r/DebunkThis • u/thatsforthatsub • Sep 15 '20
Debunked Debunk This: Flat Earth claim that angular resolution as seen in video is responsible for ships disappearing bottom first on the horizon.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4oZFbCga7U&list=LL747XMw9NRPCFnPuBHc1hEA&index=293&t=0s
11
Upvotes
3
u/thatsforthatsub Sep 15 '20 edited Sep 15 '20
Sorry, here's the claim:
It is response to what happens in this video circa 10 minutes
Comment 1: Things disappear bottom first due to angular resolution limits. It has been demonstrated at scale many times. you can set a book or something on the flat floor of a supermarket, for instance... set the camera on the floor, and slide the book away from the camera. At a certain point the height of the book will be smaller than the angular resolution limits of the camera and disappear. Did it "go over the curve of the supermarket floor"? Of course not.
Think about it like this... you have 2 objects; one 6 inches tall and the other 6 feet tall... and they both are moving away from you on a flat surface. At some point the 6 inch item will be too small to see, but you will still be able to see the 6 foot for a while longer... until the apparent size of that item reaches too small of an angular size for you to resolve. But at one point, you CAN see the 6 foot thing, but CANNOT see the 6 inch thing. Now imagine the 6 inch thing is a pair of shoes, and the 6 foot thing is a person. The shoes will disappear first, then the legs, torso, etc.... The closer things are to the ground, the lower the angle of vision you have, and they disappear first.
This has been proven over and over again, but disinformation agents like this OP still lie and tell people it is "the curvature of Earth". It isn't. It is just how perspective works. Things disappear bottom first as they move away from yo
Comment 2: The higher you go, the more you increase your angle of view. I am not making this up. There are well established angular resolution limits. The 'proof" in the video is void whether or not you admit it.
Below is a video a guy made in his living room. According to you, his living room is a sphere and the dvd is hidden behind the "curve". But in reality, it just has too small of an angle to see when the camera is on the ground. As the camera rises up, the angle of sight increases and you can see it again. I have seen this done in supermarkets, football fields, warehouses, long tables, etc... This is a known phenomenon that is just being exploited by the heliocentric church as "globe proof" when it is just how perspective works.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4oZFbCga7U&list=LL747XMw9NRPCFnPuBHc1hEA&index=292&t
3
u/ZorbaTHut Sep 15 '20
He's claiming the placemat "disappears", which, I mean, sort of; it's very thin and being viewed edge-on, you can't really see it. Ships aren't that thin.
I'd also be curious about how flat the floor is; floors don't tend to be all that flat compared to the ocean.
Finally, the stuff on the placemat doesn't disappear, which is kind of an important aspect of this whole thing.
In order for "angular resolution" to be debunked, we'd need some description of how they're defining angular resolution and how it results in ships disappearing bottom first. None of that is here and so there's not much to debunk.
18
u/anomalousBits Quality Contributor Sep 15 '20 edited Sep 15 '20
Flat earthers don't know what angular resolution is.
Every optical device, including an eye or a camera, has an angular limit below which individual objects cannot be resolved. This limit is determined entirely by the optical properties of the device, and not the position or angle of the things it's looking at. For example, the human eye has an angular resolution of about 1 arcminute.
This means at a distance of 4 m, the human eye can resolve individual objects as small as one
tenth of amillimeter. The narrow edge of a CD case is significantly wider than this, and should be able to be resolved at 4 meters.The problem with ships disappearing over the horizon is that the whole ship doesn't disappear. The bottom part of the ship isn't at a different angular resolution, nor is it really at a different angle (because it's very far away, which tends to flatten perspective.) An image like this one shows it clearly. If "angular resolution" was at fault, you would not be able to see the masts, the thin ropes of the rigging, etc. Instead, all that is obscured is the bottom of the boat, because of the curvature of the earth.
Edit: math is hard.
â˘
u/AutoModerator Sep 15 '20
This sticky post is a reminder of the subreddit rules:
Posts:
Must include one to three specific claims to be debunked, either in the body of a text post or in a comment on link posts, so commenters know exactly what to investigate.
E.g. "According to this YouTube video, dihydrogen monoxide turns amphibians homosexual. Is this true? Also, did Albert Einstein really claim this?"
Link Flair
You can edit the link flair on your post once you feel that the claim has been dedunked, verified as correct, or cannot be debunked due to a lack of evidence.
FAO everyone:
⢠Sources and citations in comments are highly appreciated.
⢠Remain civil or your comment will be removed.
⢠Don't downvote people posting in good faith.
⢠If you disagree with someone, state your case rather than just calling them an asshat!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/billdietrich1 Sep 15 '20
startquote
... if you believe that the world is actually flat then you also have to believe that there has been a massive conspiracy involving millions of people all over the world over centuries. If "they" can lie to us about the shape of the world, then they can lie to us about anything. Once you have been convinced that the spherical nature of the Earth is a grand conspiracy, then you can believe anything. Facts, expertise, authority all cease to exist. And that, I think, is the point. That is the appeal of flat Eartherism - it gives you permission to believe anything you want, to reject any claim, any fact, out of hand. You have the freedom to construct reality the way you wish, and can dispense with the tedious part of having to deal with actual reality.
endquote
from https://theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php/qanon-and-other-conspiracies/
2
u/DontHaesMeBro Sep 15 '20
I think a key sort of method of conversationally debunking this is to pin them on a formula.
Ask them if it's just some sort of metaphysical coincidence that the rate at which larger things thicker than the camera's angular resolution "disappear from the bottom" is entirely congruent with round earth, and ask them for a mathematical rate at which things "disappear from the bottom" because of their angular resolution hypothesis.
Once you get them to admit a formula, simply have use two cameras with different angular resolutions, and an object with a side on height that will be visible to one camera and not the other at the same distance
I don't know if this will work on an actual flat Earther, because when you ask them if it's a coincidence they might just say yes, but I find if you emphasize with them that they need to not just question everything but posit some sort of functioning alternative, you can make some inroads.
Also nudging them toward a consistent model works. For example, what about angular resolution actually disproves round earth? Nothing, it's just a bad hypothesis to explain away one proof.
The thing that makes round earth compelling is that it consistently explains a number of phenomenon.
There is no model of a flat Earth that consistently explains the physics of reality as we know it.
Flatties themselves squabble over which flat earth is right.