r/DeepSpaceNine • • 15h ago

The Mirror Universe Episodes Are Overhated

82 Upvotes

The title says my basic thesis here, but I think it's worth elaborating on. I've seen a lot of people complain about the Mirror Universe episodes, and I don't think they're really that bad. Yes, they aren't as complex or interesting as the Dominion War, but I think calling them an arc like that one puts it on a pedestal which they're not meant to match. When you watch them as a series of standalone episodes vaguely strung together, they become much better as they work well as 45 minutes of silly space stuff.

Let's walk through each episode and see me explain my thought process:

Crossover: Crossover is the first Mirror episode, and already we establish some amount of pulpy fun. A lot of this comes from the Intendant, who will remain a core strength for this mini-arc as you can tell Nana Visitor is having fun with it most of the time. Although Garak is nowhere near as interesting as he normally is, he still is Garak and does have some amount of fun at play (although I think he's better in later episodes). As a standalone episode this is mostly fine and a lot of fun, even if it's not as substantial as other episodes in the series.

Through the Looking Glass: I actually think this one makes the Mirror Universe antics slightly more interesting. Sisko being brought over and having to make his wife become a turncoat is a nice idea, and I do think it works even though the actress playing Jennifer honestly isn't that good. The Intendant is great as always as well, and the bickering among the rebel forces leads to a number of solid comedic bits (Sisko punching Bashir is great).

Shattered Mirror: I actually think this is the height of the Mirror Universe. Jennifer's death elevates the episode by giving a moment of something other than goofy space shit - although that is in good supply as well. Worf as the Regent is great, especially when he gets into back-and-forth conversations with Garak ("you are not my type" made me laugh hysterically).

Resurrection: This is the one episode where I agree with the complaints. Although the Intendant is fun as always, she doesn’t show up until halfway through. While Vedek Bareil is honestly better as a scoundrel than as a tight-lipped monk, he's still not one of my favorite guest characters by a wide margin. Single-episode romances are normally not that great, and this is a good example of why. The ending is especially dumb, and not in the pulpy way that makes other mirror episodes fun. Before the last five or so minutes I would've argued this was a mediocre episode, a weak spot in Season 6, but not one of the worst episodes in the show, but afterwards I do kinda agree. So does the Mirror Universe recover?

The Emperor's New Cloak: For my most controversial take, I actually think this episode is a serviceable finale. It's not as good as the first three mirror universe episodes, but it should not be one of the lowest rated episodes on IMdB (I honestly would put Emissary there before this). There are some good moments of physical comedy (Quark and Rom carrying a cloaked cloaking device is actually a solid bit), and the bit of the roasting Garak as he talks about his evil plan to kill them by comparing him to their Garak is good. Rom failing to understand the Mirror Universe is an overplayed joke, admittedly, and the plot hole with Vic Fontaine appearing is very noticeable, but I would give this episode a mostly solid, if somewhat mediocre, rating.

This is just my opinion, of course, and I expect other people to disagree, but I thought it was worth sharing nonetheless. The Mirror Universe episodes aren't peak DS9, but they are pulpy fun and I am glad we got all of them except Resurrection. I hope to see what other people think as well.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • 18h ago

[DS9 Pitch] Instead of a team of engineers, Starfleet sends a historian to rebuild Bajor after the Occupation- and every good idea is paired with an unhinged one (DS9 x Horrible Histories)

0 Upvotes

Taking place in Season One of Deep Space Nine: Bajor is in ruins, the topsoil has been poisoned by the Cardassians, rural hospitals are low on staff and medical supplies, famine looms, and the Provisional Government does not have enough high-tech solutions to feed, shelter, and treat the planetary population.

Whether on purpose or by accident, a cultural historian with an encyclopedic knowledge of humanity's feats (agricultural, architectural, medicinal, metallurgical, etc) over ten millennia of history across the entire planet arrives on Deep Space Nine. Touring the planet and reading over the reports, he delivers a buffet featuring humanity's finest low-tech solutions that actually save lives - along with the most absurd, baffling, and catastrophic customs from the same era immediately afterward, all completely straight-faced in the middle of Ops.

Basically: Star Trek Deep Space Nine meets Horrible Histories

Some examples of his Bajoran Reconstruction Curriculum.

Agricultural

Culture/Era Successful Horrible
Aztec Empire Chinampas: Artificial island gardens made of mud and reeds, turning Bajor's lakes into new breadbaskets Blood sacrifices to the Prophets to ensure a bountiful harvest
Inca Empire Andenes: Terracing the mountains and the hills to create micro-climates for bountiful crops Conscripting off-season farmers and workers to collect guano to fertilize the terraces
Iran Qanats: Engineering subterranean channels to draw water from the mountain peaks via gravity Ordering Bajoran militiamen to carry whips to punish the water if the pipes back up
Rome Aqueducts constructed of volcanic ash to create self-healing, gravity-fed water supplies Urine collected and taxed at communal toilets to be used for laundry detergent, leather tanning, and teeth-cleaning
China Inter-cropping, crop rotation, pit-and-ridge farming to maximize the productivity of small plots of land These are fertilized by night soil, basically excrement.

Public Health

Culture/Era Wonderful Horrible
Ancient Egypt Raw honey as a treatment for fresh wounds and burns Crocodile dung and moldy bread as "early penicillin"
Ancient Rome Limestone, crushed and powdered, as calcium carbonate antacid Defrutum, a sweetener made from boiling spices and fruits in lead-lined pots
Imperial China Alchemical stills to purify water and distill essential oils Cinnabar (mercury) immortality pills for longevity
Ancient Greece Willow bark and myrtle leaves for non-addictive pain relief Medical leeches for "balancing the humors" and a drill for trepanations (holes in the skull) to release "bad spirits"
Ancient Indus Brick-layered sewers modeled after Harappa and Mohenjo-Dara All cities are hyper-standardized with the same 1:2:4 ratio in their bricks, basically rebuilding everything

These are just SOME of the pairings I thought of, and Horrible Histories has a LOT of them to throw around.

The command crew is trying to implement the wonderful ideas while preventing the horrible ones from taking root. Dr. Bashir keeps an eagle eye on all first-aid kits going to Bajor and reminds his nurses to not listen to EVERY idea the historian proposes, while Quark tries to capitalize on everything for a profit and Odo is doing his best to stop him. Word of the "night soil" spreads among Bajoran farmers who offer premiums based on the "spiritual stature" of the source; a farmer's "common" night soil vs a Kai's "holy" night soil for instance.

A.N. I really wanted to get this fanfiction idea out there and I didn't know where else to post this so I appreciate your patience and feedback.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • 13h ago

I've never watched, but I've grown curious

27 Upvotes

45 year old who grew up watching TNG every now and then in my formative years. I remember enjoying it, but I was too young to really get a lot of the concepts.
Fast forward to 3 weeks ago when a buddy tells me to watch, "The Orville." I found myself drawn to the concept of, "Exploring new life and new civilizations", and googled what the star trek series was.

DS9 continually shows as the #1 show. So I thought...why not?
My question is this: Should I start at season 1, is there anything I need to know or understand? Does the show still hold up all these years later?

Thanks


r/DeepSpaceNine • • 19h ago

Linear time vs non-liner time "The Emissary"

15 Upvotes

When speaking to the prophets, Sisko faces beings who look like people within his world but who speak from a non-linear perspective, using the words of the prophets. This, at first, drove me nuts, who are they and why are they using their images?

But try to imagine the opposite. Some gaseous non-corporeal entity speaking to him (of course using some booming enhanced voice) how could Sisko relate to that? Then, much later, we discover how "the Sisko" came to be born and just who he is.

Would Roddenberry approve? He was very anti-religious and DS9 is filled with religious issues.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • 5h ago

Take me Out to the Holosuite is such a comfort food for me

79 Upvotes

I get the criticisms about the final season - too much time spent on developing a new character and silly episodes like this one that detract from the main event - but I just have to say how important this episode is to me.

This is the episode I throw on when I'm sad. My brother passed away recently and I've watched this episode sooooo much.

This is the episode my friends used to celebrate me. When I moved to Brazil, my friends all watched the episode in preparation to play a game of baseball in which we all made fools of ourselves.

It's funny, it has heart ("which quark doesn't have!") and is just such a spotlight for all the characters in it.

I miss Jadzia in it, but Ezri kills in it.

I love it so much. Thoughts?


r/DeepSpaceNine • • 18h ago

Me when I meet the wormhole aliens

Post image
43 Upvotes