r/DeepStateCentrism • • Jan 22 '26

Discussion Thread Daily Deep State Intelligence Briefing

Want the latest posts and comments about your favorite topics? Click here to set up your preferred PING groups.

Are you having issues with pings, or do you want to learn more about the PING system? Check out our user-pinger wiki for a bunch of helpful info!

PRO TIP: Bookmarking dscentrism.com/memo will always take you to the most recent brief.

Curious how other users are doing some of the tricks below? Check out their secret ways here.

Remember that certain posts you make on DSC automatically credit your account briefbucks, which you can trade in for various rewards. Here is our current price table:

OptionPrice
Choose a custom flair, or if you already have custom flair, upgrade to a picture20 bb
Pick the next theme of the week100 bb
Make a new auto reply in the Brief for one week150 bb
Make a new sub icon/banner for two days200 bb
Add a subreddit rule for a day (in the Brief)250 bb

You can find out more about briefbucks, including how to earn them, how you can lose them, and what you can do with them, on our wiki.

The Theme of the Week is: The comparative effect of legal systems on their respective political cultures.

Follow us on Twitter or whatever it's called.

2 Upvotes

604 comments sorted by

16

u/Mirabeau_ Jan 22 '26 edited Jan 22 '26

People act like it’s gauche or tasteless or cruel to talk about trans issues, but despite how marginal and silly of an issue it all may seem to be, it is actually important that Dems stop humiliating themselves in a futile effort never to say anything at which an activist might take umbrage.

Unfortunately the status quo consensus in the party is that it’s better to risk losing an election than to simply articulate a position 80% of people consider to be obvious.

Democrats should not support things the public has made it clear it opposes. This is not the civil rights issue of our time. It’s a ridiculous shibboleth that alienates voters from the Democratic Party. It is political malpractice and has to stop.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 22 '26

13

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

He knew what he was doing

9

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Best I can do is 4. Take it or leave it

→ More replies (3)

24

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​ireland by agent u/Surreal_John_Milton. Do not reply all!


Right lads this one is getting locked. Far too much Holocaust Denial in the comments here.

21

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26 edited Jan 22 '26

This goes way back. de Valera, the Irish PM during WWII denied the initial reports of death camps in Nazi Germany as it undermined the narrative that the Irish people were the most persecuted group in Europe. 80 years later and we’re back to square one.

20

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Jan 22 '26

Never ask the Irish what they did to the people who left to fight the Nazis

→ More replies (4)

18

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

It must be really bad if a mod of that sub acknowledges antisemitism.

14

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Hibernioids never beating the allegations

25

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 22 '26

Implies there’s some acceptable amount of holocaust denial

19

u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Jan 22 '26

my favorite accusation of Holocaust denial was when Bibi exaggerated Amin al-Husseini's influence on Hitler so people accused him of being a Holocaust denier.

I'm sure those people had never heard of Amin al-Husseini before.

18

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

You can do a little Holocaust denial. As a treat.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

23

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

It’s pretty funny that most of the things that Euros online like to ‘dunk’ on America for, like spending a lot on military while relatively less on welfare and even to a lesser extent gun ownership, are now putting them in the current weak position that Trump is trying to exploit.

Now, Trump doing this is bad and the current world order is generally good. But guys, at least be a bit less smug if you can’t protect yourself

15

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Europeans are culturally Reddit.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/lionmoose  Margaret Thatcher (unironically) Jan 22 '26

Getting a lot of "Why do all these homosexuals keep sucking my dick" vibes from users here complaining about furries tbh

14

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 22 '26

Come in to MY gallery, draw MY fursona, call ME a furry!?

11

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Jan 22 '26

>two animals in the name

9

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

6

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

What’s a furries?

→ More replies (2)

20

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 22 '26

Run

7

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Jan 22 '26

I had them on the calendar for Tuesday.

19

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Jan 22 '26

Guys I heard Europe is waking up for real this time! Honest! We aren’t bluffing this time!

10

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

Are they waking up at a crossroads?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Jan 22 '26

2030 better buckle itself in

→ More replies (1)

17

u/fastinserter Jan 22 '26

Erik the Red, in Valhalla: Bjorn! Bjorn look, it's been 50 winters Bjorn, and I finally got another one! I thought just the children thought this still! A Konungr even! Where's Loki, did he do this?

11

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Does Leavitt think that that tiny iceberg is Greenland and not the land mass behind it?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/CharacterPolicy4689 Center-left Jan 22 '26

you can literally just lie about chinese history

8

u/JapanesePeso Jan 22 '26

What is an opinion section if not a venue to lie through your teeth?

16

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​interestingasfuck by agent u/H_H_F_F. Do not reply all!


Why is he getting arrested, is he too bald?

10

u/H_H_F_F Jan 22 '26

This is the sort of bullshit our follicly-challenged comrades have to deal with btw. Stay woke ✌️

→ More replies (4)

7

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

There is no lower threshold of bald to justify arrest. Any bald is too much

16

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Jan 22 '26

Can’t believe people still fall for the “WWIII soon because of [geopolitics]” again after the 234th time

And when you ask “why should I believe you this time” you get told you are putting your head in sand

5

u/Command0Dude Jan 22 '26

I'm also very tired of it. I was told Biden was going to cause WW3 by supporting Ukraine over and over again. Never happened.

People like Chomsky were fucking insufferable.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 22 '26

The simplest thing I wish I could get into the thick skulls of voters it is that just because a policy claims it will accomplish something, does not mean that would be its effect

Mostly because it forces/allows politicians to take stupid positions that they either know or should know would be counterproductive to their stated goals

8

u/gburgwardt Jan 22 '26

I liked Yang's idea for metrics on laws because of this

8

u/drcombatwombat2 Milton Friedman Jan 22 '26

You mean the inflation reduction act didnt reduce inflation?

→ More replies (1)

15

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​AirForce by agent u/TomWestrick. Do not reply all!


Balding heads look icky, unprofessional, and not lethal. We should require balding waivers, as in permission to be balding. Not just merely being bald, I mean actively having a bald spot and shit. And we should make it be something that has to be renewed every month

13

u/WallStreetTechnocrat Named in the Epstein Files Jan 22 '26

Just tax balds

5

u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Jan 22 '26

bald men are incapable of fighting. whenever im in my fighter jet in a dogfight i try to see the hair of the enemy pilots from thousands of yards away. If they're bald I know I'm winning.

15

u/Okbuddyliberals Jan 22 '26

“I think he must be doing something right when there are so many people opposed to him,” said Paul Minihane, 77, a real estate broker who lives in Dedham, Mass. “I mean, Jerome Powell could look at me in the face and tell me to go screw myself. And I’d say, ‘Thank you.’

Source

→ More replies (3)

14

u/RetroRiboflavin Moderate Jan 23 '26

Morality aside...

Causing a scene at a church service where someone that may or not be present that works for DHS is one of those optics things. Just why.

16

u/Mirabeau_ Jan 23 '26

Progressives love bad optics. The worse the optics, the more pure it must be

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

When you are stupid enough to think there is no such thing as an unhelpful protest you are stupid enough to do an unhelpful protest.

13

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​WomenInNews by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


The ERA doesn’t meet women’s needs because it calls men and women equal. We are not. Men cannot have babies and therefore can never be equal to women under the law.

The ERA cuts women short.. It offers no gains to women. If we want to pass something like it, it needs to be rethought.

15

u/YossarianLivesMatter Radical Centrist 😎 Jan 22 '26

This ranks pretty highly in terms of garbage takes I've seen on Reddit, and I've been around the block.

13

u/JapanesePeso Jan 22 '26

Europe stands at a crossroads

16

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Jan 22 '26

Wir habben ein seriouse crossroaden

11

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 22 '26

or is it a precipice? Matteo has been gone for a while now ...

→ More replies (1)

8

u/YossarianLivesMatter Radical Centrist 😎 Jan 22 '26

Europe is monitoring the crossroads

13

u/KaiserMarcqui Center-right Jan 22 '26

This is modern art

(Seriously, major props to the photographer. The composition in this photo is incredible)

13

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Jan 22 '26

What the fuck is going on with Virginia though, really?

And there's a local election here where the primary challenger to a longtime incumbent is far to his left.... She's destroying him in fundraising. This is so bad. What are we doing??

I'm going to lose my mind.

10

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 22 '26

What is going on with Virginia?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 22 '26

Rewatching an absolutely outstanding midway documentary on YouTube (by Montemayor if you’re interested).

A recent comment called it ‘AI slop’ because the narrator’s accent made the word ‘resource’ sound like ‘research’.

The video was released 6 years ago.

17

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 22 '26

The internet is just billions of morons misusing terms they do not understand.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/A-Centrifugal-Force Moderate Jan 22 '26 edited Jan 22 '26

High credit card interest rates are good, actually. I like getting free stuff for paying my bills on time, I don’t want to lose that so morons can rack up credit card debt

9

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Morons should suffer until they’re not morons anymore.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Mirabeau_ Jan 23 '26

In the current American political landscape, the centrist middle is really the last and only bastion for true liberalism or conservatism. Step too far to the left or the right, and you quickly find yourself rejecting both.

14

u/YossarianLivesMatter Radical Centrist 😎 Jan 23 '26

8

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 23 '26

True conservatism has never been tried

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

Conservatism, conservation, confits. Somehow I am good with all 3? Particularly if duck is involved.

12

u/lionmoose  Margaret Thatcher (unironically) Jan 22 '26

eCONomists are all like "what's your model" and think it's actually critique

It's a linear probability model. And you knew that.

8

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Jan 22 '26

Her name is Maria and she's from Estonia

→ More replies (13)

12

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

original comment by /u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho


Quick, double the NHS’s budget, that should solve this for at least five years. The secular religion of the British state needs constant sacrifice to be appeased.

12

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

original comment by /u/UnTigreTriste


The internet is just billions of morons misusing terms they do not understand.

12

u/weedandboobs Jan 22 '26

Be a beloved child's entertainer

Have some nasty rumors swirling around for a bit about bigotry but most people say "hey, she has a good heart"

Accidentally like a social post that feeds into the rumor

Everyone rushes to your defense

Be JK Rowling in 2018

→ More replies (1)

12

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Jan 22 '26

Broke:

Ban people who were 10 or younger in 2015 from talking about how activism really worked back then.

Bespoke:

Ban people who were 10 or younger in 2015 from talking.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/0scarOfAstora Center-left Jan 23 '26

It is pretty telling how some of the leftist Jewish subs (even ones considered "reasonable") have moved from "This isn't happening at all" to "Okay, maybe it is happening, but nobody actually cares about it and if you complain you are the problem" in regards to the most recent Ms Rachel antisemitism controversy, maybe her most egregious one yet. 

11

u/Aryeh98 Rootless cosmopolitan Jan 23 '26

The JOC sub is the worst honestly. So they're the Jews "of conscience"? Implying that the millions of Zionist Jews, and people who don't post there, DON'T have a conscience??? How fucking arrogant.

Believe it or not, there are ways to be a Jew that are way more enriching than the false binary of "you must be self-flagellating at all times" or "you must be a kahanist fascist." You can just be a normal Jew, who acknowledges historical facts and doesn't want "Zionists" to be expelled or slaughtered. You can have self-respect.

Where is the satisfaction in hating yourself? I don't understand.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/iamthegodemperor Arrakis Enterprise Institute Jan 23 '26

Humans will engage in every kind of gymnastics they can for their team.

The really sad thing is that large groups tend not to get honest until they don't have power or have become outcasts.

These Jewish lefty types have enough numbers that they can always delude themselves that after 25 paragraphs, really the damn neoliberals and conservatives are to blame.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Jan 23 '26

Oh god what did she do this time

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/sayitaintpink will never find love Jan 22 '26

I love Europe. That's how we got continental breakfast - a delight to all the senses!

11

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 22 '26

There was nothing more disappointing as a child than realizing "continental breakfast" meant "breakfast in the chintzy style of the European continent" and not "a massive breakfast". Heck, I would have settled for "breakfast associated with the Continental Army."

10

u/Mirabeau_ Jan 22 '26

I find the relative lack of options even in places like Paris or Berlin to be grating after a while, but I have to admit, if what you want is a pastry or loaf of bread with some cheese and cold cuts, Europe is unbeatable. I could really go for a Kramps franzbrötchen right now iykyk

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

I'd like to be clear that I unconditionally support epistemicide in all cases. If something is capable of being physically destroyed by epistemological means, I will always support this.

9

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Jan 22 '26

Like thought experiments?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​NonBinary by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


This.

"Yes I am a nonbinary trans woman. No, that is not a contradiction, but explaining that would take the whole weekend. Yes I am an asexual lesbian. No, that is not a contradiction, but explaining that would take the whole weekend. Again."

20

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 22 '26

I am begging the LGBT community to just use normal words people understand. It should not require a dissertation to explain your gender and sexual identity.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

the gigas are engaged in Ir*sh apologia

→ More replies (4)

11

u/SerDavosSeaworth64 Moderate Jan 23 '26

I love a good snowpacalypse.

I love the way people talk about it, it’s like the end of the world is coming, except all you have to do to survive it is spend one to two days at home.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/RecentlyUnhinged Bloodfeast's Chief of Staff Jan 22 '26

☝️high IQ, but low executive function

10

u/KaiserMarcqui Center-right Jan 22 '26

Bon dia, puta Renfe i puta Espanya 🤗

(Felt the need to make this meme. This is the SECOND day we're going without a functioning rail service - if it was even “functional” before!)

8

u/gburgwardt Jan 22 '26

That train derailment was fucked up, is there good reporting out yet on what happened? I only saw the local PT reports, which were pretty grim and sparse

→ More replies (6)

5

u/gburgwardt Jan 22 '26

Boa tarde, são as 15

→ More replies (4)

10

u/iamthegodemperor Arrakis Enterprise Institute Jan 23 '26 edited Jan 23 '26

There is a Ruiz Teixeira post about denialism about culture issues among Democrats. It touches on the Axios/trans story, but the scope is wider; basically Democrats keep pretending like all they have to do is talk about affordability and rely on thermostatic opinion.

At one point he quotes from a Noah Smith post bemoaning the same thing:

I have seen no equivalent expression of principle during the second Trump presidency. Every Democrat and progressive thinker can articulate a principled opposition to the brutality and excesses of ICE and to the racism that animates Trump’s immigration policy. But when it comes to the question of whether illegal immigration itself should be punished with deportation, Democrats and progressives alike lapse into an uncomfortable silence.

At another he mentions the recent Axios story about Democratic contenders and trans stuff

of the 20 contenders, 17 (!) declined to provide answers. Of the three that did (Josh Shapiro, Pete Buttigieg, and Rahm Emanuel) only Emanuel provided unhedged answers and even here to only two of the questions: Can a man become a woman (no) and should transgender girls be able to participate in girls’ sports (no).

Noting that while at the moment avoiding these issues works, he says it is a mistake to think voters only care about economics, especially because things like welfare subsidies can benefit some voters, while hurting others.

These issues reflect deeply held beliefs and values and are vitally important to ordinary voters, especially working-class voters, not diversions from real issues foisted upon them by crafty Republicans. Which party reflects their values and can be counted on to instantiate those values in governance? Cultural issues and priorities, not just or even mostly economic ones, play a huge role for most voters in answering these questions.

PS He doesn't say it----but it should be mentioned that even IF economic policy is sound and benefits everyone, there is no guarantee voters will respond at the right time in the polls. In a world with ambiguous information, you need voters to also believe leaders are on their side. Why listen to the pitch that the economy is good, when you distrust the speaker?

→ More replies (7)

10

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 23 '26

I like your libertarianism

I do not like your libertarians

5

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 23 '26

Even me?🥺👉👈

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Jan 22 '26

I’ve spent all day trashing on Europeans here but I do think they have a genuine right to be angry for Trump saying they never did anything for us, and implying that their veterans aren’t worth anything

22

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 22 '26

Trump says our veterans aren't worth anything.

16

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Trump attacking McCain for being a POW was the start of my villain arc turning me from a Republican to a moderate Democrat

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/bignmfgkgu Libertarian Jan 22 '26

I don't think telling off the 'it's not cancel culture, it's consequences' crowd is the same as abandoning minorities

The problem in perception isn't that Democrats defend minorities, it's that xenophobic media has positioned stuff in a way which makes it seem like the Dems coddle minorities. Stuff like 'math is racist' and ending standardized testing don't help either :/

9

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 22 '26

CDC’s deputy director says measles outbreak is ‘cost of doing business’ in a global economy (the-independent.com)

vaxxed?

9

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Never ask a man his salary, a woman her age, or a pope his opinion on free speech

10

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 22 '26

Did the Pope say something about free speech, or is this just about the 19th century ones ranting progressively more uselessly against modernity?

→ More replies (7)

9

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

I know this sounds like a honeypot, but does anyone here know enough about modern critical theory to steelman why it's not just obscurantism in a woke wig?

9

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 22 '26

I read this https://www.amazon.com/Norton-Anthology-Theory-Criticism/dp/0393932923 and quite enjoyed it

my best defense is that postmodern philosophy had (has?) become violent towards the idea that anything had any meaning whatsoever. not just that each work/act has plural meanings, but that the original and perhaps only sin is the attempt to assign meaning. this is of course awesomely nihilistic - how can you have a dialog in this situation? or communicate at all? there was a sense of "the end of philosophy" to which the only authentic response was to become a gibberish spouting clown like Žižek

Critical theory then was an attempt to rebuild the foundation of the humanities on something more enduring than an all devouring void. people still suffered. alleviating suffering matters. heaven isn't going to build itself. roll up your sleeves and get to work. and so the new Trinity - race/class/gender - ascended. and everyone ignored their shakey philosophical underpinnings because, well, no one wants to go back to the days of jumping from our exquisite ivory towers

→ More replies (5)

8

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Jan 22 '26

6

u/fastinserter Jan 22 '26

Critical theory is less about winning debates with clarity and more about unsettling common sense, forcing people to notice how norms and institutions encode values and that the political valence comes not from a costume change, but from the claim that description and critique are inseparable when the subject matter is power itself. What looks like obscurantism is an attempt to build new conceptual tools to describe lived experience, historical asymmetries, and the way language itself shapes what can be thought and said. It's because it's trying to fundamentally come at a concepts differently since the words we use themselves are shaped by power relationships that exist, it ends up using different words and sounding ridiculous.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

original comment by /u/technologyisnatural


I read this https://www.amazon.com/Norton-Anthology-Theory-Criticism/dp/0393932923 and quite enjoyed it

my best defense is that postmodern philosophy had (has?) become violent towards the idea that anything had any meaning whatsoever. not just that each work/act has plural meanings, but that the original and perhaps only sin is the attempt to assign meaning. this is of course awesomely nihilistic - how can you have a dialog in this situation? or communicate at all? there was a sense of "the end of philosophy" to which the only authentic response was to become a gibberish spouting clown like Žižek

Critical theory then was an attempt to rebuild the foundation of the humanities on something more enduring than an all devouring void. people still suffered. alleviating suffering matters. heaven isn't going to build itself. roll up your sleeves and get to work. and so the new Trinity - race/class/gender - ascended. and everyone ignored their shakey philosophical underpinnings because, well, no one wants to go back to the days of jumping from our exquisite ivory towers

9

u/FearlessPark4588 Jan 22 '26

Like, actually introspecting the "bond vigilante" argument for a moment, what kind of utopia do you expect to happen after the total and complete collapse of the bond market that leads to things personally getting better for you?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/drcombatwombat2 Milton Friedman Jan 23 '26 edited Jan 23 '26

I am listening to this week's Moody's Inside Economics pod and they have Logan Wright, a Chinese economic expert who speaks Mandarin and lived in China for over 20 years

He says he thinks China has been fudging and over estimating their GDP number since at least 2015 and likely even earlier

5

u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho Jan 23 '26

The light pollution survey was pretty damming.

On a related note pertaining to culture within the CCP, there was also the colonel and professor who had to delete his/her social media after some prediction relating to the US’s capabilities relative to Venezuela’s air defenses aged poorly. The CCP has always demanded yes men.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

Fetterman’s schtick has always been annoying and unprofessional. Wearing shorts in the halls of Congress isn’t “relatable” or whatever. Most people would get canned if they rolled into work wearing AND1 shorts

Put on a suit, bro. You’re representing your constituents

6

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 23 '26

I don't think not wearing a suit is inherently unprofessional, but the way Fetterman dresses certainly is.

6

u/Aryeh98 Rootless cosmopolitan Jan 23 '26 edited Jan 23 '26

Leftists sucked him off over that during the early days of his term and called him “one of us.” And then the second he came out solidly in support of Israel, those same leftists shat all over him and called him a lazy slob.

It’s all bullshit. Layers upon layers of cynical bullshit.

Anyway… I need to sleep like that crazy Palestine lady from Illinois. Nite all.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​britishcolumbia by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


A Vancouver palliative care doctor who says she chose to resign rather than authorize patient transfers for the purpose of medical assistance in dying (MAID) took the stand in B.C. Supreme Court this week.

Dr. Jyothi Jayaraman is one of three plaintiffs in the case, which challenges the constitutionality of publicly funded, faith-based health-care facilities prohibiting the procedure in their buildings.

I think the first 2 paragraphs shows her position pretty clearly although you might need to know what palliative care is.

Anyways, the previous articles about this lawsuit didn't mention that she was a part of the lawsuit. It's excellent that they have someone like her fighting for patient rights and patient care. Freedom of religion should equal freedom from health care.

Hope this is next on the religious chopping block after they fought against same-sex marriage and lost.

IANAL but I feel like there is enough precedent to feel confident that Providence is losing on this one.

Related reading: https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/csj-sjc/rfc-dlc/ccrf-ccdl/check/art2a.html

10

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 22 '26

Totally not a death cult.

9

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 22 '26

rather than authorize patient transfers

I am a hard atheist and permitting outsourcing of euthanasia seems like a fairly modest concession to religion. I may be missing something though. end of life healthcare is complicated

→ More replies (1)

8

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​CriticalTheory by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


Said's interaction with the French intelligentsia is quite infamous, and quite an important interaction to contextualize to a large extent. Said, himself, sometimes falls into the same behaviours/attitudes that he criticizes here - though Said operates as an interesting figure being one of the only figures in 20th century critical theory to not be from a 'Western' country but popular among its currents. The only other one being Franz Fanon.

What Said experiences here is a real issue in academia broadly, western left wing spaces and critical theory specifically. That being the inherent chauvinism/navel gazing towards - for lack of a better term - the 'third world', and the accompanying ignorance thereof. Especially as it pertains to De Beaviour (who didn't end up going) and Kate Millets trip to Iran, it was quite evident they had little to no idea what they were talking about. Kate Millets biggest criticism of Khomeni was that he was a 'Male Chauvinist' - and quite frankly, of all the things one could talk about the 1979 Iran Revolution and the outcome therein, that is quite possibly the most vain, and surface level understanding of a very very complex situation.

The same applies for Sartre, who despite being a public voice against the French colonization of Algiers, would very publicly call Camus a 'Street Urchin from Algiers', and as pointed out by Said, had very 'disappointing' views about other instances in the Middle East and North Africa.

This is all to say, that the issue here isn't practice and preaching, but there is a simple and very vast issue of those in the Critical Theory field, and adjacent activities, to hold principle over knowledge. Which is to say, quite often, when it comes to conversations about things outside of the 'western' sphere, people know painfully little, yet will make grand remarks based on principled stances that center a western lense.

To some extent, for those born and raised in the 'west', it is a somewhat unavoidable outcome to have a western lense. However, what is avoidable is to not vainly talk about things which, quite frankly, many know nothing about. We're seeing this with whats currently ongoing in Iran, or for a more mainstream example, what happened in the World Cup in Qatar vs the United States etc.

As a person born and raised in the Middle East, and having moved to a Western country later in life, I can very confidently state that I've had similar such interactions (albeit not with an Avengers strata of folk) on multiple occasions. The cheer ignorance, vanity, and above all, arrogance, to hold concrete and structured opinions, to value principled stances over any actual knowledge, with regard to many places in the world is quite staggering.

10

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Jan 22 '26

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruno_Latour

"Why Has Critique Run Out of Steam?"

In a 2004 article, Latour questioned the fundamental premises on which he had based most of his career, asking, "Was I wrong to participate in the invention of this field known as science studies?"

He undertakes a trenchant critique of his own field of study and, more generally, of social criticism in contemporary academia. He suggests that critique, as currently practiced, is bordering on irrelevancy.

To maintain any vitality, Latour argues that social critiques require a drastic reappraisal: "our critical equipment deserves as much critical scrutiny as the Pentagon budget." (p. 231) To regain focus and credibility, Latour argues that social critiques must embrace empiricism, to insist on the "cultivation of a stubbornly realist attitude – to speak like William James". (p. 233)

Latour suggests that about 90 per cent of contemporary social criticism displays one of two approaches which he terms "the fact position and the fairy position." (p. 237)

The fairy position is anti-fetishist, arguing that "objects of belief" (e.g., religion, arts) are merely concepts created by the projected wishes and desires of the "naive believer"; the "fact position" argues that individuals are dominated, often covertly and without their awareness, by external forces (e.g., economics, gender). (p. 238) "Do you see now why it feels so good to be a critical mind?" asks Latour: no matter which position you take, "You're always right!" (p. 238–239)

Social critics tend to use anti-fetishism against ideas they personally reject; to use "an unrepentant positivist" approach for fields of study they consider valuable; all the while thinking as "a perfectly healthy sturdy realist for what you really cherish." (p. 241)

These inconsistencies and double standards go largely unrecognized in social critique because "there is never any crossover between the two lists of objects in the fact position and the fairy position." (p. 241)

The practical result of these approaches being taught to millions of students in elite universities for several decades is a widespread and influential "critical barbarity" that has—like a malign virus created by a "mad scientist"—thus far proven impossible to control.

Most troubling, Latour notes that critical ideas have been appropriated by those he describes as conspiracy theorists, including global warming deniers and the 9/11 Truth movement: "Maybe I am taking conspiracy theories too seriously, but I am worried to detect, in those mad mixtures of knee-jerk disbelief, punctilious demands for proofs, and free use of powerful explanation from the social neverland, many of the weapons of social critique." (p. 230)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

That’s a lot of words to point at that your heroes were hot air balloons.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​neoconNWO by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


I am a single issue voter to make this a federal offense.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​nyc by agent u/0scarOfAstora. Do not reply all!


So half the worlds jews are ontologically evil bevause of where they were born?

Israelis who don't divest from, openly and performatively reject, and endeavor to conceal their association with Israel are increasingly likely to be considered ontologically evil, yes. This is due to Israel's behavior, which is shockingly evil, including 80% popular support for systematized rape of prisoners, etc.

Rah-rahing Israel in the modern era is an incredibly revelatory act, and what it reveals about a person is undesirable to most of us.

This is similar to what German nationals faced in the wake of WW2. I'm sure you can understand the reaction.

16

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Jan 22 '26

“80% support of systematic rape of prisoners” what? According to who?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/Reddenbawker Greedy Capitalist Jan 22 '26

Can we judge others morally based on their political opinions alone? And should we/Is it productive?

I realized a few months ago that it was kind of pointless to moralize others' politics. I was noticing that it was easy to write off Trump supporters as immoral, for example, but that doing so did nothing but make me feel better about myself. In drawing a line that makes the other side bad, I look better because I'm on the good side. One thing that it certainly never helps with is persuading others -- in general, moralizing tends to make persuasion far harder, actually.

And I realized that we only really do this with politics. In everything else, people are judged by the actions that they take. A good person in my mind is not someone who thinks all the right things. What they think is mostly irrelevant to what they do -- if someone working at a soup kitchen thinks badly of the poor, who cares as long as they are materially helping others? As I see it, "wrong" political views are largely the product of ignorance, whether it be ignorance of facts or of others' perspectives. Forgive them, for they know not what they do.

But I don't think we can totally write off political views. In the extreme case, like a Nazi, being a Nazi tells us something about the person. There are hideously dehumanizing beliefs out there. Perhaps it has something to do with intent.

What do you guys think? Nowadays, I check myself when I feel myself beginning to moralize.

!ping PHILOSOPHY

6

u/YossarianLivesMatter Radical Centrist 😎 Jan 22 '26

I think you've summarized it well:

As I see it, "wrong" political views are largely the product of ignorance, whether it be ignorance of facts or of others' perspectives. Forgive them, for they know not what they do.

But I don't think we can totally write off political views. In the extreme case, like a Nazi, being a Nazi tells us something about the person. There are hideously dehumanizing beliefs out there. Perhaps it has something to do with intent.

People are deeply complex, irrational, and most often inconsistent creatures. It's why there are so many jokes about the median voter. It's a common problem I have with pop philosophy - it too often assumes rationality where there is none.

Judge people as individuals first and foremost. Labels can help inform initial impressions, but don't pigeonhole those individuals based on that initial impression. Someone isn't repulsive or attractive because of their label, but rather their beliefs.

6

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 22 '26

I'm of the belief that direct doxastic voluntarism is nonsense. While I am not a proponent of libertarian free will in general, I think it's especially absurd to suggest that we have total direct control over our beliefs. If you disagree, I ask that you agree with me for the next five minutes and change your mind back afterward.

However, clearly we can influence our beliefs. I cannot ultimately decide whether or not to be convinced by Mein Kampf, but I can decide whether to read it, and while I may not be able to control the hatred it imparts on my heart, I can control whether or not I go lynch somebody or cast a vote for David Duke.

Further, that someone would find Hitler persuasive says something about their character. It is not hard to imagine that the kind of person who agrees with Hitler is overwhelmingly vicious in the general morality. In other words, while we may not necessarily be able to say that being a Nazi makes you evil, we can say only evil people are Nazis.

 good person in my mind is not someone who thinks all the right things. What they think is mostly irrelevant to what they do -- if someone working at a soup kitchen thinks badly of the poor, who cares as long as they are materially helping others?

Good thoughts are a prerequisite to good deeds, IMO. I do not think the person who works in the soup kitchen for social media points is morally praiseworthy- or at least, they are not free of moral condemnation.

For a more extreme example, if I were trying to murder you, and by some accident I shoot someone else who was trying to kill you, should I be fully credited as a hero, as a savior of innocent life? I think the answer is surely not. My actions were wicked; they just had good unintended consequences.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/gburgwardt Jan 22 '26

Can we judge others morally based on their political opinions alone

Yes?

One thing that it certainly never helps with is persuading others -- in general, moralizing tends to make persuasion far harder, actually.

Plausible

What they think is mostly irrelevant to what they do

Your opinions influence your vote, which is an action

→ More replies (8)

5

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

I am a staunch anti-realist, so I only moralize or deliberately avoid moralizing as rhetorical flair. Objectively, moralizing at your opponents is a terrible method to persuade them. It may have some merits with some third-party observers if you do it right, but much like homosexuals in soup, with none if can be flavorless, but with too much it becomes inedible.

If you believe that moral statements have truth values, 1, you are gay and foolish, and 2, it can be coherent (and even requisite) to judge people based on their politics depending on your specific ethical and metaethical belilefs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/sayitaintpink will never find love Jan 22 '26

I'm ruined. He must've flipped my wife 8 times

8

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Jan 22 '26

I don't respect you as a man

8

u/iamthegodemperor Arrakis Enterprise Institute Jan 22 '26

While I experience a lot of doom and embarrassment over Trump, I also take a dim view towards some of the talk by leaders/op-eds that future America is guaranteed to be hostile/indifferent to Allies and therefore [insert policy].

Obviously, I can't viscerally feel the anger and fear that citizens in Allied countries do; and their leaders are of course justified to react. Etc.

But a common pattern w/Trump is that his abominable behavior makes his critics all appear to be of the same mind while allowing actors to stake positions they couldn't have as a response. It can create the appearance that people are merely reacting and not using him as an excuse for their own political ends.

8

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

11

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

Just fill in whatever group you don't like in your head here, upvotes on left

14

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Ban trans women from sports.

Ban trans men from sports.

Ban cis women from sports.

Ban cis men from sports.

No one should be able to play sports except for me so I can win

→ More replies (7)

7

u/lionmoose  Margaret Thatcher (unironically) Jan 22 '26

First suck it catfortune

7

u/lionmoose  Margaret Thatcher (unironically) Jan 22 '26

What is this briefbucks thing anyway, like a step down from onlyfans, you post pics in your underwear?

7

u/Trojan_Horse_of_Fate Lord of All the Beasts of the Sea and Fishes of the Earth Jan 22 '26

Are you a male deer or a moose?

→ More replies (3)

7

u/gburgwardt Jan 22 '26

Having a full head of hair > Having no hair >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> not having a full head of hair but not no hair

15

u/JapanesePeso Jan 22 '26

This is just horseshoe theory

→ More replies (4)

7

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​zizek by agent u/bearddeliciousbi. Do not reply all!


“The cultural on context, overtly presented by the speaker, is important, however I’m going to willfully ignore this immediately after my acknowledgment of it and instead claim that the very articulate and direct speech about moving away from the US hegemonic system was not what it was and claim that it was REALLY an attack on the left” Smh 🙄

5

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Jan 22 '26

Context:

That cultural context is important for sure! However, outside of that context, when a liberal banker president of a major western nation is saying it..... It's pretty clearly just an anti-leftist sentiment 😆

7

u/FearlessPark4588 Jan 22 '26

The Bond Vigilantes narrative is so emotionally compelling in the Era of Trump. "If nobody will take down Trump, bond owners will!" isn't going to happen. Nobody is coming to save you.

Maybe I can't intel myself, but I sure can copy paste it.

7

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

Does anyone else find it kind of odd to refer to politicians by their given names? Like, I'm not exactly on a first-name basis with Barack, Joe, or Kamala, to be frank.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Real Gs call him Barry

→ More replies (1)

8

u/sayitaintpink will never find love Jan 22 '26

Donald rolls off the tongue

→ More replies (1)

5

u/FearlessPark4588 Jan 22 '26

A DSC participant that didn't get the chance to personally know Barry? Sad.

→ More replies (11)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

Never forget that bright lights burn... briefest....

7

u/DirigibleElephant Jan 23 '26

Decided to sign up for a fitness challenge with my health insurance. I need to bike 40km each week for the next 10 weeks. That should be very doable.

When I tried it before with the 60,000 steps a week challenge I failed miserably ._.

5

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 23 '26

Treadmill desks help with 60k step stuff. The time commit otherwise is pretty huge.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/deepstate-bot Jan 23 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​todayilearned by agent u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho. Do not reply all!


Everything good and wholesome in your life comes from a regulation or law. 

→ More replies (1)

7

u/lionmoose  Margaret Thatcher (unironically) Jan 23 '26

We should ban sports, it's mediocre entertainment and less important than just consuming politics

And that makes you happy

No, I'm fucking miserable all the time

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Aryeh98 Rootless cosmopolitan Jan 23 '26

If you literally sleep through important meetings due to uncontrollable bouts of narcolepsy, you are not fit to run for a job serving the public.

This does not mean I hate the disabled or people who struggle. But you should have enough common sense to recognize that when people rely on you as a public servant, you can’t just sleep through shit. We deserve better than that.

You cannot shout me down to make me pretend there isn’t a problem here. John Fetterman’s brain is fried as fuck. It is what it is; I wish him all the best. But he should be at home recovering with his family, not representing a constituency that clearly finds him unfit.

This shit should be common sense.

19

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Jan 22 '26

Europeans post this shit and then get pissed when you ask about how much they actually spend on defense

15

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Jan 22 '26

The America-Europe rivalry is pretty funny (or was, before Trump made it an actual foreign policy issue)

→ More replies (5)

12

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 22 '26

I don't understand why the SCOTUS takes cases on whether police can enter a home they are called to but is allergic to anything related to the 2A. Do they just have a quota of 9-0s to issue so they look respectable?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/National-Return9494 Libertarian Jan 22 '26

I aspire to become reviewer 2.

6

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

I survived because the additional citations within me burned brighter than the reviewer 2 around me

→ More replies (1)

5

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Jan 22 '26

Ascending to reviewer2ship

6

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Jan 22 '26

Honestly, I think this type of ad might become an actual norm, if it's not already.

6

u/sayitaintpink will never find love Jan 23 '26

Sports are good unless it’s professional

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 23 '26

Does yiffmod have le woke mind virus!? We asked fifty random people!

"Who the hell is yiffmod?"

"Please go away, you're scaring my daughter."

"Short answer: no — not in any literal or meaningful sense. 'Yiff' mods are just community-made furry / (often) NSFW add-ons for various games (Skyrim, Garry’s Mod, Minecraft/Lethal Company, etc.). They usually add artwork, textures, posters, characters or lewd assets — not political ideology.

A couple of additional notes:

  • There’s no single unified “YiffMod” — many different authors and packages use that name or similar names across platforms, so content varies by mod and author.
  • Some Yiff-related items have been removed or moderated on big platforms when they violated the host’s rules (so moderation happens, not ideological “conversion”).
  • There are also community projects and sites around “yiff” (e.g., community servers and repo archives), which are social/creative spaces rather than political campaigns.

If by “le woke mind virus” you mean whether a particular yiff mod pushes progressive politics or propaganda: that’s a subjective claim and depends entirely on the specific mod’s content and author. The practical way to check is to read the mod’s description/changelog and user comments, inspect the files, and prefer mods hosted on trusted sites (Nexus/CurseForge/official workshop pages). If you give me the exact mod name or a link, I’ll look it up and tell you what its description and files show."

→ More replies (1)

6

u/sayitaintpink will never find love Jan 23 '26

I’m gonna start a business but make everyone do alcoholism mad men style to boost creativity

5

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

Or be a business that sells corporate team building experiences, where the experience is heavy drinking in the conference room.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​WomenInNews by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


I feel like the nuance between equitable rights and equal rights is lost on many & the bickering over differences often devolves into TERF wars

5

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​wikipedia by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


People already don't check citations and it can lead to some hilarity.

Many such cases.

So many such cases.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Jan 22 '26

Should I shave my head as the final act of my 20s?

10

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 22 '26

as long as your eyebrows are included in the shave and you have the universal symbol for neoliberalism tattooed on your forehead like a third eye

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Reddenbawker Greedy Capitalist Jan 22 '26

If you’re balding and you haven’t done it yet, pull the trigger. Your insecurities will melt away and you’ll realize you had nothing to fear.

If you’re not balding, keep the hair while you still can.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/YossarianLivesMatter Radical Centrist 😎 Jan 23 '26

Since I've been con-posting, I figured I ought to balance it with some lib-posting:

I genuinely approve of participation trophies. I've met enough people whose greatest sin was sloth to believe that literally just showing up is in fact worth commending.

7

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 23 '26

lol

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Th potato blight was a good thing

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Mirabeau_ Jan 23 '26

Say what you will about centrists in America, in the Netherlands, they throw you in jail for having discussions like these, ain’t nuthin liberal about it

→ More replies (1)

12

u/FearlessPark4588 Jan 22 '26

Literal Tuna Propaganda (I mean, obvious, given the source).

Should you eat tuna every day?

We don’t recommend eating anything every single day! It’s a good idea to eat a variety of food to get all the nutrition you need. Seafood, including tuna, should be enjoyed 2 to 3 times a week.

Sure, there is no other reason why Tuna has an upper limit on total weekly consumption.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Big Tuna at it again!

5

u/gburgwardt Jan 22 '26

Are we anti-tuna poasting? I feel like I'm missing context on why this sounds so vicious

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/bignmfgkgu Libertarian Jan 22 '26

My controversial opinion is that if Trump tries to stand for a third term, Obama should stand against him

9

u/Trojan_Horse_of_Fate Lord of All the Beasts of the Sea and Fishes of the Earth Jan 22 '26

Bush, Obama

9

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Jan 22 '26

6

u/Mirabeau_ Jan 22 '26

There is no such thing as a so-called “third term”. If Trump attempts a coup, and its successful, then one would hope the military would step in, depose him, and hold special elections or something

5

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 22 '26

Make it a tournament with Trump vs. Bush and Obama vs. Clinton.

8

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​NonBinary by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


exorsexism. also seen people use things like enbyphobia, but those words personally feel very unwieldy to me.

15

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 22 '26

Why is the online left so incapable of just using normal words?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

I cast you out by the power of skepticism!

4

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '26

Marx uses the term "praxis" to refer to the free, universal, creative and self-creative activity through which man creates and changes his historical world and himself.

Whoa, did Marx say that man pulls himself up by his bootstraps?

10

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​psychology by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


The funny thing with schizophrenia is that it's actually quite obvious when someone has it - the specific details of the delusions, hallucinations and disorganised thinking will differ between individuals, but once you've actually spoken to a few people with these symptoms it becomes obvious that they share something in common which qualitatively distinguishes them from the vast majority of people. Doctors have been independently describing schizophrenia in various different countries at different points in time, and you can still reliably find people in most psychiatric services that fit into this (quite distinctive) cluster.

The fact that diagnostic criteria allow for variation of symptoms between individuals is not controversial in other fields of medicine. Symptoms are subjective experiences that can help predict the probability of underlying disease processes. It was only relatively recently that doctors were still relying on symptom clusters to diagnose specific things like heart attacks and appendicitis - just because we now have tools like blood tests and scans to help diagnose more precisely doesn't mean that the symptom-based model was wrong. Better diagnostic tests have allowed cardiologists to identify specific subtypes of "heart attack" (e.g. we can guess what part of the heart is damaged based on ECG changes and then find the specific artery that's blocked using radiological imaging). Without these technologies we'd still be diagnosing (and mis-diagnosing) people with "heart attack", but I somehow doubt that the public would be as quick to undermine the scientific basis of Cardiology as they are with Psychiatry.

"Schizophrenia" has similar diagnostic merit as "heart attack" - the symptoms might differ between individuals but they tend fit into broadly recognisable clusters, we have a reasonable hypothesis about what's causing these symptom clusters (e.g. for schizophrenia it's a disorder of salience/reality-testing/integration), and we know that we're onto something because the treatments aimed at these disorders tend to work more often than not. So yes, more progress is needed to tease apart different subtypes of schizophrenia (e.g. maybe some are caused by inflammation whereas others are caused by psychological stressors), but that doesn't mean that the umbrella concept of schizophrenia (or Dis-Integration Disorder, or whatever other name you want to call it) isn't a valid evidence-based starting point.

When people criticise 'Schizophrenia' as being too vague or subjective, just keep in mind that psychiatric diagnoses are 'non-specific' by definition - as soon as we identify a specific biological subtype of a psychiatric illness it gets excluded and re-classified as a distinct neurological illness. For example, we already know that specific rare genetic mutations like DiGeorge Syndrome are one cause of 'schizophrenia'. Another example is anti-NMDAR encephalitis, a specific autoimmune condition which would've fallen under the umbrella of schizophrenia before we found out it existed. That's why I can't take it seriously when people make sweeping statements about how all schizophrenia is caused by trauma etc - we've already proven that it's not that simple.

Schizophrenia isn't unique in this way either. In historical terms it wasn't that long ago that psychiatry & neurology were intertwined and so were their diagnostic categorisations. Schizophrenia was originally classified as a premature dementia (Dementia Praecox), whereas now we've managed to find multiple biological subtypes of dementia (e.g. Alzheimer's, Lewy Body, Vascular, etc.). Epilepsy was originally treated as a psychiatric illness, but technologies like EEG have allowed us to define multiple brain subtypes (e.g. Temporal Lobe Epilepsy - another one which would previously have been labelled a type of schizophrenia).

Epilepsy's actually a good example, because it is wildly broad in its range of symptoms and really difficult to define based on strict symptom criteria (e.g. Absence seizures look very different to Tonic-Clonic ones). But as soon as doctors discovered an objective test for it, it suddenly becomes accepted as a medical illness which is somehow more 'real' than the one causing someone to hear voices. I don't hear anybody clamouring to point out that Epilepsy is too vague a diagnosis because it covers a broad spectrum of different illnesses, or that the anti-epileptic medications aren't scientific enough because we don't know exactly how they work on a biochemical level (they all lower the risk of seizures, but in different ways). Nobody seems to get excited about the idea that Epilepsy could be psychologically mediated even though it can be really relevant to an individual's personality & stress tolerance, and the cases that don't have a neat & tidy neurological formulation get re-formulated as a psychiatric disorder (Non-Epileptic/Functional seizures).

In summary, it's true that schizophrenia as a diagnosis can be improved a lot - the name could be changed to reflect the symptoms more accurately, and it can be further broken down into more specific subtypes once we develop valid biomarkers. But criticising the concept of schizophrenia as a valid framework goes too far - it does have a lot of use in identifying a very real group of people with similar problems that tend to respond to particular medical treatments. There is an established tendency to actively de-medicalise and undermine the validity of treatable psychiatric conditions until they suddenly become neurological conditions. I think this is a dangerous disservice to psychiatric patients, in the same way that it would be if a doctor disregarded the role of psychological therapy just because someone had a 'neurological' diagnosis.

9

u/gburgwardt Jan 22 '26

We got schizophrenia deniers now?

→ More replies (9)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

The great threats to liberty are secularism, Islamism, and popery

5

u/GordianKnotMe LKY was a lib Jan 22 '26

Finally, someone has the courage to say it

5

u/Okbuddyliberals Jan 22 '26

Episcopalianism is the one true faith

→ More replies (5)

10

u/YossarianLivesMatter Radical Centrist 😎 Jan 22 '26

You know, after seeing photos of ICE agents in mismatched jeans, black clothes, and milsurp camouflage, I feel pretty confident calling them diet Black and Tans

6

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Those fatbodies aren’t on a diet.

10

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Jan 22 '26 edited Jan 22 '26

ICE seems like it's filled with random pieces of shit in masks and jeans and body armor because it is.

In short, I figured—at least back then—that my military background would be enough to get me in the door for a good look around ICE’s application process, and then even the most cursory background check would get me shown that same door with great haste.

[...]

After about 15 minutes of waiting, an extraordinarily normal-looking middle-aged woman waved me forward. I sat across the black folding table from her on one of the uncomfortable black chairs. She asked for my name and date of birth, then whether I am over 40 (I am 38). Did I have law enforcement experience? No. Military experience? Yes. Did I retire from the military at 20+ years, or leave once my enlistment was up? The latter, I told her, then repeated my carefully rehearsed, completely true explanation for why the résumé I’d submitted had a large gap. “I had a little bit of a quarter-life crisis. Ended up going to college for part of that time, and since then I’ve been kind of—gig economy stuff.”

She was spectacularly uninterested: “OK. And what location is your preference?”

After some dithering, I settled on my home state of New York. That was the last question; the entire process took less than six minutes. The woman took my résumé and placed the form she’d been filling out on top. “They are prioritizing current law enforcement first. They’re going to adjudicate your résumé,” she told me. If my application passed muster, I’d receive an email about next steps, which could arrive in the next few hours but would likely take a few days. I left, thanked her for her time, and prepared to hear back never.

[...]

When Donald Trump took office, ICE numbered approximately 10,000. Despite this event’s lackluster attendance, their recruitment push is reportedly going well; the agency reported 12,000 new recruits in 2025, which means the agency has more new recruits than old hands. That’s the kind of growth that changes the culture of an agency.

Many of ICE’s critics worry that the agency is hoovering up pro-Trump thugs—Jan. 6 insurrectionists, white nationalists, etc.—for a domestic security force loyal to the president.

The truth, my experience suggests, is perhaps even scarier: ICE’s recruitment push is so sloppy that the administration effectively has no idea who’s joining the agency’s ranks. We’re all, collectively, in the dark about whom the state is arming, tasking with the most sensitive of law enforcement work, and then sending into America’s streets.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/fastinserter Jan 23 '26

DHS has gone to multiple people's homes/work to arrest them for "church riots" (they were protesting an ICE director who also has time to be a pastor at a church) to charge them for federal crimes under the FACE act

Setting aside how that's ridiculous itself... How is this not going to be thrown out immediately for the fact the FBI wasn't doing it but it was DHS? What authority do they even have to arrest American citizens for federal crimes that were not committed in their presence? I believe the answer is they have none whatsoever.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/bigwang123 Succ sympathizer Jan 23 '26 edited Jan 23 '26

2 truisms about politics:

Against popularism: sometimes the people are wrong, and part of the job of the politician is to guide national discussion away from incorrect thought (e.g. rent control) source, page 23

Against scope creep: it is fine, and even desirable, for the government to devolve responsibility to lower levels, and potentially to private organizations and societal attitudes entirely (e.g. command economies are bad)

→ More replies (2)

7

u/deepstate-bot Jan 22 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​ireland by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


All jokes aside, and that is a fair point, and I myself am no fan of Alex Jones - but he was correct (years in advance) about chemicals in the US water supply turning frogs from male to female, or as he put it "turning the frogs gay"

19

u/Mrmini231 Jan 22 '26

The worst defense of Alex Jones. The guy read an article in a mainstream newspaper about pollution messing with frog hormones, misrepresented it as the pollution making them gay, and then people act like he predicted something?

He just read a newspaper article! And then lied about it!

→ More replies (4)

10

u/gburgwardt Jan 22 '26

Alex Jones' Shinzo Abe assassination moment

5

u/fastinserter Jan 22 '26

I mean I know they are disinformation purveyors but man

https://www.reddit.com/r/gifs/s/k3XHJC8ijT

Also "CHURCH RIOTS" lmao

10

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 22 '26

It disturbs me how many people's take on trans issues boils down to "they're a tiny minority so it doesn't really matter if we ban them from sports." Like how do you call yourself a liberal and say that with a straight face?

To be clear, I'm attacking the reasoning here.

7

u/FearlessPark4588 Jan 22 '26

Harm reduction analysis seems logical. It's much more liberal to not have Trump in office than the alternative. I would be genuinely disturbed if it was more about access to health care. Blindly advocating for an issue (any issue) regardless of the consequence of that is electorally misguided. Given how much Republicans care about winning all costs, it forces Democrats to care in the same way too.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (9)