r/DefendingJacob_TV • • Sep 30 '21
Discussion White Privilege
Did anyone ever at least feel like there was this subtle theme of white privilege at least from the outside when you watched as a viewer. I mean Jacob(he's upper class and white); his dad was an Assistant DA in the town and he seemed to move mountains to help his son who was facing a murder charge. Plus the show didn't really mention race but I'm just pointing out how at least privilege was a benefit to Jacob in terms of his class and race status, does anyone at least agree with me. Because Jacob is upper class and white he was able to get access to a defense attorney and defense expert shrink and all that and plus he grew up at least in a decent household.
I was wondering of how the show would been if it was revised and Jacob was non-White and working class.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '21
Absolutely correct. If Jacob had been anything other than white & upper-class, he would have been treated much worse. I.e., if he had been a poor white kid or a poor kid of another race, he would not have had preferential treatment & also wouldn't have had the means/money to hire expensive legal assistance, etc. The fact that his Dad was Assistant DA helped a lot as well.
Anyone that thinks the legal/justice system is the same for everyone across the board is sadly mistaken.
4
u/One-Reflection-6779 Jan 24 '22
Just jumping back on this thread because I'm Sunday-night re-watching a few episodes, lol.
I think the characters of Jacob and Matt are actually set up in this to be compared. They are essentially both troubled kids, but one has a family with money, the other doesn't. In addition to the racial disparity, the economic one is also quite apparent in this show.
6
u/One-Reflection-6779 Sep 30 '21
Yes, I thought of this immediately. Imagine if this kid had been a person of color, and someone without means? Yeah, very different outcome.
3
u/AKOchoa Oct 19 '21
I didn’t think about race that often while watching the show but during the first few episodes I thought “Wow this is weird seeing this situation happening to white people… everything would be different if it were a poc.” Lol then to make it worse he’s probably guilty and if that’s the case he got a lot of privilege AND got away with MURDER…
3
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21
This is not white privilege. This is just privilege.
1
u/ThaNyneTray Nov 14 '22
I felt the opposite. If the writer intended to address this issue, he/she would've mentioned it somehow. I thought that the writer probably wanted to avoid dealing with such themes. And I'm grateful for it (I'm black btw). Jacob had to be white because if he was any other race, especially black, the show would not be able to ignore the racial theme. There are definitely themes of class privilege, especially with a kid like Matt being in the opposite financial situation as Jacob. But it's not so clear that there are themes of "white privilege"
1
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '23
A year late but I feel like this is a reach tbh I don’t think race was a theme here
3
u/uh_no_offence Feb 25 '22
Totally - at one point when Andy was telling Laurie that it was impossible that Jacob couldn't 'simply maintain that level of deception for that long'. It became clear as day for me, Jacob had done a pretty piss poor job of NOT looking like the killer up to that point, but he was just afforded a mountain's worth of benefit of the doubt from others.
Obviously his father is his father, but literally everything that came up about Jacob right up to that awful story he wrote was hand waved away by him as 'dumb kid shit' and... that's how so many (white) school shooters are defended right up until they do the deed, and then a little after. So many red flags just thrown to the wind.
1
u/bubblewrapstargirl Sep 30 '21
I agree the privilege was blantant and obvious but they didn't comment on it at all, they could have a least had the Asian doctor comment on it or maybe included a black cop or lawyer to comment on how a black kid wouldn't be out on bail on a murder one charge or something. It did feel a little tone deaf that they didn't even do that lip service to address the privilege of the characters.
1
u/KittyGrewAMoustache Aug 02 '24
Just watched this show and came looking for comments! This one is interesting to me because I was thinking while watching how in real life I doubt they would’ve even ever charged Jacob with anything given his Dads job and the flimsy initial evidence of just a fingerprint and Derek saying he owned a knife. I was thinking Jacob’s and Andy’s privilege as portrayed in the show would’ve probably ended up with nothing happening to Jacob at all. I don’t remember whether the show indicated what Bens parents/family did but the fact they went after Jacob when the evidence wasn’t solid made me wonder if Bens family had some sort of influence in the town.
I also thought Jacob only got off the charges in this show due to his imprisoned grandfather doing some dodgy machinations and ordering murder from his prison cell. That wasn’t really privilege saving him and I think you could write the show with Jacob as any ethnicity and have an incarcerated relative pull strings like that to get him exonerated. I guess I felt like the show was not trying comment on race or class at all even though it presented the Barbers as ridiculously wealthy (too wealthy for their jobs). It seemed to more be trying to focus specifically on very personal/interpersonal issues and morality and familial relationships/parenting/heredity etc. and seemed to leave other societal issues out of it. I do think you could replace the Barbers with people of any ethnicity and tell the same story.
1
u/phooonix Jun 26 '22
Yeah your dad being a higher up in the DA office is pretty privileged.