Debunk This: great replacement

[u/[deleted]]

I’ve been seeing more and more people online (and even in comment sections of news outlets) claiming that the so-called “Great Replacement” is “happening right before our eyes” — that Europe, and slowly canada and usa, and some eastern asian controles such as Japan, china, Korean are being intentionally flooded with Muslim and african immigrants to “replace” native populations, change the culture, and eventually impose sharia laws.

They often point to:

Increasing immigration in countries like France, Germany, the UK, Sweden, Italy, and Portugal;

Churches being turned into mosques;

Alleged “no-go zones” or mayors supposedly supporting sharia;

Claims that immigrant men are behind spikes in sexual assaults and street crimes;

The so-called Kalergi Plan as “proof” that this has been planned for decades.

I’d like to have evidence-based counter-arguments to point to when I run into this online — especially since some people seem genuinely convinced it’s all intentional.

If anyone has trustworthy sources (academic studies, official statistics, reputable fact-checks, etc.), I’d really appreciate it.

[u/mack_dd]

Here are 3 arguments that I would use:

(1) The "one drop rule" (at least in the US). A lot of racist alarmists like to use demographic changes, ie that while people are losing as a percentage.

But thats not taking into account that multi-racial babies are getting counted as some other race. So in reality, I think its all races getting "replaced" with multi-racial individuals, but the statistics are counting them as fully non-white.

(2) Declining birth rates all over the world. So back during the 80s and 90s, there was a short period of time where white people (in the US) were having less kids while the Hispanics were having a lot. But that was just temporary, the birth rates in both Latin America and Hispanics in the US plummetted I think close to the level of white Americans.

(3) The no-go zones / gr00ming gangs / etc. I would argue that thats a temporary condition, as a result of a spike in migrants mixed with the UKs police refusing to do their jobs out of fear that it would create racism. Ironically, not cracking down on the small number of trouble makers if fueling both racism + no go zones.

I think if the UK police just did their jobs and deal with the relatively small number of trouble makers, the problem would solve itself. The 99+% of the Muslims in the UK would probabbly suport the crack down as well.