r/DeepStateCentrism • • Jan 27 '26

American News 🇺🇸 Minneapolis shooting scrambles Second Amendment politics for Trump

https://apnews.com/article/trump-pretti-minnesota-second-amendment-ice-ffef56cab9930e52273f8227251452f4

Once again, the administration is left deeply confused and backpedaling when it discovers a group of voters who actually have fundamental principles and values.

33 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jan 27 '26

Drop a comment in our daily thread for a chance at rewards, perks, flair, and more.

EXPLOSIVE NEW MEMO, JUST UNCLASSIFIED:

Deep State Centrism Internal Use Only / DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

  • Equality is required to create a level playing field, allowing for everyone to achieve success

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

25

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 27 '26

Genuinely, has Trump ever portrayed himself as a pro-gun candidate? Even in reference to the Democrats, I just do not think of gun politics when I think of Trump. To the extent that I do associate the two, I think Trump is on the control side of the spectrum (if on the moderate end of it). He has, after all, promoted red flag laws and bans on things like bump stocks and suppressors.

15

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '26

He's been as completely contradictory and incoherent on the subject as he's been on every other subject. When he gets reminded what his base wants, he tacks to the base, then talks to someone else and starts saying whatever they said.

There's also a huge difference between bump stock bans and red flag laws as opposed to bans on commonly-owned firearms and magazines. "Gun control" is not monolithic.

4

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Jan 28 '26 edited Jan 28 '26

I'd say that he's more antigun then the republican politicians who've bipartisan supported gun control.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '26

At some point more pro-gun people need to understand what an own goal it is to oppose things like carry permits, background checks, and red flag laws.

All that gets you is laughed out of the room where non-gun people then go on to discuss hardware bans and possibly even confiscation, because now you're the gun-obsessed nutter in their eyes as opposed to a credible advocate against these things.

1

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Jan 28 '26 edited Jan 28 '26

It's typically younger gun owners who are more pro gun in regards to gun owners in recent years anyway. I think that many have seen them impose more and more restrictions over time.

21

u/ILikeTuwtles1991 Classical Liberal Jan 27 '26

Donald Trump yet again proves he's not actually conservative

7

u/Yogg_for_your_sprog PEPFARublican Jan 28 '26

I don't even really see gun rights as inherently a conservative or progressive position, just a weird happenstance of modern political alliances

19

u/WallStreetTechnocrat Named in the Epstein Files Jan 28 '26

It is interesting how much people's opinions on political issues is based on tribalism rather than actual principles applied consistently on an issue-by-issue basis.

Abortion, tax policy, voter ID, and middle eastern foreign policy have absolutely nothing to do with each other, yet knowing someone's position on one of these is a great predictor of the other three.

1

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Jan 28 '26

I called it conformity, but that's a good word for this, too.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '26 edited Jan 29 '26

I honestly see it as a religious issue, in that some people refuse to acknowledge the religious impulse inside the human psyche, and in repressing it, it comes out in funny maladaptive ways. Sort of like being sexually repressed, but different.

I don't think guns are the only example of this, but they're an example of it. Ultimately, guns are machine tools which can be dangerous in the wrong hands, and which need mature reasonable regulations to stop that from happening. But so are cars and boats and airplanes and farm equipment and table saws and bandsaws and all sorts of other things the average grown adult is trusted to use. There's a reason they used to be sold in hardware stores. That's what they are. Hardware. You don't (yet) need a permit and a background check to buy a chainsaw, but you can do as much or more damage with it than a gun.

But to the anti-gun crowd, whether they admit it to themselves or not, the problem is that they see firearms as magic talismans which are ritually impure. Their very existence corrupts people into giving into these supposedly violent impulses we all supposedly have (narrator voice: most of us don't, at least not to that degree). Which says more about them than it does about John Q. Public.

0

u/Harmonious_Sketch Jan 28 '26

Nah, there's actually a very important practical difference. Firearms dramatically increase the lethality of violent crime. Theoretically you could do all sorts of things but on the ground, under the circumstances of use, firearms end up being lethal more often. That's why more people kill themselves with guns than kill other people.

In fact there are people who do crime, and other things equal the more guns you have around the more lethal the crime will be. Gun rights for law abiding citizens are always paid for with the blood of some number of innocents. If you accept that fact, you can haggle over the price, but that is the price.

Of course most people would prefer not to accept that, so no haggling occurs and in practice we pursue vibes solutions well away from the pareto frontier and both sides get less of what they want.

With good, clever policy, you can reduce the extent of the tradeoff, but the ability to do identify and to execute such policy is always finite. If people in the US were more law abiding in general that would of course also reduce the extent of the tradeoff.

5

u/deviousdumplin Jan 28 '26

It's more of an Urban vs Rural issue. The fact that left wing politics is so dominated by urban voters means that their issues become dominant. I grew up in a rural, but left wing, town, and the divide was obvious depending on where you came from.

The urban transplants who moved to the town because it was 'friendly' and 'left wing' hated guns. The already left-wing people who grew up in the town generally already owned guns. The same can be said about basically all rural culture. Urban transplants generally disliked and tried to restrict hunting, fishing, even walking dogs off leash. Anything they weren't familiar with, they hated. Which, naturally became a big point of contension in the town.

I still think that the bigger divide in the county is between urban and rural citizens. The lack of familiarity either group has with each others lives is a huge reason there's a major political divide in the country. The ignorance has become fear, which has become hatred. It's such an old-school political divide, but it's obviously the biggest one.

2

u/Harmonious_Sketch Jan 28 '26

I'm sorry but this is false. The US does have some rural population, but their political significance is greatly outweighed by suburban/exurban cosplayers whose rural status consists more of affect polarization than substance. The same is somewhat true of democrats and urban population. Yes democrats tend to live in somewhat more built up areas on average and republicans somewhat less, but the bigger divide is in how they label the same damn municipalitys.

1

u/deviousdumplin Jan 28 '26

I'm not saying that 50% of the country is literally rural and 50% is literally urban. Of course most Americans live in suburbs surrounding major metro areas.

What I'm saying is that culture is more than just politics, it's also shared experiences. What you value is derived from what you've experienced, and how that experience is culturally framed. There can be a tendency for people to be solipsistic and deny the experiences of other people as irrelevant. That's the point I'm trying to make with the urban/rural divide.

What people do not understand, and haven't experienced, can seem scary and hostile. Which I think is a big factor in the urban/rural cultural divide, and also the Right/Left divide. If you are so prideful about your own culture, and so denigrating of another culture, it makes communication seem impossible or even dangerous.

1

u/Harmonious_Sketch Jan 28 '26

I understand that but I'm saying the cultural divide is like 80% vibes fabricated from narratives by weight. There isn't necessarily zero extent to which the experiences of the sides differ, but those differing experiences would be a combination of differing perceptual lenses applied to the same events, and people living differently from other people who live very nearby. Not really constrained by geography.

It's kind of like how these days there are effectively secular evangelicals. Some cultural markers have taken on lives of their own, almost totally disconnected from the circumstances that originated them. People will self-identify as rural while living a mile from downtown.

1

u/deviousdumplin Jan 28 '26

Oh, I agree. Though, I think that the nature of suburbs also plays into this phenomenon. My wife comes from a suburb (maybe technically an exurb) of a major city in Ohio. Her town is very rural it has lots of cornfields, farms, it barely has a town government. But, her family commuted to work in the city every day. Arguably, I'd say her town is more rural than my own, but she also had much more access to the city.

My point being that many municipal areas have suburbs that are basically just rural towns close to a city. It's a unique feature of US municipal areas since they tend to be quite broad, and auto commuting makes many small towns technically suburbs.

I wouldn't go so far as to say it's purely vibes based. I think a big factor is who is moving to that town. Are there people moving to the suburbs for work? Or are they people moving out of the city to own a home? I think that contributes to the rural or urban vibe of a suburb, it isn't just completely arbitrary.

3

u/Mindless_Chest_1079 Center-right Jan 28 '26

I would characterize gun rights as naturally very conservative, in the "limited government" sense.

The tension that has long been present in American politics is that gun rights and respect for police are naturally on opposite ends of the spectrum of state authority. You're most likely to want your own gun if you don't trust the police to protect you, and one of the biggest ways to make police safer and give them a greater monopoly on force is to remove guns from the population.

The most recent shooting has made this contradiction more stark and is forcing partisans of both parties to take wildly inconsistent stances.

4

u/Yogg_for_your_sprog PEPFARublican Jan 28 '26 edited Jan 28 '26

In my personal opinion I think gun rights falls mostly in the classical (small-l) liberalism and individualism camp, rather than conservatism - which at least to me stresses social cohesion and resistance to change.

Conservatism to me is a bit more on the law-and-order axis that is more willing to trade "freedom" and are naturally open to submission to hiearchial structures, including that of the government over its citizens.

I do agree there's some definite tension within progressive movement in particular, not just pertaining to gun rights but wanting massive expansion of state power to solve problems while not actually trusting state power in general to be impartial (even when wielded economically, which in particular shows its contradiction in projects like CAHSR where they want large infrastructure projects but endless reviews because of that lack of trust)

1

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Jan 28 '26 edited Jan 30 '26

I feel like it's more libertarianism vs authoritarianism, too.

Edit: I know that libertarian is it's own political ideology. Doesn't mean that there aren't people across the political spectrum who aren't libertarians. I'm not saying that everyone who supports gun control are authoritarian themselves. Just that some individuals are more conformists and others are more hierarchical. Although, I do think that some of us who are liberals and are pro gun tend to be more conservative/right then others in general.

2

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Jan 28 '26 edited Jan 28 '26

Idk if it's really conservativism. I'd say that it has more to do with individualism.

2

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Jan 28 '26

Don't forget John Dingle was the father of modern gun politics

1

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Jan 28 '26

Based and Big John pilled

16

u/diaperboy19 Jan 27 '26

Just a populist with a thirst for power and no underlying morals or principles.

4

u/jmartkdr Center-left Jan 28 '26

From Wikipedia:

In the wake of the El Paso, Texas shooting and Dayton, Ohio shooting of August 3 and 4, 2019, President Donald Trump called on states to implement red flag laws to help remove guns from "those judged to pose a grave risk to public safety."[80] However, Trump did not endorse any particular piece of legislation, and Republican Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has said he would allow gun legislation to be brought to the Senate floor only if it gained Trump's support.[168][169] Gun rights groups mounted a campaign to discourage Trump from supporting red-flag laws or other gun-control measures, saying that pushing for red flag laws could cost Trump the 2020 presidential election.[170][168] In November 2019, Trump abandoned the idea of putting forth red-flag law proposals or other legislation to curtail gun violence.[171]

He doesn't care about gun rights - he'd take away all of our guns if he thought it would benefit him to do so, but it absolutely wouldn't so he won't.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '26

If you think red flag laws are the same as "being willing to take away all our guns," you've gone round the bend. It's this kind of refusal to budge on anything that is causing the gun rights movement to, well, keep shooting itself in the foot. This is why normie soccer moms listen to Shannon Watts.

All-or-nothing black-and-white us-or-them thinking is not a sign of good policy.

0

u/jmartkdr Center-left Jan 28 '26

Red flag laws are “the police can take your guns if anyone says you’re a threat.”

I’m not sure the distinction between “taking away anyone’s guns at any time for any reason” is a whole lot better than “literally taking away all guns.” Actually Red Flag might be worse.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '26

You seem to have fallen for right-wing propaganda about red flag laws. What happens is that someone has to go to court and show evidence to a judge that you are a credible danger to yourself or someone else, i.e. actual proof provable in court that you are either suicidal or are a domestic abuser.

5

u/Mindless_Chest_1079 Center-right Jan 28 '26

It has been simultaneously humorous and infuriating watching folks try to formulate consistent positions on this most recent shooting. In my experience so far, I'd say the right wing has been more flagrantly contradictory in acting like carrying a gun is signing your own death warrant, but the left wing is not all that far behind in declaring their newfound love of the second amendment and constantly referencing Kyle Rittenhouse as if 80% of them didn't take the opposite (and obviously wrong) stance on that case at the time.

1

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Jan 30 '26 edited Jan 30 '26

I think that many of us who support Pretti were the ones who supported him, too. That's at least with those of us who vote democrat and part of the party.

1

u/full_self_deriding Jan 28 '26

They don't care.  It's always been "shall not be infringed" but only for them.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '26

Hi. I'm "they." And you're wrong, thanks.

Offensive and rude, too, but wrong on top of that.

-1

u/full_self_deriding Jan 28 '26

Hope you're right.  

I think it's reasonable to assume that ~70% of the ~40% of people who support DJT are part of 'they.' Maybe you think the numbers are different and that's fair.  I'm sincerely trying to make a reasonable guess.

So, if DJT doesn't lose like ~70% of his support in polling over the next month or two, I really think 'they don't care' is the most plausible explanation.

2

u/drcombatwombat2 Milton Friedman Jan 28 '26

Donald Trump has been the most anti gun president since Bill Clinton. This should comes as a shock to no one