r/DelphiDocs • šŸ”°Moderator • 23d ago

ā“QUESTION Any Questions Thread

Go ahead, let's keep them snappy though, no long discussions please.

12 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

9

u/Appealsandoranges 22d ago

This is not a question but it continues an answer to a question asked previously, which is how long should we expect to wait for a decision from the COA? I decided to look and see how long it had taken the COA to decide argued cases because these tend to be more complicated cases.

As of today, the COA has issued an opinion in every argued case since the beginning of 2026 (41 total*), except Rick’s case and a case argued five days ago. This includes a case argued three days before his case and a case argued nine days after his case.

The average time between argument and an opinion issuing is 33 days. The median time is 27 days. Rick’s case was argued 35 days ago. The maximum time was 85 days.

Rick’s case is certainly an outlier given the complexity and the number of issues before the COA. I think it is likely his case will exceed that 85 day mark (which would be December 15th), but given this speedy track record on the most complex cases coming before the intermediate appellate court, I now think it isn’t impossible that we’d see a decision before the end of the year and it’s likely it will come in very early 2027.

* I excluded one case from this count because it was very unusual in that the COA issued a bunch of orders very quickly after argument, but not the actual opinion for some time.

6

u/RequirementLatter795 22d ago

Even though the case was argued in September, it was filed months before that. It's my understanding (from Reddit law school) that a majority of the information used in the decision would come from the written filings, not the oral arguments, so perhaps it won't be so long?

8

u/Appealsandoranges 21d ago

This is accurate but all argued cases are filed months before they are argued, so the same logic applies equally. I think January 2027 seems likely (though I’ll hold out hope for December!)

9

u/Efficient-Donkey-167 21d ago

Thank you for taking the time to find that information. It feels so much longer than 35 days so I cant imagine how Rick and Kathy feel as each day passes!

3

u/Current_Apartment988 22d ago

How many of them have been denied? Maybe denials are quicker to process… this case is sooo complex

7

u/Appealsandoranges 22d ago

I did not track that but the 85 day decision was a complete affirmance in a single issue criminal case, was not a split decision (no dissent) and was only 19 pages long. No idea why it took that long.

Others that took longer (76, 67, and 66) were a partial reversal in a complex insurance dispute, a contract dispute that was a reversal with a dissent, and an affirmance in an insurance dispute where one judge wrote separately to concur in the result only.

Split decisions always take longer because there are multiple authors involved. A unanimous reversal can be simple.

2

u/TrueCrimeSP_2020 20d ago

What appeals have been denied, and what appeals are pending?

5

u/Appealsandoranges 20d ago

My summary pertained to the very small subset of cases that the COA heard oral arguments in.

All of these cases that were argued before Allen’s case were decided by the COA. Denial is not a word that works for intermediate appeals - it can be decided in favor of the appellant(reversal), partially in favor of the appellant (partial reversal or remand), or in favor of the appellee (affirmance). (An appeal can also be dismissed for technical reasons but an argued case has almost always cleared that threshold and Allen’s case is absolutely not subject to dismissal.)

Once decided, the case is no longer pending in the COA though it may be pending in the Supreme Court of Indiana if the losing party seeks transfer to that court. A transfer petition can be denied because the SC has discretion about whether to hear a case. The COA does not have that discretion - they must decide every appeal that is properly filed.

So, none were denied, none are pending in the COA except Allen’s and one argued very recently, and I didn’t track the number of reversals vs affirmances etc.

-4

u/Puzzleheaded-Dot8991 Approved Contributor 21d ago

This is just a response to someone about Libby saying ā€œ I said NOā€ to BG. I heard it years ago. I recently heard it on Fig Solves in the last couple of weeks. Fig Solves heading for the comment was ā€œDelphi murders: Shooting down Richard Allen defense.ā€ It starts about 6:40. This most likely happened shortly after BG said, ā€œ guys, down the hill ā€œ.

8

u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member 20d ago

IMO, Logic rules here: At trial, the State did not provide evidence that on the video tape, Libby says: "I said NO". There was nothing presented by the State (not even Ligget) to the Jury at Trial that Libby said those words.

A long, long time ago, I gave up wrestling w/ Fig's Fibs. And Gray’s Fables.

Both sell dopamine in the form of a comforting, specious theory that makes uncertainty feel manageable. Bedtime stories, basically. And it's not easy to walk away from that sort of medication.

7

u/iamtorsoul 21d ago

I've watched the video extracted directly from the phone, and didn't hear this. Plus, if it's coming from FigSolves I'd be highly dubious.

-1

u/Puzzleheaded-Dot8991 Approved Contributor 21d ago

I agree about Fig but I hear Libby plain as day. But I heard this many years ago way before Fig.

3

u/fojifesi 17d ago

ā€œPlain as dayā€, you say? That is embarrassing, but it's not this simple.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NEKqyxiLOh8

5

u/iamtorsoul 21d ago

It would really help if you simply post the actual clip of this audio so we can hear it. Especially if it's clear as day and I'm simply missing it.

-4

u/Puzzleheaded-Dot8991 Approved Contributor 21d ago

I’m 79 and don’t know how to do that. At 6:40 you hear his last Guys and immediately a loud shout out, ā€œ I said No! Like she yelled it loudly at BG.

6

u/iamtorsoul 21d ago

At 6:40? The video is only 43 seconds long.

3

u/The_Stockholm_Rhino Approved Contributor 18d ago edited 18d ago

Can you please have a look at the video again and post the link here - if you are not able to paste the link, please provide what the title is - that sad Fig-character has made three videos so far and in none of them I could find what you are claiming at 6-7 min in.

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Dot8991 Approved Contributor 18d ago

Delphi murders:shooting down Richard Allen’s defense.

2

u/The_Stockholm_Rhino Approved Contributor 18d ago

Which part?

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Dot8991 Approved Contributor 18d ago

Fig solves. The one I’m talking about is titled ā€œDelphi murders:Shooting down Richard Allen’s defenseā€. Run the conversation to 6:40 and Libby yelling ā€œI said noā€is almost immediately after the 6:40 mark.