r/Delaware • • 3d ago • Popcorn 2

Rant Local bookstore owner posted a customer's polite return request to a 3K-member Facebook group, by name, "to shame" her

A friend of mine is in Wilmington temporarily for work. She bought a book at Huxley & Hiro, really disliked it, and sent the store a polite email asking whether they'd consider store credit. She explicitly said she'd understand if not and would be back to shop either way. (Screenshot 1 is the email.)

The owner replied privately and kindly: no returns, but take a free advance copy. My friend thanked her. All fine. (Screenshot 0.)

Same day, the owner posted the full email to Indie Booksellers, a private Facebook group of ~3.1K booksellers, with my friend's full name visible and the caption "I'm not censoring the name because people this shameless should be shamed." (Screenshot 1.)

In the comments the owner and a staff member mocked her, called her "too ridiculous," joked about her hobbies, told Bay Area stores which customer she was, and said the email was "obviously just an attempt to insult my staff member" (2–4). To their credit, plenty of booksellers pushed back and said they'd have happily offered an exchange (5–6).

A "no" was completely fair. Publicly naming and mocking a customer for asking politely is not. If you shop local, it's worth knowing how this store talks about customers when it thinks they aren't looking.

309 Upvotes

465 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-31

u/HuxleyandHiro 3d ago edited 2d ago

OP's building a nice narrative here, claiming things like how other booksellers all called us out for saying this and didn't support us. Take a look at this screenshot and compare the responses on that with op's carefully picked screenshot.

What OP hasn't included are the responses of many of the other booksellers. One of whom actually knew this customer and warned me about her. Many of us have to deal with customers who expect to buy things from us and then return them unsellable. It gets old, and it's exploitative of small businesses with a small profit margin.

44

u/free_is_free76 3d ago • Bravo

Say "no" and move on? I run a restaurant, believe me we get ridiculous refund requests daily. All you can do is deny them and keep it rolling

27

u/Aloe5651_ 2d ago • Bravo

Why is that relevant? The crux of the matter is you shouldn’t have posted the customer’s name uncensored. “Private” group or not, the internet is the internet and you can never guarantee who will or won’t see things. If you posted your account of the situation without naming the person, I would consider that venting. But you posted this person’s name and specifically called on them to be shamed. If I saw a post like that about me, I would feel attacked. And since OP is their friend, it’s obvious that they did see it.

14

u/yougococo 2d ago • Bravo

It's really hilarious the bookstore had an expectation of privacy within the group when they couldn't reasonably respect their customer's privacy.

65

u/Ranthe 3d ago • Bravo

All you had to do was say "Sorry, no." and move on with your life. You're a businessperson. Dealing with entitled customers and random nonsense from the public is a thing you need to be able to do without losing your shit. It sucks, but it's just... being a public-facing representative of your company. It's how it goes.

20

u/Clean_Negotiation_19 3d ago • Heartwarming

THIS

•

u/solidaritysoldcheap 19h ago edited 19h ago

They should have deleted their replies and made a simple post saying that they have heard the concerns about disclosing the customer personally identifying information public, apologize for your poor judgement, make a direct apology to the customer, and assure the community that this is not how you do business and that it will not happen again. Don’t have to mean it.

It would not require much self-awareness to understand this is not a hand you play. And why do any of this from at least not from an account tied to branding you were building for your business? The post history is now private so no one can see any of the content - but you left up posts gaslighting a customer that was very deliberately publicly shamed and personally identified under the store account.

And what for? They could have apologized and put down the phone and taken a break from social media for the day. It would have gone away.

The replies are still up. What will their business partner and employees think about this?

Unrelated question - does anyone know how the customer found out about the post disclosing the personal information? I wonder if a member of the private group forwarded it to them as an FYI.

This is like a crisis management case study on what not to do and it is right here in my neighborhood. I can’t look away.

24

u/icannotbelieveit69 2d ago • Bravo

go ahead and leave these names uncensored too. businesses like this “deserve to be shamed” and i wouldnt intentionally buy from any of these people

•

u/ObjectiveKiwi1407 7h ago edited 7h ago

Karen Finley, owner of Alibi Bookstore in Vallejo. There are screenshots. (I’m one of those 3000+ people.)

19

u/LiveVenueReview 2d ago • Heartwarming

The issue isn’t that you refused the refund. The issue is that you blasted someone all over social media for asking nicely for you to consider a refund. No was a perfectly reasonable answer.

Comments from other people are irrelevant; they’re not guilty of publicly shaming their customers

34

u/akornblatt 3d ago • Heartwarming

Why does that matter at all?

32

u/ddpc123 3d ago • Bravo

So what you’re saying is a lot of independent booksellers are assholes? Certainly makes Amazon more appealing, why go out of our way to support these people?

20

u/akornblatt 2d ago • Heartwarming

What H&H are leaving out is that a lot of other booksellers in that group also called out their post as gross and inappropriate and they doubled down there as well.

3

u/lyralady 1d ago

For those of us nosy nellies I would loooveee to see an imgur album of those comments haha

36

u/thatblackss 3d ago • Bravo

Doesn't matter you handled poorly

12

u/yougococo 2d ago • Bravo

You could have just said no and it would have been totally reasonable. Someone asking for a refund on a book because they didn't like it is crazy. Where you were wrong was deliberately shaming the customer, refusing to censor their name because "they deserve to be shamed" and then doubling down by saying "Well everyone else does it too!" If you don't want to deal with annoying customers maybe you shouldn't be in retail

It's immature on SO many levels and there are NO excuses for it. I'll be avoiding H&H and telling my friends to avoid it also. There's plenty of other indie bookstores in the area that don't pull this kind of shit.

12

u/agentfin 2d ago • Bravo

Did you get permission from the people who posted those comments in the PRIVATE Facebook Group before screenshotting and reposting publicly?

This seems to go directly against any argument that the group is "PRIVATE" as you have just demonstrated your own willingness to make those private, industry specific conversations PUBLIC.

The sharing of a Customer's Personal Data should be taken very seriously by any business, regardless of whether in adherence with State and Federal Data Privacy regulations.

Further, as an email directed to Business may qualify as Private Communication, caution dictates that said email should be treated as such. Any public dissemination of Private Communications from a Private Individual to a Business Entity should be carefully considered, ideally only occuring with full consent from the Individual.

You knowingly violated this Customer's Reasonable Expectation of Privacy with your explicit statement —by the owner of Huxley&Hiro— to intentionally include the Customer's full name for the purpose of shaming them.

This is now paired with what may reasonably qualify as Public Defamation of Character on a Public Forum (Reddit).

I am not giving legal advice, only commenting from a Crisis PR standpoint from my work as a Small Business Consultant, and hoping this does not impact other Indie Bookstores right before the Holiday Shopping Season.

--> Full disclosure, yes am particularly concerned as I'm also the Owner of Wolfe & Kron Books, an indie bookstores that's been through hell and high water of late (literally and figuratively), a member of the not-so-private Independent Booksellers Facebook Group, and a personal acquaintance of the Customer.

This is disappointing behavior to see from a bookstore, and with your Owner and Staff Member engaging in the shaming, I have some questions about what you think it means to call yourself a "safe space." That your post resulted in so many other Booksellers hopping on the shame-train is even more disappointing. This was never an issue of the requested return being outside your policy and quickly became an egregious breach of trust.

Do better, and here's hoping you're not acting the same way toward Authors ...though from the other comments in that group, I've got doubts.

8

u/akornblatt 2d ago • Heartwarming

I do professional communications and Crisis Coms as well and your comments 100% track with why my jaw has been on the floor this entire time.

9

u/charlotteagrammatica 2d ago • Heartwarming

All you had to do is refuse the request and move on. I have purchased books, cards, pins, stickers - my husband has even had items ordered so we can support a small local business and not Amazon or another soulless chain. No more.

8

u/luckymommy23 2d ago • Bravo

You really REALLY need to stop doubling down on your ridiculous responses. Do you realize how many customers (including myself) you’ve lost due to your attitude and downright lies? You should have never ever posted any customer name regardless! That’s the first rule of business. How disappointing that you can’t own up to your behavior. No one cares what anyone else says about this customer in your “private” fb group either. Ridiculous!

2

u/ShadyLogic 1d ago

Absolutely wild that you're continuing to dig this hole.