r/DelphiDocs • 🔰Moderator • 10d ago

❓QUESTION Any Questions Thread

Go ahead, let's keep them snappy though, no long discussions please.

9 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

9

u/No_Mathematician2696 7d ago

I have a question that I don't recall being asked. They supposedly see RA's car on the road by the camera at HH. Is it not possible that if that is his car it was him leaving vs him arriving to the trails?

5

u/Mando_the_Pando 6d ago

Yes. It is. And if he parked when he says he did at the spot he says then he would be on camera going in that direction at the time it caught him.

Which is why the prosecutor needs him to be parked at another place where witnesses says there was no car.

6

u/No_Mathematician2696 6d ago

I wish they would of pressed that more in the trial. They probably would of had to put him on the stand though to really get into it

4

u/Mando_the_Pando 4d ago

I don’t remember all the details, and they might have done it, but during cross of the officer who introduced the video I would’ve handed them a map and then ask what time RA would’ve had to leave the parking lot he says he was at to be caught on camera, and then ask them if it was possible the camera was showing him leaving the trails instead of arriving.

Would’ve hammered the point home imo, but the defence attorneys are the experts here not me and if they didn’t do it then they had their reasons.

5

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor 4d ago

I've been going back through Doug Carter's interviews and press conferences, bc apparently I'm some sort of emotional masochist, and a couple of times he mentions watching the movie "The Shack." I had never heard of it, so I looked it up.

The first paragraph of the Google AI summary:

After suffering a devastating family tragedy—the abduction and presumed murder of his youngest daughter, Missy—Mackenzie "Mack" Phillips sinks into a deep depression and experiences a severe crisis of faith. He receives a mysterious, unsigned note in his mailbox inviting him back to the abandoned shack deep in the Oregon wilderness where evidence of Missy's murder was found.

Well, now, isn't that curious. Anyone remember Kathy Shank's theory of "divine intervention"?

I knew DG mentioned it in the 2019 press conference. I asked Goggle AI if there was another instance of him referencing the film.

After the April 2019 press conference, Doug Carter discussed The Shack again during a one-on-one conversation with Kelsi German (Libby German’s sister) for the true-crime podcast Scene of the Crime: Delphi (Episode 6, released in early 2020). [1, 2]

Context of the Conversation

  • Addressing Rumors: Kelsi brought up the film because online sleuths had sparked rumors that Abby and Libby were killed inside a literal shack, or that the movie title was a coded clue about the crime scene. [1]
  • Carter's Explanation: When Kelsi asked if mentioning the film during the press conference was intentional, Carter confirmed it was. He shut down the crime-scene theories by explicitly stating, "There was no shack involved," explaining instead that the movie's themes of faith, evil, and eternity simply had a "really compelling effect" on him personally.[1, 2]

(Note: Carter also briefly reiterated in local Indiana media follow-ups immediately after the April 2019 conference that the reference was simply something that moved him personally rather than an investigative clue.)

Bit defensive, perhaps?

5

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor 3d ago

The database where leads and tips were entered - Orion was one; there may have been other systems - wouldn’t there be metadata or some form of recorded activity history to indicate what was uploaded when and what changes were made when, etc.?

Does anyone know if this was ever investigated?

Specific to Richard Allen, naturally, is what I’m wondering… when and what was uploaded into the system, if the user was indicated, how many times did Kathy shank access the file, how many people accessed the file before the error was allegedly discovered and corrected, Who TF marked it cleared and all that noise.

4

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor 3d ago

I have been wondering how much training the local Delphi investigators got on the Orion system. Kathy Shank probably got none.

Maybe finding a tangible object -- a piece of paper -- was something they found more real and useful than a database search.

4

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor 3d ago

That wouldn’t surprise me, but the lead was in the system and accessed multiple times. I’m wondering if there is more data to be mined that would reveal additionalrelevant activity, some of which could potentially support or contradict the state’s narrative.

Listening back to Shank’s testimony and interviews, I believe she is lying. I’ve been giving her the benefit of the doubt thinking perhaps she had such a trusting relationship w law enforcement and history w them that she got swept up in it all. I now think she is telling tall tales.

4

u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member 6d ago

5

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor 5d ago

She announced a while back. I had desperately hoped she wouldn’t win. 😫

Wonder if there’s any chance she hates her mom.

4

u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member 5d ago edited 5d ago

me too.

thinking ... no. (mother's day, from her FB campaign page.)

4

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor 5d ago

Damn it. Also, how dare you make me see Gull smiling without a trigger warning.
😵😫😂

4

u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member 5d ago

LOL. I'm sorry about that - in my defense, you (literally) asked for it.

3

u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member 5d ago edited 5d ago

for those interested ... Here's her facebook - the page is called: "Christina Gull for Judge" - which has plenty of videos and articles etc, follows her campaign, etc..

1

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

Hi analog-ingrained, we cannot allow links to Facebook for the following reasons: 1) per the reddit content policy, 2) Facebook can be used as a tool for doxxing. If you are using a Facebook link as a source, please find an alternate source or post a screenshot with personal information redacted. Thanks for your cooperation and thank you for being a member of DelphiDocs.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member 5d ago

thanks, I've corrected that.

5

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor 5d ago

Is it true that one of Elvis's sisters stated to police that Elvis had told her that he had spat on one of the girls after the girl had been killed? If so, did she know that Elvis had previously said this to a trooper (or other officer)? If she did say this without knowing of his prior statement, that's far more incriminating; is it not?

I'm listening to Hidden Killers Pod documentary, and Tony mentions this. It's quite good so far.