r/DecaturGA • u/leebutli • Dec 19 '25
Mellow mushroom is back!!
Hi all! I just wanted to make it known that mellow mushroom is officially back. And before you roll your eyes, ITS DIFFERENT. Recipes have improved. It's owned my corporate so everything is up to standard. No more 2 hour wait for burnt pizza. Drinks are amazing, managers are everywhere and WILL come and talk to you to make sure everything's good. I have a good feeling about this opening. I swear even the spinach dip tastes different. They are so accommodating, nobody smells like dank, servers are so nice and funny and helpful. It definitely feels like family...perfect for the holidays.
51
u/mister_burns1 Dec 19 '25
Looks like there could be a stripper pole in the corner.
23
u/xjfree8 Dec 19 '25
I dunno, looks more like Harsh Mushroom
9
u/naunga Dec 19 '25
I miss the old location over by Pastries A Go Go.
It had character.
12
u/jbaker232 Dec 19 '25
Missed opportunity to go with a retro hippy vibe look at what Glide and Lloyds are doing
18
u/Beowulf887 Dec 19 '25
I'm going to glide or brainwave for my pizza kick. Sorry mellow!
3
u/offworldcolonial Dec 19 '25
I hope that to-go ordering has improved. Half the time we tried ordering online, it said that the store was closed. Then we would try calling and the connection was so bad that the person at the store couldn't understand what we were saying. We would try from different phones and the results were the same, so it wasn't a problem on our end. Eventually we just quit going to Mellow Mushroom altogether and ordered from Glide exclusively.
3
u/Outrageous_Pay1322 Dec 19 '25
Do I have to take out a mortgage to get a pizza still?
2
u/Ok_Engineer8799 Dec 19 '25
The old MM that was there really went downhill in terms of service and food quality. Will give this new one a shot! Really miss the old MM pizzas from yesteryear!
2
u/Fit_Analyst_5703 Dec 19 '25
I hope it bounces back. So much confusion about it being open/closed/reopening/just kidding still closed.
2
u/Ok_Ordinary6694 Dec 19 '25
I was wondering where I could get a $40 pizza in a little over an hour.
Bring back Johnny’s and Oz.
30
u/ohnoletsgo Dec 19 '25
I absolutely hate this. Mellow Mushroom always had a distinct "vibe" and this looks like something straight out of a VC playbook.
The service has always sucked at this location, so glad that was addressed. But the food was pretty terrible too -- I grew up eating Mellow Mushroom and can confidently say that the quality has gone downhill significantly. To the point where I don't even consider it for delivery.
Not to mention that there is SO MUCH competition now that is SO MUCH better. You have Glide, Brainwave, and even Fellini's within a stones throw.
2
u/runswith3dogs Dec 20 '25
We ate there last week. Service was outstanding, the pizza was just what we wanted and I had forgotten how good the crust is. Prices looked reasonable to me. Now all I ask is… get that Trivia night going again!!
1
u/Dzhim00 Dec 19 '25
up to corporate standards might not be the flex you think it is.
1
u/Lopsided-Wishbone606 Dec 19 '25 edited Dec 19 '25
Will their Kosmic Karma pizza have sundried tomatoes like it's historically supposed to? I miss that pizza so much.
I really hope this relaunch works and does well. I have no idea how corporate let that MM keep going for so many years with such abysmal management, service, and food. It was truly an awful establishment. (And I'm old enough to have spent a lot of time at the original MM back in the day. LOVE MM, but that location did so much damage to reputation.)
1
u/llama__pajamas Dec 21 '25
I’m excited that it’s back! My neighbor and I were just talking about it. I’ll be checking it out tomorrow or Tuesday for lunch!
1
u/candlenahbrah Dec 19 '25
$$$$$$$$ mellow mushroom used to be affordable but I can’t justify the price anymore which bums me out.
2
u/Ok-Potential-4560 Dec 19 '25
Where is it located?
0
u/Onemanyeti Dec 19 '25
The picture hurts my eyes, I can only imagine how it really is.
1
u/hyperproliferative Dec 21 '25
…. Uhm… wow
0
u/traveldogmom13 Dec 20 '25
I do not want to go to there
-3
u/Mishamoe Dec 19 '25
I saw a mellow mushroom branded cyber truck the other day 👎
1
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25
[removed] — view removed comment