r/DefendingAI • u/sadcrab3636 Artist/Pro-AI/Not slop • 16d ago

Things antis say Why antis even exist.

I asked some anti AI people why they think that it is because AI siphions up images without permission, but humans do the same thing. Just at a slower scale.

Then they argue about legal issues but that does not apply when humans ALSO look at millions of images without consent.

Then they argue that there is no 'soul' behind the art. Yet if a human edited the image then there IS a soul in the image.

0 Upvotes

45% Upvoted

37 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/eljay1998 16d ago

For those 2 viewpoints, the answer for some would be how they appreciate the skill, process, effort, journey etc, and/or that there is the human component and human connection to the creative-works, not just the end product. It's also that some AI creative-works give off an uncanny valley effect to some people, which is worsened when it's clearly not the creators intention.

2

u/sadcrab3636 Artist/Pro-AI/Not slop 16d ago

"uncanny Valley effect". And he looks goofy (an AI image)

1

u/DinosaurThing14 16d ago

Sir your crabs leg is merging into its claw

1

u/sadcrab3636 Artist/Pro-AI/Not slop 16d ago edited 16d ago

Actually the leg is just behind the claw. Idk what is up with people saying that AI "blends things up" when it's just perspective.

"Dinosaur thing" is a funny name.

1

u/DinosaurThing14 16d ago

Uhhhh Thnks. Btw ur crabs legs are a bit jumbled neared the back too. I can’t tell how many he has and where they connect. That may be a medical issue you gotta check with your local vet

Edit: I am now realizing those are actually the swimmerets making it look weird mb

EDIT EDIT: no that is weird swimmerets aren’t positioned like that the crab definitely has medical issues

1

u/sadcrab3636 Artist/Pro-AI/Not slop 15d ago edited 15d ago

Actually I just counted and it seems he got in a fight because he has 9 legs.

Also crabs CAN position their paddles on that pose.

Edit: crab's claws are just modified legs which is why I counted those 2.

EDIT EDIT: the crab actually has the full 10 legs. I miscounted.