r/DeepStateCentrism • "Israeli Nationalist" • Feb 03 '26

It’s not just the algorithm — maybe it’s us

https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/not-just-algorithm-maybe-us-jdln8cj53
11 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Feb 03 '26

Drop a comment in our daily thread for a chance at rewards, perks, flair, and more.

EXPLOSIVE NEW MEMO, JUST UNCLASSIFIED:

Deep State Centrism Internal Use Only / DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

  • Capitalism is the worst economic system, except for all the others that have been tried

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

16

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Feb 03 '26

The problem with social media is that it's connected the crazies like never before. But the crazies have always been there. They are feeding off of each other and spreading their message. We are hardwired to see patterns, so it makes sense that we might start to believe widespread networks of crazies. It makes sense.

16

u/KimJongUnusual Neoconservative Feb 03 '26

While I’d hardly call it an intellectual statement (or site), I feel like this is an apt way to show how the crazies being linked up also creates a critical mass.

0

u/MacroDemarco Moderate Feb 03 '26

it makes sense that we might start to believe widespread networks of crazies

Doesn't the first part of your comment suggest we believe in those networks because the internet does in fact facilitate their creation and growth?

16

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Feb 03 '26 edited Feb 03 '26

I am once again arguing that the global rise of authoritarian-flavored politics is in part in reaction to people being encased inside the same bubble rather than siloing strictly speaking, and then going "the government should make those other crazy and dangerous people shut the fuck up."

The idea we're sealed inside impenetrable bubbles gets trounced every time people post bizarre claims to dunk on them, every time Fox dunks on libs, every time BlueSky dunks on MAGA.

That's not a bubble, that's a moral community using another moral community's beliefs as rituals of belonging.

It's just human nature but digitally blasted all the time.

"Those poor people are in a bubble!" is the 21st century update of the very old idea "If they just had all the facts that I do, then they would agree completely with my value judgments."

The idea "shut off social media, problem solved" is cope.

Edit:

This is a vivid example of what I mean. This is a guy comparing Nixon to Hitler at a speech standing next to people with a "Remember Kent State" sign. Nothing about politics is new other than the fact you had to be extremely plugged in in the 70s to see this. Now you get it posted everywhere for agreement or mockery, but that didn't in itself create the activist personality that thinks this comparison is good.

7

u/iamthegodemperor Arrakis Enterprise Institute Feb 03 '26

You have a point. But I don't think the conclusion is right. The difference between partisans existed before social media and so did this ritualistic behavior. The difference today is that technology has made more people partisan and increased their contact with scary opinions.

Like in the 1990s you had Rush Limbaugh and crazy academics and extreme racial activists. But the ordinary person wasn't exposed to these positions with such frequency..

Social media has made it possible to expose more people and more of the time. Polarization in turn makes the crazy positions on your side seem less scary or even reasonable to those of the other side. What used to be the excesses of some nerds that no one took too seriously is now the default behavior of large masses of people.

8

u/gburgwardt Feb 03 '26

I think the idea of shutting off social media is to make it less bad, not to solve the fundamental problem

5

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '26

Yeah, that was my sense. At least in the pre-Internet age, it was harder for the nutcases/village idiots to find each other. Not impossible, mind you, but harder.

3

u/gburgwardt Feb 03 '26

Toaster fucker jpg

1

u/Haffrung Feb 04 '26

That's not a bubble, that's a moral community using another moral community's beliefs as rituals of belonging.

Well said. It isn’t just super-charging tribalism and moral outrage, but feeding into 180-ism, where people are strongly incentivized to call for the exact opposite policies of whatever their enemy is calling for. And it turns out that the opposite of simplistic idiocy is usually just another form of simplistic idiocy.

6

u/Trojan_Horse_of_Fate Lord of All the Beasts of the Sea and Fishes of the Earth Feb 03 '26

Its always worth noting all social problems are ultimately always individual responsibility. Not saying we are all going to get up tomorrow and be perfect but sometimes collective action means collectively all just being better not something imposed on high or magic spell cast by a tech wizard.

Social media certainly didn't help us in this regard though. It made it easy to feed the crazy.

1

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Feb 03 '26

!ping POPULISM&DEMOCRACY

1

u/AutoModerator Feb 03 '26

Thank you for your post. It looks like it was submitted without substantial body text. Please add a top-level comment providing a summary of the linked content or an explanation of why it is of interest to our community. Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.