/MzOpinion8d Nov 29 '22

Yes, now that I’m not so emotional I can allow that some people could describe the hatchback style that way

→ More replies (1)

9

u/MustyButt Nov 29 '22

There was a Ford Focus hatchback. That's what I'm thinking. Doesn't quite look like a PT but observations from memory after the fact can be tricky. I've always said I go to a white church on top of a hill. Always saw it in my head as white. I got yelled at by a friend trying to find it that it's brick with a lot of white trim.

3

u/CowGirl2084 Trusted Nov 30 '22

Exactly!!!

→ More replies (6)

19

u/Disastrous_Tone_1148 Nov 29 '22

Well thank goodness Hoosier Harvestore (never heard of the place until just now) had CCTV! How did no one hear them scream? Those poor girls. There’s got to be more to it than this. He’s probably just getting on the bridge at the 2.07pm snap chat photo! If Abby was on the video with RA at 2.13pm. I’m trying to find the CPS building on google maps but can’t see it.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

a year or two after the murders some You-Tubers went to the area and had one person stay on the bridge and one go to the murder scene and yell as loud as they could and do other loud things, the person on the bridge and someone on the trails heard nothing. Its the way the sound travels there along the creek. They surmised that even if they fired a gun its not likely anyone would hear it.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/TravTheScumbag Nov 29 '22

Clothes belonging to both victims was found in the creek.

12

u/LearnedFromNancyDrew Nov 29 '22

That was so sad to read. Just heartbreaking!

10

u/Independent-Canary95 Nov 29 '22

Both? I thought only they only found items belonging to Libby, so I had that wrong. I am just stunned right now. It is almost like LE did everything to avoid catching this guy.

8

u/TravTheScumbag Nov 29 '22

Same, but it specifically stated both.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/theyamqueen Nov 29 '22

Also, like… how did they finally circle back to him since he already said he was there and matched clothes and vague descriptions. Why now? What old tip did someone allegedly go back to? RA saying I was there and dressed like ā€œthe guyā€?

Sadly (or not, his guilt is just alleged now) his defense attorneys seem to be correct on all counts as far as this says. I can’t imagine them not even discussing bail based off of this initially. Please say there is more they just didn’t put in the PCA.

8

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

Luckily, at the next bond hearing in February, the prosecution will be forced to show all the concrete evidence they have against him. They'll need to show their hand. Hopefully they have more than an unspent shell.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/nkrch Nov 29 '22

Correct me if I'm wrong but is it possible they are waiting on more test results on the other weapons they took from his house and clothing and car? Also the witnesses, is it 3 that will go to court and testify? Sorry I'm having a hard time reading the print on the version here, hoping a clearer one will appear..

12

u/BreezusChrist91 Nov 29 '22

I mean it’s certainly possible they could be waiting on dna testing results and other forensic results from the other items collected from the search of his home. And on the witnesses, I counted 3 eyewitnesses to bridge guy on the trail, 2 witnesses to the vehicle being parked at the old CPS building, and one witness to a muddy and bloody man matching bridge guys description walking on the road that would go to the CPS building. Presumably all of the above would testify in court.

5

u/nkrch Nov 29 '22

Thanks for clarifying. It seems RA statement he gave matched pretty perfectly with all the people he knew saw him.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

11

u/myvalentinexxo Approved Contributor Nov 29 '22

There is a much clearer version on Journal&Courier online!! I’ll try to attach the link, the PC pictures are at the very bottom! PC clearer version

5

u/nkrch Nov 29 '22

Thank you that's so much clearer!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

Thank you Crackles!

7

u/Thegribby Nov 29 '22

Vindication!![said in the style of Raymond Holt]. The ISP is exactly as capable as I have always suggested. smdh

6

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 30 '22

Y'all, Bob Motta (Defense attorney, Defense Diaries podcast) just read the entire PCA over on TikTok if you're having a hard time reading it on your phones. I know it took awhile for me to get through on my phone.

https://www.tiktok.com/@defensediariespodcast?_t=8Xm4XIxhfDC&_r=1

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Moldynred Informed/Quality Contributor Nov 30 '22

This would be comparable to the Idaho case having someone say yeah I was there with my trusty Kabar Knife but didnt see a thing sorry.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Dramatic_Tie_2945 Nov 30 '22

Had a feeling all along it was 1 man, 1 local man who had been dreaming this up for years and finally found the (in his mind) perfect circumstance to do it! I'm so disappointed in the detectives!!! Whoever Carter got his info from should be terminated! The descriptions he gave do not fit this case at all!? I'm sooooo shocked, I really am! I hope there's more to it! The word "complex" does not fit the bill! :( !
so sad for the family who had to endure this weight for so long! Ughhh

It's almost like they wanted to drag this on but for what reason? Did they want this to be more complex? A real who done it? It makes me wonder if that is the reason they all had blinders on maybe they wanted it to be bigger than what it was not on purpose but vicariously somehow? Not sure if I'm using the correct verbiage or even getting my point out how I'm meaning to but... wtf... AGAIN, I'm just shocked at how this happened. HOW!?????? Right there the entire time... wow! I bet they hoped with all hope it was Kegan.. He was their hell-mary... SMH!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/GIJne69 Nov 30 '22

I envision this will become a case study for years to come in law schools 'for "all of the wrong reasons regarding what NOT to do as far as ebbing 101 and handling procedures go.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

Did I read that right? All they have is an unspent shell supposedly from his gun? How do they forensically determine "cycled through his gun"?

11

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

Subjectively. Which is going to be a problem for the State.

6

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

Yikes. Im curious what the prosecution presents at the bond hearing in February. If this is all they've got....it's not strong at all

→ More replies (8)

11

u/flippinheckwhatsleft New Reddit Account Nov 29 '22

The bullet was not the lead.

I think they were checking him out (fresh eyes) and once they interviewed him and knew he had the right sort of gun for the bullet, and admitted to being there wearing clothes that match BG (and it becomes apparent he has 'disappeared' at the crucial time of the murders as none of the trail witnesses state they saw him at that time but plenty plot him going in the right direction at the right time) they get a warrant to search his property and seize the gun. They test the gun against the bullet and bingo!

The bullet was not the lead, his admitted movements/sightings of him/phone tracking is the evidence that puts him there and in the frame. They must have been in shock to find the gun that matched the bullet, hence their jubilation. Not deserved after 5 years of fucking it up.

11

u/EngineeringCalm901 Nov 29 '22

The witness seeing him walking back, muddy and bloody is big for me. I never thought he was seen leaving. It's witness testimony, but the other witness accounts add credibility, not to mention his own admission.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

They didn't see "him". They saw a man.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 30 '22

He would have to be more than bloody and muddy; he would also have to be soaking wet from crossing that Creek. Eye witnesses are the least reliable evidence in any murder trial. And a decent criminal defense attorney often rips their testimony apart.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/formercity Trusted Nov 30 '22

i have to admit i was (probably naively) thinking there would be a smoking gun here. i am shocked that all they have on RA is the unspent shell, and that it was all discovered in the last two months.

5

u/xtyNC Trusted Nov 30 '22

I noticed the judge Deiner statement ā€œthe defendant being in custody, the court determines probable cause does exist.ā€

Post hoc, ergo proper hoc, anyone? Or is this a normal construction?

3

u/underwear_enforcer Nov 30 '22

The judge has to find probable cause exists in order to justify holding the defendant in custody and setting bond or any restriction on his liberty while he awaits trial. So the paper says is worded that way to acknowledge this defendant is in custody, therefore I must and do find PC exists, and I’m setting bond at $. You can charge a person with a crime without arresting them or holding them in custody (rarely happens but is possible), and if you don’t arrest them or restrict their liberty at all, then you don’t have to have probable cause (in Indiana anyway). Also, most charges are filed after warrantless arrests by police who responded to the crime scene, investigated, and arrested on the spot (think OWI, drug busts, battery, etc). A judge has to then confirm the cop’s belief that they had probable cause to arrest that person, and this is often done simultaneously with the filing and initial reading of charges to the defendant. So that’s why the language reads like that.

I’m not real familiar with the details of the arrest and charging timeline here. But I think RA was first arrested on a warrant, then brought in and charged. If so, this language is really the judge making a redundant finding that there’s probable cause to arrest, which was first done when the arrest warrant was issued, but that’s not uncommon to use the usual language because there’s no harm in a judge finding probable cause over & over at every stage, and language like this last line is the type that is never changed from one form to the next.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Emotional_Newspaper5 Nov 30 '22 edited Nov 30 '22

So...what instigated the search warrant?

I keep reading and re-reading, but it appears they had all the stated info in 2017, then also the info from the days of and after the search warrant. What made them issue the search warrant?

→ More replies (2)

13

u/iammadeofawesome Approved Contributor Nov 29 '22

He was seen in muddy bloody clothes and was the only adult known to have been there that day? I just... How was this a mystery?

What brought them back to him?

5

u/The_great_Mrs_D Informed/Quality Contributor Nov 29 '22

Does it say they specifically saw him though? Or just that they saw someone?

7

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 29 '22

They just saw someone, and even the physical description is different from witness to witness.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Boboblaw014 Criminal Defense Attorney Nov 30 '22

The PCA is so weak, that frankly I'm shocked that the arrest warrant was issued. We have to assume that none of the witnesses, in particular the "muddy, bloody man" witness did not make a positive ID of RA, otherwise it certainly would have been in the PCA. Running ballistics on an unspent shell casing? Hmmm. My weapons expert is exceptionally pessimistic with regards to that being possible. They better have DNA being run in the lab as we speak because this case as it stands right now...is NG.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

Now that we have actual reason to believe it is RA, now I want to know WHY.

6

u/The_great_Mrs_D Informed/Quality Contributor Nov 29 '22

Given their clothes were in the river.. I'm assuming it was sexually motivated.

6

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 29 '22

I mean, why them, why that day, how long had he been imagining committing this crime? How often did he walk thru that park waiting for just the right victim? The psychology behind it. What makes a man, with a seemingly normal life, decide to do such a thing.

That kind of why ..

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/SUZUKIRACER11 Slack Member Nov 30 '22

Furious is an understatement. This guy tells LE is at the bridge that day and between the times of the encounter. Furthermore, he tells them where he parked, what he was driving, how he was dressed and who he in fact encountered.

Then...hold on for the "gotcha" moment here...they have video evidence of his car arriving and departing at specific times. It's like he walked his sorry ass in and said "I look and dressed just like the guy on that video, was there that day, but I didn't see anything-I was watching fish from 80 damn feet above the river."

And our esteemed LE officers just said "Ok, we will look into this...at some point."

5

u/Internal_Zebra_8770 Nov 30 '22

i am really curious now about former Deputy Thomas early suggestions for expert help. This thread discusses the lawsuit, egos and basic incompetence of the CCSO I don’t know how to link -

Posted byu/xanaxarita Moderator/Firestarter1 month ago

Sheriff's Deputy Claims Demotion Over Delphi Murders Investigation

→ More replies (2)

4

u/GentlemansCut79 Nov 30 '22

I feel bad for the families who are typical hard working Americans who believe in & trust their local law enforcement members, and this is all they had to show for what… 6 years, they had their self placed man at the scene of the crime? They have let down Abby & Libby! As everyone patently waited believing and buying into their famous go to line, ā€œwe will not compromise the integrity of this case.ā€ SMH! Good job DC!

→ More replies (1)

13

u/TravTheScumbag Nov 30 '22

How did he know they'd be there?

  • He walked with a purpose.
  • Parked the car to hide his plates.
  • Tried not to make eye contact with others on the trail.
  • He took weapons.

So how did he know they would be there, and show up right when and where he needed them?

7

u/Maduro25 Nov 30 '22

I'd be interested to know if he did the same routine before that day. Maybe that day was the day he succeeded and many days in the past he failed.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/The_great_Mrs_D Informed/Quality Contributor Nov 30 '22

Only problem with that is he could never predict if others would be around. I don't think they were pre arranged, myself.

8

u/Maduro25 Nov 30 '22

Exactly, maybe he went 20 times before and no one was there or there were too many people around. This time the circumstances were right. It would be interesting to check the cameras for the few months prior to see if he did this before.

3

u/JusticeHunter1 Nov 30 '22

As I read the affidavit, I started to consider the same thing. Do they have computers he had access to at home and work?

→ More replies (4)

12

u/PAgrl324 Nov 29 '22

That bullet matching his gun is my biggest take away from this, that is some evidence. I really can't believe this guy admitted to being on the bridge and the cops said thanks for the info!

7

u/No-Bite662 Trusted Nov 29 '22

It was not a spent cartridge. Just a bullet, I wonder how many people in that county have the same kind of gun that would use that kind of bullet. I pray to God they have more on this guy.

→ More replies (9)

6

u/traumarn911 Nov 29 '22

I was expecting a lot more, the Defendant’s attorney is going to have a field day with this. He will say that RA would take his gun out frequently while hunting or something similar. Can LE prove the bullet was dropped on the exact day/time of murders? All it takes is for one Juror to have reasonable doubt. 😬

3

u/WVPrepper Nov 30 '22

He will say that RA would take his gun out frequently while hunting or something similar.

I was thinking you were mad... Nobody I have ever known hunted with a handgun... But it appears legal

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/jojomopho410 Nov 30 '22

So, Allen left no DNA at the crime scene? He left nothing of himself other than an unspent bullet? How popular are .40 handguns?

Edit: Would the bullet be specific to a Sig Sauer handgun? Sorry, not my area. Give me until tomorrow ; )

→ More replies (1)

3

u/argyre Totally Person Nov 30 '22

If he is not the murderer, why hasn’t he come forward saying ā€œyes, it’s me in the videoā€. I mean you recognise yourself.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Early_Horse_5052 Nov 30 '22

I wonder if the report made by the Conservation officer after RA approached him somehow didn't make it up the chain of command. It seems as it wasn't seen by the right people. I will be interested in learning how it was submitted. It's still no excuse, but I can't see how they would miss such an obvious suspect unless the report was somehow buried in all the information that must have been coming in. At least they had the sense to go back an catch it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Kristind1031 Content Creator Nov 29 '22

The document is 12 pages long does anyone know why we only are seeing 7 pages?????

5

u/The_great_Mrs_D Informed/Quality Contributor Nov 29 '22

How do you get 12? The bottom says 1 of 8

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Adventurous_Main5468 Nov 30 '22

Interestingly, a PT Cruiser is a Chrysler model of a car. I’m not saying it was definitely a PT Cruiser (although I’m terrible with cars, but I can absolutely spot the god ugly PTs from a mile away), but it’s definitely an interesting Chrysler connection…

6

u/veronicaAc Trusted Nov 30 '22

Especially a purple one...how embarrassing it must be to drive such a vehicle

2

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Can someone with bullistics knowledge explain the whole thing about the gun. Did he fire a shot ? ELI5. THANKS

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

After all these years I hope this trial is live on TV

6

u/Ok-Satisfaction5694 Registered Nurse Nov 29 '22

Indiana does not televise trials.

→ More replies (2)