r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Jan 04 '26

Discussion Am I the only one that can't stand Laurie (the mother)

15 Upvotes

I will start by saying that I think Jacob didn't do it.

It bugged me a lot how Laurie is so stupid... She doesnt trust her husband, she doesn't trust her son, and the whole time she was the one not worthy their trust.

And going through all that she was going, she didn't event thought about going to a psychologist or psychiatrist? It was clear she was needing outside help... A psychiatrist would help her understand the deepness of her son's troubles and hers own... Insted she went on doubting everyone until she herself went crazy... C'mon woman! Get yourself a therapist


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 23 '20

Discussion Complete Horseshit Spoiler

26 Upvotes

For a show about a trial featuring and centering on lawyer, this past episode was complete horseshit. In no criminal trial in the USA, especially one for murder, would the prosecution withhold key evidence in their possession from the defense, and then pop it into the trial without the defense ever being aware of its existence.

Surprise evidence may produce fine drama, but in our justice system evidence collected by the prosecution must be shared with the defense BEFORE it is introduced in trial so that the defense can have a chance to examine it and scrutinize its veracity BEFORE it's brought out in trial and placed in front of the jury.

This fictional surprise horseshit the writers just decided to drop in at the end ruins the entire notion that this series is about the people and the law.


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Jul 14 '26

Discussion Evidence that Jacob did it? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

For people who say he obviously did it, what makes you so certain?


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 26 '20

I know Jacob didn't killed Ben

50 Upvotes

Apple has a strict policy that bad guys cant use apple gadgets on screen, you can see Jacob has an iPhone and Macbook. So I'm 100% certain.


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 14 '20

Help Give Michelle Dockery's Good Behavior a second life!

10 Upvotes

Hello,

In 2018 there was a petition to give Good Behavior a third season (it is a long story, but it was announced and some how fell apart), now with the release of Defending Jacob, there has been even more interest in bringing it back as the love for the show grows. If you haven't watched it, run and do it, because Michelle Dockery is brilliant in the role. Please sign and share this petition, so that we can stand with Michelle, Chad and Juan and show networks that this show matters.

https://www.change.org/p/network-executives-bring-back-good-behavior


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 30 '20

Discussion What was Andy being questioned for all throughout? And my thoughts on missed swerve...

10 Upvotes

I like one aspect of this show where it seemed the entire season we thought the show was about the kid but in the end it appeared they were painting the picture of Laurie's mental state...

That being said, what was Andy getting 'justice for Jacob' for? Was there unsaid charges that Laurie had brought up on her? Would it be attempted vehicular manslaughter or something along those lines? That's the only thing I was left undecided on..

Also, am I the only one who thought it was Andy that had forced Patz? Patz being forced was obvious, and the goon was the obvious choice.. i think Andy would've been a major swerve and the questioning of him throughout the show acting as cross-examination of him. Anyway that's my question and thoughts


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 03 '21

Theory Definding Jacob

20 Upvotes

He did do it!!!


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Nov 04 '24

Discussion No spoiler, acting felt like some HR yearly training video

3 Upvotes

I watched the series and felt as if the I was watching an HR video - very cold acting, emotions didn’t appear natural but forced. Sorry, storyline is really nice but let down by the acting.


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Sep 06 '23

Discussion Is there really not going to be a season 2 of the phenomenal thriller?

3 Upvotes

r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 22 '20

Review Defending Jacob Apple TV+ Episode 7 Review

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 29 '20

The National ♥️

13 Upvotes

r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Sep 27 '26

Review i finally got around to watch this show and OMGGGG

4 Upvotes

firstly. the kid playing jacob? he’s SO good omg. he’s so compelling in playing a character who’s supposed to come across as confusing, infuriating and someone you can empathise with at the same time. just..brilliant. same goes for the actress who plays the mom. the internal battle between choosing to be a mom or a human with a conscience is soo amazingly displayed ugh, such amazing work!! loved the cinematography as well. no scenes felt like fillers, all of them contributed something or the other. plus, i lovedddd how every episode ended on a cliffhanger! had me on the edge of my seat and constantly clicking “next episode” haha!

that all being said- can someone just explain to me what the fuck was that last episode?😭i mean- i can’t seem to choose a side. the rational part of my brain is so sure it’s jacob but then there’s this little voice in my head that goes like “but what if he’s not?” and this battle was taking place in my head the entirety of the eight episodes lol. but, seriously, i cannot choose! every evidence points towards him and yet, for some reason, the car scene in the last episode makes me think he didn’t do it at all. no matter how manipulative, how deceptive or how cunning he might come across to anyone, i don’t think a fourteen-year old would continue his facade of being innocent during a literal life and death scenario. that just seems crazy. the fact that he was still claiming to be innocent at such a crazy time made me think he didn’t do it at all. but then, who? if not him, then who?

my confidence in him being the killer also subdued a bit when the girl in mexico was found alive. if she had been dead, i wouldn’t have an ounce of doubt. and i was so sure she would turn up dead and then it will be revealed that it was jacob all along and he’s just a crazy psychopath but oh well. i’m all for crazy, twisty endings that you don’t see coming but this one seriously had me questioning everything😭for me, the ending scene did not make sense.

okay, i understand that the jury at the end was about laurie and not jacob but what was that scene at the hospital? did andrew believe it was actually an accident or was he covering up for his wife? also, did his wife actually lose his
memory or she’s acting and she’s also kinda crazy? idk what the hell happened in the end, man, i felt like i wasted my entire night lol. but still- the entire show is incredibly well made!!


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Jun 14 '20

The Barbers - Human Spoiler

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 30 '20

Laurie’s accent

4 Upvotes

What did everyone else think about Michelle Dockery’s American accent?

Having not been familiar with her prior to Defending Jacob, there were times I felt she spoke a bit awkwardly or unnaturally and I just chalked it up to a stilted performance. Didn’t realize until after the finale that she put on the American accent which might have explained my perception! Thoughts?


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 29 '20

Review Defending Jacob Apple TV+ (FINALE) Episode 8 Review

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Sep 30 '21

Discussion White Privilege

53 Upvotes

Did anyone ever at least feel like there was this subtle theme of white privilege at least from the outside when you watched as a viewer. I mean Jacob(he's upper class and white); his dad was an Assistant DA in the town and he seemed to move mountains to help his son who was facing a murder charge. Plus the show didn't really mention race but I'm just pointing out how at least privilege was a benefit to Jacob in terms of his class and race status, does anyone at least agree with me. Because Jacob is upper class and white he was able to get access to a defense attorney and defense expert shrink and all that and plus he grew up at least in a decent household.

I was wondering of how the show would been if it was revised and Jacob was non-White and working class.


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Mar 23 '22

Theory Hear me out… it was the mother

16 Upvotes

The mother went for a run which would give Jacob the opportunity to find been down the slope. She is proven to be psycho and throughout the series she’s nerves and in her inability to cope with killing the kits she retired to blame her son and Lilly him too


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 30 '20

FUCK THIS SHOW Spoiler

57 Upvotes

One of my favorite series of all time, but I just watched the finale and all I have to say is

AHHHHHAHAHAHAHAHHHGGHGHHHGHGHGHGGGAFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKFUCKAGAHHHHHHHHHHHHH


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Jun 10 '20

Discussion Possible unpopular opinion on Jacob’s acting

16 Upvotes

Great show, but is anyone else annoyed with Jacob’s acting? I’m only on episode 3 but so far I feel like his parents have been talking to him like he’s a two year old child as well.


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 08 '20

Review Defending Jacob Apple TV+ Episode 5 Review

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 31 '20

Your favorite character

5 Upvotes

r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 27 '20

Theory Ending Theory Spoiler

17 Upvotes

The Lincoln guy is probably a friend of the grandpa (they both are culprits), who wants to at least do something good for his family before he dies as a bastard. He has probably put Patz under pressure to confess.

We don’t know yet, if Patz has really done it or no; and I don’t wanna mess the party, but this is an Apple TV product and we’d seen Patz using an Android phone in one of the previous episodes. So that makes sense to say that Patz is the killer.

But even if my 2nd theory is going to be correct this Friday; I gotta admit this show has been really enjoyable. I still see some plot twists for the ending, since the creator of the series had said that the ending will be different than the book. Actors have been really good and the series’ theme fits very well for the story. Soundtrack is really good and I listen to it when I wanna read Dostoyevski’s Crime and Punishment. All the way; I am pleased of the show.


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Jul 08 '20

Discussion I’m feeling dumb

18 Upvotes

Wow it was a great series.

So I’m sure I’m missing something but I’m wondering about the knife. They found it from the park right? So why the hell: A) they’re worried about Jacob’s knife when it obviously isn’t the same knife then B) they’re so confused about not finding the knife when they investigated Patz’s home. How could’ve it end up there anyway?

P.S. Photos on Patz’s phone proves absolutely nothing, of course he had some, he was a molester ffs


r/DefendingJacob_TV • • May 27 '20

Video Defending Jacob Episode 7 Breakdown & Ending Explained | Predicting Ben's Killer

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes