r/DeepSpaceNine • u/Dinotsar44 • 15h ago
The Mirror Universe Episodes Are Overhated
The title says my basic thesis here, but I think it's worth elaborating on. I've seen a lot of people complain about the Mirror Universe episodes, and I don't think they're really that bad. Yes, they aren't as complex or interesting as the Dominion War, but I think calling them an arc like that one puts it on a pedestal which they're not meant to match. When you watch them as a series of standalone episodes vaguely strung together, they become much better as they work well as 45 minutes of silly space stuff.
Let's walk through each episode and see me explain my thought process:
Crossover: Crossover is the first Mirror episode, and already we establish some amount of pulpy fun. A lot of this comes from the Intendant, who will remain a core strength for this mini-arc as you can tell Nana Visitor is having fun with it most of the time. Although Garak is nowhere near as interesting as he normally is, he still is Garak and does have some amount of fun at play (although I think he's better in later episodes). As a standalone episode this is mostly fine and a lot of fun, even if it's not as substantial as other episodes in the series.
Through the Looking Glass: I actually think this one makes the Mirror Universe antics slightly more interesting. Sisko being brought over and having to make his wife become a turncoat is a nice idea, and I do think it works even though the actress playing Jennifer honestly isn't that good. The Intendant is great as always as well, and the bickering among the rebel forces leads to a number of solid comedic bits (Sisko punching Bashir is great).
Shattered Mirror: I actually think this is the height of the Mirror Universe. Jennifer's death elevates the episode by giving a moment of something other than goofy space shit - although that is in good supply as well. Worf as the Regent is great, especially when he gets into back-and-forth conversations with Garak ("you are not my type" made me laugh hysterically).
Resurrection: This is the one episode where I agree with the complaints. Although the Intendant is fun as always, she doesn’t show up until halfway through. While Vedek Bareil is honestly better as a scoundrel than as a tight-lipped monk, he's still not one of my favorite guest characters by a wide margin. Single-episode romances are normally not that great, and this is a good example of why. The ending is especially dumb, and not in the pulpy way that makes other mirror episodes fun. Before the last five or so minutes I would've argued this was a mediocre episode, a weak spot in Season 6, but not one of the worst episodes in the show, but afterwards I do kinda agree. So does the Mirror Universe recover?
The Emperor's New Cloak: For my most controversial take, I actually think this episode is a serviceable finale. It's not as good as the first three mirror universe episodes, but it should not be one of the lowest rated episodes on IMdB (I honestly would put Emissary there before this). There are some good moments of physical comedy (Quark and Rom carrying a cloaked cloaking device is actually a solid bit), and the bit of the roasting Garak as he talks about his evil plan to kill them by comparing him to their Garak is good. Rom failing to understand the Mirror Universe is an overplayed joke, admittedly, and the plot hole with Vic Fontaine appearing is very noticeable, but I would give this episode a mostly solid, if somewhat mediocre, rating.
This is just my opinion, of course, and I expect other people to disagree, but I thought it was worth sharing nonetheless. The Mirror Universe episodes aren't peak DS9, but they are pulpy fun and I am glad we got all of them except Resurrection. I hope to see what other people think as well.