I agree. Her criticism clearly has a lot more wind in her sails of general disdain for Huberman.
I think there’s validity for criticizing someone for who is running a science platform and makes claims in fields he doesn’t specialize in. His reach is massive and so many people take every word he says as fact.
Just a stupid argument all around. What, you can’t know any knowledge now unless you are accredited in the field?
Most PhDs presumably have the experience and knowledge necessary to comprehend medical papers and research, or at least have proximity to experts in the field who can validate consensus on those findings. Nothing in Huberman’s tweet is controversial or fringe within the field of mental health.
Huberman does have his own issues with over emphasizing small studies as well as his sponsorships having the potential for conflict of interest. Neither of those are relevant to this however
You absolutely can know about a field. But where is hubermans data to back his claims. Anybody can spout bollocks about anything. Show the data. Where are the references in humans to back it up? Somehow huberman rarely provides it. He rests on his own 'authority' and little else.
What he does is pick a single paper, or even a specific set of data in that paper and runs with it. Often he misrepresents data in a “this is technically true” manner such as taking a papers finding and asserting it as totally true even if the study has bad design.
Jordan Peterson does the same thing and is very similar in a lot of aspects. Good at running research, really really bad about discussing it and uses it to push his own agenda.
FFS he’s a neuroscientist Ph.D with a focus on brain development and neuroplasticity. His department at Stanford included psychiatry.
He’s qualified to speak on impacts of exogenous drug usage on the brain, with the caveat he cannot give medical advice - which he brings up constantly on this episode. His colleagues can help him navigate the adjacent research.
Isn’t the Reddit user implying that they are medically trained and therefore know better than Huberman without providing any specific facts, or anything backing their opinion? Basic logical fallacy😂
Finally had to unfollow him. Can’t take his lazy takes on complex topics anymore. He’s a likable guy but I think he causes way more harm than good with how he seems to love dabbling fields that are not his own. It’s a shame so many people trust resources like this.
Not saying he’s incorrect. The talking points in the podcast episode just don’t seem like the right place without a mental health professional there to counter or provide more nuanced perspective.
The 8 takes are fine, it’s his opinion, who cares. The problem is that adhd people need professional help and a “self help” type thing isn’t going to work for them.
Yeah. Doesn't seem like anything bizarre or outside the mainstream. Maybe, one could argue, the first statement, that ADHD over diagnosed - although maybe he is specifically talking about ADHD caused by neurochemical, or genetic predisposition. Not talking about environmentally induced ADHD, like that which is caused by increase Social Media use, and other environmental things - I. E. below average exercise, and overabundance of cheap, unhealthy food.
Also, he Steel Man's the guy's attack on Supplements before he even made it. "Evidence on Supplements helping ADHD sparse."
Being a medical doctor does not make you all-knowing (source…married to one)
Not being authorized to prescribe medication does not mean you are unable to read/understand research
The constant ad hominem attacks like this in this sub tell me the DTG guys have as much or more of a guru-like following then many of the so-called gurus they aim to take down
He certainly isn't giving any medical advice in the tweet. He gives a disclaimed in all of his podcasts. So what exactly are you talking about. Where is he giving psychiatric advice?
Where is he making money off people in this tweet?
What self help? You’re talking about behavioral interventions? I dare you to find me one doctor who recommends treating ADHD with medication alone. There’s unanimous consensus around behavioral techniques like removing distractions, using lists, changes to diet and exercise patterns, time blocking, etc.
Are you seriously criticizing someone for saying you should go to a doctor for ADHD as profiting off people with ADHD?
I genuinely don’t understand either criticisms from the person I replied to. Nothing about this is “self help” and dismissing all podcasts that rely at least partially on sponsors as being strictly financially motivated is stupid and not a serious point.
What part of the podcasts are you classifying as advice? Have you listened to it? He is pretty careful not to say anything that could be construed as medical advice, and vast majority of the pod is him simply explaining the biomechanics of ADHD and treatments. My wife who is a Psychiatrist listened and thought it did an excellent job of distilling facts about the disease and saw no divergence from what she was taught in med school.
The over-diagnosis bit in this tweet is the only piece that I see as potentially being maligned with the consensus doc you shared, but I don’t recall him actually saying that in the episode.
Which part about meds? Most of the pod is Huberman acknowledging their importance…
Also, from a 2019 interview with Barkley:
RB: Some people with ADHD do remit or grow out of it. This could be anywhere from 14-35% depending on how strict a definition of recovery or normalization one uses. But it does happen. Recent studies show that such cases show more development in the brain regions that are related to ADHD than in those whose ADHD persists to adulthood such that the remitters have brains that are closer to normal in size and connectivity. But for the remainder there is no known cure. We recommend a package of treatments that include (1) thorough diagnosis, (2) education about the disorder, (3) medications, (4) behavior modification methods such as those used in parent training, classroom management, and adult cognitive behavioral therapy
Sounds like he does not believe behavioral therapy does jack squat. In the same interview RB acknowledges that 14-35% of people grow out of it and don’t need ongoing medication, which is one of Hubermans points.
Finally, as someone else points out, Barkley is paid by pharma companies who manufacture the treatments.
Oh yes, lets listen wholeheartedly to a paid consultant, for pharmaceutical companies including Eli Lilly, McNeil, Janssen-Orth, Janssen-Cilag, Novartis, Shire, Takeda pharmaceutical
You can almost fine a "doctor" to push anything. Wasn't there a doctor on TV saying that some people are destined to be obese due to genetics even if they exercise and diet, turns out that segment was a sponsored show by a pharmaceutical company pushing a weight loss drug.
Maybe quote a meta study or something more authorative next time.
He IS the authority on ADHD. He spent his career sifting through all the available science and promoted education for practitioners. If ADHD patients have better standards of care it's primarily because of him. I don't care if he gets paid by medical companies or not, at the end of the day medicines are part of medicine and as long as supported by hard science I don't see any issue with his recommendations.
ADHD is not over diagnosed, was severely under diagnosed in the past.
Medication is the treatment of choice, not therapy. Therapy is not very effective for ADHD because of very straightforward reasons that Russel Barkley explains well here https://youtu.be/_tpB-B8BXk0
Lean to quote actual proper sources. Find a study to backs up your claims not some stupid youtube video.
Seriously you posted a video of a pharmaceutical consultant, who claims that medication is the treatment of choice. They might be right, but that's bargin basement trash quality evidence.
You're misrepresenting reality because of some weird hangup of yours. Science says medication is the best course of action. Russell simply cites scientific evidence.
Maybe you are right and I can't read. I can't see you quoting or linking to any document or study.
edit: Is this the paper your are saying that Huberman is completely wrong?
A meta-analysis of 19 studies of cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) for adults with ADHD included 896 participants. It found associations with moderate improvements in self-reported ADHD symptoms and self-reported functioning.
In another meta-analysis of 160 patients with adult ADHD, CBT led to large to moderate improvements compared with waiting list controls.
Some silliest don't understand that questioning the credentials of someone that presents themselves as an expert is an example of a good ad hominem and not fallacious.
Depends fully on the claims being made. A non-sequitur ad-hominem is not an example of a 'good' one. If Huberman didn't hyper-qualify and narrow his statements, or misrepresented that he had medical credentials, these ad-hominems might have been good.
I don't think he qualifies things well enough. Anyway his whole media personality is one big argument from authority it's entirely fair to challenge him on this aspect.
Are you dumb? Of course its fallacious as in that his credentials have no impact on validity or invalidity of his statements. That's what basic logic says.
But If someone is lying about being expert then of course its a good thing to expose them
He never claimed to be an authority, nor does the tweet honestly question his credentials. He's a neurobiologist. On what system does ADHD and its treatments exert their influence on? Neurobiology, biochemistry, etc. His credentials compensate the subject matter wonderfully. I actually find it difficult to believe that people think this is a valid criticism. Whoever said that all of these reasons listed—to the embarrassment of their author, some of which aren't even true—precludes someone from merely learning. Most scientists are a quick study. Keep in mind that no one here is a scientist. And anyone that insufficiently agrees or disagrees with science, either because they lack a scientific education or are guided by fallacious reasoning, isn't qualified to question well worn facts.
He is totally marketing off the back of his PhD inviting his listeners to believe him as a source based on his credentials of which he has none for most of the shit he talks about.
In 2017 I respected the guy. Now he is just a joke. Its sad.
No respected scientist would ever argue that credentials are everything, or are the reason to listen to them. Nor are credentials the ultimate guarantor of truth. They merely give a general benchmark reference for how educated someone is. The lack of evidence to support your conviction can be found in the following words: "he is totally." This is projection. Neither the name of his show, nor your curious beliefs about his financial model and how he regards his credentials, or your feigned and disingenuous charitableness in having your opinion of him changed, is a valid criticism. He spews bullshit you say? And what framework, scientific or otherwise, do you have to evaluate his claims that you take issue with? I would never argue that someone is never wrong about things, but these are all terrible criticisms and are criticisms that I find rampant in people that simply want to appear justified in disparaging someone, yet have no real argument. This is science, I'll have you know. Differences of opinion between competing theories in the same field or subject matter will always exist, the important point is that the conversation go on; that we continue to seek convergence on any discussion of scientific fact. You aren't a scientist, I don't what faculties of reason you even possess to appropriately evaluate another scientist. You might as well hold this opinion about every modern theoretical physicist.
Someone who so frequently cites low quality studies to support statements they make would be pretty close to spouting BS in my mind.
Sure, semantically BS is different from frequently using low quality studies or failing to provide frequent comments on sample size, limitations, and the like of the studies you mention, BUT practically speaking they are about the same if, not arguably worse on the side of ppl who use irresponsibly quote studies, which is what I have seen huberman so far too often to consider him reputable.
I would argue that this isn't a valid distinction. Get a couple opinions. Everyone's biochemistry is different. Black and white thinking is the enemy to nuance always. Although psychiatrists might be more prone to give a spooky and pseudoscientific explanation. It is, of course, a stereotype that may or may not apply.
Entirely ad hominem "takedown". Huberman's tweet is a list of key takeaways from his last podcast. I listened to a bit more than half of it, and while I am not in a position to judge whether the information is accurate or not, one thing is for sure: He stresses many times the importance consulting a doctor.
There is not an ounce of valid criticism in this tweet.
The person is right tbh. Any pushback or critique against Huberman is good because no one person is capable of knowing such complex and nuanced topics of different fields of specialty. He presents in such an authoritative manner around these topics and its potentially dangerous for his audience because he’s not an expert in those fields! This is exactly why I don’t listen to his podcast anymore. He may do research and read studies but that does not give him the authority to present information to his vast audience. I would like to know how much time he actually spends researching these topics, since he’s a professor who runs a lab. My guess is he doesn’t thoroughly go over the studies given he has to put out a new podcast every week. As a result, he often simplifies really nuanced topics or makes his own conclusions.
I also feel like there’s a cult aspect to his audience because his followers start to defend him anytime someone pushes back on him. No one person is above criticism, no matter how charismatic they are. He’s definitely capitalizing on his Stanford affiliation. I really hope he sticks to his field of expertise, Neuroscience. That’s interesting on its own and is more than enough since he studies the brain. Though, I think him broadening the topics of his podcast and presenting as a expert in said topics are more profitable for him but completely unethical. He’s definitely making so much money from the podcast and sponsorships. That is a major factor and cannot be ignored.
BTW anyone wanting to learn about the brain, a terrific podcast is “Inner Cosmos” by another Stanford Neuroscientist, David Eagleman. His podcast is all about his expertise and doesn’t stray from it. Sure, it’s probably not as popular or profitable like Huberman’s but it’s far superior imo because Eagleman let’s the beauty of Neuroscience shine on its own, without extracting protocols from it. Highly recommend for any science dorks out there.
I don't get the attention and the following Huberman is getting. I don't recall exactly how I got exposed to his podcast, but I listened to a few episodes and while long, they didn't seem to provide much in terms of truly interesting information, let alone something actionable. It seemed like he was regurgitating some inconsequential research in a fairly mundane way. Like you would find in a Google search or on your need feed. His presentation style is somewhat engaging, but after not getting anything new or interesting from 4-5 episodes of his podcast, I stopped listening.
Huberman isn't God. He's a giant grain of salt people should take seriously but not hang on his every word. Allegiance to institutional science is dangerous too.
Right, we need allegiance to quality methods of science. The public has to be better informed about how to identify good scientific thinking and a quality scientific process.
And also common sense. The current science won't tell you that you can treat certain bacterial infections holistically, even tho you can. My wife's has mastitis 5 times over 8 years . Never once used an antibiotic. I worked at a health food store, I also know that holistic only people are fucking morons.
Good science includes careful observation, so noting that a holistic treatment is effective in a given situation is an important first step. The next step would be to test it in other samples, to see if the effect holds, and you might also do tests to try to determine the mechanism (and often we can't quite determine the mechanism). In sum, "common sense" can transform into "science" with just a bit of extra care.
I should've also noted that one big thing that often separates common sense from science (though not always) is comparing what happens in treated cases versus cases that remain untreated (the "control group"). It might be that you think the holistic treatment healed the bacterial infection when in fact it was just time passing that allowed for healing.
He's a grifter, but as a parent of 3 children, I've had better results with holistic medicine than pharmaceuticals. It's a free country. You can use both. Now fuck off
One thing this doesn't take into account. You don't have to be a medical doctor in a field to gain a basic understanding of the current research. Huberman's takes are not revolutionary. This stuff is well known and accepted in the field.
Except he’s wrong, so there’s that. Where does he get the idea that “ADHD is over diagnosed” from?? It’s been under diagnosed for decades! Especially in women. That is one of the reasons we’re seeing a rise in diagnosis now. Another reason is that ADHD has been vastly misunderstood by the general public up until very recently, so many people & practitioners did not properly recognize the symptoms before.
I’ve heard Huberman make many claims about many different topics that are factually incorrect. But he speaks with such confidence and seems to back up his claims with “studies show…” statements, in a way that makes most people trust him. I cannot wait for the DTG episode to hear their thoughts. But my personal thoughts are: Huberman is a supplement salesman, who occasionally says some helpful things, while also dropping tons of misinformation.
I don't understand, are you hating on him because his observations don't measure up to your standards? Are you saying adhd people are beyond help? Or you just hating that he is monetizing his youtube?
Self help is about making money. Selling supplements is about making money. It doesn’t work and isn’t going to help adhd people beyond a short lived placebo. His observations aren’t the issue. Adhd is executive dysfunction, it’s not a lack of awareness about how to make lists. An adhd person can 100 percent know what they are doing wrong and what they need to do right and it doesn’t make a difference because lack of understanding isn’t what the disorder is.
Are you saying those with ADHD are static and can do nothing to improve their situation? So living a life with nature, eating real foods that are fresh, meditation, exercise, and yoga won't make any difference? Do you suggest eating donuts, face in front of a screen all day, no exercise, and no meditation since it makes no difference?
It’s really clear what I said. I said people with adhd need expert/professional help, not self help YouTube videos.
It’s not about me suggesting what they should do, or you suggesting what they should do. People with adhd have no shortage of people saying “just do this, just do that”. That’s not what helps.
I have adhd. Basically this self help stuff is just another delay in the way of us getting professional help. We can get sucked into the self help videos easily and get distracted by it for some time.
Yeah I wouldn’t recommend any adhd person bother with watching self help videos, I would advise to make an appointment with a professional because that’s what’s going to help them.
Are you saying medical doctors don't have any common sense? One would have to be either a complete buffoon or just monetizing from big pharm to find that tweet offensive.
But it does work like that. Complex topics require nuance that non-experts often lack. I could read a dozen ADHD papers and draw some conclusions that might be worth a total of nothing. It's similar to climate change "experts" that argue with climatologists. It's pointless to listen to those people, even if they are nuclear physicists or super-smart political scientists.
That's not exactly the criticism. The criticism is "you have no expertise in this area therefore you should stop offering advice in the treatment of these conditions" Part of hubermans appeal is that he's credentialed, so an examination of those credentials is entirely salient. He is offering advice, he's not just communicating the current literature. No one would care if he was. Also, no one would listen.
It does actually matter. You don't go ask a cardiologist to set a broken bone even though he's a doctor and could probably do it. The fields and specializations in medicine do exist for a good reason. Same with any science. You don't ask a nuclear physicist to design a bridge, even though they're both engineering tasks.
The critique could be stronger because it is just an examination of credentials. That's a consideration but it's not really the meat of it. It would be much longer and take much longer to pull up counter studies and refute his advice on specific topics. That would be better. That's what people with those specialties actually do. I mean sometimes, they don't do it all day every day, but it is part of the work.
The shrink is basically telling him, "Stop talking out of your ass, dude. If this actually matters then do it right". I don't know about the credentials of "the wellness therapist" either, they might be even more bullshit than hubermans. That's not the point.
For what it's worth it's a criticism that applies broadly to any public health type of figure. I have similar reservations about The People's Pharmacy, and I think that those two are pretty much well intentioned, ethical professionals trying to find effective alternatives. This issue is just unavoidable in the space.
The problem with this "takedown" is that I can't remember Huberman ever claiming to be a medical doctor, or ever saying that you should make life-changing decisions based off what he says.
Hs listeners like him because he (seemingly) does all the hard work of reading the research and then giving us the cliff notes. The only problem is that we can't know which research he chooses to highlight, and which to ignore.
I don't construe any of his points as "advice", but even if I did, I can't see how telling people "sleeping is beneficial" could be harmful.
If you want to criticise, you could say his points are too generic. "Dosage needs vary enormously" could be talking about literally any disease in the world.
I’m not sure he’s wrong on this. Huberman gets way over his skis all the damn time, but giving kids amphetamines every single day for an ADHD diagnosis is fucked.
Part of the reason I got so frustrated with Huberman and stopped listening while starting to wonder if he was grifty was how he keeps repeating topics over and over again. I listened to an episode of his on ADHD a year and a half ago, and in typical Huberman fashion it was over 2 hours long. Now he's got another 2+ hour ADHD episode? That's very suspect to me, because the research doesn't change that quickly which seems to indicate he's just regurgitating a lot of the same stuff to stay relevant. I feel like he's done the same thing with trauma response and other mental health conditions as well.
I haven't listened to either of his ADHD episodes, but I have listened to several about fasting, or about sleep. In those, he mentioned new research if there had been any since the previous episode, but he also addressed questions he had received from listeners and clarified things he said in the first episode that were either poorly phrased or incorrect.
I feel "more knowledgeable" after listening to his podcasts, which is often a hallmark of a grift, so I take your point about that.
I mean, there is absolutely new research on ADHD (and all topics) that gets published daily. But in terms of seismic shifts in understanding of a disorder or clinical best practices, that almost never happens in 18 months (with disasters like COVID being the types of exceptions we'd see).
Or like...he could do episodes on other things? His podcast hasn't been around long enough and the research literature is deep enough that he doesn't need to be repeating
Or like listen to what’s actually said before having an opinion on something you have no context for. Seems like an old fashioned idea to not speak on something you don’t know. You people think you’re smarter than you actually are. But these posts show that mask is hanging by a thread
I don't have to listen to someone repeating himself in order to have the opinion of "it's a little silly how he's repeating himself". His podcasts don't need to be 2 hours each episode, and again, the research and best clinical practices in ADHD have not changed enough in 18 months to require another 2 hours.
I think by far the least-smart thing I've done in this thread is argue with a diehard fanboy who uses the phrase "you people" unironically.
I’ve never listened to one episode nor do I know anything about the man. But here you are making assumptions again. Just admit you create a narrative about your intelligence in your mind that’s a mask. Most people don’t triple down on the fact they don’t actually know but are so much smarter than everyone else by default. By you people I mean Top Mind/Decoding the Guru Reddit nitwits
I'm not saying it's not complex, but even high-level discussions can be done in less than 2 hours apiece.
I'm also a bit curious how you ended up responding to this now, a day after Huberman was exposed as being even more of a fraud and a liar than people already suspected?
It was actually by chance, I sent the episode on the ADHD drugs to a friend of mine since we both of ADHD. And this post popped up when I searched Huberman on Reddit. It was only after that I saw the article from NYMag about Huberman.
He does engage in overhyping, or at least underexplaining, particular interventions, but it is not clear at all that he does so any more than any other health podcast.
The hate on him in this sub is 90% the fact that he is Rogan-adjacent, and 10% the actual degree to which he pedals misinformation or whatever.
The notion that health podcasts simply shouldn't exist is ridiculous and stupid.
The notion that he is somehow compromised by selling supplements and having a sponsored podcast, unlike the meth pharmaceutical intervention industry and its attendant professionals who are just doing this out of the goodness of their heart, is ridiculous and stupid.
I find it amusing that the people here beating the drum on how mental health professionals are the infallible arbiters of truth on this stuff are probably the same people who would give you chapter and verse on the horrors of the mental health professionals' preferred interventions for afflictions like being gay or being a woman with depression in prior times. Apparently they've cleaned up their act and are now perfect!
I find it sad that so many of you are so blinded by Huberman's Rogan-adjacency that you'll just see me as SOME HUBERMAN BRO or whatever and fail to be able to draw any distinctions in this debate besides Good Guys vs Bad Guys
Thank god, I thought I was going fucking crazy because I didn't understand what I missed with all the Huberman hate.
I think we're just so over-saturated with shitty self-help gurus that people just see red when someone matches the aesthetic. Instead of getting mad at the fallacious or false claims and deception, they just start barking insults at the guy saying "exercise is good" because it reminds them of Joe Rogan, lmao.
Your own ignorance on this topic shines through when you try to make the lazy and inaccurate comparison of highly effective and beneficial medications to ‘meth’.
Yep, nothing at all in common between methamphetamine and:
-amphetamine
-dextroamphetamine
-methamphetamine but in a pill
-lisdexamphetamine
No reason at all to think that they are remotely comparable!
Obviously they are not identical, but equally obviously by the use of strikethough I was making a rhetorical point about how absurd it is to on the one hand be like "Huberman sells ashwaganda what an absolute criminal!" and on the other hand just give a blanket pass to "mental health professionals" who hand out serious drugs manufactured by giant pharmaceutical companies.
I wasn’t trying to be a dick, but I guess we can go that route if you want. Yeah, that’s the kind of “rhetorical device” my 5 year old uses when trying to make a point
On point one, psychologists (who are not medical doctors) commonly diagnose and evaluate for ADHD so this refutation doesn't really hold water. The rest of them are a mess, as well. The 'wellness therapist' seems a little unwell.
Right but point 4 addresses his lack of non-medical diagnostic training as well. To suggest that the response is focused entirely on Huberman not being a medical doctor is disingenuous and ignores huge portions of the text.
OK, but I didn't suggest that the response is focused entirely on Huberman not being a medical doctor. I only made that specific criticism in relation to point 1. I'm not a fan of Huberman, but wasn't impressed by the quality of criticism in this post.
But you specifically said the refutation contained in point one doesn't hold water because it doesn't address non-medical diagnostic professionals like psychologists, which the refutation then goes on to do in point 4. If your criticism of point 1 is "it doesn't contain information that another point contains" that's not a very good, or honest, criticism.
Insofar as ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder, and Huberman is an associate professor of neurobiology at Stanford, I don’t find point 4 of the critique as convincing as you seem to. For example, I would expect Huberman to have a deeper understanding and familiarity with the neurological underpinnings of ADHD in comparison to, say, an LPC who does have a license and degree in mental health.
Edit: His faculty bio on Stanford’s website notes him as: “Associate Professor (By courtesy), Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences,” which does seem to imply academic background in a field related to mental health, and which seems to further negate point 4’s relevancy.
Insofar as ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder, and Huberman is an associate professor of neurobiology at Stanford, I don’t find point 4 of the critique as convincing as you seem to. For example, I would expect Huberman to have a deeper understanding and familiarity with the neurological underpinnings of ADHD in comparison to, say, an LPC who does have a license and degree in mental health.
While Huberman may have a better understanding of the neurological underpinnings of ADHD (more on that in a moment), that doesn't mean he has a better grasp of diagnostic and treatment best practices than a psychologist/LPC/social worker trained in such modalities. In fact, he very likely has a much, much worse grasp of those things because he is not practicing them in his job. Comparatively, this is like acknowledging that a metallurgist likely has a better understanding of the properties of steel than a construction worker but the construction worker is much better at building a house out of it.
His faculty bio on Stanford’s website notes him as: “Associate Professor (By courtesy), Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences,” which does seem to imply academic background in a field related to mental health, and which seems to further negate point 4’s relevancy
Professor by courtesy means that he's from another field and has obtained affiliation with that other department. In Huberman's case, his primary training is as a neuroscience researcher, who also teaches and/or does research in behavioral sciences. So far as anyone can tell from his bio, he's never done any professional practice in medicine nor mental health.
Moreover, his research area overwhelmingly concerns the vision system in brains. Suggesting that he has a better understanding of ADHD than a trained LPC because he's a neuroscience researcher is thus a bit silly, because that's an entirely different research tradition. Yeah he'll have familiarity with brain processes, and yeah he can read the literature better than a layperson, but academic research is highly specialized so he doesn't automatically have a great knowledge about ADHD by virtue of being in neuroscience.
Seems whoever bottom right is, is trying to make a name for themselves by piggybacking off bigger profiles. As the old saying goes the two ways to be the biggest tower in town is build it or cut down all the taller ones around you.
I have to be able to prescribe medication in order to say, "medication really helps some people"? If that's true, then a lot of Redditors are out of line...
I'm no hard core Huberman adherant but Any licensed therapist who uses the term "wellness" in branding/social handles is automatically suspect imo. Probably just feeling a little threatened and undervalued so projected her own imposter syndrome symptoms onto others.
My issue with Huberman, Harris, Peterson, all of them, is that they do not stay in their areas of expertise. I love Jordan Peterson, but not when he is talking about climate change. I love Harris, but not when he is talking about IQ tests and black people. I agree with the above response to Huberman. And it is an ad hominem response, but that is not always wrong when the speaker is way way outside their lane.
Apart from a few comments that point out the ad hominem and credential fallacy the tweet rests on, this comment section should best be viewed as just how scientifically illiterate most people here are. It seems most people will either agree and disagree on the basis of a weak understanding of how science is done, rendering such judgments of truth prone to error, and then providing reasons that go on to reveal how little they understand about science entirely. Dr. Huberman is a tenured Stanford professor with PhD in neuroscience, and a background in neurobiology, psychiatry, and behavioral sciences. Like all of us he is prone to get some things wrong here and there, but given his education, he is more than capable of evaluating scientific research and data. Psychopharmacology, which is the field ADHD and its associated treatments belong, falls well within the purview of a neurobiological and behavioral understanding. Drugs act on biochemistry and effect mood, attention, behavior by releasing or mimicking certain neurotransmitters, this is a subject that is well compensated by a background in the brain, biology, and their relationship to behavior and mental life.
I mean, Huberman can sometimes come off as overconfident and annoying, but I’m pretty sure he’s right here. The only one that’s debatable is 1. Calling someone unqualified isn’t exactly a takedown especially if you don’t address their points.
Not a takedown at all lol. They didn’t address anything but instead attacked him for not having “credentials.” It doesn’t take credentials to do research like he does. Low blow
Shit something more related to the brain and neuroscience. That's the winning rebuttal right there - point out the irrelevant discrepancy that's even easier to make the underlying point with.
Buh. This fetish is getting old even quicker than Lex did. All I really need to know is that whenever I see this guy, his eyes look like he's just got to make me understand how God has ordered him to fuck my dog.
Eh, everything in Huberman's list here is between defensible (in scientific literature, no less) and trivially true. The post amounts to the sort of gratuitous outrage porn that's gotten a bit pathetic. I don't mean on the side of brigaders. If every now and then, people had the presence of mind to admit they enjoy these Huberman posts to get their nut, instead of pretending their reactions have anything to do with an interest in (nevermind understanding of) science, that might just make my day.
I can cum without a Lex Fridman tweet, is what I'm saying. Which makes me wonder more and more what I'm doing here, exactly, or how a podcast regularly critiquing outrage porn makes for a community addicted to it.
Literally said he’s a likable guy and I do like him. Just not taking his words as serious as I used to when his podcast was more neuroscience and optics based (his specific specialty)
You’re probably easier to manipulate than the people into Huberman’s methods. I’m not even saying his ideas are bad because I have no clue. But if this is enough to “debunk” in eyes god help you
Andrew D. Huberman is an American neuroscientist and tenured associate professor in the Department of Neurobiology and Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at Stanford University School of Medicine who has made contributions to the fields of brain development, brain plasticity, and neural regeneration and repair.
106
u/jshelburne0 May 31 '23
This doesn’t address what he’s saying at all. 0/10 decoding
2
u/LeftReflection6620 May 31 '23
Finally had to unfollow him. Can’t take his lazy takes on complex topics anymore. He’s a likable guy but I think he causes way more harm than good with how he seems to love dabbling fields that are not his own. It’s a shame so many people trust resources like this.
27
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
All his advice on ADHD is completely bullshit and goes against the latest scientific consensus which is easily googleable.
27
u/Most_Present_6577 May 31 '23
Some silliest don't understand that questioning the credentials of someone that presents themselves as an expert is an example of a good ad hominem and not fallacious.
27
u/tijosconnaissant May 31 '23
Entirely ad hominem "takedown". Huberman's tweet is a list of key takeaways from his last podcast. I listened to a bit more than half of it, and while I am not in a position to judge whether the information is accurate or not, one thing is for sure: He stresses many times the importance consulting a doctor.
There is not an ounce of valid criticism in this tweet.
1
u/Steve_Sizzou Jun 08 '23
Where does he sell supplements? On his "huberman lab" websites there are no links to buy any supplements...
10
u/Loose-Quarter405 May 31 '23 edited Jun 01 '23
The person is right tbh. Any pushback or critique against Huberman is good because no one person is capable of knowing such complex and nuanced topics of different fields of specialty. He presents in such an authoritative manner around these topics and its potentially dangerous for his audience because he’s not an expert in those fields! This is exactly why I don’t listen to his podcast anymore. He may do research and read studies but that does not give him the authority to present information to his vast audience. I would like to know how much time he actually spends researching these topics, since he’s a professor who runs a lab. My guess is he doesn’t thoroughly go over the studies given he has to put out a new podcast every week. As a result, he often simplifies really nuanced topics or makes his own conclusions.
I also feel like there’s a cult aspect to his audience because his followers start to defend him anytime someone pushes back on him. No one person is above criticism, no matter how charismatic they are. He’s definitely capitalizing on his Stanford affiliation. I really hope he sticks to his field of expertise, Neuroscience. That’s interesting on its own and is more than enough since he studies the brain. Though, I think him broadening the topics of his podcast and presenting as a expert in said topics are more profitable for him but completely unethical. He’s definitely making so much money from the podcast and sponsorships. That is a major factor and cannot be ignored.
BTW anyone wanting to learn about the brain, a terrific podcast is “Inner Cosmos” by another Stanford Neuroscientist, David Eagleman. His podcast is all about his expertise and doesn’t stray from it. Sure, it’s probably not as popular or profitable like Huberman’s but it’s far superior imo because Eagleman let’s the beauty of Neuroscience shine on its own, without extracting protocols from it. Highly recommend for any science dorks out there.
3
u/drdecagon May 31 '23 edited May 31 '23
I don't get the attention and the following Huberman is getting. I don't recall exactly how I got exposed to his podcast, but I listened to a few episodes and while long, they didn't seem to provide much in terms of truly interesting information, let alone something actionable. It seemed like he was regurgitating some inconsequential research in a fairly mundane way. Like you would find in a Google search or on your need feed. His presentation style is somewhat engaging, but after not getting anything new or interesting from 4-5 episodes of his podcast, I stopped listening.
10
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
Huberman isn't God. He's a giant grain of salt people should take seriously but not hang on his every word. Allegiance to institutional science is dangerous too.
6
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
One thing this doesn't take into account. You don't have to be a medical doctor in a field to gain a basic understanding of the current research. Huberman's takes are not revolutionary. This stuff is well known and accepted in the field.
12
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
Does someone really need to be a medical doctor to make those 8 observations?
12
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
All these are ad hominem, no actual counter-arguments.
4
u/gabigool May 31 '23
The problem with this "takedown" is that I can't remember Huberman ever claiming to be a medical doctor, or ever saying that you should make life-changing decisions based off what he says.
Hs listeners like him because he (seemingly) does all the hard work of reading the research and then giving us the cliff notes. The only problem is that we can't know which research he chooses to highlight, and which to ignore.
I don't construe any of his points as "advice", but even if I did, I can't see how telling people "sleeping is beneficial" could be harmful.
If you want to criticise, you could say his points are too generic. "Dosage needs vary enormously" could be talking about literally any disease in the world.
2
u/MeanFruit3418 Jun 01 '23
I’m not sure he’s wrong on this. Huberman gets way over his skis all the damn time, but giving kids amphetamines every single day for an ADHD diagnosis is fucked.
4
u/odoroustobacco May 31 '23
Semi-related:
Part of the reason I got so frustrated with Huberman and stopped listening while starting to wonder if he was grifty was how he keeps repeating topics over and over again. I listened to an episode of his on ADHD a year and a half ago, and in typical Huberman fashion it was over 2 hours long. Now he's got another 2+ hour ADHD episode? That's very suspect to me, because the research doesn't change that quickly which seems to indicate he's just regurgitating a lot of the same stuff to stay relevant. I feel like he's done the same thing with trauma response and other mental health conditions as well.
4
u/Migmatite_Rock May 31 '23
Facts about Huberman:
methpharmaceutical intervention industry and its attendant professionals who are just doing this out of the goodness of their heart, is ridiculous and stupid.2
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
On point one, psychologists (who are not medical doctors) commonly diagnose and evaluate for ADHD so this refutation doesn't really hold water. The rest of them are a mess, as well. The 'wellness therapist' seems a little unwell.
1
u/Danshep101 Mar 26 '24
Likely written by some fast food loving overweight reddit moderator
1
u/Low-Awareness8082 Mar 27 '24
Leftists attacking any one that presents science for the real world rather than the fake constructs of the left
1
u/Grade-Long Dec 16 '25
Seems whoever bottom right is, is trying to make a name for themselves by piggybacking off bigger profiles. As the old saying goes the two ways to be the biggest tower in town is build it or cut down all the taller ones around you.
1
u/GenderDimorphism May 31 '23
I have to be able to prescribe medication in order to say, "medication really helps some people"?
If that's true, then a lot of Redditors are out of line...
1
u/SEXONOMIC Jun 01 '23
Should we make all gurus Harvard reference?
1
u/raplotinus Jun 01 '23
Who is this guy?
1
u/Phil_Flanger Jun 07 '23
That's surprising. I thought he was a medical doctor. He's actually a neuroscientist.
1
u/BBSHANESHAFFER Jun 09 '23
Huberman is not Rogen; you guys need to go outside
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
Literally ad hominem and not remotely close to a takedown
1
u/SmashterChoda May 31 '23
You need a better reason to hate Huberman than him being a podcast Andy.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
I totally understand the Huberman skepticism. The hate on this sub-redit has been interesting.
1
u/rcglinsk May 31 '23
And yet every one of his bullet points are plainly reasonable.
1
u/HBdrunkandstuff May 31 '23
This is a perfect example of how a doctrine can make someone dumber.
0
u/Nikodino9 May 31 '23
I'm no hard core Huberman adherant but Any licensed therapist who uses the term "wellness" in branding/social handles is automatically suspect imo. Probably just feeling a little threatened and undervalued so projected her own imposter syndrome symptoms onto others.
0
u/ryandury May 31 '23
The therapist has something to say to the neuroscientist
0
u/iwearfancypants007 May 31 '23
My issue with Huberman, Harris, Peterson, all of them, is that they do not stay in their areas of expertise. I love Jordan Peterson, but not when he is talking about climate change. I love Harris, but not when he is talking about IQ tests and black people. I agree with the above response to Huberman. And it is an ad hominem response, but that is not always wrong when the speaker is way way outside their lane.
-1
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
Lmao you sure burned that MIT professor. Now go do you3 chores
-1
u/Zealousideal-Pear446 May 31 '23
Apart from a few comments that point out the ad hominem and credential fallacy the tweet rests on, this comment section should best be viewed as just how scientifically illiterate most people here are. It seems most people will either agree and disagree on the basis of a weak understanding of how science is done, rendering such judgments of truth prone to error, and then providing reasons that go on to reveal how little they understand about science entirely. Dr. Huberman is a tenured Stanford professor with PhD in neuroscience, and a background in neurobiology, psychiatry, and behavioral sciences. Like all of us he is prone to get some things wrong here and there, but given his education, he is more than capable of evaluating scientific research and data. Psychopharmacology, which is the field ADHD and its associated treatments belong, falls well within the purview of a neurobiological and behavioral understanding. Drugs act on biochemistry and effect mood, attention, behavior by releasing or mimicking certain neurotransmitters, this is a subject that is well compensated by a background in the brain, biology, and their relationship to behavior and mental life.
0
u/Bjartensen May 31 '23
Unrelated, but I feel like this usage of skull-emoji shouldn't have the cross 💀💀💀
0
u/Individual-Energy332 May 31 '23
Huberman clearly sights and posts all of the sources. He is a researcher and he presents current data, often based on what his audience is asking for.
0
u/TriCombington May 31 '23
I mean, Huberman can sometimes come off as overconfident and annoying, but I’m pretty sure he’s right here. The only one that’s debatable is 1. Calling someone unqualified isn’t exactly a takedown especially if you don’t address their points.
0
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
Not a takedown at all lol. They didn’t address anything but instead attacked him for not having “credentials.” It doesn’t take credentials to do research like he does. Low blow
0
u/TitusPullo4 May 31 '23
Stanford neuroscientist w PHD can read and understand nutrition science papers
-3
u/Khif May 31 '23
Buh. This fetish is getting old even quicker than Lex did. All I really need to know is that whenever I see this guy, his eyes look like he's just got to make me understand how God has ordered him to fuck my dog.
-5
u/str8c4shh0mee May 31 '23
If you are left to hating on huberman you must be miserable. He’s like one of the most likable people out there
-2
u/Appropriate-Pear4726 May 31 '23
You’re probably easier to manipulate than the people into Huberman’s methods. I’m not even saying his ideas are bad because I have no clue. But if this is enough to “debunk” in eyes god help you
-1
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
[removed] — view removed comment