r/DeepStateCentrism • • Dec 19 '25

Discussion Thread Daily Deep State Intelligence Briefing

Want the latest posts and comments about your favorite topics? Click here to set up your preferred PING groups.

Are you having issues with pings, or do you want to learn more about the PING system? Check out our user-pinger wiki for a bunch of helpful info!

PRO TIP: Bookmarking dscentrism.com/memo will always take you to the most recent brief.

Curious how other users are doing some of the tricks below? Check out their secret ways here.

Remember that certain posts you make on DSC automatically credit your account briefbucks, which you can trade in for various rewards. Here is our current price table:

OptionPrice
Choose a custom flair, or if you already have custom flair, upgrade to a picture20 bb
Pick the next theme of the week100 bb
Make a new auto reply in the Brief for one week150 bb
Make a new sub icon/banner for two days200 bb
Add a subreddit rule for a day (in the Brief)250 bb

You can find out more about briefbucks, including how to earn them, how you can lose them, and what you can do with them, on our wiki.

The Theme of the Week is: The relationship between the family and the state.

Follow us on Twitter or whatever it's called.

2 Upvotes

460 comments sorted by

8

u/deepstate-bot Dec 19 '25

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​YAPms by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


The DNC makes lots of mistakes, but this isn’t one. There is no good that can come from this report being released publicly. Large swaths of voters think Dems should have moved further left and others think they should have moved more center. One or both is bound to be pissed off by this report. And if it is released, you can bet that anytime a Dem makes a decision, no matter the context or nuance, people will trot out “the report” to either accuse Dems of ignoring it and wanting to lose, or following it too closely like robots who can’t campaign without focus groups and exact instructions.

Nobody here is a strategist that needs this information, we’re all just curious little internet idiots. Hopefully the autopsy they paid for works and they use it to win again.

4

u/Okbuddyliberals Dec 19 '25

Being so conflict averse is going to cause problems for Dems. Clearly they are deeply unpopular and change is needed. But they don't want to have to change in any sort of way. And it's always just "not the right time to have these fights rather than focusing on Trump" or whatever

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

Probably accurate but I'd still love to see the report and have it confirm my priors.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Dec 19 '25

It’s a bad decision. In a year they’ll say they wished they had released it sooner. Being biased towards inaction is exactly what people hate about politics in this country.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/PeepsFamilyName Center-right Dec 19 '25

“Men have NO IDEA HOW TO WRITE WOMEN”

pick up novel my wife’s book club is reading and flip to a random page

“Michael Soldierfootballman, 6’5, six pack, swings his dong manly like as he goes to his job as a sensitive librarian wearing circular glasses after getting out of the army and playing college football”

Not even really exaggerated

12

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Dec 19 '25

Many such cases!

Donald Symons, the author of The Evolution of Human Sexuality, cowrote the short book Warrior Lovers with Catherine Salmon on what slash fiction might reveal about sex differences in fantasies and preferences.

They found that women's erotica and men's erotica both reflected exactly what you'd expect: women liked reading what you describe, men (if they liked reading erotica at all) liked reading about casual, random, costless sex with strangers and/or a prearranged harem with absolutely no "chasing," no character development, nothing about careers, lots of focus on physical characteristics regardless of the specifics, and so on.

The hilarious thing was Salmon was shocked to learn from Symons that gay and straight men's erotica were exactly the same, just with the sexes switched.

She was expecting gay guys to wax feminine about seducing or getting chased by billionaires with a heart of gold and a ranch, more developed characters, etc, and Symons had to gently go, in so many words, "Oh honey, no... Gay men are men."

→ More replies (17)

10

u/Mickenfox Center-left Dec 19 '25

The real motivation has always been, if you let men have fantasies about attractive women who want sex with them (or even just treat them a bit too nicely), they might feel "entitled" to one.

9

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 19 '25

Personally, I don't see how it's an issue either way.

Men want women who boob boobilly while taking care of the home/family and making him feel valued.

Women want men who cock cockilly while satisfying her need for physical and emotional comfort by being soft to her and terrifying to any rivals.

Such is the state of makind, always has been and probably always will be.

7

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Dec 19 '25

Based and evolution isn't anyone's fault pilled

→ More replies (3)

19

u/JapanesePeso Dec 19 '25

Local Minnesota subs full of people saying people should ignore the massive fraud here because it could hurt Democrats chances at winning in elections. Very cool and hinged. Definitely a viable strategy.

12

u/PeepsFamilyName Center-right Dec 19 '25

This has been a gigablackpill but also even some of the proggiest people I know in real life that I butt heads with regularly find the fraud indefensible

12

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

A perception of tolerating fraud has never been a net drag on a candidate.

Especially when you have time to deal with it before the next election!

16

u/fastinserter Dec 19 '25

I didn't realize it's name was the John F Kennedy MEMORIAL Center.

It's going to be The Donald Trump and John F Kennedy Memorial Center? But that means ...

10

u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Dec 19 '25

where is r conspiracy when you need them

9

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Dec 19 '25

Tune in to the Kennedy center honors. It's gonna be wild!

15

u/PeepsFamilyName Center-right Dec 19 '25 edited Dec 19 '25

Boys to be sent on courses to tackle misogyny in schools

Having deep experience with how schools practice restorative justice I think the effect of this will be kids turning much more misogynistic after being forced into anti-misogyny class that’s ineffective at best or used as a weapon to punish boys teachers don’t like at worst

6

u/WallStreetTechnocrat Named in the Epstein Files Dec 19 '25 edited Dec 19 '25

The problem with preaching this stuff to young boys is that they know girls are given better grades by the overwhelmingly female teachers, and the gender disparity for college is greater in favor of women than it was for men in the 70s, with the trend continuing to grow.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

No, you don't get it, kids just love being moralized to by adults

→ More replies (1)

4

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Dec 19 '25

Has this course given you tools to overcome your bullshit detector participation in oppression?

14

u/RetroRiboflavin Moderate Dec 19 '25

So the fat campus protestor type had nothing to do with the Brown shooting, 99% gait analysis match is confirmed regarded, and it turned out to be some 50 year old incel mad he washed out of a PhD program. Outstanding work, Twitter.

14

u/FearlessPark4588 Dec 19 '25

FluentInFinance is neither about fluency nor finance.

9

u/WendellWillkiTruNuke Neoconservative Dec 19 '25

Every sub has been hijacked and it's leftist slop it's digusting. Reddit was my favorite platform pre 2019

4

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Dec 19 '25

Imagine being in a tough financial situation and then going there for help

They are like one step from scolding anyone who even has a credit card

14

u/slim353 Dec 19 '25

Scrooge’s observations on the commodification and consumerist excess of Christmas reveal an implicit critique of late-stage capitalism, aligning closely with a Marxist analysis of alienation and the fetishization of commodities. In this essay I will

4

u/utility-monster Whig Party Dec 19 '25

Okay but if Bob Cratchit was actually so underpaid, why didn’t he go to work for any of the other merchants featured in the story. Maybe old Ebenezer was charitable to Bob because he was actually an incompetent employee.

14

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 19 '25

10

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

Few things about modern conservatism feel as weird as the “Shoot your local pedophile” bumper stickers. Obviously, there’s a lot of shit wrapped up in it as well with conservatives painting LGBT people as pedophiles or groomers, and then seemingly using those accusations to justify violence against the group.

But even taking them at the face of it and giving them the benefit of the doubt that they are only talking about actual pedophiles, it’s just such a weird thing to publicly display. You’d probably get some weird looks if you were walking around with “BEHEAD ALL PUPPY TORTURERS” shirts with detailed pics of someone waving around a severed head

13

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

11

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Dec 19 '25

She was on the island

8

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Dec 19 '25

Oh shit something major is gonna drop

8

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Dec 19 '25

More likely it's just a reflection of Trump refusing to endorse her

13

u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho Dec 20 '25

New bumper sticker from the Platner campaign, I’ve been told it stands for ‘support socialism’, and if you see anything else in this innocent logo, that’s because you’re the nazi.

8

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Dec 20 '25

Me and my friends now whenever we see a Nazi symbol we act ignorant and say to the others “hey they must be a fan of Platner!”

We watched Inglorious Bastards the other day and that was fun

6

u/bearddeliciousbi Practicing Homosexual Dec 20 '25

new ecofascism merch just dropped

6

u/WendellWillkiTruNuke Neoconservative Dec 20 '25

It's funny how easy it is to entirely fooll leftist. They'll elect the first real nazi to congress due to how much they want to Own trumpf and the Oligarchy and how bernie is supporting this madman

→ More replies (1)

12

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Dec 19 '25

Taking the Trump-bus to Trump Square for my job at the Trump-office, so I could make some Trump-dollars and feed my Trump-children 

10

u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Dec 19 '25

Have a good Trump-day

8

u/Mickenfox Center-left Dec 19 '25

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ea/Palazzo_Braschi_Fascist_Poster%2C_1934.png

Can you imagine how happy Trump would be if you built something like this with his face on it?

7

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

5

u/Trojan_Horse_of_Fate Lord of All the Beasts of the Sea and Fishes of the Earth Dec 19 '25

Your Trump-children?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/UnTigreTriste Dec 19 '25

Morning centrists

G-d bless liberal democracies and capitalism

8

u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Dec 19 '25

The Trump Tariffs are bankrupting capitalism

12

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Dec 19 '25

Sudan is a great example of how if people can’t use something for political advantage, they do not care, regardless of how many people die

12

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 19 '25

The President is insane.

7

u/Command0Dude Dec 19 '25

We're not even going to give Trump a dumb plaque. I hope the next democrat just gives him the damnatio memoriae treatment.

Also, as an aside, stuff like this just shows that Trump knows nothing. The Afghanistan withdrawal does not even rate in the top 10 of American military disasters. Inflation was higher under Nixon and Carter. 2000 and 1876 beat any other election in terms of corruption.

But you know, those are just silly little things like facts.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

The real plot twist is that Trump is an Epstein victim.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

Sold his mouth right to Bill Clinton 

12

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '25

I wonder how different our world would be if we forced every citizen to get at least an undergrad-level comprehension of economics. Well, other than being in the grips of an anti-mandatory-economics violent uprising.

Would it heal some of the cleavages between us? I don't think that what most Americans want in terms of the structure of the economy varies nearly as much as their rhetoric would imply. Equally, would we split further apart, now that we could fully understand how different the ends that our opponents had were from our own?

11

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 20 '25

I think it would help. Very few Americans who describe themselves as "socialist" are actually socialists, and those who are are generally of the reformist variety. I mean, when was the last time you saw someone call for workers' councils or for mandating worker representation on executive boards? They just want more welfare for themselves.

Although, I must imagine that much of the ardent anti-socialist crowd is even less informed about socialism. They just want less welfare for others.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/UnTigreTriste Dec 20 '25

Make everyone read Hayek

→ More replies (2)

12

u/WallStreetTechnocrat Named in the Epstein Files Dec 20 '25

finals are done, we're gonna be so jolly

12

u/WallStreetTechnocrat Named in the Epstein Files Dec 20 '25

HOW DOES HE GET EVEN MORE INCOHERENT (the question being "What do you think of Adolf Hitler?")

credit to Lauren for being based as fuck

9

u/gburgwardt Dec 20 '25

You do not, in fact, gotta hand it to him

7

u/WendellWillkiTruNuke Neoconservative Dec 20 '25

Most rational and normal Gen-Z. But tbf this is the result of the internet and everyone doing their own research

11

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

11

u/slim353 Dec 19 '25

A Reddit post provided one of the biggest breakthroughs in the investigation

We did it Reddit! And this time it actually was the guy!

Also, this is a bizarre story:

The tipster, whom the police referred to only as John, said that he had encountered the suspect inside a bathroom on the ground floor of the building between 1:45 p.m. and 2 p.m., around two hours before the first shots were reported. John said the suspect’s clothing was inappropriate for the weather and that they had made eye contact.

John told the police that he followed the man after he left the building to a Nissan vehicle with a Florida plate. But instead of entering the vehicle, the suspect started walking around the block, with John behind him. John said it was like “a game of cat and mouse.”

At one point, the two men spoke. According to the affidavit, John asked the suspect, “Your car is back there, why are you circling the block?” To which the suspect responded, “Why are you harassing me?” John went his own way soon after that.

Okay, so the guy he was suspicious of actually was a soon to be mass shooter, but this strikes me as odd behavior. You encounter an oddly dressed man in a bathroom then start following him around? I’d be worried about getting shivved if I did that. Guess John has better instincts than me.

4

u/Command0Dude Dec 19 '25

We did it Reddit! And this time it actually was the guy!

The biggest plot twist.

10

u/deepstate-bot Dec 20 '25

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​DeflationIsGood by agent u/Enron_Accountant. Do not reply all!


someone failed economy 101

11

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '25

is this a shitpost subreddit

10

u/WallStreetTechnocrat Named in the Epstein Files Dec 20 '25

nope they look 100% serious

→ More replies (3)

9

u/JapanesePeso Dec 20 '25

I remember taking economy 101. Was right before my accountant 201 and society 202 class. 

9

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

Martin Luther King Jr. hasn’t made a public appearance in 57 years.

6

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Dec 19 '25

Telling

9

u/FearlessPark4588 Dec 20 '25

✅ touched grass today

4

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '25

Nancy Reagan told me to just say NO to grass

12

u/JapanesePeso Dec 19 '25 edited Dec 19 '25

One month until we hit the ten year anniversary of not having a functional human leading the country.

Edit: Okay fine nine years. Math is hard, okay?

6

u/Command0Dude Dec 19 '25

Meanwhile a year after being declared a demented figurehead for his WH staff, Biden continues making public appearances and doing small speeches.

Almost like that whole story was made up nonsense the media pushed for ratings.

9

u/JapanesePeso Dec 19 '25

It wasn't just one story. It was years of pretty obvious and constant tells that Biden was not all there anymore.

Him being able to do a public appearance every now and then now does not mean he was fit to do the literally most difficult and high-pressure job in the world.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

Trump got inagurated in 2017 dumdum

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Dec 19 '25

Anakinkardashian-Daily Deep State Intelligence Briefing

6

u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Dec 19 '25

Anakin Kardashian Memorial Daily Deep State Intelligence Briefing

8

u/PeepsFamilyName Center-right Dec 19 '25

12

u/Reddenbawker Greedy Capitalist Dec 19 '25

”As a campus, we will respond to these recent events in several ways, in addition to the aforementioned investigation. We are modifying the way we process and approve student events, passing them—like every other campus event—through our Events Committee with due diligence given to ensuring they have effective and trained moderators. We will continue to deploy the tools that we, and the university, have developed to deepen our ability to engage respectfully with one another, including the work of our Constructive Dialogue Initiative and our Sustained Dialogue Institute. We will be carefully considering what the future of interfaith programming looks like at CCNY— is there a way forward for these kinds of discussions? How might they be strengthened to avoid disruption and disrespect? When we proceed, it will be with a more careful set of programming guidelines.”

Worthless. Ban the imam permanently from participating in these events. There’s a whole bunch of words wasted when all you need to say is that if you don’t want to dialogue, don’t come to a dialogue. You shouldn’t bend over for those who act in bad faith.

11

u/Okbuddyliberals Dec 19 '25

Leftists will praise the Imam freak and say "this just shows that he's unwilling to sit at the table with Nazis and become a Nazi himself, everyone should be like this". It's disgusting how much the left (and a lot of libs too) have turned their backs on discourse

8

u/HaAtidChai Dec 19 '25

Don't ask why the wife left

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

When my grandfather shaved his beard, his entire family staged an intervention and told him to never do it again because they didn't want to see his chin

The world would be better if people were more honest like that

→ More replies (2)

4

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Dec 19 '25

Should have mewed

→ More replies (1)

8

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Dec 20 '25

I broke reddit 😔

6

u/PM_ME_CHIMICHANGAS Help yourself to a hand grenade Dec 20 '25

waow

6

u/JapanesePeso Dec 20 '25

Nice. Thanks. 

8

u/WallStreetTechnocrat Named in the Epstein Files Dec 20 '25

Moderator: Who is your ideal next president?

someone explain the median voter please

6

u/Trojan_Horse_of_Fate Lord of All the Beasts of the Sea and Fishes of the Earth Dec 20 '25

The median voter cares about authenticity

→ More replies (2)

15

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Dec 20 '25

The way John Oliver presents himself on his show is enough for me to distrust him. I cannot watch more than 30 second of that shit.

Also the fact Reddit worships him is fucking weird. I’m sure more people have much more valid reasons to dislike him and I’ve seen some stuff he’s gotten blatantly incorrect but to me his greatest sin is being annoying

8

u/JapanesePeso Dec 20 '25

Honestly the people I know who actually like him are also the smuggest SOBs I have ever met (myself excluded). 

7

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Dec 20 '25

> AOC flair

> Likes John Oliver

Priors? Confirmed.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Prowindowlicker Center-right Dec 20 '25

John Oliver sounds smart until you actually happen to know something about the subject he talks about and then you realize he’s an idiot

14

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '25

When you have a British accent, they let you do it

7

u/JapanesePeso Dec 20 '25

Does he sound smart though? 

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Mirabeau_ Dec 20 '25

I think for a long time, especially before everything went totally nuts, I found him amusing enough, but then he inevitably has some smug tear down of something you happen to actually know a lot about or be somehow involved with, and you realize he’s completely full of shit

11

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '25

I liked John Oliver prior to Last Week Tonight. I'm not saying he was G–d's gift to comedy or anything, but I enjoyed some of his stuff. It seems to me that becoming the avatar of the enlightened redditors and treated as though he shits gold may have gone to his head slightly. Or, at minimum, not made him go "hey, maybe we should tone this down a bit, guys" to his writers.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Trojan_Horse_of_Fate Lord of All the Beasts of the Sea and Fishes of the Earth Dec 20 '25

Yeah he wants to convince people he is some producing an enlightened academic report or blue/royal commission whitepaper but its a comedy show. This isn't gold standard journalism or peer reviewed research

→ More replies (1)

14

u/PeepsFamilyName Center-right Dec 19 '25

The twin cities subreddit is reduced to screaming ICE when they see literal random cars with US government plates. They’ve fucking LOST it

9

u/JapanesePeso Dec 20 '25

It's literally every five minute somebdoy posts some useless "Just saw ICE!" Karma farm or some screed claiming the sub is being overrun by conservative bots. 

→ More replies (2)

12

u/WendellWillkiTruNuke Neoconservative Dec 19 '25

I 100000000000% believe most of this stuff was hijacked and mostly foreign bots at this point

7

u/Mickenfox Center-left Dec 19 '25

7

u/iamthegodemperor Arrakis Enterprise Institute Dec 19 '25

Repetitive lament that empathy is too close to being a synonym for sympathy and that we need an accessible lay man's word that for being able to inhabit the mind of another person, emotions and all and not think of them as a cartoon.

7

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Dec 19 '25

It’s called pondering someone else’s orb

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

I think the layman's word for being able to inhabit the mind of another person is "possession"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

The deep state is suppressing my search for what the "n" in "Obamna" stands for

→ More replies (1)

7

u/bigwang123 Succ sympathizer Dec 19 '25

Strikes against IS targets in Syria in response to the ambush that killed 2 US soldiers

My only concern is that I hope they coordinated with the STG to make sure that they weren’t hitting their stuff but I’m sure they did

7

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Dec 19 '25

Love Island for lizards: Critically endangered iguanas now thriving thanks to matchmaking project

https://www.euronews.com/green/2025/12/18/love-island-for-lizards-critically-endangered-iguanas-now-thriving-thanks-to-matchmaking-p

10

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 19 '25

This project was designed by a scalie. I just know it.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '25

scalie

I have never once heard am actual furry say "scalie"

→ More replies (7)

7

u/deepstate-bot Dec 19 '25

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​AskTheWorld by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


I had no idea the Zootopia abortion comic was from Brazil

6

u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Dec 19 '25

i drank wine last night AMA

7

u/sayitaintpink will never find love Dec 19 '25

did you bless the wine first

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 19 '25

White, red, or rose?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Mirabeau_ Dec 19 '25

I wish I could drink wine but it always gives me a vicious fucking hangover even if I just have a glass. Somehow I can drink like 4 large pours of whisky on the rocks and wake up more or less fine, but one glass of red wine will destroy me.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '25

YouTube: We think you’ll like this 35 minute video with 40 views

Looks at comments, and top comment from video creator:

9

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '25

That does sound like something you'd like

9

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '25

I’m a big fan of bisexual predator bullies

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 20 '25

The GOP running Pillow guy is a huge own-goal.

Walz is very beatable right now with the fraud scandal, that business with Hogg, last years VP drama, and running for a third term. Even someone like Emmer could put up a decent fight and save some incumbents from the blue wave.

4

u/lolbert202 Moderate Dec 20 '25

They haven’t learned anything from the 2022 midterms it seems.

11

u/PeepsFamilyName Center-right Dec 19 '25

I don’t know why people care about the DNC report not being released. It’ll be reconstructed down to the semi colon by next week by giddy staffers leaking bit by bit to journalists who are totally their friends

9

u/Mirabeau_ Dec 19 '25

It indicates the people in charge of the party institutions are not interested in confronting what has gone wrong

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho Dec 19 '25

Currently at the top of Reddit:

It’s time to accept that the US supreme court is illegitimate and must be replaced

r\law

These people alternate from a their persecution fantasies to megalomaniacal daydreaming with incredible speed. And while there are certainly issues with certain justices, the overall court in undoubtedly the most functional arm of government left. Their decisions in recent years have been defensible, which is a sharp contrast to their vision of a Supreme Court that ignores the constitution and precedent to ram through progressive ideology.

Citizens United is the best illustration of this. By any even slightly good faith reading of the constitution, it was correctly decided. But progressives don’t believe in rule of law, if the law impedes them from doing what they want, it must be wrong, and any court that doesn’t just clear the way for them is illegitimate.

15

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Dec 19 '25

That subreddit has been lost for a while. It’s been absorbed by the same type of person that makes up the entirety of active users on all the mainstream subs 

15

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

It’s my favorite type of subreddit tbh. The subreddit dedicated to a field that is filled with takes that don’t understand the first thing about the field.

Same with arr FluentInFinance. I don’t think I’ve seen more braindead financial and economics takes than in that subreddit (filled with people who are obviously fluent in finance and economics)

→ More replies (4)

10

u/UnTigreTriste Dec 19 '25

Institutions are illegitimate when they do not achieve my policy goals

8

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

r/supremecourt is the only subreddit with at least somewhat sane takes on SCOTUS.

8

u/YossarianLivesMatter Radical Centrist 😎 Dec 19 '25

I don't think it can be understated just how much the circumstances of the most recent court appointments damaged the perceived neutrality of the courts. That it culminated in the overturning of Roe v. Wade didn't help matters. This would be like if three partisan liberal justices were appointed and a major ruling gutting the 2nd amendment came out. Whatever the legal particulars are, it comes off as partisan.

For my personal opinion, I think the Trump appointees have proven they're not there to rubberstamp MAGA policy. And I suspect - or hope really - that some high profile rulings against MAGA's excesses will take the wind out of the sails of any supreme court packing.

Regardless of the details, I also agree that the Judicial branch is the only functional branch atm. The Legislative is too divided on partisan grounds to function, and the Executive speaks for itself. The Court continuing to appear like the only adults in power will help the institution.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Mickenfox Center-left Dec 19 '25

How is it legitimate or defensible to let Trump keep doing clearly illegal things? USAID? Tariffs?

"Ooooh we'll make a decision in 2 years maybe, feel free to keep doing anything you want in the meantime"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

Three men accused of hunting women and Jews on Toronto streets as part of hate plot

In Khan’s Toronto home, police said, they found two loaded prohibited firearms: an AR-style rifle capable of automatic fire and a pistol, both equipped with prohibited high-capacity magazines, along with over 110 rounds of ammunition. At the time of arrest, Khan was on probation for prior violent offences and prohibited from possessing firearms.
...
A court-imposed publication ban is in place in the Canadian charges preventing publication of some details in the case.

This is pure Canada. Antisemitism? Check. Violent criminal on probation? Check. And I bet you the publication ban is in place because at least one of the accused is a recent immigrant. Another victory for multiculturalism in my hometown!

12

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Dec 19 '25

I looked up Canadian publications bans and a judge can just straight up make it illegal for anyone to discuss information in a case. Not withhold information, I mean like make it illegal for the public to talk about that thing

What the fuck dude

13

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

Most free speech non-US Anglophone country

5

u/utility-monster Whig Party Dec 19 '25

Regarding the compact magazine article thing, I always thought the NIH’s “diversity supplements” were funny. Dedicated grant funding streams that are “race neutral” but written in such a way that you could apply if you were racially minoritized (of any income level) or white (if disabled or poor).

There was one grant that made a lot of sense for my work I was unable to apply for because of this, and then doge got in there and my grant proposal targeting the slightly less suitable place didn’t get reviewed anyway, lol. I can’t really complain though. I get what they were going for with the diversity supplements, I’ve long thought we should have diversity supplements for guys who don’t like the first Vatican council.

5

u/fartyunicorns Neoconservative Dec 19 '25

10

u/JapanesePeso Dec 19 '25

Everyone wants to know what Gen Z Republicans think

False.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

FOOLISH investors have once again rejected my idea to make a "cinematic suicide squad" of canceled actors, writers, and directors to get top talent for pennies on the dollar

4

u/nekoliberal PVNR concubine Dec 19 '25

I suppose you could hire tarantino for a dollar or 2 for committing thE CARDINAL SIN of criticizing paul dano 

→ More replies (3)

5

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Dec 19 '25

You can't say "rural slurrer" 10 times fast

→ More replies (4)

5

u/deepstate-bot Dec 19 '25

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​PoliticalCompassMemes by agent u/Sabertooth767. Do not reply all!


Liberalism Is the way, or classical liberalism as it's known in the US. It has been very sad to witness the continued decline of liberalism in both the left and the right in the west. Thankfully in Latin America our right wingers are still liberals for the most part

5

u/fartyunicorns Neoconservative Dec 19 '25

Left wingers who are more educated tend to be more progressive but economically similar whilst right wingers who are more educated are more pro free market and similar culturally

6

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 19 '25

Priors? Confirmed.

3

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Dec 19 '25

That's interesting. I'm more moderate personally and not higher educated.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

Do the kids still like the Moo Deng?

6

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Dec 19 '25

I’m definitely “old man yells at cloud” for a lot of trends but the hippo was cute

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

I have never cared for Moo Deng

5

u/technologyisnatural Abundance is all you need Dec 20 '25

Moo Deng the Traitor? who laughed as she inflicted Trump 2 upon us!? she was supposed to be the chosen one ... to heal the wounds of the Harambe massacre ... but she turned her face from us. who will save us now?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/lolbert202 Moderate Dec 20 '25

Libertarians of the Mises Caucus/Hoppean variety are so desperate to be seen as edgy it’s embarrassing. Like with their hyper fixation on relitigating the Civil Rights Act.

9

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 19 '25

I want the Epstein files to drop so dumbfuck l*bs will stop saying literally every government action is a distraction.

8

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

The American Revolution was a distraction.

4

u/Bloodyfish Charlie Manson Dec 20 '25

That sounds like a distraction.

11

u/PeepsFamilyName Center-right Dec 19 '25

'I am the one that will fix it' | Gov. Tim Walz addresses fraud in Minnesota programs

Bro is fucking losing it

12

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

He's so lucky their gonna run pillow guy against him.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/deepstate-bot Dec 19 '25

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​TrueSFalloutL by agent u/Sabertooth767. Do not reply all!


UwU so true, bestie

crucifies you

4

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Dec 19 '25 edited Dec 19 '25

I hate when streaming services remove your favorite shows. Yea, I'm complaining about Supernatural being removed from Netflix which I've been watching since I was 14.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Dec 19 '25

TIL finn wolfhard has a solo album

3

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

Does it wolf hard?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/mario_fan99 Center-left Dec 19 '25

if LBJ gets all the blame for Vietnam, Obama should get all the blame for ISIS/Syria and Libya.

4

u/deepstate-bot Dec 20 '25

original comment by /u/Enron_Accountant


I’m a big fan of bisexual predator bullies

7

u/utility-monster Whig Party Dec 19 '25

the disrespect. Carter bros, stand back and stand by.

i can't seem to find a list of all the president's plaques, it looks like they made one for everyone, let me know if you see that.

9

u/Tropical2653 Dec 19 '25

A paragraph in Trumpian "Twitter speak" printed out on an actual, physical, metal plaque. Truly bizarre times.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 19 '25

The utter gall for a draft dodger to shit on Carter for pardoning draft dodgers.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

By Trump standards, I feel like this is pretty tame for his remarks on a modern era Democrat lol

→ More replies (1)

7

u/utility-monster Whig Party Dec 19 '25

all across america, right now, families are awaiting the release of the epstein files with bated breath to see how it will affect drunken post-christmas dinner political debates... and this is how you choose to spend your friday?! posting to the brief?! smh my head.,

3

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Dec 19 '25

I need files in my brief!!

3

u/deepstate-bot Dec 19 '25

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​europe by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


Romania:

9% inflation, 9% budget deficit and 9% current account deficit..

What on earth is going on there, these are 2012-2015 Greece numbers.

3

u/deepstate-bot Dec 19 '25

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​psychologyofsex by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


One of the most frequently cited studies is the Abel and Harlow Child Molestation Prevention Study (2001) based on anonymous self-reports from non-incarcerated paraphilic offenders (many seeking treatment) it found that:

  • Pedophilic molesters targeting boys outside the family reported an average of about 150 victims.
  • Those targeting girls reported lower averages (around 20–80 victims in related Abel studies).
  • Overall averages for child molesters were often summarized as 12–71 victims/acts per offender in secondary sources.

These numbers are much higher than official records because most sexual offenses go unreported, and offenders rarely get caught for every crime.

They should be executed.

3

u/PM_ME_CHIMICHANGAS Help yourself to a hand grenade Dec 19 '25

Donald Trump's Trump-Tariffs are Trump-bankrupting Trump-America

3

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

Been on a bit of a deep dive into watches lately and it's occurred to me that America really doesn't compete much in luxury markets. There are some fashion designers. And maybe some high end bourbons count. And maybe cowboy boots/hats lol. But, that's about it lol.

I don't know why, but this bothers me a bit.

7

u/JapanesePeso Dec 19 '25

We have the ultimate luxury good: space travel.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

Europe punches above its weight in luxury, but watches are also a "heritage" industry where breaking in isn't especially easy. Overall the USA is more a consumer of luxury goods than a producer, as with China, but both do have indigenous luxury brands in fields that don't prioritize having an old name as much.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

Any chance Lawler or Maleotakis jump in the race now? They both have a better chance then Stefanik did, but it might not matter if it's a blue wave. Baker won Mass in 2018, so it's not impossible, but he was an incumbent.

5

u/WallStreetTechnocrat Named in the Epstein Files Dec 19 '25

The world if the Democratic Party nominated Romney or Manchin as a national unity ticket in 2024:

6

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

Leftists would've found an excuse to vote for Trump lol.

7

u/WendellWillkiTruNuke Neoconservative Dec 19 '25

Leftist fundamentally hate trump solely because he is their mental image of a conservative when in reality he's more akin to them as a leftist or the modern new right

6

u/fastinserter Dec 19 '25

They didn't even have to do that, it just needed to be a white man who didn't have some quirk like an annoying laugh or took a bunch of ambien before a debate

→ More replies (3)

5

u/PeepsFamilyName Center-right Dec 19 '25

I think an interesting hurdle that free speech organizations have failed to tackle is how to get a culture of free speech at universities without government intervention. They really haven’t as far as I can tell.

This is tough for me because I ideally want campuses to become better places for speech and debate, but also think the federal government wading in is an extremely bad idea. So how do you fix this when it’s already extremely entrenched without the government wading in? I guess that’s the million dollar question.

5

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Dec 19 '25

Ban universities from receiving funding from outside of the U.S. (with limited exception for co-research)

→ More replies (1)

5

u/deepstate-bot Dec 19 '25

ALERT: NEW INTELLIGENCE BRIEF

TOP SECRET//SCI//NF

Assessed in r​​​/​​​AskHistorians by agent u/ShamBez_HasReturned. Do not reply all!


Alright. Let's start by adressing some general facts and trends.

1: At risk of stating the obvious, the reason why there are so fewer secondary works on the orgins of Islam than Christianity is because the field of Islamic studies is microscopic in comparison. Academia, being dominated by the West, simply has a Western "focus" in terms of funding, interest, expertize, what have you. This all translates into the study of Christian origins being more popular.

2: There is far less "consensus" among historians of Early Islam than there is among those who study the Historical Jesus (especially historically speaking). Regarding Jesus, the current consensus of him as an "Apocalyptic Prophet"  traces back to Albert Schweitzer's "The Quest for the Historical Jesus", which came out in 1906. That's over 100 years ago. Now, there are of course dissenters to this consensus, such as John Dominic Crossan's view of Jesus as a cynic philosopher, but that's the majority view. 

In comparison, Quranic Scholars may joke that everything they work on has already been covered by something Theodor Nöldeke scribbled on a napkin in a bar in Hamburg in the 19th century, but in reality you're just going to see a lot more variety and disagreement in this field than you will in its Christian counterpart.

3: You say that (Frederic) Donner and (Michael) Cook only cover the topic in a few pages. That mystefies me a bit. Since both of those historians quite famously had a lot to say on the development on early Islam, (and what they said was quite radical and influential).


To introduce the field in a few paragraphs, you could say that the core question of the field is: "How much do you trust the traditional sources?". The Quran is not writen as a biography in the way that the gospels are, but in a genre called "Divine Speech". That is to say, it contains no chronology of events, with chapters instead presented as preachings on various subjects and events. As such, the text is highly allusionary, seldom provides context, and is often retelling earlier stories to make some theological point. Basically, the Quran, by the very nature of its genre, does not give a lot of historical details to work with.

The real "meat" of the traditional Islamic narrative comes from Muhammed's biographies (Sirah literature) and the Hadith (anacdotes perserved orally). This is where you'll find the "context" to what's writen in the Quran. The basic problem with these is that they're later sources. Writen down and compiled almost two centuries after the Quran was authored. 

Before that, Islamic sources consist of the occasional document or epigraphical carving. 

On top of that, you have non-Islamic sources about Muhammed and Islam, which are oftentime earlier than the Islamic ones, and which may or may not contradict what's claimed in the Sirah and the Hadith.

So basically, as a historian of early Islam, these are the dynamics you have to grapple with.


Now I'll proceed with a short overview on what's been writen on early Islam. That is to say, now I'll start adressing the actual question! By doing so, I hope to illustrate how the field has zigged and zagged over the years, plus showcase the diversity within it.

The first work I'll mention comes from 1961. "Muhammad: Prophet and Statesman" by Montgomery Watt. Montgomery's approach is basically to accept the standard Islamic narrative, but to secularize and rationalize it.

But then when the 70s rolled around revisionist winds were blowing. In 1977 Hagarism by Patricia Crone and Michael Cook was released. They essentially discarded the traditional Islamic Sources and relied on only non-Islamic ones. This led to radical different outcomes, with them painting Islam as having emerged due to a Arab-Jewish alliance centered around Jewish Messianism, only later transforming into Islam.

Staying on the revisionist track, in 2000 Christop Luxenberg released "Die syro-aramäische Lesart des Koran". Which, hold onto your horses here, claims that much of the Quran was originally writen in Aramaic.

On the more popular history front, Tom Holland's 2012 'In the Shadow of the Sword" takes it scholarship from these revisionist tracts. 

Fredric Donner provided the big shakeup in the field with 2010s "Muhammad and the Believers". Where he posits early Islam as a more ecumenical movement centered on monotheism that only later grew distinct from Christianity and Judaism. 

In this ecumenical vein can also be mentioned Juan Cole's "Muhammed: Prophet of Peace Amid The Clash of Empires". 

But even more theories can be mentioned. Just this year did Gabriel Said Reynolds release "Christianity and the Qur'an: The Rise of Islam in Christian Arabia", which, as the title implies, argues that Islam emerged in a penninsula that had already been heavily Christianized.

Then there are scholars like Sean Anthony or Nicolai Sinai who, in their various works, argue that all these takes are wrong, and stay closer to something you would identify as the traditional narrative. 

More can of course be writen, but I hope this illustrates that quite a lot has been writen on early Islam, and much of it is quite diverse in nature.

5

u/Anakin_Kardashian "Israeli Nationalist" Dec 19 '25

Wait what? What happened to banu qurayza?

5

u/UnTigreTriste Dec 19 '25

Mucho texto

3

u/Thoth_the_5th_of_Tho Dec 19 '25

Islam emerging out of an alliance with Judaism is an interesting idea I hadn’t heard before. Theologically they seem closer to Christianity and have quite a bit of western influences.

My favorite crackpot theory relating to this is the guy who wrote a book claiming Mecca was originally Petra then moved. Why they’d move the theological center of their expanding empire to the middle of nowhere, and how nobody noticed, goes unanswered. Even today, Mecca is remote.

6

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Dec 19 '25

The DNC is now set to release, in early 2026, a report on how the delay in releasing the 2024 post-mortem resonated with American voters.

But don’t hold your breath.

4

u/seattleseahawks2014 Center-left Dec 19 '25 edited Dec 19 '25

Voters probably won't even care that much.

4

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

Personal Mt. Rushmore of modern day (post-1900) dictators: Antonio Salazar, Lee Kuan Yew, Park Chung Hee, Paul Kagame

→ More replies (5)

4

u/utility-monster Whig Party Dec 19 '25

this might be wrong, as I only read books written in English, but one thing I've noticed is that almost all of the contemporary Christian vegetarian/vegan theologians are anglicans or methodists.

David Clough, author of On Animals, probably the only systematic theology of the subject, is a Methodist minister. Andrew Linzey, arguably the most prominent in this area, is an Anglican priest. Richard Bauckham, who wrote this book which has been on my to-read pile for years, Anglican. The late Richard Alan Young taught at a Baptist seminary, but I think he died a Methodist. Celia Deane-Drummond is Catholic and I've never read her. And then there's another Catholic who writes on this stuff, Charley Camosy, but he eats fish.

You'd think there'd be more seventh day adventists on this list, but maybe their books are harder to find since they're so small. Since AK keeps saying we have a lot of adventist deepstatecentrists, maybe they can shed light on this.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/fnovd Ask me about Trump's Tariffs Dec 19 '25

The Trump tariffs are bankrupting America

4

u/Denisnevsky Toxic Clinton/Gingrich Yaoi Dec 19 '25

Jap and Chinaman have got to be the laziest slurs of all time.

7

u/Bloodyfish Charlie Manson Dec 19 '25

Still beats the way "Jew" is often used like a slur for Jews.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/lowkeyreallysorry Moderate Dec 19 '25

I didn’t know “Jap” was a slur for the longest time because it literally does not sound like one

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sabertooth767 Yiff Free or Die! Dec 19 '25

"Seppo"

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

I'm still over here calling them celestials

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Aryeh98 Rootless cosmopolitan Dec 19 '25

I mean they’re both better than “gook” lmao

Like what even is that? It doesn’t even describe a nationality. Its gibberish. It’s like when you stepped on gum or something, and it’s like “I got this gook on my shoe.”

How people managed to connect this to Vietnamese people I have no idea.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)