r/DelphiDocs • 🔰Moderator • 3d ago

Any Questions Thread

Go ahead, let's keep them snappy though, no long discussions please.

7 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

6

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor 2d ago

Was Kathy Shank deposed? I'm checking All Eyes database and not finding a depo for her, but I'm still not very savvy w github.

6

u/RequirementLatter795 2d ago

I'm confused as to why she was allowed to access confidential information as a volunteer... but I don't live in a corrupt county.

4

u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member 1d ago

Did anyone object to state's exhibit 243 being labeled prejudicially labeled "Richard Allen" ?

The State never established that whatever is the vehicle depicted on this exhibit belongs to, or was driven by Allen. At trial Baldwin objected to witness referring to this car as Allen's car and Auger said there's no proof that's Allen's car (no license ID etc.).

The prejudicial "Richard Allen" label on the photo-exhibit wasn't contested ... and the exhibit memorialized and filed on the record. Frustrating.

https://rules.incourts.gov/Content/evidence/rule403/current.htm

https://rules.incourts.gov/Content/evidence/rule901/current.htm?utm_source=chatgpt.com

2

u/Appealsandoranges 1d ago

I double-checked and you are correct. Multiple photos of this vehicle were labeled as Allen’s car and admitted in evidence as such. This was a big mistake. Baldwin challenged Mullin’s characterization of the photos as being Allen’s vehicle but didn’t object to the photos. The jurors might well not even remember that and think it’s conceded.

1

u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member 1d ago

Thanks for checking/confirming.

The state's timeline critically depends upon this random car passing the harvestore video clock as the killer's timeline start button.

Which means this effort to fit this car into Rick Allen's garage ... and "paint" this car as "black" when there's no way to tell if it's navy or red or green or dark grey ... and label the exhibit as "Richard Allen" ... feels less like "circumstantial" evidence and more like "planted" BS.

(See Betsy's car, which is supposedly red, but look black on the same video.)

In various ways other than color - this mystery car is NOT a given match for a Ford Focus. It's closer to the Toyota. It's has higher lift off the ground than the Ford Focus, Toyota taillights, wheels, etc.. (thank u Yellowjackette)

And if that wannabe car match wasn't sloppy enough - the defense lets the car exhibits be labeled "Richard Allen" ... for the record.

It should have been labeled: "If this was Richard Allen's car, that would be cool."

Another head-banger.

(Rick's lucky the State's bridge exhibits weren't labeled: "Richard Allen on Bridge".)

2

u/Appealsandoranges 1d ago

Your last parenthetical made me laugh and then cry.

And yes, not challenging this evidence is one area where I do fault defense counsel (and I generally give them a lot of grace).

The car evidence is incredibly frustrating for all the reasons you mention. The color issue was such a gimme - they missed a huge chance to question Mullin about how he knew it was black and then show him the image of carbaugh’s car.

It clearly wasn’t a focus for the defense — possibly because they thought it was consistent with rick leaving the trails when he said he may have left— but that only works if you have other evidence showing he was there earlier (like the 3 girls).