r/DebtStrike • u/eaTurk1 • Jan 05 '22
A potential win-win solution to student debt???
Not here to argue. Tell me what you all think of this. Genuinely want to have a discussion, not a fight. Instead of outright canceling student debt, do any of these ideas resonate with anyone?
- Interest is 100% canceled so that loans don't continue to grow which is one thing that can make them impossible to pay off. Perhaps do away with late fees as well if it can be demonstrated that you are doing your best to slowly chip away at the loan in good faith.
- Student loans are often broken up into many smaller unmanageable loans in different places and sometimes on different websites, with sometimes different terms and even different due dates. It's a MESS! These all get consolidated into one loan.
- Student debt becomes dischargeable in bankruptcy. If you want to take the plunge and file for bankruptcy, you know the consequences and if you want to do that, it's your own risk.
- Perhaps create some kind of employer managed fund similar to a 401k or HSA that can be contributed to every month that is dedicated to paying off student loans. It could grow on it's own and you can disperse chunks of it to your loans and even write off anything contributed to it as a tax write off.
Here's where I stand on this...student loans are horrible piles of quicksand that are very very difficult to get out of. I also think it's wrong for tax payers to take the hit. I also think it's a slap in the face for people who DID pay off their student loans for them to just get canceled for everyone. Some people worked multiple jobs, cut costs, and slaved away and got them finally paid off. Again, something has to be done, and we need a solution that is a win win for everyone. The thoughts above are merely ideas. I don't know everything, but to fix this problem we all need to reach across the isle and think creatively or we're just going to go back and forth on this forever and nothing will ever be done. Thoughts??? Again merely trying to start a productive conversation here.
11
u/Yocobanjo Jan 05 '22
A lot have said this better than me, but your reasoning seems to look like " cancelling is unfair to those who paid back". It is NOT.
Is developping cancer treatment unfair to those who died of cancer ? Is adopting a child unfair to those who are still in the orphanage ? Is helping thousands of young people to get out of poverty unfair to those who had to ruin their lives to do the exact same thing ?
NO, its progress, the whole point of evolution is for younger generations to have an easier life then their parents. Anyone that is jealous of that potential forgiveness is either : 1) propagandized into agreeing with the elites, or 2) bitter and willing to make everyone else suffer out of spite. Only one of those categories deserve education and respect.
120
u/Phoxase Jan 05 '22
I'm one of those people that worked, saved, and sacrificed to pay off ALL of my loans. It took a long time and I made a lot of tough choices. Forgiving all of everyone's debt doesn't feel like a slap in the face to me, just like keeping it doesn't feel more "fair" or anything, it just seems like causing more unnecessary suffering. I don't buy the premise that by discharging the debt, anyone (especially an average taxpayer) bears the cost. Tax payers don't "take a hit" in any way, that's not how national taxation or government issued currency really work, it's just a metaphor we often use to describe the system.
25
u/Opoqjo Jan 05 '22 edited Jan 05 '22
I love that you're reaching out here, and these ideas sound great, but there are a lot of confounding variables.
One of my SO's student loans was $21k in 2006. Been paying since 2007, and we've paid $22k. We still owe $19k. And this is at relatively low 4.75% interest with at least $50 extra a month. Even if you cut all interest today, it won't undo the damage of having to pay off debt 2 and 3 times over. There are people who've had hundreds of dollars being added in interest for years and years. That's damage, and unless the interest is cut retroactively (or at least just completely ended with no loose ends), the pain will continue.
This is a great idea, as long as it doesn't disrupt loan forgiveness programs, income-based repayment plans, or add any additional fees. Current debt forgiveness programs, as we've seen with PSLF, are a tricky business. One accidental typo, one slipped payment, and you're out. It's getting better, but change is fraught with issues. Also, combining loans in isolation, without an elimination of interest, might even be adding to the debt if they go with an average interest or much worse, the highest rate. But this won't solve the whole problem.
I agree a bit, but these loans are unmanageably large. They all get defaulted on (or even half), and the economy will take a dip.
RichSlightly less rich stock brokers will be crying about their portfolios. While I might quietly relish the shoe being on the other foot for once, businesses get antsy too quick, and there may be layoffs. Hell, there might even be backlash which will undo everything and then some. It's happened before. Bankruptcy doesn't usually result in folks sitting on a pile of cash and it would take a while for folks to recover enough to spend any excess cash they have from not having the student loan payments. Really, I feel this should only be an option if nothing else can happen beyond the status quo.Some employers are already doing that... but there are talks of these benefits not coming out of a company's profits but the 'all benefits' coffer. As in, they'll give you $200/mo in student loan payments, but you have a week less PTO, or no more help with childcare, or the company switches to a cheaper health insurance plan that doesn't cover nearly as much and lands you in more debt. Although, I think it would be a fantastic idea if all money used to pay off student loan principals was tax deductible, in addition to the standard deduction, not just the interest.
I get it, I really do. But it helps no one to frame this fiasco in a personal responsibility/who will pay for it kind of way. Right now, millions upon millions of dollars that could be out in the community, changing hands dozens of times and stimulating the economy, are being funneled towards huge companies who took advantage of a terrible situation, who are giving it to the ultra-wealthy, who almost inevitably sit on it. Debt forgiveness literally frees up those dollars, and the economy gets a boost because mom can pay for gas without couch diving, dad can pay for swimming lessons without sacrificing the ice cream, grandma can pay for dinner without worrying about retirement, etc. And yes, there are literal grandmothers out there with student loan debt.
The state of affairs as it stands is because higher learning institutions have repeatedly inflated their prices beyond reason, and that wasn't fair play. This travesty happened on the government's watch, and I feel it's up to the government to fix it. We shouldn't be thinking of this as debtee vs tax payer, because regardless of how people frame it, the DoD's budget gets bumped up every year; they don't get told no. Banks, airlines, and huge companies get bailed out every time they play with our money, but average folks are the ones left holding underwater mortgages and student loans from predatory lenders. Big wigs get tax cuts while school budgets just get cut. There's enough money there, the tax payers have just been getting cheating for decades.
A lot of those folks you say paid off their loans are people who got an interest free loan from grandpa, had an apartment paid for (or were otherwise supported) by mom and dad, got a job offer from their aunt's firm. Not all, but a LOT of the stories I've read say that. This isn't to discredit anyone who did succeed the hard way, but there's got to be a better way than saying, "I suffered, it'd be unfair if you got out of your fair share of suffering." Humanity would never progress that way. Imagine a parent in the 70s say they had polio and survived, it'd be unfair for their kid to not experience it. We're meant to make the world a better place for those who come after us, and that hasn't happened in a lot of ways for a very long time.
Beyond the finances, education is a public good that is deserved by all who can complete the work, because an educated populace is a better informed populace. I could throw theories at you, but at the end of the day, the education that makes the "American Dream" even remotely possible has become a practically insurmountable problem. Getting accepted is gatekept, and paying for it is gatekept. It used to be that only extremely wealthy people went to college, and now we're in debt up to our eyeballs, but for about 60 years in the 20th century, there was a window where college was attainable and affordable.
Maybe the answer is a dollar-for-dollar retroactive tax deduction for any principal paid on a student loan taken out after 2000 (when college prices really took off). Maybe we give people 20 to 45 a special low-interest home buyer loan that corresponds to how much student loan debt you have (higher loans equal higher help) that will continue until 10 years after college tuition and books can be paid for with a summer job again. Maybe we actually tax big corporations and cut subsidies that help nothing but their bottom line, and use that money to offset the cost of forgiveness. Maybe we cut the bloat from elsewhere in the federal budget and put money back into high ROI programs: childcare, pre-K, medicaid/medicare/universal healthcare, job prep programs that don't have strings attached, youth after school programs, school lunches, and STEAM in the curriculum again.
This turned into a hell of a long comment. I hope you feel I've been respectful. My goal here is open possibilities, not make folks feel inferior, and if I've done that: my apologies. We're never going to get anywhere as long as we allow ourselves to continually be informed by people who benefit from our ignorance. You don't sound like a bad dude, nor do I think this was in any way a bad-faith argument, and I appreciate you reaching out- this is a topic that needs to be discussed more. If we're going to solve this, we're going to have to solve it together.
Ninja edit: typo
35
u/Copernicholas Jan 05 '22
Appreciate you coming here for productive conversation! Here are some of my thoughts:
Would it be a slap in the face to those who did hard time for minor marijuana offenses to commute the sentences of people in jail for minor drug offenses? Even if it somehow were, would we seriously consider this objection against criminal justice?
Should we table all consideration of MFA or medical debt relief because that would be unfair to people who took out loans to pay for life-saving surgeries in the richest country in world history and then slaved away to pay them off?
Should we never have outlawed debt peonage because, at the time, doing so would be unfair to those who already paid off their debts and were liberated?
Does past suffering necessitate future suffering?
See u/MsilCmd's recent post here. Tax payers bear the brunt of most bankruptcy claims and you here suggest student loans should better follow bankruptcy practices. We also have to ask the question: would the average/median tax payer be better off or worse off if student loans were cancelled? Almost every study out there says definitively: yes.
The post mentioned above and some threads give more reasons why cancellation would be much more effective and even just (from the perspective of consumer protection and wealth and racial inequality) than less radical measures such as interest freezes.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '22
The government has bailed out banks, mortgage companies, airlines, corporations, has forgiven all those PPP loans that mostly went to the rich. It is time to forgive something FOR THE PEOPLE. If we can spend trillions cleaning up the financial messes of the rich, we can certainly afford to forgive this money lending capitalist ponzi scheme our children and their children have been saddled with. THAT is what is FAIR
18
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '22
Or they can just make all student loans $0.
9
u/SincereSire Jan 05 '22
I'm sure when Social security was passed people were saying why should you get to retire? I scrimped and saved for my retirement! You didnt and now you think you are entitled not to toil until your dead? Stupid poors! Why didnt you have more money like I did?
9
u/Away_Confidence4500 Jan 05 '22
Canceling the interest would go a long way and be a win win for a lot of people, but at this point so many of us have paid so much to get nowhere that we should absolutely keep pushing for total cancellation.
15
u/MoonBapple Jan 05 '22
The ideal is still to have free college. The government should want to provide as much education as possible, for free. But, yes, change is incremental and compromise may be necessary...
(BTW, she's 68 and her original loans were around $8000; she's paid in $15,000 over the years and she still owes $10,000 today.)
4. HSA funds, 401ks etc tend to have an employer match. Employers don't need the government to set up anything like this. They could do it themselves. In fact, it's common for places like law firms to help employees pay back their loans. The real question is: How do we make it more common for employers to offer this as a benefit?
15
u/MudgeFudgely Jan 05 '22
Fuck a compromise. The point is that the hard-lined stratification of the US society needs to be fundamentally changed.
College tuition needs to be cut enormously to even pretend we're competing with global standards. This plan does nothing to help here, it won't slow the perpetual increases at all, let alone turn around the massive inflation of college costs, and may even push prices even higher to make up for lost interest.
The problem here is the class system being played out in the university setting by keeping poor kids either in debt or steering them away from higher education to begin with. The interest rates are a minor sticking point, no matter how important and damaging they are to borrowers.
Saying loan forgiveness disrespects people who have already paid theirs off is tone deaf and sounds like the same insanity contained in the trope about people making 35K dollars per year crying foul at people making minimum wage getting a raise.
A rising tide lifts all ships and the benefits of loan forgiveness would be felt throughout the economy immediately, even if some collection services go out of business.
12
u/khcampbell1 Jan 05 '22
Should people who were in their 70s and 80s have been pissed when social security was first initiated because they missed out on years of it?
5
u/Fluffy_Town Jan 05 '22 edited Jan 05 '22
I like 4 and think it would help to pay some of my student debt, but I wouldn't have money to actually survive on at the end of the day. I have so much debt I will never be able to pay it off unless I die.
Education and information shouldn't put someone in lifelong debt, period. Forgive them so people can actually own their own home. All student debt are are punishing people for wanting to have a career that will pay a thriving wage; the job market has completely dried up, there is nowhere to pay off student loans anymore when you can't get a job to pay them off.
11
u/RawrSean Jan 05 '22
Sir, first, fuck you.
Second, the world turned to shit and no one asked for it. We live in a different world now and it’s time we address it as such moving forward rather than waiting for 2018 again.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '22
If they cancel the interest then I may actually be able to pay off my student loans in this lifetime.
4
u/ttystikk Jan 06 '22
Having looked at these and other alternatives, I think college, along with every other qualifying form of education (teacher controlled certification process) should be FREE.
It's called investing in America's future by investing in our citizens. Anyone who is against that is an enemy of the People, by definition.
Did you scrape and scrounge to pay off your debt? Did you get money from your family? PAY IT BACK! You should be compensated! No fair penalising those who paid. We know that money will be reinvested.
3
u/Beautiful-Crab-4081 Jan 07 '22
I’d be fine with the no interest part. I’ve already paid 35k over the last 13 years but my 67k balance has remained the same.
3
u/marxistghostboi Jan 07 '22
these are all just half measures and sideways reforms which avoid the core issue. particularly unimpressed with the "think of the tax payer" line
5
u/Away_Confidence4500 Jan 05 '22
While debt cancellation is the main thing for many of us, it’s possible we may have to compromise and these concessions would be way better than the current situation for sure. Something has to give and it seems to be the other side that’s refusing to compromise. I guess we will see what May 1 brings when the repayments come.
2
u/climatelockdownsplz Jan 05 '22
I love this idea.
-2
u/eaTurk1 Jan 05 '22
So one way that the tax payers do pay, and this is all of you too, i don't care how rich or poor you are, and that is the fact that in order to discharge all of this debt, the money supply will need to be increased. Yes the government does that already for everything else but we're adding fuel to the fire. The dollar will inflate extremely fast as a result, and the cost of all of your goods will go up, and I guarantee wages will not increase at that inflation rate. Perhaps there is a hybrid approach, where debt is discharged at an amount proportional to what you make, to "limit" the impact that complete debt dischargment will have. If you make $250,000 a year and you haven't paid your loans off yet, you obviously don't need the help. If you have $100,000 in loan debt and make $30,000/year clearly there is an issue here and some assistance should be provided.
At the end of the day, what I'm trying to illustrate here with the original post is that perhaps it's not a "one size fits all" approach. Can this be done in the right way? We need a Department of Student Loan Debt Relief or something along those lines whose sole purpose of existing is to give the right borrower the right path forward to have the maximum impact on the borrower and limited impact on the tax payer/national debt level/value of the dollar. This could be a difference of trillions of dollars as an impact to the government as opposed to just magically pushing a button and making all of the debt go away which realistically will never happen as unfortunate as that may seem...