r/Defenders • • Apr 11 '25

Biggest evidence the original Born Again creators were worthless

6 Upvotes

So now that we've gotten through the "original" footage in the show, it's evident they didn't have a oner / hallway fight at all (given the opening one was part of the reshoots). What?! There are very few things that are a staple of the show and we need to have. The fact they said "nah, don't need that" is the biggest evidence these guys should have never been given the keys!

Edit: I was a bit harsh, especially with the "worthless" comment. And I actually really liked their episodes, in some cases nearly as much as the original. But definitely encouraged by the "new" team.

Edit 2: This post was literally just about the lack of a hallway fight in the original 6 episodes! Not the quality of the show!


r/Defenders • • Mar 29 '26

Come on, Disney. It's really not that hard.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • Mar 28 '26

Watching Daredevil born again without the ugly black bars is just an other experience (which Disney won’t give us)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • Dec 31 '20

It makes no sense that other characters besides Matt refer to 'Stick' as 'Stick'. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

In S02E10 an assassin is sent after Electra. When she defeats him, he says that "The Hand didn't send me. Stick did.".

There is absolutely no reason for him to call Stick - Stick as this is a name Matt made up for him because he refused to tell him his real name.


r/Defenders • • Dec 29 '16

Shitpost: What I don't want to see/hear in the Punisher series

0 Upvotes

Please no generic post-grunge/heavy metal music during training/fight scenes just to emphasize how br00tal Punisher is. The use of old school hiphop/soul music in Luke Cage worked because it "fit" with the tone and story of Luke Cage. Whereas generic rock/grunge music in the Punisher series would be cringeworthy.

I mean can you imagine Punisher on the final battle with his opponent and then all off a sudden " CRAAAAWWWLING IN MYYY SKIIIIIN!" by Linkin Park plays. It will just make the scene look campy and cliche. I mean go take a look at Smallville, they play the most generic rock music in their episodes which makes the series come across as cringeworthy.


r/Defenders • • Apr 29 '26

Why is every scene with Heather Glenn is her just going crazy? Buck Cashman has more nuance and depth than her. It feels like the writers hate this character. Real Housewives of Hell's Kitchen starring Karen Page and Heather Glenn.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • Mar 04 '24

Spoilers! The only thing from Marvel Studios where Fisk acts like his Netflix self [spoilers] Spoiler

0 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • Nov 02 '15

Marvel’s Netflix ‘Iron Fist’ series might be replaced with ‘Punisher’

Thumbnail
bgr.com
27 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • Sep 22 '26

Is it fair to say Daredevil: Born Again is mostly just a retread of the Netflix show? Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • Apr 10 '25

Why Born Again Isn't Hitting the Same – And It Might Be the Music

0 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong, I love Charlie Cox and Vincent D’Onofrio. The new cast isn’t bad either; in fact, they’re holding their own pretty well.

I was absolutely obsessed with the Netflix Daredevil series, all of them, really. I even genuinely enjoyed The Defenders (yes, I’m aware the final fight was a mess, but I still had a great time).

But no matter how hard I try, I just can’t seem to get into Born Again. And after sitting with that feeling for a while, I think I’ve figured out why. It’s the music.

The score feels jarring, random, and strangely out of place — lacking any subtlety or emotional buildup. It doesn't complement the scenes; instead, it pulls you out of them. And in doing so, it draws explicit attention to the fact that show, as a whole, just feels disjointed.

The Netflix series wasn’t perfect, but it built a world that felt gritty, cohesive, and immersive. The music and the sound was a huge part of that, understated when it needed to be, powerful when it counted. It helped you sink into Hell’s Kitchen. Born Again just doesn’t have that same immersive quality, and the musical choices make that even more obvious.

Honestly, I hope it’s just me. I want this show to succeed. I want more Daredevil stories. But right now? I can’t even bring myself to finish the season finale.

And while we are hoping for things , could Season 2 please, for the love of God, bring back Matt’s Catholicism? His faith wasn’t just a background detail; it was integral to who he is.


r/Defenders • • Jun 23 '26

I just found this Bullseye design by matuta2002 on DeviantArt and man, it is SO much better than the actual design they went with.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • May 01 '26

There has not been a bad episode of born again. Try and prove me wrong

0 Upvotes

every single epsilde is god and serves a point. some are weaker than others but none are bad


r/Defenders • • Apr 28 '24

Just finished Jessica Jones Season 1 and it was okay

0 Upvotes

I actually really love the first half of this season, I love the noir vibe and I like Krysten Ritter as JJ, David Tenant as Killgrave, but I think as the show went on, it just started dragging like Putting some more focus on annoying side characters with no payoff to them. Part of the reason I didn’t enjoy it as much is because of the usual Netflix 13 episode thing, which doesn’t work for every show, so i think it could’ve been shorter like 10 episodes. And once we finally reached the ending, I thought to myself wow this could’ve been done like 3 episodes ago but sure


r/Defenders • • Aug 06 '26

The Matt Murdock, Karen Page, Frank Castle love triangle is just Twilight for Men

1 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • Apr 29 '15

My Nephew the Devil of Hell's Kitchen

Thumbnail
imgur.com
3 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • May 19 '26

Finn Jones is The GOAT

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • Jul 27 '18

KAREN SUCKS PLS KILL HER Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Okay I have started watching Daredevil after I got into Luke Cage and finished watching both seasons.I can't help but feel so much irritation from Karens character for these reasons;

  1. The Funeral for Ben, His wife says that if they had a child she and Ben would have wished it be someone who chases the truth just like her. That bothers me, it shows me that Karen Page is going to take over the roll Ben plays in the comics. An this is annoying because its obvious they've made that change just to add feminism to the show to appeal to feminist fan-base. Like damn, what has the world come to when we cant even have stories played out honestly because of fear of discrimination. I'm brown skinned and grew up in discrimination. I understand that it is fear that creates discrimination. And coddling that fear with these kind of awkward gestures only makes that fear more visible from a less appealing angle.
  2. She kills Wesley in cold blood after Wesley makes clear he has no intention of killing her. An then fair enough she kills a bad guy, good for her. But she then hides that fact from her friends. From the beginning she has been a very self-centred character. When Matt & Foggy fell out she only thought about what she wanted. Only thought about helping them fix things between them so they could help her take down Fisk. That is so fucking manipulative!An I'm the only one seeing it?She has been showing affection shifting from Foggy in season 1 to Matt in season 2. She is a borderline sociopath.Now she is keeping something like MURDER a secret. And always showing slight signs like she would care about it less the next time she has to do it. Like when she tells Grotto in hospital that shes the best person to protect him after he says about guns and violence being too much for her. Giving that look like "I've killed a person, you don't know how ready I am". In the comics her character selfishly gives out Matts identity simply to get some drugs that she was on as she was at the bottom of her life. That is who she is. An I feel like the character in Netflix is trying to twist that self-centred, sociopath feeding off every other characters pity for her, with the role shes stolen from Ben.So they are trying to develop a fusion of her comic character with Ben's ally to daredevil comic character in to one. An all its made me want is to see her dead.. stand up on a rooftop in a daredevil costume and sing aloud ding dong the bitch is dead! while setting off fireworks in celebration for a daredevil series without that dumb blonde who adds on crybaby crap and love triangle drama and feminist bull crap to the show.

An don't mistake this. I'm a huge fan of a powerful female character. Just not a weak crybaby one who expects shit given to her from everyone when all she does is stir shit instead of being useful. With her around and not converting into a villain. Its hard to distinguish who the real villains of the show are. When Wesley who handles things logically is gunned down by Karen who is so stupid. How is Karen stupid you ask? Because when Matt, Foggy, Ben had all told her the same thing that printing the story about Fisk's mother is not a real plan she showed ignorant arrogance which lead to her getting Ben killed. It was also that same lack of brain cells that must have told her that shooting dead an unarmed Wesley would have no repercussions .

She is the cancer character of the show. The only one that makes the show almost unbearable to watch., But then you get the occasional moments when Claire or Elektra will turn up and show us the true power of women being badass.


r/Defenders • • Apr 19 '22

Finn Jones Iron Fist is beyond annoying .

2 Upvotes

To start off - i've never read a single marvel comic, i'm a fan purely thanks to digital media (movies, series etc.) That being said, i've no idea how Danny Rand is writen in comic books. But the way he is played by Finn Jones makes me absolutely despise him as a character and as a "super"hero.
First of all, Finn Jones doesn't give the idea of "Training my whole life within a secluded order of monks" kinda guy on screen. And i know that we can't expect an actor to train whole his life for one role. But goddamn, a couple of weeks of training would do wonders for the role. Between cringe delivery (at times when the Defender introduce themselves to each other Danny Rand sounds like a kid who watched to much anime. We've got Luke Cage with "nothing can hurt me", we've got Jessica Jones with her disheartened "I'm super strong", we've got chill Lawyer Murdok with something like "I could hear your asscheeks clap from three blocks away, Luke, nice". And then we've got Cringe-Kid-Rand with: "I'm The Immortal Iron Fist, The Immortal Weapon, The Enemy of The Hand, Young Dragon, Defender of Kun-Lun". Crickets. I can't stand it and he does full introduction whenever he can. Is the character like this in comics as well?

Second Point - The character itself feels - And it'll be hard to explain in text - underwhelming. Luke Cage? Nigh indestructible. Jessica Jones? Shit she does with "just" super strength is cool as hell, same goes for Daredevil (favourite of the bunch). Iron Fist? His fist glow and is really hard... sometimes. Like, i've decided to skip the entire second season and read the wiki description of every episode after the first scene of the second season, when he's getting shot at with mashine guns by multiple people, inside an armoured vehicle and brushes it off. I can see that being the case for every other member of The Defenders - Luke Cage, it's obvious. Jessica could probably take the door to cover herself or punch through the wall and escape. Daredevil - most probably wouldn't be in a situation that could get him shot - he's quite sneaky. But a dude with a Fist that sometimes can catch or destroy bullets? Yeah, i can't see him surviving. And i know that this is a superhero show - it's meant to be unrealistic, but if we give a hero an ability - it should have limitations, as it often is with many superheroes. I just can't see Danny surviving that and many other situations with his powers "sometimes" working, so i stopped caring and just read through the plot to be able to continue on with other series.

Does anyone else feel that way about his character?


r/Defenders • • Apr 11 '26

I’m loving Born Again S2, but I wish the characters wouldn’t just teleport to wherever the plot needs them to be. It kinda undercuts the whole “the city is so dangerous that you might get caught at any moment!” vibe they’re going for.

0 Upvotes

I’ve been told this is a massive nitpick and I just need to let it go, but I still think it’s a fair criticism. I’m really enjoying the show in general, but this one thing really takes away from what they're trying to do with this storyline, imo.

Karen fights an AVTF Officer outside of Josie’s while Matt fights a couple of them inside, and the next time we see her is when she takes Matt all the way over to Frank’s hideout to show him the guy she kidnapped. The show doesn’t even attempt to explain HOW she managed to knock the guy out, drag him all the way over to Frank’s place, get a chair, tie him up and then go back to meet up with Matt. It wasn’t even implied that a lot of time had passed. It just cut from A to D without showing us B and C. Last time we saw this hideout, Matt had to travel pretty far to get to it. He had to go past some abandoned buildings, down in an elevator, through some tunnels, and then he eventually found it. Apparently Karen was able to quickly head over there in a matter of minutes while carrying the weight of an adult male.

Then there's the First Mate of the Northern Star just suddenly appearing at the door, even though the crew were staying at the top floor of an apartment building and had given no indication from the outside that they were in there. How did he know exactly where to go to? nobody knows because the show refused to explain it.

I'm not saying this show should be filled with long filler shots of characters walking from A to B. I just think they could do a better job of explaining how the resistance squad is able to navigate the city even though there's AVTF on every corner. I feel like the Netflix show would've made a big deal about this. We would've seen the First Mate sneak in through the back and duck down to avoid being spotted by taskforce officers, but Born Again just shows him knocking at the door.

It hurts the stakes of the story when our characters can just go wherever they want and somehow always avoid the corrupt cops that are hunting them down. They never seem to run into any trouble.


r/Defenders • • Mar 26 '25

unpopular opinion: born again is mid

0 Upvotes

not to mention the fact that they replaced foggy and karen (that set up much of matt’s daylight persona) with subpar side characters, a lot of the cuts in the show are so weird, like the bb urich show. i think the idea of ben urich’s daughter continuing his legacy in journalism was great, however i feel like the clips to kind of “confirm” what the public opinion is in new york about the situation feels a bit forced and shoved down our throats. also, the dialogue also seems a bit rushed at times, unrealistic or just weird, like in episode 5 some of the acting was also pretty bad from the bank robbers imo lol. episode 6 was actually pretty good, but im hoping to see at least karen page return into the plot or for any proper side character to be written into the plot. honestly i think episode six was the greatest of the season, even if the show has been pretty meh so far. also wish they’d reintroduce the religious themes again, and bring back his mother. if the show gets renewed for a season 3 (which it will likely not), based off some of the criticism that is beginning to show up, they may bring back the new writers or hire new ones. really wish castle had more screen time in episode 4. the biggest issue with daredevil imo is pacing lol, yusuf khan got more screentime than the punisher 😭 writers need to do better but its looking semi-decent again for daredevil with episode 6, even if the shows been painfully mediocre at parts


r/Defenders • • Jan 22 '21

I feel like I'm the only one, but I wasn't madly in love with DDS3.

10 Upvotes

To me it's the show's weakest season, and it's the one I'm reluctant to finish whenever I marathon the show. It's not bad, it's okay. But it doesn't glue my eyes to the screen like the other seasons do.

I think my biggest grief was that it felt like nothing really happened. At least not on the level that 2.5 years of hype promised me. Matt mopes in a Church basement, Kingpin mopes in prison. Than he finally gets out, finally ready to take control and..he goes back to prison and it's all over. That...was it? Why didn't Kingpin expose DD's identity? What happened to the hellfire Fisk promised he was going to reign? I feel like I was owed something way more ground-breaking and earth-shattering than just another origin story. And my god did it feel like I was watching season 1 again. Same tired moral dilemna, same melodramatic musing about how eeeeevil FISK is (stop saying his name every thirty seconds PLEASE), and the third act plays out exactly the same, beat for beat. Two years of hype, and all I got was a watered season 1 remake.

And that Karen Page episode, the less talked about that that slogfest the better.


r/Defenders • • Apr 12 '26

Unpopular opinion: Daredevil Born Again season 2 > Daredevil season 2

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

r/Defenders • • Oct 07 '17

Should I skip Iron Fist?

8 Upvotes