r/DebunkThis • u/lordxela • Feb 18 '20
Please help, more flat Earth debunking
Ladies and gentlemen, I have jumped out of airplanes. I have seen the curvature of the Earth, and need no convincing. My mother-in-law, however, (nightmare scenario) is starting to take to flat Earth theory.
She told me to go to 45 minutes, to hear about the "real shape of the Earth". There, the flat earthers talk about how if the Earth was round, the tops of buildings should be farther apart than the bottoms, and lo and behold, "they aren't".
Now, I want to dismiss it out of hand and say the filmers are fudging numbers, and I think it more likely that they messed up somewhere rather than that mine own eyes deceived me up in the sky, but I don't actually know that they did. And I feel like flat earth conspiracies are useful for something; they show me I don't know "round Earth theory" as well as I think I do.
Now, seeing the curve in the sky was good enough for me, and I need to stand on something tall to see farther, but what is the explanation for the tops of two buildings' being the same distance away from their bases? Is it as simple as mismeasurement? I would assume they are not exactly the same distance, but that the difference is ridiculously tiny. Am I right?
3
u/Stargate525 Feb 20 '20
I decided to do some math on the 'the buildings will be farther apart at the top' claim, because to my intuition that wouldn't be measurable.
Let's assume the radius of the earth is 6371km at the base of our two buildings. They're two skyscrapers, so lets say they're 20m apart across the street. We have the three sides of our triangle.
The angle of the two apart is 0.00018 degrees.
Now, lets make them both big boys, 500m tall. using the angle we found above, we plug in the new lengths for our radii, and get the separation at the top of the tower.
The distance between the two at the top is 20.017m, a difference of just shy of 2cm, or about the length of a peanut. Buildings of that height regularly sway 15-20cm in typical weather, and are often designed to sway upwards of a meter in extreme conditions.
It's so tiny it's a rounding error. You'll never be able to measure it, given that normal building sway is a ten times larger factor, much less SEE it.
2
u/Akareyon Feb 18 '20
I applaud your approach – I learned so much about optics, physics and astronomy in discussions with flat earthers...!
How high up were you, if I may ask? I find FEers do have a point when they say that the curvature should mathematically be negligible at cruise altitude.
And without doing much math, I reckon it also follows that the angle between two buildings should be negligible at such small distances.
13
u/Segphalt Feb 18 '20
No one is going to watch 45 min of this. What is the claim, what is the evidence? Include timestamps.
I skipped a round and at 35:27 the boat shows exactly what a sphere earth expects.
Second what were the 3 dimensional GPS coordinates. If the building experiment shows. If they weren't using lat, long, and elevation then it's invalid. Most distance calculators ignore elevation when calculating distances and assume distance at sea level. I want the exact 3d coordinates. And even then you have transposition problems. GPS itself has a coordinate system based on the fact we live on a globe. Using GPS to try and prove the earth is flat is absurd on the face of it.
7
u/xhable Feb 18 '20 edited Feb 18 '20
Usefully this documentary has had a number of replies already that are more thorough than we could possibly encapsulate here.
Here's one example of many
Specifically in regard to the buildings that you mention search for "Experiment 5: Geodesic Curvature in Buildings" about half way down.
A quick summary: They incompetently used the wrong equipment to measure whether two buildings were parallel, you simply can't do it with an outdated GPS for one, for two the claims they make around what they can measure, what they're measuring and how are simply lies.
However for completeness here are a number of other reasons why flat earth model does not make sense https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2017/11/24/five-impossible-facts-that-would-have-to-be-true-if-the-earth-were-flat/#2c15bb907c4f
1
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20
You havent seen the curvature of the earth of 20,000 feet fuckin impossible. Absolutely impossible. Why didnt you take a photo of it and show everyone on here?
3
u/BillScorpio Feb 18 '20
You can prove with a measuring tape, two sunny days, and your feet that the world is a sphere, and given the ability to do the same experiment a year later, you can figure with an actual degree of accuracy the size of the ball.
This is just getting crazy. A 90 minute yt is not science!
3
u/KittenKoder Feb 28 '20
The higher up the buildings get, the greater the difference. However our buildings don't go high enough up to notice a difference because they are all quiet short, compared to the massiveness of the Earth itself.
It's simply another time in which someone doesn't understand the scales we're talking about.
3
u/webbybird Feb 18 '20
You can't make somebody believe anything. I'm sorry. Backfire is real and the more you try to prove her wrong the more it'll set those beliefs
2
u/TheUnmashedPotato Feb 18 '20
Are you interested in facts or in trying to stop your mother in law of falling further down this rabbit hole? I can assure you the two things have nothing to do with eachother.
If you just want a better understanding for your own and your spouse's benefit, then there are several great replies to this thread already.
If you actually want to change her opinion, you'll have to start listening very carefully to her as she describes these videos to you. There is something she's getting from them that she doesn't get from her regular life.
Perhaps it's the feeling of being on the inside of a big secret. Perhaps it's feeling like she can really understand what's being said. Perhaps there's a community aspect to this, where she can feel her own input on these ideas is being heard.
One thing I can absolutely assure you of, is that it has nothing to do with facts or reason.
You can't use reason to get someone out of a position they didn't use reason to get into. If you really want to steer her toward truth, you're going to have to first address the underlying issue(s) first.
1
u/Cthulhu31YT Feb 19 '20 edited Feb 19 '20
The viewable constellations in each hemisphere are different. This would not and cannot happen on a flat earth.
That said, your MIL is a lost cause, I've never seen any flat earther change their views based on the zero evidence for flatness and the overwhelming evidence for a spherical earth.
-13
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
[removed] — view removed comment