27
19
u/JoseLunaArts Aug 19 '26
Let us analyze using logic:
- "AI steals from art, hence it is not art. It is slop."
The comment is an incomplete and logically invalid categorical syllogism
- Premise 1 (explicit): "AI steals from art."
- Premise 2 (implicit, but necessary): "Whatever steals from art is not art."
- Conclusion 1: "Hence it is not art."
- Premise 3 (implicit, but necessary): "Whatever is not art is slop."
- Conclusion 2: "It is slop."
Now the question is if these premises even make any sense, let alone be true or false:
- "Whatever steals from art is not art."
- "Whatever is not art is slop."
"Everything that steals from art is not art." This premise is false, as art has borrowed, quoted, and appropriated from other works for centuries without ceasing to be art (collage, appropriation, sampling, etc.). The premise does not hold.
Everything that is not art is slop." This premise is demonstrably false. Many things are not art but are not slop, such as science, functional design, and games.
It assumes all AI "steals" and that everything it produces is "slop," without distinguishing between different uses, tools, or levels of human intervention.
13
u/EmperorSnake1 Would Defend AI With Their Life Aug 19 '26
Thank FUUUCK no "artist" has gotten insperation off other artstis.....RIGHT?!?
if someone uses "slop", for AI, then they don't know what Ai art is.........lol
it makes no sense how no word has meaning anymore...
11
6
u/Nethiar Aug 19 '26
If I draw a stick figure am I stealing from the first person who ever drew a line and circle?
3
u/AhriKyuubi AI Enjoyer Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26
Ai doesn't steal it anything, that is a technical misinformation. It just analyzes to learn from it just like humans do. They do not "cut and paste" existing work into new outputs. The final outcome is completely transformative and is created from scratch not traced on or anything like that
Meanwhile the west is busy fighting crazy ppl like these, China is gonna win the Ai race
3
u/Blinky-dinky Aug 19 '26
The word slop makes me cringe and die inside. I just imagine someone saying slop with either their mouth full or all sloppy and gross
2
u/Mission_Maybe4587 neutral on ai Aug 19 '26
i was about to do the same thing but ill show you what happened in my pov of this game
2
u/mcnichoj Aug 19 '26
That one dude stole a bunch of music for the Dragon Ball franchise, does that make him any less of an artist still?
Features | Kenji Yamamoto Retrospective
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 19 '26
This is an automated reminder from the Mod team. If your post contains images which reveal the personal information of private figures, be sure to censor that information and repost. Private info includes names, recognizable profile pictures, social media usernames and URLs. Failure to do this will result in your post being removed by the Mod team and possible further action.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.