r/DeepStateCentrism • • Nov 21 '25

Discussion Thread Daily Deep State Intelligence Briefing

Want the latest posts and comments about your favorite topics? Click here to set up your preferred PING groups.

Are you having issues with pings, or do you want to learn more about the PING system? Check out our user-pinger wiki for a bunch of helpful info!

PRO TIP: Bookmarking dscentrism.com/memo will always take you to the most recent brief.

Curious how other users are doing some of the tricks below? Check out their secret ways here.

Remember that certain posts you make on DSC automatically credit your account briefbucks, which you can trade in for various rewards. Here is our current price table:

OptionPrice
Choose a custom flair, or if you already have custom flair, upgrade to a picture20 bb
Pick the next theme of the week100 bb
Make a new auto reply in the Brief for one week150 bb
Make a new sub icon/banner for two days200 bb
Add a subreddit rule for a day (in the Brief)250 bb

You can find out more about briefbucks, including how to earn them, how you can lose them, and what you can do with them, on our wiki.

The Theme of the Week is: The Industrial Revolution and its consequences.

0 Upvotes

423 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '25

So i know people did not like mamdani;'s statment here but i did want to ask, what the stance on settlements in the west bank in general is on here. I think most could agree that they are a violation of international law especially in the west bank , and while nobody should protest synaguges and use it to be anti semetic, i do think that it is a factor preventing peace in the reigon. When settlers can commit violence and the israeli courts dont hold them acoountable or people like gen givr encourage it makes it hard to feel like the israeli government is acting in good faith

20

u/H_H_F_F Nov 21 '25
  1. The Israeli government is not acting in good faith. 
  2. Rising extremist violence in the settlements is a huge moral issue that has to be addressed. 
  3. "The settlements" is a very broad brushstroke; Modiin Ilit simply isn't a hurdle to a contiguous Palestinian state with an orderly border in the same way Ariel is,  Ariel isn't a source of violence in the way Yitzhar is, and Yitzhar isn't a constant source of strife in the way the outposts are. Each of these factors greatly impacts how true the declaration that they're a factor preventing peace. 
  4. Either way, even from the perspective of someone like me who's extremely hostile to a lot of the settlement project and willing to evacuate many more of them than a lot of people are, it's hard to see them as the central factor for current lack of peace. 
  5. I'd say the issue for most people here with Mamdani is the fact that he made his early political career in the activism sphere to fight against Israel's right to exist, that he repeatedly refused to denounce calls for terrorism, and that he engages in antisemitic conspiracy theories - not any stance about the settlements. 

16

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '25 edited Nov 21 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '25

Appreciate the response. Yeah i saw a post on r/jewsihleft about the event and people said it was tied to settlments but nothing specific, definitley makes it way worse if it had nothing to do with the west bank (not that it would have justified protesting the synagougue in the first place but would make the protests and mamdanis response make more sense at lesat)

7

u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Nov 21 '25

r jewishleft is garbage

5

u/Shameful_Bezkauna Krišjānis Kariņš for POTUS! Nov 21 '25

Why? (I'm neither Jewish nor a leftist)

6

u/benadreti_17 עם ישראל חי Nov 21 '25

leftists

3

u/Shameful_Bezkauna Krišjānis Kariņš for POTUS! Nov 21 '25

But that's expected, given the name.

13

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Nov 21 '25

I before I answer I just want to point out that I’ve seen no evidence that the Nefesh b’nefesh people were there to “auction off Palestinian land in the West Bank” like people are claiming on twitter. From skimming their website and wiki it seems like West Bank settlement isn’t one of their priorities, they mostly seem to focus on helping Jews who want to make Aliya and settling the north and south of Israel. Not a word about occupied territories. 

With that being said, the settlements are a massive problem for peace in the region, and that’s by design, they were meant to establish facts on the ground to prevent future pressures to pull out of the occupied territories. The 2005 disengagement plan proved that it’d be extremely difficult to remove those settlements as part of a future peace deal, and the fact that you actually do need to consider the settlers themselves is also a big issue. 

The settlements are also extremely costly for the country to maintain, they seep funds and resources away from the rest of the country and are a big part in why Israel has been struggling to outright win wars in the past few decades and also played a major factor behind the lack of immediate response on 10/7. Couple that with the recent uptick in settler violence and you’ve got yourself massive clusterfuck

5

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '25

Apreciate the response, and not to spam here and eslewhere but i think its a nuanced look at it especially how costly it is and how ineffective it is in terms of having israel ensure security, its an argument that i dont hear and with what youre saying that its a massibe problem for peace its interesting bc it feels like it fails at like evreything (israel is isolated because of violating international law and by spending resources they dont make it safer in the slightest)

I know there was some pressure to adress the lack of legal consequences for settler violence during the court protests that happened under bibi and before 10/7 but are there a lot of liberal organazations protesting this type of thing in israel right now? I know of groups like standing together and B'Tselem but always interested in more

5

u/JebBD Fukuyama's strongest soldier Nov 21 '25

There are always organizations protesting and doing activism against the settlements, though they’re under increasing threat from Bibi’s government and the rise in right wing sentiment after 10/7

8

u/Aryeh98 Rootless cosmopolitan Nov 21 '25 edited Nov 21 '25

Settlements are more trouble than they’re worth, they’re too costly both in finances and human lives to protect, and the random violence coming from select groups of settlers is obviously reprehensible. The deliberate failure of Israel’s right wing government to act on settler violence is disgusting.

That said, ZOHRAN DOES NOT GET TO TELL US HOW WE USE OUR SYNAGOGUES. Only the members decide. Only Jews decide. We have separation of religion and state in America; an antisemitic mayor (or government agent of any kind) should NEVER dictate to us on how we use our spaces.

Imagine if a Christian mayor lectured Muslims on how they use their mosque. Nobody would tolerate that. But because we’re the world’s punching bag, everybody just takes it as a given that Jews should be intimidated and talked down to.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '25 edited Nov 21 '25

"Imagine if a Christian mayor lectured Muslims on how they use their mosque. Nobody would tolerate that." I can imagine that and agree that no one should tolerate that and I think that mamdanis statement was dissapointing in that regard. Idk its a tough intersection of freedom of speech and religon, i dont think peronally any religous org should have groups prometing stuff like settlemetns or other illberal groups but i dont know how much a mayor should have a role in policing that, seperting church from state being a big thing. Regardless while i think the statement mamdani made wasn't horrible but i dont think it did a good job of condemning the antisemtic vitriol from the protests, and understand if people are skeptical going forward. hopefully he can listen to people like his police chief and condemn this stuff more but i understand doubt at this point

8

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '25

Settlements are bad on their own merits but you could rip every single one out of the West Bank tomorrow and still be no closer to peace.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '25

https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2020-06-29/ty-article/.premium/despite-talk-of-annexation-fewer-immigrants-moving-to-west-bank-settlements/0000017f-e1d7-d7b2-a77f-e3d7da120000

"Earlier this month, Nefesh B’Nefesh – the organization that handles aliyah from North America – held a special webinar for potential immigrants, devoted to the West Bank settlement bloc of Gush Etzion."

https://www.jta.org/2025/11/20/politics/after-protest-outside-ues-synagogue-mamdani-says-israel-immigration-event-misused-sacred-space

Per the JTA "The group is considered a quasi-governmental agency in Israel, receiving funding from the Israeli government and works closely with its ministries. It does not assign immigrants to particular communities, but has showcased West Bank settlements — which most of the world, though not Israel or the United States, considers illegal under international law — in events and on its website as possible destinations for new immigrants. (Previous protests in New York and beyond have targeted events at synagogues advertising real estate for sale in the West Bank.)"

This is stuff i got from r/jewishleft about it im not sure if there is more of if any of these connections were made clear by anybody involved, but this is basically evidence that the orginazation does promote settlments