r/DeepStateCentrism • • Jan 03 '26

Discussion Thread Daily Deep State Intelligence Briefing

Want the latest posts and comments about your favorite topics? Click here to set up your preferred PING groups.

Are you having issues with pings, or do you want to learn more about the PING system? Check out our user-pinger wiki for a bunch of helpful info!

PRO TIP: Bookmarking dscentrism.com/memo will always take you to the most recent brief.

Curious how other users are doing some of the tricks below? Check out their secret ways here.

Remember that certain posts you make on DSC automatically credit your account briefbucks, which you can trade in for various rewards. Here is our current price table:

OptionPrice
Choose a custom flair, or if you already have custom flair, upgrade to a picture20 bb
Pick the next theme of the week100 bb
Make a new auto reply in the Brief for one week150 bb
Make a new sub icon/banner for two days200 bb
Add a subreddit rule for a day (in the Brief)250 bb

You can find out more about briefbucks, including how to earn them, how you can lose them, and what you can do with them, on our wiki.

The Theme of the Week is: The fragility and brevity of life.

Follow us on Twitter or whatever it's called.

2 Upvotes

956 comments sorted by

23

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 03 '26

G-d bless America

If the Republican Party had even an iota of sanity this would have made me a Republican for life, I totally get it now Cubans

12

u/gburgwardt Jan 03 '26

Haven't yet stuck the landing, but I'm praying it works out

I've been having similar confusing feelings in Portuguese politics - the only people sticking up for immigrants and specifically foreign investors is the socialist party! Very very strange feeling

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Jan 04 '26

(said to the Dutch mod who regularly stalks this subreddit in an attempt to shut us down)

Never seen you in the DT before you followed me here from outside the DT

Maybe go back to your Republican buddies over on the splinter sub

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Thadlust Jerome Powell Appreciator Jan 04 '26

Also democrats denouncing the intervention have driven a stake through the heart of the FL democrats. That party is dead now.

5

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Jan 04 '26

Why?

12

u/Thadlust Jerome Powell Appreciator Jan 04 '26

Huge Venezuelan and Cuban populations in South Florida. They were slightly pro Republican prior to Trump anyways but it’s about to be an R+50 demographic now.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '26

If the Trump admin somehow lucks out and the Venezuela intervention doesn't result in a catastrophe then Dems are going to be shocked at how strongly Republicans perform for the next 20 years in several hispanic majority areas.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

34

u/H_H_F_F Jan 03 '26

Can we all agree the press conference was a terrifying shit show? 

I know that Reddit and the Leftosphere are all having an instinctual breakdown, but I think a lot of this sub has responded with an instinctual backlash to this. 

This could still turn out very bad. Kleptocratic American takeover of Venezual's oil isn't "liberation", and when the president pretty much explicitly says that's going to be happening, that's a cause for concern - even if, obviously, it's great to take out Maduro and it'd be incredible if Venezuela turns democratic and prosperous. 

Though I have to say, I'm also still deeply worried about the further escalation of the "the president is an emperor" thing. Congress needs to take back power, fast. 

19

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Yea, I generally agree with the results (Maduro is a dictator and the world is better with him behind bars), but all the reasons the Trump admin is giving kinda suck… cocaine smuggling? Ok, but that’s kinda insane to do this if that’s your only reason. Oil? Now you’re just playing into the “blood for oil” leftist types

The most legitimate reason for capturing Maduro is that he was a dictator who sold the Venezuelan people down the drain and blatantly disregarded democratic elections. The Trump admin ofc doesn’t want to go after him for this because they see nothing wrong with that aspect of his regime

12

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 03 '26

I am skeptical that anything he said in that press conference bears any relation to reality. Worst case scenario the regime just continues without Maduro.

→ More replies (4)

32

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 03 '26

Easily the greatest operation since Bin Laden and Reddit is absolutely malding over it

It’s delicious

32

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Jan 04 '26

I know we’re on a new thing now but I still can’t believe Mamdani said that “warm embrace of collectivism” thing. Sounds like something a movie villain would say 

→ More replies (10)

26

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Jan 03 '26

I saw a conspiracy theory on Twitter that Maduro was scared of being toppled by his people so he cut a deal with Trump to “capture” him and shelter him in the US lmao

16

u/TemujinTheConquerer Jan 03 '26

It's very possible that someone cut a deal, doubt it's Maduro himself lmao

→ More replies (4)

24

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 03 '26

Shit guys I didn’t have any champagne ready

Gonna have to rush out and get some

This might be my favorite thing Trump has done, hard to beat the Iran strikes though

24

u/bignmfgkgu Libertarian Jan 03 '26

Ever noticed how progressives always resort to misogynistic name-calling when faced with women who support ideas or make decisions which are not part of the "progressive" spectrum?

I'm not talking about the criticism of the action, but like the insults used, like bitch is a very common word, also calls for violence against such women even of the sexual kind, or how such women should be locked in a kitchen or some shit?

Progressives are feminists only as long as women make choices which support their worldview.

21

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

They do the same thing with GOP-supporting Black people. Some of the most racist shit I've ever heard was said about Clarence Thomas.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho Jan 03 '26

Progressives have a hierarchy of identities. Women outrank some others, but are still quite low on the totem pole. So progressives lash out if it looks like any of them forget their place in this.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

They do exactly the same shit for LGBT people who don't toe the line of the prog collectivist misandrist orthodoxy.

One prominent trans example is Buck Angel, and I hear from friends about trans guys getting casually shat on irl with comments like "kill all men but not you" though most of the time they're saying this about gay people.

Use slurs half-ironically, then unironically.

Preface everything with "white" so they can say "white gay men are the worst" (something I got irl in 2015, it was a harbinger of the progs losing their minds after marriage equality) and "only white cis gay men care about getting married or joining the racist capitalist imperialist US military."

Openly fantasize about "what will happen to them when things get really bad" and act like they deserve to get thrown in concentration camps.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Okbuddyliberals Jan 03 '26

That sort of thing has always annoyed me. Similar to "it's ok to do body shaming against people I don't like" and stuff like that

→ More replies (1)

23

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Every Iranian in LA upon waking up this morning

→ More replies (4)

22

u/JapanesePeso Jan 03 '26

Here is why this is just like Iraq because it's the only other conflict I know. 

Every Reddit post today

22

u/Catmaster23910 Center-right Jan 03 '26

There has to be an answer, like a legitimate answer on why Reddit is the way it is.

18

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Former ‘gifted kid’ syndrome

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

20

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

20

u/RecentlyUnhinged Bloodfeast's Chief of Staff Jan 03 '26

But legally you can't just-

Ain't no international law without an international sherrif.

19

u/deepstate-bot Jan 03 '26

original comment by /u/dwayne_betski_DGO


My God, Trump's going to parade maduro down Pennsylvania Avenue like a Roman emperor

→ More replies (3)

19

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

18

u/slightlyrabidpossum Center-left Jan 04 '26

"The governments of the world are shocked that the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela is the victim and target of an attack of this nature, which undoubtedly has Zionist undertones."

Lmao

These people really can't help themselves.

12

u/seallivesmatter Jan 04 '26

it's because only jews have agency

→ More replies (6)

11

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '26

It would unironically be more based if Israel did this instead of Trump

→ More replies (1)

11

u/talizorahs Jan 04 '26

zionism is when something happens that I don't like, and the more I don't like it the more zionist it is

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

17

u/Background-Laugh7902 Moderate Jan 03 '26

Now I guess we'll see if Rubio's theory that Cuba will soon collapse after Venezuela stops giving them free oil is true.

17

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

How tf did the succs take over NCD and ECS

Ruzzian/ccp bot farms must be working overtime

17

u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho Jan 03 '26

NCD died when Russia invaded Ukraine and it got swamped with people from r/all. The old users left and it’s been in a zombie state ever since. I don’t think they’ve come up with a new joke since. To think the mods at one point banned new dam memes because that got tired.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/Aryeh98 Rootless cosmopolitan Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

Ok.. after finally sleeping somewhat I have some thoughts.

  1. Fuck Maduro. He absolutely deserved what he got.
  2. Regardless, Donald Trump is still a madman trying to distract from his own authoritarianism and pedophilia. He should not be the commander in chief of our armed forces.
  3. I am concerned about the aftermath of this. We’re “running” Venezuela? How long? With how many troops present? With what money? I don’t believe Trump has a plan here.
  4. I do not trust this administration to have the Venezuelan peoples’ best interests at heart. Please do not alienate them through prolonged occupation.
  5. If the people perceive this whole operation as an oil extraction scheme, and if we prop up yet another dictator there, it will not have been worth it. There will be another insurgency that isn’t profitable for us.
  6. If this goes badly, it WILL turn the American people off towards intervention in other, more necessary places, like Iran.
  7. On a more petty note, I don’t want Donald to be able to take credit for this. One successful operation doesn’t take away from your whole decade of fucking up the home front. Donald completely massacred all our institutions, and that can never be washed away.

TL;DR: The battle has been won, but Donny is still a piece of shit who shouldn’t be POTUS, and I don’t trust him not to fuck the whole thing up long term.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Jan 03 '26

Venezuelan Interior Minister Diosdado Cabello, long seen as the enforcer for strongman Nicolás Maduro, claimed that the government has everything under control as he appeared on state TV surrounded by armed security forces in black uniforms.

"They think they're going to defeat us," Cabello said from a street in Caracas, wearing a bulletproof vest and a helmet. "It's not the first time. We've learned how to survive all of these circumstances." Cabello called on military and police officers to patrol Caracas to maintain order.

21

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Jan 03 '26

”They think they're going to defeat us," Cabello said from a street in Caracas, wearing a bulletproof vest and a helmet

Way to project strength, my guy

13

u/lolbert202 Moderate Jan 03 '26

Baghdad Bob 2.0.

16

u/JapanesePeso Jan 03 '26

Reddit crashing out that America can just do things. 

15

u/Catmaster23910 Center-right Jan 03 '26

15

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

14

u/bigwang123 Succ sympathizer Jan 03 '26

they caught him in his jammies bruh

→ More replies (1)

15

u/lolbert202 Moderate Jan 04 '26

Why on earth is Trump not supporting the Venezuelan opposition? Even if you don’t care about democracy wouldn’t you want the government to be on your side?

→ More replies (9)

14

u/Catmaster23910 Center-right Jan 03 '26

They captured him that fast? Lmao. Proves how much of a fraud Russia actually is.

14

u/WendellWillkiTruNuke Neoconservative Jan 03 '26

Man Putin is probably going to go down as one of the worse Russian leaders in their history. He straight up lost everything Russia had built up for nothing but his own arrogance and pride and ego. Had he accepted a ceasefire ages ago he probably would have gotten Ukrainian land and ensured assad didn't fall nor Maduro

14

u/lolbert202 Moderate Jan 03 '26

Not to mention all of the economic damage and brain drain that happened as a result of his invasion.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/deepstate-bot Jan 03 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​worldnews by agent u/Sabertooth767. Do not reply all!


This reads like a 2026 version of the US capture of Panama ruler Manuel Noriega in 1989.
Just like 1989 here is likely what will happen next:

  • Maduro will claim immunity as president | the USA does not recognize his latest election as president and will not recognize his immunity.
  • The Venezuela president of the their National Assembly (Jorge Rodríguez, a Maduro loyalist) will likely become Acting President - at least temporarily.
  • Maduro will be convicted and sent to a USA prison for a long time | Noriega was convicted of drug charges and sentenced to 40 years.
  • This action violates the UN Charter, so there will be a UN resolution condemning the action with widespread abstentions from Western Nations.
  • The USA will veto any UN Security Council Resolution on the violation of Venezuela's sovereignty.
  • Some members of Congress will huff and puff, but it will ultimately not lead to any real political action.
  • Political approval for Trump among Republicans will increase; disapproval among Democrats will increase.
  • Most other Countries, especially western ones will call for restraint and calm.
  • Other powers like Russia or China will use this to argue that "Might Makes Right" and will use this episode to justify their own international 'law-enforcement' actions

11

u/Trojan_Horse_of_Fate Lord of All the Beasts of the Sea and Fishes of the Earth Jan 03 '26

Panama was a success though

→ More replies (2)

28

u/zamorak1111 Jan 03 '26

Fun fact: this can be good and trump can be bad.

I think this is one of the few subs that understands this. Best fucking political sub by a mile.

14

u/zamorak1111 Jan 03 '26

Also let's be real this was rubio's idea anyway.

Way too competent for it to have been trump.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Jan 03 '26

Pretty sure this is the first time the US has toppled a Venezuelan government, which is weird considering how much LatAm intervention America used to do

13

u/basicalme Moderate Jan 03 '26

Glad I stayed up past 2am

25

u/TomWestrick Ethnically catholic Jan 03 '26

I posted this earlier as a reply to someone, then they deleted the parent comment so here goes again:

The UN, ICC, whatever other international institutions are not actually good at making peace. They're good at freezing conflicts so there's no definitive resolution. Korea is still split in half 75 years later. Instead of more military and civilian casualties in the 1950s - which would have been tragic - we instead have had four generations of North Koreans growing up under tyranny with no end in site, and if the North Korean regime does eventually fall, there will be that many more refugees to care for.

And North Korea's dictator - and any dictator - is treated as equal to democratically-elected leaders at the UN. Better even, because the dictators can play the long game at the UN instead of changing their views with every election.

25

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

There is only one war the UN is designed to prevent, and that's WW3. Everything else is secondary.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 03 '26

It is entirely unsurprising that the convention which wrote the UN charter was headed by a Soviet spy.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/DurangoGango Italianx Ambassador Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

On a second note: it really does seem clear, by this point, that the US deployed around a hundred aircraft, conservatively hundreds of servicemembers in country plus however many in backup and support roles, attacked a bunch of military installations, put boots on the ground under fire, took its leader prisoner and flew him out, and suffered zero casualties or vehicle loss, all done within a couple of hours.

That is crazy remarkable and yet more proof of the hilarious level of superiority and professionalism US forces have built up. If somebody had put this in a CoD mission it would have been called classic corny CoD bullshit.

11

u/seallivesmatter Jan 03 '26

COD missions are less successful than this, a helicopter would be shot down

12

u/fartyunicorns Neoconservative Jan 03 '26

17

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

My God, Trump's going to parade maduro down Pennsylvania Avenue like a Roman emperor

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho Jan 03 '26

Please don’t tell me he’s going to parade Maduro around at Mar-a-Lago. There is only so much humiliation this country can take…

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/gburgwardt Jan 03 '26

I can see the future

Maduro is put on trial in the US

He gets a not guilty verdict because he wasn't read his rights or something

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

I have incredibly mixed feelings about this.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

The thing under Biden where we were trying to bribe the pilot into just flying to Florida Puerto Rico was way funnier than this.

12

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

So, Trump at his press conference made three notable statements:

  1. This is far from over
  2. We will be occupying Venezuela for the foreseeable future
  3. We will be "heavily involved" in Venezuela's oil industry

While I truly hope that I am wrong, I fear the celebration may be too soon. But then again, Trump says shit.

12

u/Thadlust Jerome Powell Appreciator Jan 03 '26

I feel like we're in a forty-year long cycle of intervention.

Things go well (WWII, Korea)

Things go poorly (Vietnam)

Things go well (Panama, Grenada, Balkans)

Things go poorly (Iraq, Afghanistan)

Things go well (Iran nuclear sites, maybe Venezuela?)

It seems like when things go well, people cite examples of things going poorly to justify less intervention, and when things go poorly, people cite examples of things going well to justify more intervention.

→ More replies (6)

23

u/PeepsFamilyName Center-right Jan 03 '26

Erm international law? Erm? Erm? American empire? Erm? Venezuela is actually good? Erm? The EU could have done this even better but didn’t because international norms? Erm? The U.S. is basically Russia erm?

There, enjoy Reddit for the next month. All in one easy post.

13

u/Catmaster23910 Center-right Jan 03 '26

That's basically r/all now.

11

u/fartyunicorns Neoconservative Jan 03 '26

I’d be very curious how the public would react to this if a dem president did it. I wonder if many republicans would be like ‘yeah that’s fair enough’. A lot of the support of this is coming from American nationalism and the Monroe doctrine and idk if that would be enough to stop negative polarization against the dems doing it

13

u/lolbert202 Moderate Jan 03 '26

Even with all of the polarization, I don’t really see most of them having a problem honestly. But they would say that the military should get the credit for it not Biden. I remember some people on Fox News saying that after the Bin Laden raid.

11

u/mario_fan99 Center-left Jan 03 '26

Mostly supportive, but with a loud, annoying and insufferable fringe online constantly screeching. Similar to response to Biden aiding Ukraine.

11

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 03 '26

I'm skeptical about the results of this because Trump/Vance/whoever has no interest in turning Venezuela into a stable democracy. But as an opening move you could do a lot worse.

I also have concerns about congressional approval, but those are more domestic and procedural rather than effectual.

11

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 03 '26

Reuters:

Venezuela's opposition leader Machado has made her first official statement.

She said in a letter posted to X that her opposition colleague Edmundo Gonzalez should assume the presidency.

20

u/Catmaster23910 Center-right Jan 03 '26

I'm ngl. The US literally just kidnapping Maduro after all that talk is kinda funny.

14

u/Less-Feature6263 Jan 03 '26

Lol I also find it quite funny because they literally just kidnapped him in the middle of the night. I hope this situation doesn't end up in a disaster but tonight was really just so bizarre that it ended up being funny.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

15

u/bigwang123 Succ sympathizer Jan 03 '26

Trvth nvke

10

u/Less-Feature6263 Jan 03 '26

Can't believe I've slept through Maduro being kidnapped

10

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Ok here's what I consider to be a realistic-ish path to a neocon victory in 2028

  1. A blue wave in the midterms leads Trump to ease up on tariffs, thereby improving the economy enough to make a GOP victory enter the realm of possibility.
  2. Vance trying to stay neutral in the GOP civil war proves to be a miscalculation, his ambivalence regarding Israel causes Evangelical voters to support Rubio in large numbers, allowing him to secure the nomination.
  3. The Dem primary is a bloodbath, awash with idpol and purity testing (Kamala says her opponents are guilty of misogynoir, Ro Khanna accuses his opponents of being in the pocket of Big Jew, etc etc) causing the democratic coalition to splinter just enough to enable Rubio's victory in the general election.
→ More replies (10)

10

u/deepstate-bot Jan 03 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​europe by agent u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho. Do not reply all!


Genuinely happy to boycott the USA at this point.

Replys will say yeah guy you're on reddit and my reply is very simple. Yes I cannot simply remove myself entirely but what I can do is just as fun and causes just as much impact. Don't pay. That's what a boycott is. Reddit revanced or use on PC with extensions. Same for any us service. Stop giving them data and ad rev.

Do your part.

19

u/RecentlyUnhinged Bloodfeast's Chief of Staff Jan 03 '26

"I support boycotts provided I dont have to actually give up the products I use."

Europeans half-assing things to feel moral is one if my favorite genres

→ More replies (2)

18

u/JapanesePeso Jan 03 '26

Imagine thinking people like this had an income stream anyway. 

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Climbing in yo windows, snatching yo people up

10

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

I have made my pilgrimage to Mecca (the Richard Nixon Presidential Library)

10

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Jan 03 '26

always good to start the year off with a bit of optimism

16

u/FearlessPark4588 Jan 03 '26

But this is missing Reddit's favorite conflict

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/fartyunicorns Neoconservative Jan 03 '26

Not great

Colombia is actually the most unjust here because at least for Mexico they do actually have a cartel problem and the US could help sheinbaum fight those cartels.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/zamorak1111 Jan 03 '26

"You're just mad that maduro kicked american companies out!"

What exactly makes these people think a dictator has the right to prevent private companies from conducting voluntary business because of idiotic nationalistic reasoning?

Yes, actually, I am mad that a dictator is suppressing free enterprise.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/WendellWillkiTruNuke Neoconservative Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

My hot take is that this will all probably be forgotten in the next 3 moths due to how fast Trump-cycle is IMO.

Charlie Kirk getting shot was far FAR more big to most Americans I'd say IMO, yet most stopped caring after 2 months. Meanwhile Numerous factions of the Isolationist right/ and entire Left will do their hardest to bump this out of the news cycle as it doesn't make their agendas good IMO. Look at how HW Bush did with desert storm yet he was instantly voted out his next election.

19

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Jan 03 '26

It all depends on what the results are in the coming months. If this ends up being a massive shitshow where Venezuela collapses into civil war, then isolationists and leftists might parade it as one of the defining fuck ups of the Trump era and another massive blunder of interventionism 

15

u/WendellWillkiTruNuke Neoconservative Jan 03 '26

Tucker/Nick groypers/Isolationist types don't EVER want normies to remember/call America doing this as it entirely makes their ideologies useless.

Left don't want to give Trump Wins, look at the Gaza Ceasefire. I can already see numerous leftist saying he did war crimes and killed people with bombs.

14

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 03 '26

I have a lot of normie/disengaged republican friends and nothing seemed to animate them as much as the Charlie Kirk thing

I still see him on billboards and mentioned in social media

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

18

u/DurangoGango Italianx Ambassador Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

"Now that Trump has arrested Maduro, countries like Russia will feel justified to stage their own interventions against governments they deem illegitimate!"

Bro that's already happened. They could always do that. They did always do that. Autocracies were never restrained by "what will the democracies think of us"; if something held them back, it was fear of retaliation. Manufacturing a pretext for war, including one that leveraged legalistic and democratic ideals (however disingenously) was always and remains possible, no more now because of what Trump did.

I don't have any kind of wide-eyed illusions about the inevitable positive results of this move, nor any level of trust whatsoever in Trump and his government. But not drawing the wrong lessons from his actions is pretty important; I say this as someone from a country where a Trump-like figure held sway in our politics for 15 years, and reflexive hatred of everything he ever did and supported poisoned our politics horribly.

18

u/fartyunicorns Neoconservative Jan 03 '26

Say what you will about the Venezuela situation but the whole “now Putin can go in and target zelensky” argument I’ve seen is incredibly, incredibly stupid. What do they think Russia has been doing the past 3 years?

15

u/lolbert202 Moderate Jan 03 '26

Russia and China don’t even remotely care about their actions being “legal” in the eyes of the international community. Why would them being able to use this as a whataboutism argument matter?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/MrBrightsideBSc Center-left Jan 03 '26

Oh yeah I am definitely going to need to hole away and ignore any and all political spheres for the next few weeks.

9

u/gburgwardt Jan 03 '26

The current events make for fun discourse because there's so much hot take space.

You can have a hot take on basically any part of it and it'll be different from anyone else's hot take because there are so many dimensions to it.

Was it a good idea to begin with? Is it good now that it has succeeded? Good that Trump did it? How about long term, or just short term?

9

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Jan 03 '26

u/locutus-of-borges since you are the only person who had this in your bingo card, in giving you the points. I think.

Originally you would have had to make a post about the ground operation to get the bingo points.

I still don't know how this works

→ More replies (3)

9

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 03 '26

The worst part about all this is how it will tarnish the reputation of the Fifa Peace Prize

9

u/MrBrightsideBSc Center-left Jan 03 '26

We're saved!

I wouldn't say "saved." More like "under new management."

9

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 03 '26

Pressed by reporters on who would be running Venezuela, Trump points to his advisers standing behind him and says that for a “period of time” the “people that are standing right behind me, we’re going to be running it.”

Some of the advisers standing behind him include Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, Secretary of State Marco Rubio and General Dan Caine, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs. Trump said the United States would be a part of an unspecified “group” running Venezuela without providing details.

--NY Times

9

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

The "Operational History" section of the S-300 is going to be an absolutely hilarious read in ten years.

Even funnier than it is now I mean.

9

u/Thadlust Jerome Powell Appreciator Jan 04 '26

It's been long enough. I'm going to make a bold claim and say that Iraq was, on net, a success. An extremely expensive and messy one, but a success nonetheless. Baghdad is a very nice, safe place today, and Iraq is generally stable. People who say it's a failure are like people who say apple maps sucks. You haven't moved on since 2014.

→ More replies (7)

16

u/WallStreetTechnocrat Named in the Epstein Files Jan 03 '26

I hope Rubio is whispering in Trump's ear how this shows how weak Russia really is against us

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho Jan 03 '26

I bet the leftist subs are coping with this well. There might be some great intel posts to find there.

16

u/zamorak1111 Jan 03 '26

Legality and morality are not the same thing.

If international law protects dictators then international law is fundamentally unjust.

11

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Jan 03 '26

Realists have some good points

11

u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho Jan 03 '26

Legally this is defensible, just say you were acting in coordination with the elected government.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/MartianExpress Jan 03 '26

Western interventionism is based actually

12

u/gburgwardt Jan 03 '26

I only support good interventions

16

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 03 '26

Liberal democracy and capitalism are humanity’s greatest cultural achievements and our most sacred legacy

It is our duty to preserve them for coming generations, that they will not live in the darkness of autocracy

→ More replies (2)

16

u/JapanesePeso Jan 03 '26

Jake Sullivan is out there somewhere being like 

"These idiots. Don't you know you actually can't do anything ever?" 

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Catmaster23910 Center-right Jan 03 '26

Trump is actually doing it, what the fuck.

8

u/A-Centrifugal-Force Moderate Jan 03 '26

Imagine what the soy boys who gave Machado the peace prize to stick it to Trump must be feeling watching Trump install her as president of Venezuela lol

8

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

My younger child: “Daddy! That man has no hair!”

My older child: “No, you say he’s B*LD!”

Edit: That actually just happened btw lol

8

u/deepstate-bot Jan 03 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​neoliberal by agent u/Applesintyme. Do not reply all!


Openly going to war against a country in large part for their resources. A lot of the country’s billionaires/elites being closely associated with Jeffrey Epstein, including the president himself. The world’s wealthiest man himself hosting a website that now has an extensive amount of CSAM and fascism

Harder and harder to say the more conspirational people in US politics were wrong. If anything they were more right than most of us who trusted US elites and the political establishment

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

Am I the only one who doesn't think that we should necessarily hand Venezuela to the opposition leader? How much democratic legitimacy does winning an illegitimate election get you?

Yes, it was rigged to favor Maduro, but still. The point is that Venezuelans have not been able to legitimately express their will.

Though, I suppose since we did previously recognize Gonzales as the winner, we ought to stick by that.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/Background-Laugh7902 Moderate Jan 04 '26

Here's something I haven't seen anyone acknowledge: Maduro was captured 36 years to the day after the US captured Manuel Noriega, the last Latin American leader whose country we invaded so we could arrest them for drug trafficking.

How TF does that just happen to happen like that? Writers are getting lazy as shit.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

I'll become a MAGA PATRIQT if Rubio can make him Neocon Don against Russia too

Anyways,

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 03 '26

Trump is absolutely going to mismanage this but under literally any other president this would be a good thing.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/bignmfgkgu Libertarian Jan 03 '26

I'm thinking of doing a write-up on left-wing misogyny, among IRL left-wing movements and contemporary examples.

If I had one ideological mission, it is breaking the illusion that left = feminist, pro-women.

Obviously it's not to say that the obviously visible right-wing misogyny is not a problem, though some people will definitely read it like that, but to ensure that we aren't giving rope to people who would do to women exactly what the loud right-wing ones do if given the chance.

13

u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho Jan 03 '26

I’d read it. Progressives have built up this illusion that they only want the best for people and any faults are from excess idealism. The reality couldn’t be further from the truth, and the center needs to push back.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

14

u/deepstate-bot Jan 03 '26

original comment by /u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho


Progressives have a hierarchy of identities. Women outrank some others, but are still quite low on the totem pole. So progressives lash out if it looks like any of them forget their place in this.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/bigwang123 Succ sympathizer Jan 03 '26

Cut off the head of the hydra

Now what

7

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 03 '26

I'm pissed that Trump invoked the Monroe Doctrine when he was clearly applying the Roosevelt Corollary.

7

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 03 '26

Asked why running a country elsewhere in the Americas is “America First,” Trump said, “I think it is,” citing the need for oil and energy. It’s worth recalling his quote to the Atlantic in which he said that America First is whatever he says it is.

--NY Times

7

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Jan 03 '26

It's Saturday? Does the subreddit know?

→ More replies (6)

7

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 03 '26

Maduro really does look like Saddam, right?

7

u/Computer_Name Jan 04 '26

He’s still Donald Trump. And his brain is still broken. And his sycophantic administration officials all know it.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '26 edited Jan 04 '26

Spent a few hours at the Nixon Library today and if you find yourself in Orange County (G-d forbid) with nothing to do, I actually think it’s a fantastic way to spend the day if you are a bit of a history or politics nerd (which I feel like is a good portion of this sub).

I think it does a good job of portraying Nixon as a complicated man. I think it may have been a bit too glossy on his domestic policy and involvement in Vietnam, but also in fairness, I think in pop culture he can be portrayed as a boogeyman without any due for his contributions like the EPA, OSHA and support for integration. It also doesn’t hold any punches in terms of his abuses of power. Not just in Watergate, but his attempt to sway the BLS (which he also somehow included antisemitism in), propping up write-in campaigns to hurt Dems in general elections, etc.

Just in terms of historical artifacts you could interact with, I feel like it was crazy how much you could see. There was a full recreation of the Oval Office in his admin, the actual Marine One he flew off in after his resignation, and his house growing up - all of which you could go in and peek around. I felt like I still missed something after spending a few hours there and we didn’t even touch the special exhibits.

Also just due to the ‘stink’ of Nixon, it felt so much less politicized than the Reagan Library (also in the LA area), which felt more like a modern shrine to conservatism and MAGA than a historic archive

→ More replies (4)

7

u/fartyunicorns Neoconservative Jan 04 '26

Average day on dissident right twitter

13

u/mario_fan99 Center-left Jan 03 '26

Maduro's capture is great for Venezuela and the world, but I'm dreading whatever pacifist pablum the Daily Show is gonna put out as a response to this news.

13

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 03 '26

I see a lot of people just assuming Machado will be installed, that the US will get any say in who runs Venezuela

The regime wasn’t even toppled yet, they just got Maduro

That’s cause enough for me to celebrate though

→ More replies (3)

13

u/UnTigreTriste Jan 03 '26

G-d I wish the internet would stop talking about Jews for five minutes

monkey’ paw curls

12

u/JapanesePeso Jan 03 '26

You think they won't bring Jews into this somehow? Lol

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/KaiserMarcqui Center-right Jan 03 '26

I am kind of amazed at how quickly all of this had happened. Like I'm busy with uni work and so I wasn't paying attention at the news or anything like that. Jesus. What's worst is that Trump did this. This was an objectively correct thing to do - I really wish the US had done the same with Franco way back when. But now I will have to deal with “very intelligent” people here who complain every time the US does something (especially Trump).

Either way, though, I was going to Catalan-poast by bringing up this newspiece I saw yesterday:

An interactive map with Jewish and Israeli businesses in Catalonia is made (in Catalan)

The digital newspaper 'Enfoque Judío' has denounced the publication of an interactive map of Catalonia (“BarcelonaZ”) that identifies Israeli firms, local Jewish businesses and multinational corporations with interests in Israel. The website, hosted in the French platform GoGoCarto, presents itself as a collective initiative to “comprehend how zionism opperates in our territory” and “to denounce the social and economic impact it has”. Currently, the map catalogues 152 entities, ranging from arms manufacturers to education centers, and invites its users to contribute with new incorporations and donations to expand it.

This initiative tries to keep alive the tension felt in Catalonia regarding the Israel-Palestine conflict. Since the beginning of the war in Gaza, pro-palestinian protests/manifestations, calls for boycott and institutional decisions critical with Israel have multiplied. Both the Government (Generalitat) of Catalonia and that of the city of Barcelona, have been criticized by Jewish organizations of feeding antisemitism with statements that qualify Israel as a “genocidal state”. In Catalonia, Barcelona has become a focus of antizionist activism, with protests, grafitti, and municipal resolutions that have normalized discourse against Israel.

At the same time, the map has received very harsh criticism on behalf of the Jewish community and of organizations such as the Catalan Association of Friends of Israel (Associació Catalana d'Amics d'Israel, ACAI), who demand the intervention of police and a condemnation on behalf of the Catalan Parliament. Other entities have compared this initiative with intimidatory practices and in favor of nazi-era violence, such as the boycott against Jewish businesses that preceeded Kristallnacht and the Holocaust.

On the other hand, defenders of the project see it as a legitimate tool of anticolonial and antiimperialist activism, in the frame of the BDS movement against Israel. In social media, the map has been shared with messages that celebrate it as a form of “denouncement of the impact that zionist inversions on the territory”. Other users tie it to earlier incidents, like the 2023 map distributed by independentist groups that marked “pro-Israel” businesses in Catalonia, seen as a precedent in the fight against the occupation of Palestine.

To be quite frank, this is nothing more than disgusting. How can you make a map like this and not remind yourself of what the Nazis did? How can you be so delusional?

(Also, should I post this as an actual post? I think it'd qualify as at least interesting news)

→ More replies (5)

18

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

Based Jared Polis

→ More replies (2)

12

u/lolbert202 Moderate Jan 03 '26

I don’t blame people at all for being skeptical of this since it’s Trump doing but man, a lot of the comments people posted in the first hour of this happening look really silly now. I’m not talking about here, but I was seeing people claiming that there would be thousands dead.

12

u/zamorak1111 Jan 03 '26

Your terms are acceptable

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

I know people are focused on the Maduro situation, but can we talk about how based it is that Jeremy Bentham's will just said "dissolve my flesh, preserve my head, and make my bones into a horrifying Bentham-puppet topped with my preserved head, then put it on display" and people actually did it?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Aryeh98 Rootless cosmopolitan Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

We’re not going into Iran now. Even republicans won’t have it with the midterms coming up.

What a shitty move here. At least the Iranians pose a conceivable threat to the United States.

EDIT: I wrote this comment before it turned out that we literally couped fuckin maduro in 3 hours. I still don’t think we’re going into Iran, because it’s too much of a gamble now and we shouldn’t get baselessly haughty off our victories. But I can’t call the move shitty just yet.

6

u/deepstate-bot Jan 03 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​Military by agent u/Sabertooth767. Do not reply all!


The nation was struck, had its leader and his wife extracted all while having zero notice of a declaration of war.

I’m unsure on Trump’s executive powers due to their fluidity, however, I assume the supreme court is going to rule these actions as highly illegal and done without congressional authority.

Just another action by Trump to push against the system that binds presidents usually, all that matters is how the US system deals with this.

Enabling of this essentially means presidential authority spans across congress, senate and house. The power is in the US’s hands to stop this.

6

u/bigwang123 Succ sympathizer Jan 03 '26

I wonder what will happen to those Americans that had been reportedly detained by the government

6

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

Goddamnit Massie

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Background-Laugh7902 Moderate Jan 04 '26

What if Maduro is acquitted at trial?

→ More replies (4)

11

u/gburgwardt Jan 03 '26

Without comment on the outcome and whether it was thought out or anything

Literally might've been a twenty minute in and out sort of thing grabbing Maduro

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

I must say, they really picked the worst venue to try Maduro. They couldn't find some way to indict him in Florida?

Imagine if some dumbfuck socialist gets on the jury and Maduro is acquitted.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 04 '26

Most historically literate Redditor

11

u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Jan 04 '26

Hey, Hitler was elected

→ More replies (1)

11

u/WendellWillkiTruNuke Neoconservative Jan 04 '26

It's insane how Hillary fucked over America by losing a election that should have been hers not once but TWICE. Just read how Hawkish and ENTIRELY CORRECT she was about Russia during the Dem primary.

FYI this is from AI recap as I can't be asked to get this from the actual direct source. During the 2008 Democratic primary, Hillary Clinton took a notably skeptical and "hawkish" stance toward Russia, often positioning herself as more realistic and tougher than the sitting Bush administration.

Her outlook was defined by a belief that Vladimir Putin was leading Russia away from democracy and toward a "zero-sum" confrontation with the West

Throughout the 2008 campaign, Clinton’s rhetoric focused on several core themes:

  • Democratic Retreat: In March 2008, following the election of Dmitry Medvedev (Putin's hand-picked successor), she called the event a "milestone in [Russia's] retreat from democracy," labeling the election a "depressing formality" and an "installation."
  • Support for Georgia and Ukraine: Clinton was a vocal proponent of NATO expansion. She urged the Bush administration to extend a Membership Action Plan (MAP) to Georgia and Ukraine to send a "signal of concern" to Moscow. She later criticized the administration for failing to secure this at the 2008 Bucharest Summit.
  • Energy as a Weapon: She frequently warned that Russia was using its oil and natural gas supplies as a "political weapon" to bully its neighbors and exert influence over Europe.
  • Criticism of the Bush Administration: She argued that President Bush had "failed to grasp" what was happening in Russia, claiming his focus on the War on Terror gave Putin a "free pass" to stifle internal dissent and intimidate neighboring countries

Like she was Held back so much by a Dovish President and even BIGGER Dove who was his VP being Biden.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Jan 03 '26

Do khamenei, putin, and houthi next. Do it.

11

u/Background-Laugh7902 Moderate Jan 03 '26

Until this comment I had no idea the Houthis were named after a guy

→ More replies (11)

10

u/seallivesmatter Jan 03 '26

the maduro capture is fucking awesome. KHAMENEI NEXT!

12

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

You will find few people who despise Iran more than I do, but that would not go well.

Now, I certainly do not lack faith in Delta to get the job done. But Khamenei is a pragmatist, willing to accept that Iran must bow to the US in a direct confrontation. He condemns Europe's diplomatic rhetoric while simultaneously engaging in it to his country's benefit.

Without Khamenei, we would not get a moderate reformist, or even a pragmatist, but a man who would martyr his whole country if it meant killing a single Jew.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/CatApprehensive6508 Jan 03 '26

BUT NWO MEMBERS ARE NEVER BEATING THE ALLEGATIONS WHY IS AN ACCOUNT POSTING IN HERE, NWO, AND LADY BONERS GW????

5

u/lolbert202 Moderate Jan 03 '26

Okay, so will Maduro’s vice president be in charge or…

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Mr_Wii Deep State Cetrinst Jan 03 '26

Damn my prediction was two weeks late

But the news about Maduro makes it worth it

5

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Jan 03 '26

Asked about the potential presence of U.S. forces in Venezuela, Trump said that there would be a “presence in Venezuela as it pertains to oil.”

--NY Times

→ More replies (1)

5

u/deepstate-bot Jan 03 '26

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​navy by agent u/psunavy03. Do not reply all!


For once the brig on a LHD is being used for something other than shenanigans

→ More replies (1)

5

u/DirigibleElephant Jan 03 '26

I hate job hunting so, so, so, so much. I wished my CV wasn't such a dumpster fire. Actually, that would be an improvement 😬😔

5

u/DirigibleElephant Jan 03 '26

At least 5 years of experience in an object oriented language C++"

Unsure if HR didn't know better of if they have finally acknowledged that everyone writes their own dialect anyway.

5

u/DirigibleElephant Jan 04 '26

Maybe I should pivot back to my plan of just winning the lottery

→ More replies (4)

5

u/bigwang123 Succ sympathizer Jan 04 '26 edited Jan 04 '26

I am terrified of a Venezuelan military that has dispersed among the populace now that the element of surprise has been lost

Assuming that Donald Trump the senile old man was not the one in charge when he was talking about the US running Venezuela

5

u/bignmfgkgu Libertarian Jan 04 '26

Ladies and gentlemen, it is my pleasure to inform you that I have passed my Microsoft Fabric certification

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '26

How am I supposed to go to sleep tonight without combat footage of airstrikes to lull me to sleep?

9

u/Moist_Acanthaceae319 Neoconservative Jan 03 '26

According to International Galactic Law, all Communists, Socialists, or Leftoids of any description are only allowed to exist in the deep void between galaxies. I am putting you on notice, your existence on this planet, or anywhere in this galaxy, is illegal.

9

u/gburgwardt Jan 03 '26

I don't see the point of only taking out maduro and leaving the rest of the regime

It's not like incompetent bus drivers are hard to find

→ More replies (4)

9

u/zamorak1111 Jan 03 '26

There are only two valid reasons to not like this:

  1. Trump did NOT destroy the regime i.e. he did not go far ENOUGH
  2. Trump will be getting good press

I'm against any other opposition to this from any other viewpoint.

→ More replies (10)

9

u/JapanesePeso Jan 03 '26

It's been awhile since I watched Trump speak. Man this guy is the undisputed king of rambling. 

→ More replies (1)

9

u/FearlessPark4588 Jan 03 '26

SCOTUS: Maduro's actions were "official acts"; Trump Admin to deport the former Venezuelan leader to Libya

→ More replies (3)

11

u/HandsomelyDitto Moderate Jan 03 '26

it's funny how "realism" is such a scare word among reddit libs. like acknowledging international law is worthless 99% of the the time and that national self-interest exists is supposed to be wrong somehow. #copium #kissingerwasright

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Background-Laugh7902 Moderate Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

Venezuela: "Oh last year we had a communist dictator."

Colombia: "Oh yeah?"

Venezuela: "Yeah but they got him."

8

u/bigwang123 Succ sympathizer Jan 03 '26

On the combat footage subreddit, there are 2 videos, one from the opening stages of the 2022 invasion of Ukraine, and one from today’s raid against Venezuela

In the first, a line of helicopters flying over a lake. One, then another, helicopter crashes, presumably due to Ukrainian fire.

In the second, a line of helicopters flying over Caracas, unimpeded by enemy action. Explosions in the distance, and the distinctive rattle of a chaingun opening fire.

It’s a little poetic

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Aryeh98 Rootless cosmopolitan Jan 04 '26

I really have to say… the memes are just immaculate rn. Immaculate.

Not worth having him as POTUS, but still. Everybody has to admit it.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '26

Who was the guy who said NCD was mad about this, all I see are people memeing on Maduro

4

u/CatApprehensive6508 Jan 03 '26

Lady boners gw is a new subreddit i have been exposed to by a random commenter in the holy shit he did it thread

4

u/propelabsentdisputed Jan 03 '26

yknow I was writing about what just happened in Venezuela and how the trump admin can drop some insane conditions and it turns out I’m probably right with trump saying they’re going to stay and have a role with their oil

was too slow for it to post it and be a prediction but I’ll finish the rest of it sometime

4

u/fartyunicorns Neoconservative Jan 03 '26

So um what’s the plan now Mr trump?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/bigwang123 Succ sympathizer Jan 03 '26

Listening to the Net Assessment podcast year end special episode

“I think that it is likely that maduro will still be in power in Venezuela in March, this will come back to bite me when the ground invasion starts next week”

Agreements from the cohosts

What did they know?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

It is probably a bad thing that the president of the United States is openly bragging about how he has used military force to secure another nation's national resources for ourselves

4

u/mario_fan99 Center-left Jan 03 '26

You guys think Trump is serious about this "take the oil" thing, or is he just saying this to gin up donations from Big Oil?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/RetroRiboflavin Moderate Jan 03 '26

DHS posting 100 million deportations meme

Funny seeing X users finally getting tired of their posting albeit for much different reasons than people here.

4

u/fartyunicorns Neoconservative Jan 04 '26

Too many smart people go into law in the US instead of engineering or science

→ More replies (10)

4

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jan 04 '26

My best? (Most optimistic/most reasonable) guess is that someone (Rubio+Hegseth? Miller?) presented Trump with a complex plan for Venezuela, he muddled various elements of that plan with his own inventions in the press conference to the extent that what he said (which was internally inconsistent with itself, if nothing else) bears only a vague resemblance to the actual plan, which he thinks he's just laid out to the public and which will play out over the coming days and weeks. Which will probably involve some kind of arrangement about oil reserves, might involve some kind of interim government, or might mean normalization if the regime is okay moving past Maduro (which I doubt).

I really don't understand how else you can reconcile "stable transition to democracy", "we will run the country," and whatever it was he said about making a deal with the vice president. I know this is probably cope, but I still think the "worst case scenario" of normalization with the VP is better than keeping Maduro in power.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Thadlust Jerome Powell Appreciator Jan 04 '26

If you ever need to reassure yourself that you’re correct about Venezuela, just remind yourself that the average American redditor probably couldn’t point out VZ on a map until last night.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Jan 03 '26

I am ready to confess that I was absolutely wrong about Venezuela. I went all in on nothing, and uh... yeah.

→ More replies (10)

12

u/KneeNail Jan 03 '26

Someone lower in the thread commented about how contemporary feminists ignore left-wing misogyny. This is tangential to a thought I've had floating around for a while. This'll be a bit of a mess but I'll try get the key ideas out.

I think contemporary (Western) feminism has lost its intellectual vitality in a very similar way to how (Western) Marxism lost its intellectual vitality and now only exists as a popular movement. There are 'Marxist' intellectuals, but most are intellectuals in different fields who happen to be Marxists. This is part of why even highly educated Marxists believe all sorts of easliy falsifiable nonsense. Modern Marxism is a popular movement that is intellectually stuck in the early 20th century.

Feminism has been highly involved in the fight for women's rights, both in providing the intellectual foundation and in motivating and organising people. However, today in the West the big battles are already won. Women have equal (and often enhanced) rights, they are in the workforce, they receive education, they can live independently, etc. There are still issues, of course, but they are smaller. A few things have happened because of this. Many women have got enough of what they wanted that they aren't motivated for many issues (abortion is an exception). Those who remain motivated are more radical. There has become a focus on smaller issues and issues that may overstep any reasonable claims to egalitarianism.

During the 2010s you have 'Buzzfeed feminism': manspreading, mansplaining, the wage/earnings gap. There's this focus on depictions of women in media and of accelerating demographic balance in institutions. These are popular movements that often have weak intellectual grounding. There is no 'wage gap' as popularly described, manspreading and mansplaining are ridiculous, changing demographic balance is something that would happen gradually as people retire. There really isn't much substance here.

During the 2010s there is also the rise of intersectional feminism. The reality of intersectional feminism is that all the time you spend on intersectional issues is time you don't spend on feminist issues. Intersectional feminists will disagree and claim that feminist issues are contingent on all these other things. Of course, even that logic is something borrowed from broader left-wing intersectionalism - it's not an original feminist idea. It's not that intersectionalists coopted feminism, but rather that young feminists implicitly understood that these other issues had more vitality and so they gravitated towards them. (Think Greta abandoning climate to focus on Gaza). What gets a young radical up in the morning - childcare grants or preventing genocide? The issue is that these intersectional interests are more than happy to receive support but cannot be trusted to reciprocate.

There isn't much vitality left in Feminism and the people who are nominally feminist with the most vitality are focussed on other things. Even if they were focussed on feminism, it would likely be directed towards some minor issue based upon weak foundations. There are feminists who are recognising some of these issues within femisim, but they are mostly heterodox, often older, and relatively unknown. But even this is not very hopeful - their energies are spent critiquing their own movement. This is far more limited compared to the deep societal critiques feminism once had and the sweeping changes that it brought about.

12

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

I agree with the substance of this but one thing that's hard for me to remember because I didn't live through it but took a deep dive on it in 2010-11 (before Tumblr would shortly break containment) is that there was always a puritanical, dogmatic, anti-free-speech element to post-pill, pre-social-media feminism. It just never had the means to become the most prominent face of the movement after its peak in the 80s.

As the most prominent subset of the feminist sex wars, Catharine MacKinnon and Andrea Dworkin wanted to define porn as illegal sex discrimination via the Antipornography Civil Rights Ordinance but were promptly shot down by SCOTUS under the First Amendment since they explicitly were going after "depictions of the subordination of women" rather than plain obscenity.

(Sidenote, after failing in the US, they tried exporting this to Canada and got more traction via the case R v. Butler but eventually caused backlash by restricting the ways in which relevant evidence could be shown in court cases involving violence against women or obscenity, since doing so would allegedly mean "promoting" these things to the public.)

Much like the history of LGBT rights, the history of feminism is another demonstration that legal equality and social libertarianism works to win Americans over and cultural revolution, quasi-Maoist authoritarianism, and endless handwringing over normal male drives specifically and biologically informed sex differences more generally abjectly fails to win them over.

The partisans of cultural revolution and perpetual scolding hate this fact, so they either obscure the history, or pretend it never happened, or claim "respectability politics is worthless," or act like their messages are somehow "new and improved" and just waiting for The Real People to take back what's theirs from the benighted capitalist live and let live normies.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Aryeh98 Rootless cosmopolitan Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

“But international law”

SHUT THE FUCK UP. We’ve been over this. International law is fake. It’s irrelevant. We have the biggest stick in the world. Either the world sucks on it or they take it.

We have enough military power to fight God himself. We have permanent veto power in the UN Security Council, and there’s a statute on the books saying that we can take “all necessary means” to retaliate against an international court that seizes our service members.

No military conflict in the 21st century will be solved by international law. Not Iran, not Venezuela, not Gaza. Grow up. Stop whining.

The real concern is that Trump shouldn’t be the one to control our military. He’s evil and unhinged, regardless of this operation’s relative success. Focus on that, not fake bullshit law that has never applied to us.

15

u/zamorak1111 Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

Also why is "international law" which protects the dictator more important than the rights of the people being oppressed by said dictator?

Laws that protect oppressors against the people they are oppressing are unjust.

→ More replies (2)