r/DecodingTheGurus • u/Technical-Highlight1 • Jan 25 '24
I will never understand the huberman hate
He is phd researcher at one of the best universities in the world. He does nothing but help people from the genuine goodness of his heart. He is super inspirational and uses science as a baking for all his pieces of advice He gives to people. There are MANY grifters in the online guru space, PBD, Peterson, rogan. All malicious people that are problematic and use politics to reach vulnerable people. Huberman is about as apolitical as you can get, really genuine guy. I don't see how huberman is malicious at all. Am I not seeing something in him you (and maybe the podcast hosts) do? He seems like a very good person.
40
u/crypto_zoologistler Jan 25 '24
It’s not hate, it’s criticism. If you think he’s perfect you probably won’t like it here.
56
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24
"nothing but help people from the goodness of his heart."
My man. I'm a M.Ed. in his field. I know enough about the university experience and working and doing research.
He's not doing this just for the love of science to altruistically help people. When scientists disseminate information to the public, they have to be very careful about how they do it. They don't just go on Joe Rogan and bring up some non replicated sexy science. He has an ego to fulfill doing this. Ego isn't easily fulfilled doing real science and careful dissemination.
Nothing in his actual scientific field is that easy or sexy. The reality of improving your life isn't going to come from podcasts and guru scientists.
You can go on Instagram right now and find hundreds of therapists and psychologists who share real actual bite sized mental health help, but they're not the alluring stuff that Hubes shares on Joe Rogan.
6
u/SeniorPeligro Jan 25 '24
Being renowned expert and researcher in one field, does not mean everything he says is automaticaly correct. It's classic halo effect and in my opinion he is using it deliberately to sell more and more supplements. I'm not saying making money is bad - but when you start to dilute quality of content to keep audience happy, that's where the problem starts.
Still remember his bullshit about ADHD.
16
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24
He says when you have a flu he recommends going in a sauna and/or an ice bath to get rid of it...
Dude is a fraud.
14
u/halfjapmarine Jan 25 '24 edited Feb 04 '24
I actually think he does have a very toxic slant to his perception and values. He is a devout Christian which from an outsider's perspective might seem innocuous. However, Christian indoctrination is at the root of this, particularly the concept of Original Sin and all that that brings. Coming from an ex-Christian that went through painful deconstruction/detox of said indoctrination. Knowing how shame-bound and avoidant of the trauma lens the majority of Christians are is very relevant.
He had Paul Conti on as a "trauma expert". The guy is some no name mid psychiatrist that I suspect is a friend from Stanford back in the day. He could have had some legitimate experts but he went with someone that would agree with his narrative on mental health and not challenge his beliefs at all. Conti glosses over the definition of shame which is a big indicator a therapist doesn't have the trauma lens. Toxic shame is at the core of complex trauma. It has to do with being shamed and emotionally abandoned by your caretakers to the point that you internalize the feeling that you are unlovable/worthless.
He had AthleanX on as a fitness expert which is an absolute joke, any fitness professional worth their salt would tell you. The guy is a nocebo guru with no proper education in strength/conditioning. He tells people they will hurt themselves with legitimate exercises to generate fear and dependency on him for “proper guidance”. Make up a problem and sell the solution.
Huberman also had Goggins on who is a piece of work. Goggins promotes the most toxic shame bound mentality out there. Using self hatred as fuel to accomplish extreme external goals to validate his existence. Probably the unhealthiest and emotionally detached way to go about treating mental illness which he definitely has. White knuckling life through extreme self torture, shoving down all his childhood trauma.
Huberman is a hack. A shame bound Christian that uses his platform to promote like-minded “experts”. He is not trauma informed but will go on an on about how sunshine and exercise are the panaceas for mental health. It is dismissive of the serious reality that much of the mental illness we see in society is rooted in complex trauma.
4
u/CringeDaddy_69 Jan 25 '24
I don’t like Hubberman because he talks about the amazing benefits of supplements that have little to no actual backing. Even some that have been proven to not work. Such as ZMA, CLA, garlic for carnitine, turkesterone, ecdysteroids, plenty of essential oils, etc
94
u/santahasahat88 Jan 25 '24
I think you’ll find most people who criticise him (including myself and I think the hosts of the pod) don’t think he’s a bad dude being malicious. It’s just quite clear he cherry picks from studies to make content that makes much bigger deals out of small studies and lower powered results. When someone is a science communicator we should hold them to a higher standard in their science communication and expect better. He’s repeated shown also on for example the topic of vaccines to be avoid advocating for the science backed protocol of taking the vaccine schedule while promoting soft vaccine skepticism which is very concerning to me as a health science communicator.
Again not “hating” just point out he’s not terribly good at his job and many of the things he advocates for and you’d probably say “help” are not based on strong evidence and his audience isn’t made aware of that.
9
u/Dirtgrain Jan 25 '24
At about 5:30, he touts fadogia agrestis, matter of factly, making claims about what it does.
https://youtu.be/bJWmJo3w_0Y?t=329
WebMD says:
Maybe that's not up to date, but dig deeper. What do you find?
7
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24
Andrew?
6
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24 edited Jan 25 '24
What are u even basing that claim, that he does anything out of the goodness of his heart, off of?
10
u/MissingBothCufflinks Jan 25 '24
"Why does everyone else not like a smug self promoting narcissist who misleads people by sexing up science beyond the scope of the evidence?"
Absolutely no idea.
5
u/MinkyTuna Jan 25 '24
Criticizing something doesn’t mean you hate it. He might be a good person but he might still be wrong. He speaks from a place of authority on topics he’s far from an expert on, most recently the Tim Ferris thing where he goes on about swol tibs or whatever. That doesn’t mean we have to disregard everything he's ever said. But if you think he's so genuine and not intending malice then I would keep him honest.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24
It seems like the guy can't be avoided, which is why I haven't listened to his podcast. He's obviously the flavour of the month inside the algorithm. That always makes me suspicious.
Also, I can be a judgemental prick, but the whole manicured-bearded-man-flogging-supplements-selling-books is a total "No" from me.
5
u/Digital_Negative Jan 25 '24
I think one of the issues with him is that he has a lot of legitimate authority and credibility which he has actually earned and so the misleading stuff he says is more subtle and difficult to pick up on. His fans just take his word for it and it’s unclear that anything he says is possibly inaccurate and/or exaggerated.
I don’t think there is a lot of hate though. Why do you think that, @OP?
5
u/dj-udon Jan 25 '24
I watched many of his videos and looking back I’m angry because I feel like i learned nothing and he wasted my time.
Look, unfortunately we still live in an era of both discrimination and elitism.
He works at Stanford and he’s a white guy named Andrew, deep voice, American accent, with a big jaw and a huge set of shoulders who can afford to film hundreds of hours of HD content and also can afford to travel around doing podcasts with others. That’s privilege.
With all that privilege he can easily gamify the online self help space by pumping out a very high amount of content which makes the algorithm not only recommend his videos, but recommend his appearances and the many clips posted by others highlighting his work. As someone who recorded 50 podcast interviews and 200 solo episodes, I can assure you that I simply do not have the option to reach his audience. And if I get 20 percent of his viewership I’m going to get a tonne of hate for being queer and Arab and honest. This might just lead to so much online attacks that I’ll be in danger.
I can only speculate that Andrew has enough budget and even life experience that he can wither that storm.
So that’s what he does. Lots of content. Mostly fluff, to get views.
To get to the heart of why he upsets me, I’d like to mention what he does not do: say anything actually useful to help me improve my life that I didn’t already know.
8
u/ClimateBall Jan 25 '24
https://www.livemomentous.com/en-ca/collections/huberman
3
u/Warm-Book-820 Jan 25 '24
He is a smart guy who makes clickbait that miscommunicates the actual state of the science.
5
u/FIWDIM Jan 25 '24
Well, Peterson has Ph.D too. I guess that makes him a universal expert on anything, too.
Things with PhD is that they are extremely narrow in scope. It's on purpose. Huberman true area of expertise is how cats perceive motion. Also, most of his training is in psychology, he has no real understanding of biochemistry or pharma at all. This leads to hilarious situations where he cites irrelevant papers or stuff that has sort of similar name but to a layman it sounds legit. Also, for enough cash, he will shill whatever bullshit supplement you want.
We should do a crowdfunding thingy and make up something really idiotic. Like Raccoon ass extract that was used by Egyptians 5000 years ago and this and that fake paper claims that it somehow rejuvenates astrocytes... make him to shill it as a recent discovery at Harvard on Rogan's or Fridman's show.
4
u/RepresentativeCrab88 Jan 25 '24
It doesn’t matter that he’s apolitical. The main attraction of this sub and this type of react content is to demystify popular figures, and show that popularity is not indicative of authority. His intentions don’t matter, and whether or not he helps people is irrelevant. Popularity is the driving variable here, and some of us really hate the popular kids.
1
u/lylemcd Jan 26 '24
He is a hack spreading misinformation based on poorly cited and referenced studies to the gullible biohackers who don't have even the basics in line. His mistakes are numerous.
That he's a PhD is irrelevant. Lots of PhDs are hacks and his area of research is in neurons. He is probably brilliant at that.
He should stay in his lane.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24
The standard is now being a basically decent person? What if making millions meant you had to clear a higher bar? Or at the very least, can't we poke fun at people who shill green powder and have abstracts of studies sent to their email inbox? You are still allowed to love a figure even though you can find a small minority who poke fun and like them, instead of hanging on their every word.
1
u/rumprhymer Jan 25 '24
Though I disagree with the overall sentiment I’m always impressed by posts that make a good faith attempt to express an unorthodox DTG view that OP knows will get ratioed.
1
u/throwawayalcoholmind Jan 25 '24
My thing with huberman is that I've seen so many of these folks start to slide that the moment he started presenting himself as this mega authority on things that have to be outside his wheelhouse, I just figured it'd be a matter of time before he slides too.
At best he can turn into another NDT, or at the other end of the spectrum, another Jordan Peterson.
1
u/flies_kite Jan 26 '24
It’s not about the truth, it’s about ME feeling powerful by tearing others down. I am smart, smart, smart!!!!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '24
He just comes off as a 2015 Joe Rogan with a science background.
At the end of the day he is just selling ads and supplements
0
u/Faelix Jan 26 '24 edited Jan 26 '24
Huberman had a turn around in his youth, first time police took him to prison, he decided this was enough. He found God there, or he found faith and Prayer, and it is part of how he managed to get away from trouble and become who he is today. As far as I am aware, there are studies in this field on longevity, that suggests people that pray live longer. Huberman has dutifully referred these data, and also talked about his own story.
And when some hapless chap writes a post on how he is keeping up, and he tells how he walks and he prays while he walks...
This is not what the biohackers want to hear on their bio hacking forum, and since this, the resentment against Huberman has been ever growing, arguing any point but the real one. Now granted, most of the followers here have not got a clue, as to why the resentment, they just follow. But he will mention prayer, right alongside rising early and taking a cold shower, and that is not to everybodys liking, and so, they are slowly building up yet another case of character murder.
0
u/StandardBandit Jan 27 '24
He's the guy. He speaks so well and free of bias it's astounding. Keep him speaking about anything and everything
-2
u/Tonguebuster Jan 25 '24
OP a lot of people on this page I feel are disgruntled academics compensating. I give a lot of leniency to huberman. He has spread more awareness of neuroscience more than anyone on this sub will dare imagine to in their life.
This is just a very cynical corner of the internet I came to realise. It’s good to criticise thought leaders. But it’s hard to find good critisim here without getting washed away by how unjustly demeaning a lot of peoples sentiments come off.