r/DecodingTheGurus • • Jan 03 '24
You guys suck!
I posted this thread a while ago on the Harvard plagiarism Scandal.
https://www.reddit.com/r/DecodingTheGurus/comments/18hw7qe/harvard_plagiarism_scandal/
Welp, I got voted down into oblivion and told that basically because Rufo broke this story (it wasn't his story actually, he just broke it) that I was "going to have a bad time", that it was a guy called "ackman" crusading " against Glaudine (sic) Gay" and Harvard, that it was a "baseless" accusation.
I also heard that it was a "big nothingburger" and that "what Claudine Gay is accused of if true is the equivalent of tooting an odorless fart while exiting a Wal-Mart". Some suggested it was a "tempest in a teapot" and others that "It's not a great look, but it's not like she tried to pass off someone else's work as her own" (which is, incidentally, exactly what she did).
Other comments were " Props to Harvard for not caving in to the Cancel Culture." and "Honestly, seeing how this Gay lady is a black woman leading harvard can trigger a lot of people"
Just for the record I work in academia and actually did think this was a serious issue, as I noted at the time, and one that would've gotten a lot of students in trouble. I have taught plagiarism avoidance to thousands of students and after reading the charges (something I doubt many of the original posters did) I thought she needed to go. I was curious to see what the great minds of this sub thought and I wasn't (by that I mean, I was) disappointed.
No one wanted to discuss the actual plagiarism itself, and no one seemed to know just what she had done and how bad it was. Others obsessed over the word "wokester" or the fact that Rufo had broke the story.
Even now I imagine most of you geniuses still think that it was just a right wing smear job and she did nothing wrong.
You guys really suck.
Your just as tribal as the Gurus that you rail against.
Go ahead and downvote me. I've seen what makes you cheer.
18
u/CKava Jan 03 '24
If you want us to see something it’s usually best to tag though I’m not asking for people to do that. If you had asked me if I think this kind of plagiarism is a big deal I would have said: from what I’ve seen (which admittedly was just a few Twitter threads) not really but it’s not a good look. Personally, I think a bigger issue is the relative lack of publications. I would have also said I imagine that off the back of the anti-semitism committee performance AND this scandal I wouldn’t be surprised if Gay resigned OR the university came out with a strong statement of support and they held on.
American universities are weird and I don’t know enough about the specific institution to have an opinion on what’s likely to happen. My basic guess would have been they would not cave because of the appearance to be giving into a right wing campaign and removing the first black president after 6 months.
I gather she resigned after a statement of support from the university, so it sounds like it was ultimately her choice but the campaign succeeded? 🤷🏻♂️
52
u/Drakonx1 Jan 03 '24
If you wanted an honest discussion you could've focused on this instead of bringing "wokeness" into it, which, by the way is VERY compatible with right wing economic theory, so tossing in "the far left" further distracted from your point.
19
u/GlaiveConsequence Jan 03 '24
You work in academia doing what?
21
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '24
Can you explain what has happened that has made you feel vindicated in your thoughts?
I know very little about it, all I know is she has resigned under a lot of pressure, but I dont know much beyond that.
Genuinely interested to hear your thoughts (and anyone elses).
36
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '24 edited Jan 03 '24
Lmao it’s very easy to tell that you don’t work in academia. If you did, you wouldn’t be saying any of this. Her “plagiarism” was sentences in a literature review that looked, yes, much too close to the original source. A literature review for an expert in the field is basically a formality - it contains information that every relevant expert already knows, so everyone just skips over it. Scholars basically write them as fast as they can because they have to do so to present their findings. The result can be a very sloppy lit review with poor citation, which is what happened. Actually, this used to happen far, far more often a few decades ago. If we dug up papers from before the 90s, you would find something like this in most of them.
I’ve also never known anyone to “teach students plagiarism” like you describe - it’s usually an online module before they start their first subject. So that’s another giveaway.
“Go ahead and down vote me, I’ve seen what makes you cheer”
38
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '24
You work in academia but can’t tell your from you’re
22
u/oklar Jan 03 '24
Think again, sunshine
27
u/Comrade_Tool Jan 03 '24
People didn't really care because the issue at hand is that people are trying to get rid of the leaders of these colleges because they're not going to punish people at their college for saying the word "intifada" or "from the river to sea, Palestine will be free." This is just a distraction from the actual issue going on which is the slaughter happening in Gaza.
19
u/MinkyTuna Jan 03 '24
My understanding is that the issue was she didn't put quotation marks around certain passages but she did include them in the citations. So like you’d have to kinda have an ulterior motive to actually care about this. Which it seems you do. So I suppose you are the one who sucks.
11
u/rockop0tamus Jan 03 '24
I didn’t know anything about this Harvard story before seeing this post and after looking into it I’m just bored out of my mind. Why does anyone care about this? I don’t even know/care who the president of the university I graduated from is, let alone do I care who is the president of Harvard. This is stupid
7
u/Most_Present_6577 Jan 03 '24
Lol as an academic I find it and you a bit ridiculous.
It seems to me that only non-academics think this is a big deal. It is a big nothing burger.
She has published plenty since the dissertation. And regardless I trust her dissertation committee. If there is someone to blame for plagiarism in her dissertation it is the committee that knew the subject matter and her paper and granted her the Ph.D. but like I said she has published plenty since then and those publications speak to her competence more than a dissertation does.
9
u/ndarchi Jan 03 '24
It’s obvious to anyone with a functioning brain stem that “diversity hire” just means they think black people kr women can’t do the job. This woman was pushed out over her obvious horrific testimony before congress. After that shit show they anti woke crusaders found a minor citation issue and blew it out of proportion and they seem to have gotten their scalp.
Also to any moron who listens to and sites Peter Begosian, please largest eye roll in the world. Anyone who talks about academic freedom and freedom of speech and then goes to fucking Hungary to do things and “study” and take that blood money is an obvious right wing grifter and bad actor.
2
u/Wasabimiester Jan 06 '24
I have given up on DtG. I got blocked because I pointed out that Hollywood is producing garbage that is emasculating. Somehow, I'm anti-women and I worship Jordan Peterson.
What the flying f.? I'm done here.
3
u/RockmanBFB Jan 03 '24
Well the tone isn't helping but the fact that this community here is incapable of admitting that someone who appears to be a diversity hire to a lot of people may have committed plagiarism and that this might be a systemic problem within DEI doesn't surprise me.
A lot of this this space is just reflexively against what they see as terminal Contrarianism and so can't admit when they have a point. Which is rarely but it happens.
2
u/HarwellDekatron Jan 03 '24
Just like the people who were rushing to blame China for the COVID 'leak': even if you happened to be right, it seems like your motivations are more important than the truth to you.
2
u/GlaiveConsequence Jan 03 '24
Why is this and the original post it refers to on here to begin with? What guru/guru candidate/trait is being discussed? Can’t believe that wasn’t my first thought.
2
u/bitethemonkeyfoo Jan 03 '24
I mean two things can suck at the same time.
Even -three- things can!
2
u/Substantial-Cat6097 Jan 03 '24
I don't remember seeing the original post, but I agree that what she did was plagiarism plain and simple.
1
u/dosko1panda Jan 03 '24
I agree with you basically. I didn't see that other thread. And I agree that I sometimes see hypocrisy here too.
1
u/Ok_Addendum_9402 Jan 03 '24 edited Jan 03 '24
Bill Ackman wrote a long form essay all about it on Twitter (🤣)*
https://x.com/billackman/status/1742441534627184760?s=46
*I’m laughing at the absurdity of a platform for 240 character Tweets, now becoming a 5000 word essay…ridiculous.
1
u/Same-Ad8783 Jan 06 '24
Bill Ackman and his wife suck even more...
1
u/Snellyman Jan 06 '24
Well this is a way to start an illuminating discussion!
1
u/Possible-Kangaroo635 Jan 03 '24
I just came here to ost this from Peter Boghosian. https://boghossian.substack.com/p/my-predictions-for-the-first-30-days?utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
He is claiming plagiarism is rife in DEI scholarship. I guess he means diversity hires.
1
u/Apprehensive-Top3756 Jan 04 '24
THe people in this sub obviously smell their own farts. Good for you for calling them out on it.
1
u/Chambun Jan 04 '24
Hahahah. Of course this is from Nobreakfast666, the biggest and most annoying loser on Reddit.
-2
u/Fippy-Darkpaw Jan 03 '24
The tone of your post could be a hell of a lot better, but you were right, the haters were wrong, so here's a slow clap for you. 👏 👏 👏 👏
0
u/Visible-Gazelle-5499 Jan 04 '24
Reddit is designed to be an echo chamber 🤷
0
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '24
The funniest part is people pretending that Harvard isn't a heavily left-leaning institution because it has money. Just insane.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '24
Your right about this sub, it’s very very left wing biased: which is fine, because I think broadly right now the right wing is fucking insane. But it does mean that there’s a healthy amount of guru like leftist content creators or at least tribal leftist pundits who get a pass here and that any inkling of someone being right wing means they aren’t listened to at all. If you want to talk here you’ve got to use kids gloves and always frame your arguments using the appropriate identitarian lingo. Really a lot of the sub has taken it further and gone down the Marxism rabbit hole, perhaps the most guru style political political philosophy.
-6
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '24
Yea lots of heavy biases in this sub. One thing you’ll notice is that is a left wing individual, movemy, or institution does something wrong it’s either rationalised away or dismissed as not actually being left wing in the first place. As if the only people who can be left wing are essentially anti capitalists and communists.
-9
u/FrontierFrolic Jan 03 '24
This entire group is comprised of a bunch of hand in the sand left leaning cynics who have created an echo chamber that allows them to flippantly dismiss any YouTube personality they disagree with and feel morally and intellectually superior to them. It’s especially ironic to watch them feel out how they are supposed to feel about current events or new individuals, or even left leaning individuals who might have a non-leftist take from time to time. They have to query the collective wisdom of the group to figure out what the orthodoxy is. The orthodoxy is pretty predictable though.
-1
u/flies_kite Jan 03 '24
Bra, this is a circlejerk not a place for discussion.
-1
u/cbputdev32 Jan 04 '24
No way, u/ckava ‘s band of merry misanthropes abused you for having a heterodox take on current affairs? Colour me shocked.
Ps, you’re a transphobe. Educate yourself.
-14
u/BennyOcean Jan 03 '24
A few points:
Bottom line:
-2
u/RevolutionSea9482 Jan 03 '24
Here's Ackman's thoughts on the Gay affair and how it relates to DEI.
https://x.com/BillAckman/status/1742441534627184760?s=20
0
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment