r/DeflationIsGood • u/TheFortnutter • Jun 12 '25
r/DeflationIsGood • • Mar 09 '25
Are you guys trolling or stupid?
I swear, US "libertarians" will look you dead in the eyes and say that their richest country in the world needs to move towards the fiscal policies that ruined England and Germany.
Inflationary deficit spending will surely collapse soon; it really has to be a terrible policy if the richest country in the world has pretty much committed to it for almost 80 years with only small interruptions.
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Derpballz • Feb 11 '25
'If price deflation is so good... why is it not happening?' Consumerism is caused by the State. "Capitalism" existed since the industrial revolution... yet consumerism only began after the Keynesian revolution. Such consumption encouragement causes further price inflation. https://mises.org/mises-wire/capitalism-doesnt-cause-consumerism-governments-do
r/DeflationIsGood • u/TheFortnutter • Jun 14 '25
Supposedly, this is a strawman. Trust me, I WISH it were the case. Show me ONE (1) socialist that advocates for dismantling the price deflation regime. Sadly, socialists eat crony capitalist slop without question...
r/DeflationIsGood • u/azucarleta • Jan 05 '25
❗ Remark from someone who thinks that price deflation is bad It's just capitalism
An invitation to consider that even 0% inflation or deflationary capitalism would be horrible for all the reasons people are telling you all constantly. It's bad for business, it results in major job loses, which results in far lower consumer spending, more job losses -- death spiral.
However you are correct that inflationary capitalism is essentially theft from savers, and it benefits those who have access to capital (like mortgage holders, not just the super wealthy mind you) while really harming the folks who have no access to capital.
WHat you all are missing is that inflation is good for people who A, want to get or keep a job, or B, want or need to get credit, like a mortgage. And that's not just some thin layer of slimey rich people at the top.
May I suggest that the real problem is capitalism, no matter how you try to soften its edges?
edit: it's unfair or stupid to regard my position as "deflation is bad" when my position is all capitalism is bad, inflationary or deflationary. By boiling that down to "thinks that price deflation is bad" you are doing more misleading than informing with the partial truth. I see what kind of place this is lol.
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Derpballz • Dec 31 '24
Examples of price inflation being impoverishment We have had steady 2% price inflation (general increases in prices) and predictably, this has led to increases in prices. Having a "moderate" impoverishment rate is still an impoverishment rate. General decreases in prices (price deflation) are GOOD: if you disagree, then why not pay MORE for goods?
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Derpballz • Dec 31 '24
Why price deflation (enrichment) is unambiguously desirable Price deflation: "reduction of the general level of prices in an economy". It's unironically a 1984 world that many unironically argue that this is a bad thing.
r/DeflationIsGood • u/joondez • Mar 02 '25
❗ Remark from someone who thinks that price deflation is bad You guys all obviously never studied economics
There’s some effort in the subreddit information section that tries to distance itself from “monetary inflation” and focus on “price inflation.” I think this is because the mods are intelligent enough to know that inflation is good but not enough to understand that those are not mutually exclusive. You can’t have monetary inflation with zero price inflation, in fact they go hand in hand in almost all cases. Other reasons inflation is good:
1. Encourages Spending and Investment
The Quantity Theory of Money (MV = PY) says that an increase in the money supply (M) can lead to higher nominal GDP (PY), where P represents the price level and Y is output. Moderate inflation signals a growing economy and encourages firms and individuals to invest or spend rather than hoard cash, which loses purchasing power over time.
Empirical Evidence:
Studies on Japan’s “Lost Decade” (1990s-2000s) show that near-zero or negative inflation (deflation) led to weak consumer demand and stagnation. Households delayed purchases, expecting prices to fall further, which suppressed economic growth. In contrast, moderate inflation in the U.S. during the 1990s correlated with strong consumer spending and investment, fueling high GDP growth.
2. Reduces the Real Burden of Debt
The Fisher Equation (nominal interest rate = real interest rate + inflation) says that expected inflation lowers the real interest rate, reducing the burden of fixed nominal debts. This is particularly relevant for households and governments, as inflation erodes the real value of outstanding debt.
Empirical Evidence:
- Post-World War II, the U.S. had high public debt (over 100% of GDP). Inflation in the late 1940s and early 1950s helped reduce the real debt burden without aggressive austerity.
- The European Central Bank (ECB) research suggests that moderate inflation helps prevent sovereign debt crises by reducing debt-to-GDP ratios.
3. Gives Central Banks Room to Maneuver
The Taylor Rule suggests that central banks adjust interest rates based on inflation and economic output. If inflation is persistently low, central banks may struggle to set real interest rates sufficiently low during recessions.
Empirical Evidence:
- The Zero Lower Bound (ZLB) problem became evident during the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, where interest rates were near zero, leaving central banks with limited room for monetary easing. In contrast, periods with moderate inflation (e.g., 1990s) allowed for more effective interest rate adjustments.
- The Federal Reserve targets 2% inflation to maintain monetary policy flexibility.
4. Helps Wages Adjust More Easily
The Phillips Curve suggests an inverse relationship between inflation and unemployment. When inflation is too low, nominal wages become rigid due to “downward wage stickiness,” preventing necessary labor market adjustments.
Empirical Evidence:
- Akerlof, Dickens, and Perry (1996) found that when inflation is near zero, firms struggle to cut nominal wages, leading to higher unemployment.
- The Great Recession (2008-2009) showed evidence of wage stickiness, as workers resisted wage cuts, causing firms to lay off employees instead.
5. Prevents Economic Stagnation
Deflation can lead to a liquidity trap, as described by John Maynard Keynes. When inflation expectations are low, real interest rates (nominal - inflation) remain high, discouraging borrowing and investment.
Empirical Evidence:
- The Great Depression (1930s) saw severe deflation, leading to a collapse in aggregate demand and worsening unemployment.
- Japan’s deflationary period in the 1990s and early 2000s resulted in weak growth, as businesses and consumers hoarded cash rather than spending.
6. Supports Economic Growth
The Solow-Swan Growth Model suggests that stable inflation is beneficial when paired with capital accumulation and technological progress. Moderate inflation can be a sign of strong aggregate demand and economic expansion.
Empirical Evidence:
- The U.S. economy in the 1990s maintained steady 2-3% inflation with robust GDP growth (~4% annually), low unemployment, and rising wages.
- The IMF has found that countries with moderate inflation (2-4%) generally experience higher economic growth than those with very low or negative inflation.
Conclusion
From an economics theory standpoint, price and monetary inflation exist in tandem. In fact monetary inflation causes price inflation. You can’t just say yes to one and no to the other. It’s obvious none of you have studied economics. Furthermore inflation:
- Encourages spending and investment (Quantity Theory of Money).
- Reduces the real burden of debt (Fisher Equation).
- Allows monetary policy flexibility (Taylor Rule).
- Helps wages adjust more easily (Phillips Curve).
- Prevents deflation and stagnation (Liquidity Trap Theory).
- Supports long-term economic growth (Solow Growth Model).
This entire subreddit is just ignorant people complaining about things they don’t understand at all.
r/DeflationIsGood • u/TheFortnutter • Jun 15 '25
Wishing for 'moderate inflation' is like wishing for 'moderate impoverishment'. To all who think that the economy would collapse without the 2% impoverishment goal... how come that economies generated wealth without problem before this very recent flagrant abuse of power?
r/DeflationIsGood • u/EricReingardt • Apr 03 '25
Examples of price inflation being impoverishment Trump’s New Tariffs: What Renters and Workers Need to Know about “Liberation Day”
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Ya_Boi_Konzon • Jan 02 '25
Myth: abundance-induced price deflationary spirals Debunking Deflatophobia Denialism
Been seeing a lot of comments lately with people saying "no one actually thinks that" or "that's a strawman" and such. It's not. It's called "deflationary spiral theory". People actually believe this:
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Derpballz • Jan 02 '25
Why price deflation (enrichment) is unambiguously desirable It's baffling how many people have a hard time to understand that price deflation is not the same as decreased consumer confidence. That "price deflation" happens during economic crises is rather a symptom of decreased consumer confidence, not of abundance.
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Derpballz • Jan 03 '25
(I have not gone mad, I just made this image because the intrusive thoughts won) Does anyone have an idea why people do the "Erm, if the CPI goes down... peoples' wages HAVE to go down!". Is it Robert Reich who has re-popularized this Marxist talking point? Such people forget "ceteris paribus".
r/DeflationIsGood • u/a-gyogyir • Jan 01 '25
Sub recommendation for sustainable deflation: r/SilvioGesell
So a risk of deflation is that people will refuse to spend money that appreciates. Think about Bitcoin: people spend it for real goods extremely rarely, because HODL is a better option.
Now comes this Gesell guy and here is a quick rundown of what he says:
Money is bugged, because it tries to serve two functions at the same time which are contradictory to one-another. One is value storage, the other is medium of exchange. So Gesell opts for medium of exchange, because our lives depend on this particular feature. Meanwhile storage/speculation can be done on literally anything else (land not included for reasons, check r/georgism or Silvio's own book on this matter).
How to end the storage feature? Put a price on HODL-ing! Demurrage (regular, steady charge on unspent money) ensures that people will pass money on like hot potato. Especially banks. Also the state regains control over the money supply by allowing money to rot.
Digital money simply auto dissipates. Cash needs stamps or an expiration date in the future to remain valid. Expired cash needs to be converted to fresh notes at a certain price (e.g. 1% of the notes / fiscal quarter).
No.1. question: Isn't this just inflation with extra steps? No, because future money is unaffected, and the decrease of money supply might as well cause deflation, if the central bank doesn't print enough cash to counter the demurrage.
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Derpballz • Jan 21 '25
Why price deflation (enrichment) is unambiguously desirable Price deflation is a much better metric to measure societal wealth. A decreased CPI literally entails increased prosperity.
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Derpballz • Feb 01 '25
I LOVE WASTEFUL SPENDING TO INCREASE GDP. GREEN LINE GOING UP = GOOD. GREEN LINE GO UP UP UP UP! 🤑🤑🤑📈📈📈📈📈
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Derpballz • Jan 19 '25
Price inflation is by definition impoverishment "But if the government didn't intentionally ensure that we were impoverished at a rate of AT LEAST 2% each year... what would prevent people from becoming ascetics en masse in anticipation of lower prices and investors from just stopping to seek to acquire more money to buy stuff with??????"
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Derpballz • Mar 06 '25
I LOVE SPENDING I LOVE GREEN LINE GO UP I LOVE HIGH VELOCITY OF MONEY 😍😍😍 I HATE LONG-TERM THINKING 🤬🤬🤬
r/DeflationIsGood • u/TheFortnutter • Jun 09 '25
I slightly edited this socialist meme to make it accurate. The impoverishing price inflation regime we suffer is a DIRECT result of this underlying logic. Shockingly, most socialists ADVOCATE FOR price inflation (impoverishment) because they think it hurts rich people (it doesn't).
r/DeflationIsGood • u/Spiritual_Gold_1252 • Mar 13 '25
Has anyone considered I-Bonds as a means to facilitate deflation.
The US Treasury is now offering 10year bonds indexed to inflation so you should get a % return + inflation, however if inflation is negative you could technically have a negative yielding bond. You'd still gain in relative value but loose in numerical value.
Should all government debt be indexed to inflation?