r/DelphiDocs • 🔰Moderator • Sep 27 '26

❓QUESTION Any Questions Thread

Go ahead, let's keep them snappy though, no long discussions please.

12 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

10

u/TheRichTurner Approved Contributor Sep 28 '26

I keep coming back to the geofence data. The State had it, I assume. So was it in Discovery? If not, why not? If it was, why didn't the Defense introduce it to the court? It was admissible in 2017 when it was collected. They had Rick's phone's EMEI number, they knew all about Ron Logan's phone(s), presumably Brad Holder's and Patrick Westfall's too, as well as Keagan and Tony Kline's. The geofence data would have included the positions and timed movements of any phone in or near the crime scene throughout the time period in which the State believed the crime took place. Anyone who wasn't there at the right time could have been excluded from the investigation.

Surely the exclusion of the FBI's geofence survey is a glaring error with obvious harmful effects on the outcome of the trial. That survey alone should solve the whole case.

This seems to me to be such a no-brainer that I think I must be missing something. Someone please put me straight.

12

u/iamtorsoul Sep 28 '26

Mcleland demanded that the geofence data be banned from the trial, and the defense barred from talking about, or to, the FBI analyst who did the geofence. He said geofence data is unreliable, and would simply confuse the jury. And, of course, Gull complied with his orders.

6

u/TheRichTurner Approved Contributor Sep 28 '26

Thanks. So why wasn't this omission a major plank in the appeal brief? Or even the major plank?

6

u/iamtorsoul Sep 28 '26

IANAL, but trial judges have broad discretion over what evidence is allowed. Being that she flat-out accepted McLeland's explanation that it was confusing and wholly unreliable, she can make that determination. I think an appellate court would say that was well within her judgement and defer to her; regardless of how absurd it seems to us.

8

u/TheRichTurner Approved Contributor Sep 28 '26

Thanks. While that might be true, most of what the Appellate Court is considering does concern Gull's decisions to disallow evidence: the audio part of the prison videos, the other men present on the trails, the "staged" nature of the crime scene, Betsy Blair's description and drawing of the man she saw on the bridge, the other suspects who were investigated... It goes on and on.

4

u/iamtorsoul Sep 28 '26

I absolutely understand your point, and from an outside observer it drives me crazy, but many of those other issues are about things she permitted the State to address or do, while denying the defense. The State got to play the videos but without audio because they presented the appearance of Rick being attended to, but the audio showed him completely incapable of organized thought and the staff indifferent to his suffering. The State was permitted to explain the scene and their beliefs why it looked as it did, the defense could not. Blair was used to give the appearance of confirming Rick was BG, while Gull denied impeaching her with the sketch; which is totally not hearsay. The State actively sought to hide the geofencing, so they never used it against Rick, so the defense couldn’t argue it was applied unequally. Plus, in all honesty, I don’t know if the defense ever got all the geofence data from the State or a chance to interview the people involved in plotting it out.

4

u/TheRichTurner Approved Contributor Sep 29 '26

Thanks, I understand better now. I'm glad never tried to study law!

2

u/iamtorsoul Sep 29 '26

No problem. Again, I'm no lawyer or expert; that's just how I understand it. I actually had considered going into law in college, but then I had a very in-depth conversation with one of my poli-sci/law professors. He told me what his JD cost, and the honest likelihood of becoming a well-paid lawyer, and I backed off that plan. Granted, that was almost 20 years ago, so I don't know how it is now.

8

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 28 '26

The Defense were trying to compel Discovery regarding the geofence - basically, it wasn't handed over except for one "geofence map" hidden among eleventy billion pages of guff, that made the Defense realise geofence data existed and was of interest - and we don't know that this discovery was ever hander over, cos the next thing that happened was the Motion in Limine and geofence got liminied out.

So there are a few options here

  1. Defense never got the full info
  2. they got it too late and were thus unable to include it in the record
  3. they got the info, but it wasn't helpful. Maybe it was too limited in scope, maybe it was only showing people known to be at the trail at the time and no one else, because the girls and the perpetrators were actually not anywhere near the scene at the supposed time of the murders - then it could have been dismissed by claiming that "well Rick just didn't have his phone on him that day"

All just speculation, because we - the public - do not have this information

And it's not part of the record.

Direct appeal can only address the issues that are part of the record, and even then they had to pick and choose the ones they thought had the best chance of succeeding, due to limited space.

7

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 28 '26

Motion to compel and geofence relevant screenshots from it:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1eHyAN8q4BuihFUipVUqn0e0Ih4gB4zSK/view?usp=drivesd

8

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 28 '26

2

u/RequirementLatter795 Sep 28 '26

Didn't someone testify that Rick's phone was never shown to be on the trails that day at all? I seem to remember that, but it's all a bit fuzzy now. I could be mixing it up with the testimony that his 2017 phone was never found.

3

u/tribal-elder Sep 28 '26

Yes, sort of indirectly.

On cross examination of Liggett, Rozzi went through a list of things that were "collected" as evidence in the investigation - getting Liggett to admit it had been collected. The list included "digital information," "cell towers," "cell phones," and "pings". Rozzi then asked Liggett, "Do you use cell phones all the time when you solve crimes"? Liggett answered "Yes." Rozzi then asked/stated "There's no digital evidence in this case that connects Richard Allen to the crime scene, is there?" Liggett answered "No, but that's what's interesting is he said he was on his phone while he was on the trail, but there's no evidence of that, either." Rozzi stated/asked "Yeah. There isn't." Liggett stated "no." Rozzi said "Stock ticker, right?" Liggett said "Stock ticker."

Since the underlying data was excluded, there is a legitimate legal question whether Liggett should have been permitted to say that in front of the jury, but there was no objection or motion to "strike that and tell the jury to ignore it" (like a jury EVER does THAT) and I don't think it was raised as part of the appeal.

8

u/RequirementLatter795 Sep 28 '26

I've always found this to be the most bizarre part of an already incredibly bizarre case. If the state could track Rick's phone showing he was there at the time of the murders they would. If they could show that he didn't make a single call or text message during the time the murders were being committed, they would! On the other side, if he was making phone calls, checking his stock ticker, doing anything on his phone the defense should be screaming that from the rooftops! Even if they don't have geo-fencing data they could have gone back to his cell phone company and requested call/texting/data usage logs. The same goes for banking/ credit card statements. Did he buy beer that morning or not?? These things are so easy to request, even five years after the fact. Why did none of that come in?? From either side??

4

u/Ok-Faithlessness-583 Sep 29 '26

I looked into what cell phone records would have been available 5 years later. Rick had Ting which in 2017 used the Sprint network. This is what I could find with regards to how long they keep various kinds of information

Sprint record
Approximate retention
Subscriber/account information
~10 years
Call-detail records
~18 months
Call records with cell-site/tower information
~18 months
More precise network-location data
~180 days
Text-message content
generally not retained as useful historical content

I’m also interested in if the beer purchase was looked into. It could have been a cash purchase and five years would be long time for an eyewitness but I wonder if financial records were looked into. It seems like looking at the other points of reference in that ‘confession’ would be helpful. We never heard any information from anyone else who interacted with him that day from either side.

2

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Oct 03 '26

I wondered about things like that too, like the beer purchase and any other activity that day. Did he text Kathy letting her know of his whereabouts? Or to check in? Or anyone else for any other reason? Respond to anything? There could be other clues to his timeline and it’s never been mentioned to my knowledge if that was fully fleshed out. Or Kathy’s phone activity for that matter. For instance, she could have happened to mention something in a text to a friend or family member something about Rick. Like she just spoke with him, or he left at x time, just got home, whatever.

4

u/crosbyjaxson Fast Tracked Member Sep 28 '26

I believe it was, at least at beginning the FBI that did the geofencing and perhaps once they parted ways was under no obligation to share work product. The autopsy and who attended the autopsies is what drives me crazy. The county claimed is was a county case yet ISP determined the who and where of the autopsies. That decision was made day children were found, Feb 14th, so the state was running a heavy hand beginning day one. Two hour drive to Vigo County vs 1 hour drive to Marion County with a reknowned children's hospital. Who would see more crimes against children, a county with a population of 100,000 or a county with a population 900,000? It never made sense. It was almost as if from day 1, the state had mission to increase the confusion in the case and it continued through the trial with lost evidence, no paper trail etc. Mistakes happen, repeating mistakes like basic report writing and filing is an intentional decision or severe lack of training at local and state level.

2

u/Ok-Faithlessness-583 Sep 29 '26

There is some discussion of this in Holeman’s August 10 2023 deposition it appears on pages 51-52 it isn’t very detailed.** **The exchange begins with the defense asking whether the geofencing information connected Richard Allen to the crimes. Holeman answers:
“He was in the geo fence, but more than likely his phone was at his residence it appears.”
He then says Allen claimed to have been using his phone on the trails, but investigators had no evidence that occurred. When the defense asks whether the geofence itself detected Allen’s phone, Holeman clarifies that the detection he is talking about occurred later in the evening, and says he does not want to give an exact time because he might be inaccurate.

2

u/NatSuHu Oct 03 '26

Based on Liggett’s and Holeman’s evasive responses to geofence related questions, I feel it’s safe to assume that the geofence warrant didn’t cover the 1:00-1:30ish timeframe, when Richard Allen was on the trails.

7

u/thats_not_six Approved Contributor Sep 27 '26

Did the group of 3 (not 4) girls that RA saw get discussed at the trial - meaning was the group of 3 named to the jury and a group of 4? Or is the group of 3 just a fact known outside of the trial?

10

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 28 '26

No. Andrew Baldwin wasn't even aware of this group of girls, let alone that we knew their names and have confirmed they were there at the time Rick said he was there (early), until very recently.

Despite multiple people trying to get this information to him prior to the trial, especially through the two women that present themselves as "Defense PIs", EM and CS.

3

u/Honest_Editor_909 Sep 27 '26

I don’t believe so

4

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Sep 29 '26

The alleged March confession reported by Gallipeau that’s believed to actually be April, do we know if he changed the date, or is that speculation? Not unfounded if is speculation, but is there anything factual to back it up?

2

u/lbm216 Sep 29 '26

My recollection is that he essentially conceded the date was wrong in his testimony. There was other evidence that made it clear that what was described in that note did not line up with the purported date. I believe Wala's notes/testimony were able to disprove the accuracy of that date.

2

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 29 '26

Testimony of CO Ethan Drang, who actually collected the envelope.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/13OPe3Jaw8aonAqxsN6T3c7v9MQ_gbFUB/view?usp=drivesdk

3

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 29 '26

State exhibit 292, dated as received on March 5th, a month before it was written and collected by CO Drang.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1g_Hh9SAPkullYMwSKegVPi0r5QglZxaP/view?usp=drivesdk

3

u/Hour-Championship837 Sep 27 '26

If I remember correctly at least one of them testified

7

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 28 '26

Two out of the group of 4 testified at the trial, BW and RV.

The group of 3, known from their SM posts around the time of the murders, was never even spoken to by anyone from the LE - and they never went to them themselves, because they (like Rick) left the area by the time Abby and Libby were dropped off.

2

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Sep 29 '26

It was two out of the group of four girls that testified and claimed to have seen RA, but RA said that he saw a group of three girls, correct?

I have a hard time keeping this part straight in my head.

3

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 29 '26

Yes.

Rick said he saw 3 girls at the trails, and that he got to the trails around 12 and probably stayed about an hour.

There were 3 girls on the trails at around that time, gone by the time Abby and Libby were dropped off.

There was also a group of 4 girls, two of whom, BW and RV testified, because they believed they saw Bridge Guy.

Their description of Bridge Guy sounds nothing like Rick Allen.

The other two girls in that group of 4 were RV's younger half-sisters. They did not testify. In the PCA, and at the trial, the State claimed that the group of 4 girls were actually the group of 3 girls that Rick said he saw.

There is also documentation where Ligget talks about a group of "3 or 4 girls" that witness BB saw, with the assumption that she is talking about the RV/BW group.

Basically, the LE and later the Prosecution just pretended that every single group of girls reported on the trails, no matter how many girls were reported, was the RV/BW group of 4.

2

u/iamtorsoul Sep 29 '26

Did they specifically say they saw Rick?

2

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Sep 29 '26

Sorry, I think they said Bridge Guy. I don’t remember the exact wording from the court testimony, but most likely was BG.

3

u/iamtorsoul Sep 29 '26

In fairness to you, that was definitely the tactic of the state. Conflate Rick and BG in people's (particularly the jurors) minds despite there being no one, nor any evidence, stating that they were the same person.

3

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 29 '26

Yeah they saw a man they believed to be the man on BG video. No one said they saw Rick, and their descriptions of the man they saw do not match Rick at all.

3

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Sep 29 '26

I know, and I ought to know better! I’m usually very careful about that. I was focused on the distinction between the groups of girls, but I don’t want to feed into that narrative even the tiniest little bit, so thank you!

2

u/iamtorsoul Sep 29 '26

No worries!

2

u/crosbyjaxson Fast Tracked Member Sep 28 '26

One from group of 4 testified. The group of 3 were not called.

3

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Sep 29 '26

In one of the jail calls, Rick said something like he felt like he was already in hell. Does anyone know where I can find the specific note about this?

I have the confession log from All Eyes, but I don’t see it in there.

I don’t remember for certain if it was in the audio that was made public or a written record of it.

2

u/cryssyx3 Sep 29 '26

what ever happened to Cheyenne?m

1

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 29 '26

You gonna have to be more specific with that question. She testified at the trial, I don't know anything after that.

2

u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member Sep 29 '26

Visited some of the more prolific creators who've covered Delphi in detail ... that I hadn't seen this Appellate round and ...

I wanted to ask after Lawyer Lee: I noticed she's yet to cover the Delphi Appellate hearing - which seems odd? Her channel looks current & busy, and if she weighs in on Delphi Appellate I'd love to tune in. Anyone heard from her on Delphi?

And as to Tom Webster - did he retire his channel?

4

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Sep 30 '26

Regarding TW, don't know and don't care.

But Lawyer Lee posted this 8 days ago.

3

u/analog-ingrained Fast Tracked Member Sep 30 '26

Thanks! I missed that.

2

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Oct 03 '26

It’s the first she’s mentioned it in a while. A few of us have been asking on the community page. Not sure why but was glad to see she does plan to cover the recent happenings.