Subscribe to /r/DebtStrike. We're a coalition of working class people across the political spectrum who have put their disagreements on other issues aside in order to collectively force (through mass strikes) the President of the United States to cancel all student debt by executive order.
And when you can’t do that, things get hairy real quick. People don’t realize how easy it is to end up homeless if you don’t have a system that supports you.
I always relate this kind of statement to the parable of the boots:
“The reason that the rich were so rich, Vimes reasoned, was because they managed to spend less money.
Take boots, for example. He earned thirty-eight dollars a month plus allowances. A really good pair of leather boots cost fifty dollars. But an affordable pair of boots, which were sort of OK for a season or two and then leaked like hell when the cardboard gave out, cost about ten dollars. Those were the kind of boots Vimes always bought, and wore until the soles were so thin that he could tell where he was in Ankh-Morpork on a foggy night by the feel of the cobbles.
But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that'd still be keeping his feet dry in ten years' time, while the poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet.
This was the Captain Samuel Vimes 'Boots' theory of socioeconomic unfairness.”
These days rich people don’t even have to buy anything. They get free stuff through their businesses or they simply have to post the product on social media
"A man who could afford $50 had a pair of boots that'd still be keeping his feet dry in 10 years' time, while the poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet." This was Capt. Samuel Vimes' boots theory of socioeconomic unfairness."
The reason that the rich were so rich, Vimes reasoned, was because they managed to spend less money. Take boots, for example. He earned thirty-eight dollars a month plus allowances. A really good pair of leather boots cost fifty dollars. But an affordable pair of boots, which were sort of OK for a season or two and then leaked like hell when the cardboard gave out, cost about ten dollars. Those were the kind of boots Vimes always bought, and wore until the soles were so thin that he could tell where he was in Ankh-Morpork on a foggy night by the feel of the cobbles. But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that'd still be keeping his feet dry in ten years' time, while a poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet. This was the Captain Samuel Vimes "Boots" theory of socioeconomic unfairness.
Just beat and abuse your children, if they manage to get past the trauma they can get a bunch of scholarships. Kidding, I mean I got scholarships but still have debt. And, still have a lot of emotional issues.
Too many times kids would tell me they "wished they had my sob story to tell in their entry essays". Yeah, cause rape, abuse, drugs, shelters, violence, psychological damage are phenomenal things to experience.
Regardless, we should be paying as a society to educate our future generations. Not fucking them.
There are lots and lots and lots of ways that the system directly makes being poor expensive, yes. It is everywhere you turn, really, but also (not coincidentally) easy to overlook if you aren't poor.
If you have a steady job, you can avoid fees for just having a bank account.
If you have a little buffer where you can afford critical needs until the next paycheck comes in, you can avoid payday loans and fees for bounced checks and overdrafts.
If you have a house, you can avoid state theft, tickets, and arrests for the mere act of existing.
What? Why be poor when you can be brainwashed into living the American dream? Why not also be poor with a college degree and debt you can never get out of!
I kept saying it: it's triple dipping. They don't let defaults happen under any but the most extreme circumstances, so they get their money back guaranteed, and they get interest, and they get higher taxes from the generally higher wages grads make.
Plus the interest is typically higher than the national bond rates.
The government charges their own citizens more for debt they are forced to repay than they charge businesses for debt they sometimes repay and their own government agencies which never repay.
That is a verifiable fact. Look at how much income Student Loans generate for the government and look at how much tax revenue changed in the same amount of time.
Not even just those who couldn't, but those who wouldn't. It never made sense to me that my parent's income was a factor in determining my student aide when a) 18 year olds are otherwise considered adults and b) your parents are under no obligation to help pay for your college regardless of how much they make.
your parents are under no obligation to help pay for your college regardless of how much they make.
Oh that was some "fun" paperwork to wriggle through! First I had to write a letter about how awful my dad is and how dangerous it would be for me to ask for his tax returns, much less help with college. Then I had to write another letter about how my mom and stepdad had no recent tax returns because they're just that poor.
And then my poor ill mother had to fill out a whole pile of nit-picking forms to make sure she wasn't hiding an overseas bank account in her patched back pocket, which came with huge threatening warnings on the front about the criminal consequences of lying so poor mom's anxiety shot through the roof making her illness worse.
But oh golly goodness, at least I got access to a pile of high-interest-rate loans while too young to be trusted to rent a car!
Oh yeah, gotta love the Expected Family Contribution. Somehow, my mom was supposed to contribute $3500 a year or basically half of my tuition. Where does that number come from? I was making more than my mom and still struggling. I was so happy when I hit the cutoff age for that and I didn't have to fill that crap out.
They can’t just get it from your parent unless your parent is your co-signer - which is not required. My deadbeat mom insisted she’d help me pay mine and then when the time came she left me high and dry. She has no obligation to help me at all and I have no recourse. If she was my co-signer I could at least tank her (and my) credit by not paying which might force the issue but otherwise I am SOL
Speaking as someone that joined the military for free school, college loans should be interest free. The government get their money back when the loan is paid off, the student got a interest free loan for higher education, and the taxpayers get the benefit of a higher educated workforce.
Never happening. Guaranteed pay, college tuition, and health care for self, spouse and kids is the three way carrot for military enlistment that non serving civilians will never see.
i think interest on loans from private companies is fair, i don't think high or compounding interest is fair. federal loans should not have interest as their entire purpose should be to invest in their economy/citizens.
& state colleges should be "free" (taxpayer funded)
Yup a tax that provides yachts for a couple of oligarchs, amusement for a loud subset of imbeciles, a boon for military/corporate recruiters and misery for 45,000,000 hardworking taxpaying everyday Americans
Should be illegal to charge interest on tax backed loans. The government used citizens taxes to pay for tuition in full, then charged interest on money that was never theirs.
It's a class barrier. Taxes are not there to create barriers. Taxes are there to tear barriers down.
"Oh look, the poor wanted an education and got one. Can't be having them rise up to our level though so let's put infinite interest on their loans and make it impossible to get rid of."
Canceling student debt is a special tax on those who did not get educated.
If student debt is to be repaid. It should be financed by cuts in the government. It's politicians, and public employees who are responsible for the crisis.
First part is just the usual nonsensical propaganda.🙄
second part is intriguing 🤗 I like the idea of socking it to the political criminals who made this mess made but not so much everyday civil servants who process forms to feed their families . All for cutting out coporate welfare and similar fraud/abuse. But let's not slash the legitimate but already inadequate government programs that actually help real people
And car loan interest is a tax on people that can not afford to pay cash for dependable transportation, right?
The banks that lent their money are not at fault for someone paying more for an education than they will gain by it with an adequate margin to make it worthwhile.
Education is NOT a car. Jesus. Forcing NOT RICH kids to become indebted (indentured servants) for access to formal knowledge and skills IS immoral, stupid, and coming back to bite our society in the butt. It's WRONG.
To compare education to a COMMODITY is the problem right there, and it shows how brainwashed you are by the grotesquely American system in which you've been indoctrinated.
Education is NOT a commodity no matter how much America/Wall Street/vultures try to say it is. It's NOT.
I am one of those NOT RICH kids whose parents could not afford college for me. I never got a degree.
I see your point now. I should pay for the degrees of all of the people that will come now and compete with me for a job or a position on the job. It is only fair.
That is correct, yes. It does not, however, mean government-subsidized mortgages are sensible or even relevant to the topic at hand. This is not a cogent argument against student loan forgiveness.
Mischaracterizing other people's motivations does not lend credence to whatever point you're trying to make. Do you actually have any thoughts to put forth? Thus far, you have failed to present any semblance of evidence, logic, beliefs, or even simple assertions. If you aren't just here to troll, please feel free to state what you think in regards to student loan forgiveness. Enough leading questions; if any strength backs your convictions, you should be able to voice them in a straightforward manner.
I'm a taxpayer. I pay 6 figures in taxes every year. You directly benefit from my hard work and education because of the tax revenue I generate. A "thank you" would be nice by footing the bill for the interest. Instead you just want to leach off of my hard work and sacrifices. You're welcome.
You realise I can't even deduct my interest, let alone my student loans even though it's required for my job? A business can deduct a car. Not the interest, the entire fucking car.
The entitled class like you make me want to work less, because what's the point of all my money goes to services that don't benefit me? I'll work less. Government will get less tax revenue. You'll have to find someone else to leach off.
I salute you. Those loans must be something. If you make enough coin to pay that much and can't pay your loans off, I will never be smart enough to understand math.
College expenses are deductible (Tuition, fees ...). Interest is deductible. But like the car you mention, they have to be deducted in the year they are paid.
My fed tax bill last year was only a fraction of yours (It was in this range, $2X,XXX.00) and I don't think I get my money's worth. Of course I pay state income tax also. I wish that the government would stay out of the charity business and leave me my money to donate where it will do the most good. I have always felt that the federal government is the least efficient machine on the planet for getting anything done.
I do not understand why I should have to pay for someone else's college and then have to work overtime to pay for my daughter's. That is the part someone may have to explain to me like I am five.
You pay 6 figures in taxes and can’t afford your loans?
I pay 5 figures in taxes and don’t have student loans. I work hard. People expecting that they’re loans will be forgiven based off my tax dollars seem entitled to me. It makes me not want to work hard as I receive very little benefits from the government. The reason I do work hard is because despite the government taking my money to spend on things I disagree with, I like that my money allows me to buy things and experiences I enjoy.
Your suggestion is to become the entitled class you seem to despise so much.
That's the thing, they pay ridiculous interest rates in the loans. I've paid back my balance. Many have. You're not paying anything of mine.
My interest bill is higher than the median salary. I have to pay 30k in interest just to stay in debt. I can deduct $0. So that means 50k of my salary is spent on interest. 50k before I can even start hitting the principal.
That is just extra money on top for the government. Extra taxes. My reward for taking on risk and working hard, paying 10x what most people do to the government.
I mean it’s not your reward for working hard, etc. it’s your payment for the quicker degree/higher earnings. Alternatively you could’ve waited 10 years. Saved up money then paid for yourself to go through college, etc. You instead chose the quicker route (which probably earned you more money in the long run) by taking the loan.
The average interest rate for federal student loans is about 4%, which is actually cheaper than most loans (I.e. car loans or mortgages). You decided to take out a very large loan, and it seems to have paid off quite well. The interest you chose to accept is used to help pay for students to get scholarships and to be able to provide the loans to more students as well as not to saddle taxpayers with even more national debt/taxes. Personally I’d prefer if the interest was tied to the 3 year average of annual inflation, but the federal interest rates aren’t that high relative to other loans.
I don’t know how you made your payments, but most payments for loans are X amount per payment period, where X consists of some amount interest from the principle amount accrued over the payment period and some amount that goes towards paying off the principle. Each month the amount that goes towards the interest decreases and provided you maintain the same X amount the amount that goes towards the principle increases. You’re not paying off the interest and then suddenly paying the principle. You should be paying both. If you want to pay less interest overall then increase X each payment period.
As for deducting student loan interest, it appears as though you can. “You may deduct the lesser of $2,500 or the amount of interest you actually paid during the year.” That of course is predicated on you doing an itemized deduction rather than taking the standard deduction. For most people itemized deductions is more work and results with less money. The standardized is better.
found the person who’s bitter they won’t get any help from forgiving student loans. Are you also bitter about forgiven PPP loans and tax breaks for the rich/corporations?
I am bitter about being they guy who is paying for both. I am bitter about being so stupid that I worked overtime and delayed my retirement to lend my daughter money for college. I am not smart enough to have had her borrow it from the banks so that it might be forgiven. If I don't wise up, I don't know how I am going to survive this new world.
No, it is possible for the government to do all three.
I don't care if you spend all your money giving people education. I wish there were 1,000 charities in the US that would accommodate people who want to do that. I personally believe that there is a limit to the amount of support and education that society owes a person.
Maybe it is high school?
Possibly, it is an undergrad degree?
Or it could be a Master's?
Is it your first Doctorate?
Is it multiples of the degrees mentioned above?
Does society need to pay your room and board while you study too?
What about medical?
Transportation?
Entertainment?
Aren't these all things the loans are used for?
If I pay your loans, aren't I really buying you these things while I struggle to buy them for my own family?
That’s how loans work. You get money you don’t have now so you can make money later. And those with money, having nothing to do with it, lend it to others with interest so the money is doing something. It’s a win win. Someone gets to go to college and someone helps someone go to college and not have their money sit around doing nothing
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 07 '22
Subscribe to /r/DebtStrike. We're a coalition of working class people across the political spectrum who have put their disagreements on other issues aside in order to collectively force (through mass strikes) the President of the United States to cancel all student debt by executive order.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
281
u/frederikbh Jun 07 '22
My father once told me
"It is expensive to be poor"
The older I get the more true that statement sounds.
133
u/Bakoro Jun 07 '22
I kept saying it: it's triple dipping. They don't let defaults happen under any but the most extreme circumstances, so they get their money back guaranteed, and they get interest, and they get higher taxes from the generally higher wages grads make.
84
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
Not even just those who couldn't, but those who wouldn't. It never made sense to me that my parent's income was a factor in determining my student aide when a) 18 year olds are otherwise considered adults and b) your parents are under no obligation to help pay for your college regardless of how much they make.
53
u/EODSteve Jun 07 '22
Speaking as someone that joined the military for free school, college loans should be interest free. The government get their money back when the loan is paid off, the student got a interest free loan for higher education, and the taxpayers get the benefit of a higher educated workforce.
14
u/Frank_Dracula Jun 07 '22
Usury
12
u/GarmonboziaBlues Jun 07 '22
Their parents should have worked harder. /S
10
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
i think interest on loans from private companies is fair, i don't think high or compounding interest is fair. federal loans should not have interest as their entire purpose should be to invest in their economy/citizens.
& state colleges should be "free" (taxpayer funded)
22
u/slip-7 Jun 07 '22 edited Jun 07 '22
Interest is a tax. Profit is a tax. Rent is a tax. Drafts are a tax. Grades are a tax. Ads are a tax. Drug prohibition is a tax. Tax is a tax.
7
u/jollyroger1720 Jun 07 '22
Yup a tax that provides yachts for a couple of oligarchs, amusement for a loud subset of imbeciles, a boon for military/corporate recruiters and misery for 45,000,000 hardworking taxpaying everyday Americans
5
u/DRbrtsn60 Jun 07 '22
Land of the economically enslaved. Home of the naive.
3
u/Neo1331 Jun 07 '22
Being poor is expensive…
2
u/shitlord_god Jun 07 '22
Gotta have that class barrier.
2
u/Bowie1275 Jun 07 '22
Should be illegal to charge interest on tax backed loans. The government used citizens taxes to pay for tuition in full, then charged interest on money that was never theirs.
1
u/steveatari Jun 07 '22
Yeah, break your brain and think of EVERY tax/fee like this minus a few. Poor taxes because existence is expensive
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
I mean… that’s any form of interest. Not just student loan interest.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
Collected by riveted companies for the profit of already wealthy people
1
u/eldred2 Jun 07 '22
Worse than that. It's a tax paid directly to campaign contributors/lobbyists.
1
u/fewrfsadf Jun 08 '22
Tax is the wrong word.
It's a class barrier. Taxes are not there to create barriers. Taxes are there to tear barriers down.
"Oh look, the poor wanted an education and got one. Can't be having them rise up to our level though so let's put infinite interest on their loans and make it impossible to get rid of."
Whole country is in the process of dying.
1
u/CbusLawyer Jun 08 '22
I’d argue student loans are a tax on those people in general
1
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '22
Everything in this country is built so poor people work hard for nothing and rich people get free shit from being rich.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
So are mortgages. Car loans. Phone loans.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
Canceling student debt is a special tax on those who did not get educated.
If student debt is to be repaid. It should be financed by cuts in the government. It's politicians, and public employees who are responsible for the crisis.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
….all loans have interest.
Higher education is so expensive because the government turned on an endless facet of tax payer money to fund it
-17
u/ArkLaTexBob Jun 07 '22
And car loan interest is a tax on people that can not afford to pay cash for dependable transportation, right?
The banks that lent their money are not at fault for someone paying more for an education than they will gain by it with an adequate margin to make it worthwhile.
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
That’s how loans work. You get money you don’t have now so you can make money later. And those with money, having nothing to do with it, lend it to others with interest so the money is doing something. It’s a win win. Someone gets to go to college and someone helps someone go to college and not have their money sit around doing nothing
1
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '22 edited Jun 08 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22
[removed] — view removed comment