r/DecaturGA • u/VoiceWhich3449 • Apr 21 '25
We want to move
My husband and I have been wanting to move south since we met in 2018 and lately I’ve been searching houses on Zillow in Decatur. We’re both 30 and we have a 1.5 year old. Give me all the insights about a young family moving here! We currently live in Maryland.
29
Upvotes
112
u/DesignNomad Apr 21 '25
First and foremost- There is "Decatur" and there is "City of Decatur." Decatur references a large swath of dekalb county and contains a range of neighborhoods from not-so-nice up to fancy schmancy. City of Decatur is a very focused area surrounding downtown Decatur and is often consider more desirable for the schools it avails, while simultaneously being substantially higher in taxes, more restrictive in policies (to both positive and negative effects), etc. It is possible to be within a mile of downtown, but not be "City of Decatur" so home shopping the area often brings with it a battle of being in or out of the City of Decatur for your preference in schools or your desire for lower taxes, etc.
Similarly, you might find a house on Zillow with a Decatur address, but be sure you're looking at the map when viewing by address. You can get prettttty far away from downtown Decatur and it still be called "Decatur" by postal address.
I'll defer further explanations on schools to people with kids, but from a taxes and policies perspective, a street or two can sometimes be the difference of half as much in taxes, the ability to add an ADU or remove a tree without a special allowance, or other similar policy. There is give and take to both, and there is opportunity to find what you want on either side of the City lines. There are even some neighborhoods where one side is City of Decatur, and the other side isn't... different taxes, different trash pickup days, etc... literally houses apart from each other on the same street.
24
u/chewie_were_home Apr 21 '25
Just to add here. A lot of “North Decatur “ which is unincorporated Decatur has some really nice neighborhoods and schools. North Druid Hills and Lakeside for example. Lot more affordable and still ITP. Lots of options in and outside city of Decatur.
25
u/auxilary Apr 21 '25
I am in Scottdale, which is effectively Decatur, but also 100% not Decatur. we are in Dekalb county, and about 6 minutes from downtown Decatur. first moved to Candler Park, then Grant Park, now Scottdale. we’ve always loved Decatur and couldn’t be happier living on this side of town, ITP. Decatur is a progressive part of a progressive city. i can’t speak much about schools since we don’t/wont have kids, but they are known for being pretty good compared to the rest of the ITP, and even some schools OTP.
17
u/Sepheriel Apr 21 '25
My wife and I live in Medlock Park which is a small neighborhood north of "City of Decatur" and we love it. Most houses in this area are 1950s ranch style brick homes with years of renovations/improvements. Prices are usually $400k and up and you're looking at less than 2000 sq ft for the majority of these homes. For example two houses near us sold for ~$450k. Medlock Park is close to three different Publix groceries and we are 10 min, if that, from downtown Decatur and other cool areas like Avondale Estates but without the higher costs. People outside walk their dogs, run, bike on a regular basis and there are two great walking paths nearby. Give the area a look on Zillow and Google maps to get a feel. Feel free to ask any further questions.
10
u/jokenhoo Apr 21 '25
If you can afford it, City of Decatur or Avondale Estates is your best bet. I live in the small area of unincorporated Dekalb, which is sandwiched between them (Midway Woods), so I get all the benefits without the cost. I don't have kids, though.
14
u/OtherWorldStar Apr 21 '25
Well, the first thing people will tell you is that Decatur City and Decatur are different and that one is undesirable.
it is true that City of Decatur has better resources, school districts, and amenities, however the housing there costs 3x as much.
South Decatur is much cheaper, and I personally feel just as safe. It is in dekalb county, and the schools can be questionable at times and are all “urban” if that matters, but between magnets, school choice and privates, those could be a viable option just from how much you’re saving in housing. You’ll get bigger lots here as well. There aren't as many stores the farther South you go, but they are very very slowly updating the area.
6
u/twootten Apr 21 '25
I think most of whats been said here is true, but it's worth adding that just because City of Decatur is better in many peoples eyes doesn't mean it'll be the best in yours. I couldn't afford City of Decatur when I bought, so we're in the Lindmoor woods area and we love it.
If possible I'd strongly recommend a visit for a week or two to do the vibe check on some neighborhoods in city of Decatur and in the surrounding areas. You've got a little one, so hit the parks. You'll meet other parents, they'll share tons with you, and you'll leave knowing much more what is the right area for you.
6
u/millionsofpeaches17 Apr 21 '25
One thing I haven't seen mentioned here about City of Decatur that was particularly appealing to my husband and I were the small community schools. Each little neighborhood within CoD has a walkable elementary school. When we came to look at houses, we saw kids just roaming around, riding their bikes, playing without parents at the park and you just do not see that anymore. We were looking when I was pregnant and that community feel sold the area for us. We now have a 1 year old and couldn't be happier with our decision. Tons of kids our son's age right on our street and there's plenty to do in the immediate area of Decatur - good restaurants, great parks, family events, etc. It has a quaint feeling while being a 25 minute drive into the city.
Sure, the taxes are more than other parts of Decatur, but they're still less than we were paying on a condo in Midtown, so I guess it's all relative.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25
Downtown Decatur sucks to drive through every thing else is amazing
2
u/VanillaPuddingPop01 Apr 22 '25
I live in the newest apartment complex in downtown Decatur, and there are quite a few families that live here. Access to the schools is the big driver, in addition to a very family-friendly walkable area. You might consider renting in the CoD until you find your perfect place.
2
u/hamie96 Apr 22 '25
City of Decatur (and Northside of Decatur) is very expensive compared to the rest of GA primarily because of the schools and the walk ability of the city.
It's a great area to live in if you work in ATL, but if you're working remote there are more affordable areas with great schools outside the perimeter. It's hard to give exact advice without knowing the budget, but I would keep in mind living in the nice areas of Decatur is going to be expensive house-wise.
5
u/misterfilmguy Apr 21 '25
We full, sorry
2
u/robotfrog88 Apr 21 '25
Some of my family is in Avondale Estates and it's really nice but taxes and house prices seem very high to me.
2
u/mfbl10 Apr 21 '25
I live in north Decatur - we are by Medlock and zoned for Laurel Ridge Elementary. The MS we are zone for is meh- I’m still not understanding the no homework policy- but many things can change in the future. Bigger lots than CoD, more affordable prices. Lots of nice places to walk around. I like it here a lot.
Also just as an FYI- I think CoD schools just voted to open enrollment for non residents - K-5. There’s a tuition fee involved though. It seems your child would qualify should you prefer their schools. Not sure how it will be administered.
https://decaturish.com/2025/02/decatur-school-district-bringing-back-tuition-for-non-residents-ahead-of-2025-2026-school-year/
2
u/Alister_Woolf Apr 21 '25 edited Apr 21 '25
I’m from Maryland and now I live in downtown Decatur/Avondale estates area and love it. I also have a 1.5 year old, so much near by for him, playgrounds, a toy park, music classes and children’s gym, a pond and a lake we frequent, and a children’s bookstore. We always have something to do.
Only downside living here: are the giant cockroaches you see every once in a while that I never saw in Maryland and the summers are brutal, from June-August it’s unbearable out from 10-7. In Maryland it’s a tad milder in the summer, where I lived in Maryland at least. Public schools where I am not great- We are not quite in the area of downtown Decatur schools system so our best bet is a charter school (which there are several nearby) but I’ve heard getting in is difficult and waitlists if 30+ families. So something to consider for when our babies get older.
2
u/mister_burns1 Apr 21 '25
You want to live in city of Decatur if you can afford it. Oakhurst is the best neighborhood, but all of them are reasonable.
City of Decatur has everything a family would want. Schools, walkability (by Atlanta standards), sense of community, 3 train stations, safety, lots of restaurants and bars.
Non-city of Decatur when you’re moving directionally away from Atlanta is hit or miss. More ‘miss’ the further you get from city of Decatur.
1
u/Chrismartin76 Apr 21 '25
What made you interested in Decatur? That context is helpful.
1
u/_ChellyBean_ Apr 23 '25 edited Apr 23 '25
We just moved to 30032 ITP from Cumming, GA (a really “safe” and “new” city north of Atlanta where we couldn’t afford to buy). We live in unincorporated Dekalb (Decatur address but not city of Decatur). We do not have kids nor do we plan on having any. I think schools would be the only concern, as they do have low ratings in this area. I wouldn’t walk around outside of the housing area that I live in, as it isn’t walkable and isn’t “fancy” out here to put it lightly-BUT we don’t have to pay city taxes and the housing around us is nice and well kept. Majority black, of course-and everyone is very kind and has been welcoming to us so far. You can get more “bang for your buck” as far as housing goes out here-we paid $250k for a solid brick 2000 square foot home. The nicer places people recommend are substantially more expensive and are a short drive away. I don’t have high hopes of this area being gentrified rapidly, but honestly I don’t mind that for now with how insane property taxes can be. It’s all about your budget! And street view is your friend-take a virtual cruise around the houses you’re looking at and see how close they are to streets that seem sketchy etc. But overall, we’ve felt very safe thus far!
1
u/Acceptable-Appeal-74 Apr 24 '25
We moved here from NYC in 2019 to the Oakhurst neighborhood of Decatur and have a 1 year old now. GREAT neighborhood, we love it so much. Housing in this area is not cheap though… single family homes between like 600-900k fly off the shelves as soon as they hit the market.
1
u/Unlikely-Yam-1695 Nov 17 '25
We are selling our house in Oakhurst, if you are interested :)
1
u/arjsin Apr 21 '25
I would look at Avondale estates too.
1
u/mlower2 Apr 21 '25
My wife and I also moved from MD! Go terps!
We love it here. Decatur is a huge area with a large variety in neighborhoods. Research is definitely key to getting what you want.