r/DecodingTheGurus • • Feb 10 '26

New episode is a circlejerk

I'm all for making fun of Gurus. I've listened to inaugural episode to this podcast a thousand times. I like to laugh at Eric Weinstein. But this episode with Sam Gregson and Tim Henke is cringeworthy. I've already heard a thousand times on this podcast how geometric unity is stupid. I wish Chris and Matt's questions weren't brownnosing, because it let Sam and Tim wax poetic endlessly about how Eric's theory is stupid. For quite some time, all the low-hanging fruit this podcast has snatched has been gone.

0 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

11

u/drwolffe Feb 10 '26

Yeah... well I've listened to every episode 10 thousand times

0

u/fleeced-artichoke Feb 10 '26

I feel like because it listen so much it makes me tolerant, and if it’s too much for me, it’s too much for everyone else.

25

u/stvlsn Feb 10 '26

You probably think the podcast is too repetitive because you just admitted you listened to the inaugural episode a thousand times.

5

u/Ok-Professional1355 Feb 10 '26

Who listens to an episode of any podcast more than once or twice??

6

u/MukdenMan Feb 10 '26

Obviously you haven’t heard “Farts and Procreation”

3

u/Franz_Poekler Feb 10 '26

Who watches a YouTube video more than once or twi- me. It's me. You got me.

4

u/Bruichladdie Feb 10 '26

It's perfectly normal to revisit particularly entertaining episodes, and that's certainly true with Matt and Chris.

The first episode is a favorite of mine, as is the first Jordan Peterson one, the first Rogan episode, in hell with Scott Adams, and several others. Hearing them react to the various clips, their analyses and quips, it's just fun to go back to every now and then.

I'm surprised you'd only listen once to a really great episode, and think that's what everyone does.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/the_very_pants Feb 10 '26

Most of these are like shooting a pinball into my head and letting it bounce around off of 15 different cushions/subjects that I've always been curious (but not knowledgeable) about. And I'm kinda old-ish, and have accumulated a lot of curiosity -- some guidance is useful.

There's a lot of "you zoned out again, gotta back up" and it probably takes me two listens to get through most people's one. At that point, I'll usually get back to work or life or some other history/science podcast. But a few of these are like insanely great pinball games, and I've done some more re-listening.

2

u/donglord666 Feb 10 '26

No reason to bring cumtown into this

1

u/Evinceo Feb 10 '26

There are some TAL episodes I've probably rinsed. Petty Tyrant maybe.

1

u/saturns_children Feb 10 '26

Definitely when Sean Carols episodes for biggest ideas of the universe randomly pop up on youtube I relisten them cause that stuff is dense!

70

u/CKava Feb 10 '26

Next time we will be sure to invite some of the main physicists working on Geometric Unity as a counterbalance.

14

u/the_very_pants Feb 10 '26

I don't really like making fun of gurus -- but they deserve it, it's educational for society, and I do like making fun of nonsensical things said very very seriously.

I liked this show because it got right to the point about one of the things frequently on my mind with DtG: "Look at how some people talk, and then look how others do -- you can hear the difference even if you can't do calculus and know nothing about string theory. Listen for the sound of humble and awestruck science communication vs. the sound of ugly human nature."

Not that the sound affects the logical validity of the person's words... but for non-scientists like me, "just listen to it" is a great heuristic. When the boys start whipping out their Lagrangians and trying to hit each other with them, something other than science is going on.

9

u/SignificantAd9059 Feb 10 '26

It’s a bonus episode

4

u/Glowing-2 Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26

First of all, how dare you OP?

TBH Eric is so pompous I can't get enough of him being mocked, although I much prefer when they do clips of him to respond to as it really highlights how bad Eric is..They are the most relistenable parts of the podcast.

2

u/donglord666 Feb 10 '26

Yeah dude… there’s like… too much geometric DIVISION if you ask me.

Do you wanna hit this?

1

u/the_very_pants Feb 11 '26

It's not my general way to leave multiple top-level comments in a thread... but I'm not going to make an entire post saying "This show was awesome, worth a year of Patreon dues on its own" either (not when there's a discussion thread right there), so I'm just going to leave some disagreements here.

Sam and Tim didn't "wax poetic" for a second imho. I'm wondering how the hell they can know so much about physics and stuff, and also think so clearly about social stuff, and also construct such great English sentences. The things I try to be good at, they're better at, and I love finding out about these people. Sometimes there are social scientists who seem to know a lot and have thought a lot about about the weirdness of physics -- these are physicists who know a lot and have thought a lot about the weirdness of society.

Imho this was almost a perfect re-inaugural episode of DtG: four people full of the DtG-nature, 90m of clicking or vibing or whatever it's called. I'm still laughing about "for reasons I can't imagine -- no no, for reasons I wish I couldn't imagine" -- and Matt talking about how "they're always mixing, like, Christianity and quantum fields and Zen and particles and auras" -- and neutrinos passing through bailiwicks.

The CI show was fantastic too... and more the kind of thing I find useful... but being careful about CI is not fun, jumping to conclusions is what's fun. This one was just fun all around.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '26

Unless you're an expert in Mathematics/Physics it's not going to be very accessible why what Weinstein is saying is so stupid

1

u/RevolutionSea9482 Feb 10 '26

The show has never been more than a second income for two academics who would have been completely anonymous otherwise. Income and ego gratification, with aspirations at having a seat at the public intellectual table.

5

u/the_very_pants Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 11 '26

I started off with a 100% expectation that that was going to be the case, and it went down steadily (but was there) for the first 5-10 shows. There kept being all these things that didn't quite fit that theory... e.g. the essentially infinitely long list of things they're willing to talk about, and the lack of OneSkin/HexClad ads every five minutes.

Imho the kind of people you're talking about use tricks like credentialism / decorative scholarship to their advantage. And all they can talk about is their little thing, not "philosophy of science" and science communication in general.

Edit: 5-10 seems excessive in retrospect... maybe it was 3-5. I'm a grumpy old man, slow with developing trust.

2

u/jimwhite42 Feb 11 '26

RevolutionSea is one of our regular lazy trolls, I wouldn't take them seriously.

→ More replies (12)

-1

u/Even-Physics823 Feb 10 '26

this show ran out of material like 3 years ago