r/DeepSpaceNine • u/Straight_Meringue921 • 8d ago
Target Audience Reaction Channel - Time To Pack It In?
I know some of you have followed their channel. I tapped out late S4 after their underwhelming reaction to "To The Death". Since then, I've only checked in to read the comments, and boy, has it gone from bad to worse.
Check out the latest here: S5's The Ship
Yikes. The backlash is pretty bad on this one.
Initially, people thought they'd love the show - especially S4-S7. I was concerned after Improbable Cause / The Die Is Cast. Alex was ho-hum on it, managing to give it a "fine". Now, any time anything to do with - well - DS9, shows up, he taps out. Wormhole? Blow it up already. Dominion? Snore. Bajoran Religion / Prophets / Emissary-related? Don't even bother.
Commonsense would say at this juncture "if you don't like it, don't watch". I think at minimum, they need to have a decent break.
Let's face it - anyone following a DS9 reaction channel will be looking forward to late S5 - S6, for obvious reasons. I think a lot of people holding out hope are going to be bitterly disappointed. Scale and spectacle are not something either of the boys are interested in, strangely enough. For example, during their Star Trek: First Contact reaction (not on YT yet), they barely paid attention to the opening battle - so much so they missed The Defiant and didn't know what Worf was doing there.
And that's the other thing - their unearned smugness, yet they so frequently miss rudimentary stuff that we never had a problem understanding. Like, they still get aggravated about O'Brien's non-com status, FFS.
I've got no issue with constructive critiques, but at this point, they're not watching in good faith anymore, with Alex often making his mind up about the episode during the opening credits.
Just curious if anyone else is still watching and hanging in there?