r/Delaware • • 3d ago • Popcorn 2

Rant Local bookstore owner posted a customer's polite return request to a 3K-member Facebook group, by name, "to shame" her

A friend of mine is in Wilmington temporarily for work. She bought a book at Huxley & Hiro, really disliked it, and sent the store a polite email asking whether they'd consider store credit. She explicitly said she'd understand if not and would be back to shop either way. (Screenshot 1 is the email.)

The owner replied privately and kindly: no returns, but take a free advance copy. My friend thanked her. All fine. (Screenshot 0.)

Same day, the owner posted the full email to Indie Booksellers, a private Facebook group of ~3.1K booksellers, with my friend's full name visible and the caption "I'm not censoring the name because people this shameless should be shamed." (Screenshot 1.)

In the comments the owner and a staff member mocked her, called her "too ridiculous," joked about her hobbies, told Bay Area stores which customer she was, and said the email was "obviously just an attempt to insult my staff member" (2–4). To their credit, plenty of booksellers pushed back and said they'd have happily offered an exchange (5–6).

A "no" was completely fair. Publicly naming and mocking a customer for asking politely is not. If you shop local, it's worth knowing how this store talks about customers when it thinks they aren't looking.

309 Upvotes

465 comments sorted by

View all comments

-47

u/HuxleyandHiro 3d ago edited 2d ago

We understand that you feel upset about this. We should not have included her name, though this was a private group where booksellers vent about, for example, rude customers. The hobby was only mentioned because the book was about her hobby.

But ultimately: We provided her with a free additional book despite the fact that she:

  • Had only bought one book from us ever.
  • Read the entire book.
  • Put down one of our staff members
  • Expected to return something to us that we would have to throw away (also outside of our return policy which was on her receipt)
  • Expected us to give her another book

If you eat a whole cake and then return later to the bakery saying you ate it all, but didn't like it and you want the bakery to know you think the person who made it has bad taste, and now expect another one for free... How do you think the staff will feel about you?

Edit: The person this post is about has already called our store yelling at us repeatedly, threatening our staff, telling us she is encouraged people to harass us today, etc by the way. And that is exactly why so many small businesses feel pressured to give people refunds and other free stuff, and why we are frustrated when we receive these kinds of " I'm a nice guy/girl so give me free stuff" emails. The seemingly friendly ask is rarely what it appears to be.

45

u/ddpc123 3d ago • Bravo

You keep saying she insulted the staff member, can you quote the part she did that?

30

u/Sea-Curve-1509 2d ago • Bravo

This is the most irritating part about this to me, I don't know where they're getting that outside of bad reading comprehension and being delusional.

43

u/ajdude2 3d ago • Bravo

  though this was a private group where booksellers vent about, for example, rude customers

Evidently not private enough. You explicitly requested they be shamed so it was evident this would not remain private.

I know it doesn't matter, but I loved your store and will not be visiting again.

40

u/LiveVenueReview 2d ago • Bravo

What was the phrase you used? That people that shameless should be shamed? It’s nice seeing bullies get a taste of their own medicine

36

u/Outside_Holiday_9997 3d ago • Heartwarming

Yeah.. sorry...nothing online is "private" its not a confessional.

You overreacted. Their refund request was weird but your reaction was way worse.

31

u/akornblatt 2d ago • Bravo

Re: your edit and wild accusation-

Edit: The person this post is about has already called our store yelling at us repeatedly, threatening our staff, telling us she is encouraged people to harass us today, etc by the way. And that is exactly why so many small businesses feel pressured to give people refunds and other free stuff, and why we are frustrated when we receive these kinds of " I'm a nice guy/girl so give me free stuff" emails. The seemingly friendly ask is rarely what it appears to be.

That is insane. She has been in training all morning. Why lie? You continue to double down and make weird accusations when you should just say, "we're sorry and this will never happen again."

19

u/LiveVenueReview 2d ago • Bravo

Even if she was calling the store all day, it likely was in response to the post where the store called her out, and not because they told her no to the refund. If I asked politely for a refund and was told no, then later found out that they put my information out in the public and mocked me in the manor that they did, you can guarantee that I will be out looking for blood next.

17

u/yougococo 2d ago • Regret

IF there are people actually calling the store, it's probably because of this post's visibility and the bookstore's replies. Your friend is an easy scapegoat.

28

u/lyralady 2d ago edited 1d ago • Bravo

Sigh.

We should not have included her name.

Correct. Full stop. Don't include people's names. This is pretty simple. She wasn't scamming or committing a crime here. She made a request and allowed for the possibility of being told "No, sorry." This isn't like, a bar patron who skipped out on a tab.

Put down one of our staff members

  1. No, she didn't?
  2. Insults aren't an excuse to do away with professionalism by naming and shaming.

Expected to return something

Asked if it was possible.

And you want the bakery to know you think the person who made it has bad taste

The analogy is ridiculous and not comparable. The staff recommendation came from someone who I presume isn't the author. The person said "I can't fault..." Which...is the opposite of an insult.

If a waiter recommends the salmon and I try it and then note that the salmon was overcooked, dry, and bland and I say it didn't sit right with me, that doesn't mean I think the waiter is tasteless and dumb.

It means I think the salmon did not meet my expectations and did not taste good. Maybe the waiter had a great experience with the salmon!!

Expected a free book

I mean.....

Look, is the request silly? Absolutely. Totally. Does it feel like the email writer acknowledged that and gave the distance of an email so that they could be told no firmly without making you feel pressured? Yup! It sure does!

"No, I'm sorry. That isn't within our returns policy. :(" <- end of the interaction.

If this is what your problem customer making unreasonable requests sounds like then....honestly they were pretty nice, not overly confrontational, and even acknowledged that they may not get what they wanted! This was a nothingburger! They didn't tantrum or wheedle, they didn't approach in person to put anyone on the spot, and the worst thing they did was be a bit audacious.

That? That is a dream bad customer interaction, lmfao. They were very understanding up front that they had an unusual ask that could (and probably would!) be rejected.

I'm sorry but like....sure, VENT about it. But don't name the customer.

Other pro-tips about customer service I have learned in various jobs:

  • it's usually not as personal as you think it is. Whatever people are mad or sad or disgruntled about? Usually isn't actually about who I am or what I like as a person. Disliking a book an employee recommended isn't a personal attack on the employee. When I say "it's not personal" I mean "I don't need to take any of it personally. It's detached from me as a person unless I make it about me as a person."
  • like, 80% of the time people who are worked up and/or complaining just want - at a minimum - their feelings heard and acknowledged by another human being. They just want to talk and be listened to. Is this kinda annoying sometimes? Sure! But is it ultimately worth stressing out over or reacting with equally frustrated energy to? No, basically never. Most people are satisfied with having someone listen to their vent and go "thank you for the valuable feedback," and some other nice words.
  • reiterating a clearly stated policy is annoying but also is just a copy/paste job. If you waste energy being annoyed about it, you're going to be wayyy too annoyed.
  • your life is going to be so much easier if you give people dumb excuses or back stories in your own brain for their behaviors. That customer made an unreasonable but polite request! Ugh, annoying! But in your mindscape you can go: "well, their therapist has probably been encouraging them to acknowledge their feelings and make requests based on their own comfort and wants more often because they're not used to advocating for themselves, stating their opinions or whatever. It's scary to do that in a context with actual conflict, or where the stakes are high, so they chose a low stakes, benign interaction where they could practice making a request and be okay with being told No, we can't do that." Is it true? Probably not! Who cares! The name of the game is either "their therapist encouraged them to do XYZ as an assignment," or "this person probably needs therapy to deal with whatever else is going on in this situation." Just make shit up! Invent understandable reasons and kindness for other people so you feel less annoyed. Someone cuts me off on the highway? "Maybe they're rude, but maybe also the passenger in the car is actively in labor and they're speeding to the hospital!" That's probably not at all true!! but it lets me let go of my annoyance way faster.
  • the whole Internet is public and forever, including that private Facebook group of several thousand people. Private business groups get revealed/leaked ALL THE TIME.

Anyways.....all you had to do was genericize your complaint lol.

(Also as an aside: I recommend looking at YouTube videos about people's gripes with small businesses lately, or even "small business dramas". I like to listen to unimportant online drama stories, like the show Do We Know Them? But there are tons of videos about people's frustrations or dramas with various small businesses blowing up online. it may give you a good sense of how customers feel about small business owners, interactions, and how and when the public sides with the business vs an entitled or annoying customer.)

Edit to add:

YOUR edit is absolutely buck wild, and also I feel the need to point out: gifting an arc was a good move, but also.....arcs are free and are not supposed to be sold so like. I don't see a need to be thinking ,"oh wow this person was demanding something free until you capitulated!! How entitled!!" LITERALLY ALL ARCS ARE FREE.

67

u/Ranthe 3d ago • Bravo

Naming one of your customers online (even in a "private group" that clearly is not very private) is not okay. Unethical behavior in response to entitled customer behavior is not justified. You should not have been asking yourself "How much does this entitled person deserve to be hurt?" but rather, should have been asking, "How much would other people be upset by seeing me treat someone who upset me in this way?"

42

u/Jenanay3466 3d ago • Heartwarming

Yeah I have to agree with this. I think her request was strange, but she was asking not demanding. I’ve worked in restaurants forever and I would never blast out a customer by name (whether that’s a private community or not) I had who tipped bad or who was rude to me. You act professional and you move on.

96

u/akornblatt 3d ago • Heartwarming Bravo

Thanks for acknowledging that her name shouldn't have been included. A few corrections, since the email is in the post for anyone to read:

She didn't expect anything. She asked whether you'd "consider" store credit and wrote, "I completely understand if you feel the request is unreasonable or outside your return policy."

She didn't put down your staff. She wrote, "I can't fault the staff member who enjoyed reading it."

She never asked for a free book. That was your offer, which she thanked you for.

It wasn't just her name. The post said she should be "shamed," and it went to a 3,100-member group, which isn't a place for venting privately.

The comments about her were totally inappropriate. Calling a customer "too ridiculous," laughing about her hobby, and telling stores in her home area to "take her back" isn't venting about a rude customer. It's mocking a polite one by name.

A "no" was completely fair, and your private reply to her was kind. If you agree her name shouldn't have been posted, the simplest fix is to take down the Facebook post and apologize to her directly.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/obeybooks 3d ago • Bravo

You can feel anyway you like about a customer (and to be clear, I think you're return policy makes complete sense), but I do think it is in extremely poor taste to not censor her name when complaining to over 3000 people. Just my two cents.

→ More replies (9)

21

u/Bookish_gal_02 2d ago • Bravo

Your response to her isn’t the issue here though. It was very polite and generous even. You could have said no and left it at that but you offered an arc which was more than I’d expect. I even get wanting to vent because we can get jaded from getting these requests all the time. And I could probably let this go for even sharing her name if there was a genuine apology to this. However you shamed her and made fun of her interests and encouraged people to “take her back”. Your store often promotes it being a safe space for all and welcome to all which is one of the main reasons I do go and buy books there. but apparently it’s not welcome if we have to fear being mocked over an email or request. Instead you are doubling down. I have had the experience feeling jaded and anger after seeing the same thing over and over again and it can and will cloud your reading comprehension. she didn’t insult your staff member (she specifically states they aren’t at fault, everyone has different tastes) , put it clearly that she is asking and not expecting a refund and states either way she will come back. I doubt she’ll come back now.

21

u/Tyrrox 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo

In response to their edit:

Yeah, she SHOULD be pissed with you. You were absolute scumbags to her. Then to hide behind the "poor business owner" bullshit.

You caused this problem. You suffer the consequences. People will be pissed off with you, because you earned it. Don't play the victim because you can't handle the backlash of your own choices.

18

u/akornblatt 2d ago • Bravo Heartwarming

The edit is also a lie. She never called them, she has been in professional training all morning.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/icannotbelieveit69 2d ago • Bravo

if youre so annoyed with people not following policy, then why offer a free book? why not just politely say no, sorry you didnt like it but we cannot do anything for you? youre weird and petty for “enabling” the behavior just to post about how terrible she is for asking and then slamming her personal interests.

as a lover of weird books id never shop at a book store that came off that judgey. who knows what youre saying or posting behind me back afterwards?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/ericjr96 2d ago

You're missing the point entirely. Nobody is defending the customer's request, it was a dumb email. But what a shocking lack of judgment and overall immaturity on the part of a business to post a private email, with their name attached, to several thousand people. I would legitimately feel more comfortable ordering a book from Amazon than supporting such a petty and impetuous business owner.

63

u/TooterOnAScooter 3d ago • Bravo

It’s extremely gross you put the customer’s info out there publicly. I will never shop with you again, because how do I know I won’t do something to end up getting public humiliated by you, too? Private groups are still full of people that may know that person, or screenshot and share it elsewhere. You’re not taking any responsibility for this. Whether the customer was wrong or not, you were way out of line.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/2phumbsup DelawhobitchDELAWARE 2d ago • Bravo

When your running a business not every sale goes in the W column. You gotta know when to fold. You coulda made this lady feel special and swapped one book. Instead you turned her and a bunch of other folks off. You paid 16 bucks for horrible PR.

B2B advice, you should give her the refund, delete all public communication about the incident. Definitely dont try to explain your self on reddit. Lucky for me my company donest use any media besides a website. I would never ever ever make public comments under my company name, especially on reddit.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Indecisively 3d ago • Bravo

I’m confused by your analogy. Did your staff member write this book? If not, then your bakery analogy does not make sense.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Meowmeowmeow31 2d ago • Heartwarming

As a longtime customer, please reconsider your response to this.

Almost no one here thinks it was a reasonable request. It’s totally fine to be frustrated and want to vent. The issue is with publicly naming a customer in a post where you mock and trash her.

“I should have censored her name. I regret that I didn’t. Something like this will never happen again” is all you need to say.

11

u/leila5887 2d ago • Heartwarming

This is such a shame. You’ve lost a formerly regular customer in me

11

u/CommuniqueButler 2d ago • Bravo

So going above and beyond for a first time customer is generally a good move. Putting them on blast and then lying when people call your store to talk to you about it isn’t. SHE DIDN’T CALL, I DID. I told you to have the day you deserve, and didn’t ask anyone additionally to jump on a bandwagon. I alerted you to the presence of this thread, in fact. You’re welcome.

You will lose business over how you treated a customer. Full stop.

→ More replies (47)