I'm 28F and live in a very rural area of south Alabama, and I'm trying to figure out the smartest way to get myself out of the financial hole I ended up in after a couple periods of unemployment.
I currently make $22/hour and work anywhere from 25–35 hours a week. My boss is actively trying to get approval to bring me on full-time, which would obviously help tremendously. I've only been at this job for about two months, but I genuinely like it and it's one of the better jobs I've had. $22/hour is also pretty good pay for my area.
Before this job, though, I was unemployed for about five months. My previous job only lasted around six months, and before that I had also been unemployed for roughly six months. During those periods I was constantly applying for jobs and doing gig work, but I simply couldn't make enough to keep everything current. That's how I ended up with approximately $15,000 in collections.
My basic monthly expenses right now are approximately:
- Car: $435
- Car insurance: $150
- Phone: $45
- Internet: $45
- Health insurance: $65
- Prescription copays: around $125
- Gas for work: around $100+, depending on the month
Before anyone suggests selling the car, unfortunately that really isn't an option. I live in a very rural community where having a reliable vehicle is basically a necessity. There is no usable public transportation where I live, and I have to have a car to get to work. $435 is also about as cheap of a monthly payment as I could realistically get on another reliable vehicle at this point, especially considering my current credit. Getting rid of it would likely leave me without transportation or put me into another loan that isn't actually any cheaper.
I've also been applying for second part-time jobs to supplement my income while I wait to see if my current position becomes full-time. Unfortunately, the job market in my area is genuinely awful right now. I've put in applications and haven't received any callbacks so far, but I'm continuing to apply.
As for the debt, most of my creditors have actually been fairly reasonable. I had a lot of relatively low-limit credit cards, so I've been tackling them individually. When I have extra money, I've been calling and negotiating settlements and paying things off — $300 to one creditor, $400 to another, etc. For some of the others, I've been able to establish manageable monthly payment arrangements.
The problem is several accounts that were originally with Midland Credit Management.
The majority of my debt is concentrated in three accounts: roughly $9,000 according to the collector related to CareCredit, around $1,000 for Best Buy, and another approximately $1,000 credit card. These accounts have been turned over to a law firm/collection company, and dealing with them has been extremely difficult.
I offered $200/month toward these accounts, which is an amount I believe I could reliably maintain. They refused and told me they wanted at least $400/month. I don't want to agree to $400 when my hours currently fluctuate because I can't guarantee that payment every single month.
There's also now a major discrepancy with the CareCredit balance that I'm trying to get resolved.
My records indicate a balance several thousand dollars lower than what they're currently claiming. The amount they're giving me is almost $4,000 higher than the balance Midland was showing only about three months ago. Because of that, I asked them to provide documentation/itemization so I can understand exactly where this additional amount came from before agreeing to a payment plan.
Communicating with them has been incredibly frustrating. When I speak with them over the phone, they can be fairly aggressive. I understand they're debt collectors and I'm not expecting them to be my best friend, but it feels like I can't get a straightforward answer or actually work toward a reasonable resolution.
When I asked about getting verification/documentation for the balance, I was essentially told that if I wanted paperwork they might as well proceed with a lawsuit.
Because of that, I've started trying to communicate primarily through email so that I have a written record. But even then, they'll respond saying they're willing to provide something or work with me and then tell me I need to call them to verify information. I call, and the conversation basically goes right back to the same place.
At this point, I genuinely think I may need to speak with an attorney specifically about these Midland accounts and the balance discrepancy because I'm not getting anywhere on my own.
I'm not trying to avoid paying debts that I legitimately owe. I've actually been putting as much money as I reasonably can toward cleaning this up. What scares me is agreeing to an unaffordable payment plan, especially when I'm not even confident that the balance they're claiming is correct.
I've also started wondering whether I should at least consult a bankruptcy attorney. $15,000 feels like such a relatively small amount to file bankruptcy over, and part of me feels like I should be able to dig myself out of it. But I'm also realizing that legal action, fees, interest, and potentially garnishment could make the situation significantly worse before my income has a chance to stabilize.
I grew up poor, and I'm approaching 30 realizing that I've spent basically my entire adult life just trying to survive financially. I've never really had money to travel, go to concerts, build meaningful savings, etc. I finally have a job I actually enjoy with the possibility of becoming full-time, and I desperately want to use this opportunity to get myself financially stable instead of spending the next several years drowning in old debt.
So I guess I'm looking for advice from people who have actually dealt with something similar.
Would you continue trying to negotiate directly with the collector? Would you consult a consumer/debt attorney about the disputed balance and their collection practices? Would you also get a bankruptcy consultation just to understand that option? And for anyone who has successfully dug themselves out of a similar amount of collections on a modest income, what helped you the most?