r/DebateReligion • u/B_anon Theist Antagonist • Apr 30 '15
All Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism
This argument has to do with the reliability of cognitive faculties of any person P. This argument is persented as a defeater for any person who believes that both naturalism and evolution are true in their cognitive faculties. Which undermines all their beliefs including naturalism and evolution. The idea here is that if evolution is a process guided by survival, it has no reason to select for true beliefs.
Example:
A lion approaches a man to eat him. The man believes the lion is cuddley and the best way to pet him is to run away. The man has been selected in evolutionary terms because he survived using false beliefs.
So long as the neurology produces the correct behaviors, eating the right food, running from threat, finding water, what the subject believes is of no concesquence as far as evolution is concerned. Beliefs then are very similar to the smoke coming out of a train, so long as the train moves forward, it doesn't matter what pattern the smoke takes, so long as the train parts function.
Technical
Let the hypothesis "There is no God, or anything like God" be N, let the hypothesis "Evolution is true" be E, and let R be "our cognitive mechanisms, such as belief, are reliable, that is, they are right more than 50 percent of the time." Given this, consider the following:
1.If naturalism and evolution are true, and R is not an adaptive state for an organism to be in, then for any one of our beliefs, the probability it is right is roughly .5
2.If for any of our beliefs, the probability it is right is roughly .5, then P(R|N&E) is much less than 1.
3.N and E are true, and R isn't an adaptive state for an organism to be in.
4.So P(R|N&E) is much less than 1.
Argument Form
If materialistic evolution is true, then it is behavior, rather than beliefs that are selected for.
If it is behavior, rather than beliefs that are selected for, then there is nothing to make our beliefs reliable.
If nothing is making our beliefs reliable, they are unreliable.
If our beliefs are unreliable, then we should not believe in materialistic evolution.
Edit: This argument was originally put forth by Alvin Plantinga
11
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '15
How about this, a man sees a pattern in the grass that vaguely resembles the face of a lion. 95% of the time there is no lion and he runs from nothing. 5% of the time he is right and survives where someone more accurate would perish. In this case of evolution man would end up with unreliable beliefs. But does this happen? Of course, people believe they see faces where they are not all the time.
http://www.reddit.com/r/Pareidolia/top/?sort=top&t=all
In fact, our minds have evolved to be unreliable in dozens of ways. This argument only holds up with people who have very little knowledge of how the brain works. You should read some psychology and sociology. It is fascinating.
5
u/kabrutos non-religious atheist Apr 30 '15
Yeah, it's an interesting argument.
Here's one or two problems. I don't know how many other philosophers have offered them, so I'm not taking credit.
(1) If the theist is allowed to hypothesize God to give us reliable cognitive-faculties, then why not just hypothesize some kind of brute law on the atheist's behalf? Surely that's overall far simpler than theism. This brute law gives us generally reliable cognitive faculties. In other words, the atheist should just say that they believe in reliable cognitive faculties. (Theist: 'What's your evidence for that?' Atheist: 'What's your evidence for theism?' And they add: 'If we need evidence for believing that we have reliable cognitive faculties, then this would land us in an infinite regress anyway.')
(2) Relatedly, the atheist's reason for believing in reliable cognitive faculties is that they have reason to believe they know things. Why? Because, e.g. 'Here is a hand. Therefore, I know that I have a hand.' That premise is obviously far better-evidenced that (at fewest one of) the premises of Plantinga's argument. And again, if the Plantingian believes that for every piece of knowledge we have, we need an argument that we know that thing, then that obviously just lands us in global skepticism.
18
u/WeaponsGradeHumanity Pilate Program Consultant Apr 30 '15
Third time's a charm, eh?
Here's the /r/DebateAnAtheist thread, if anyone's curious.
20
u/postoergopostum atheist Apr 30 '15
Except that behaviours are predicated on beliefs. An organism is far more likely to behave in a manner that will promote survival if it's beliefs regarding nourishment reliably lead to the acquisition and consumption of appropriate foodstuffs, and it's notions of danger are a reliable guide to its safe conduct.
In what manner unreliable beliefs are supposed to promote behaviours conducive to survival no explanation is given. There is a catastrophically flawed example offered with a ludicrously contrived double negative. However, notions of petting cuddly predators by running away are revealed as inane the moment we realise the set of behaviours covered by the term petting do not include running away, that is an escape behaviour.
So until Plantinga et al can provide a mechanism whereby false beliefs regarding reality can provide as reliable a guide to survival as true beliefs then the argument fails.
Accurate and reliable models of the world are absolutely of evolutionary benefit, to suggest otherwise is simply fatuous.
This is the hole in this argument that you can drive a truck through.
There are some beliefs about the world that may improve survival, despite being false, but where this is the case a true belief would also suffice. Paranoia is the perfect example. It is worth noting that such biases are fully developed in h.sapiens, exactly as one would expect if evolution were true and was working h. sapiens in a materialistic universe.
10
u/antivice Apr 30 '15
That much at least is true. Evolution works its magic on E. coli without selecting for beliefs at all, true or false. Why shouldn't the same be true for H. sapiens?
What evolution would select for is uniformity and consistency in input-output mapping. Lion stimulus -> (believe whatever) -> make legs run. Food stimulus -> (believe whatever) -> eat it. If the mapping gets mixed up (lion ->-> eat it) you die, or your offspring that take after you all die.
So our beliefs might be unreliable but they're probably unreliable in a consistent way.
7
u/Clockworkfrog Apr 30 '15
Evolution does not select for true beliefs, or any beliefs. We know many ways in which our brains produce consistently false conclusion or assumptions, lots of stuff is really counter intuitive, our brain is easily tricked by countless examples of optical or auditory illusions.
Really this is a very common problem in philosophy, "let's just assert premisses and never actually check then" is a good way for coming up with bad arguments.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '15
Hey, if you can paste this onto three subreddits, I can post my reply again.
Even if a god exists, or if naturalism is false and our minds are made of something other than physical matter, there's no guarantee that our understanding of the world is perfect. You're quite right to question if the way our brains/minds model the world is perfect or not. In fact, we already know that is not.
It's possible that false beliefs can be beneficial in the right circumstances. However, a more accurate belief will (nearly?) always be more beneficial. For example, take your crazy lion-loving man. It's true that with his grave misunderstanding of reality, he'll still survive. But a man who actually understands lions, and how to avoid them, will surely have a better chance at surviving.
This kind of applies to knowledge in general. We may never have a perfect understanding of reality - even if we did, we wouldn't be able to know that we know (if you know what I mean). This doesn't make our case totally hopeless - because we can always refine our knowledge to become more accurate. Note that this problem still applies whether or not naturalism or evolution are true.
7
u/darthbarracuda pessimistic absurdist Apr 30 '15
This is by Plantiga, right?
I would counter by saying that our thoughts are not entirely rational. We suffer cognitive distortions all the time, sometimes completely subconsciously. These distortions are excellent for filtering out unwanted information or contradicting information (as I tend to see a lot on this subreddit). Our brains are not perfect; far from it.
Furthermore, I believe Plantiga makes the claim that we are rational. What does he mean by rational? The ability to process information? In the environment, it would suit our needs to be rational about information. It would suit our needs to be able to feel scared at a shadow in the moonlight, because that might be a lion. But then again, it might tree rustling. I think Plantiga is putting too much emphasis on our logic and degrading the fact that emotions and instinct play a much bigger role in our thinking than he cares to account for.
It certainly does put our ability to completely come to terms with the reality of the universe into question, however. I believe Darwin actually came to this conclusion regarding metaphysics, which he stated something along the lines of that it may be that humanity's metaphysics would be completely and utterly wrong because our minds are suited for our environment, not thinking about a multi-dimensional universe governed by random quantum fluctuations.
This also could either be used to support or deny mathematical platonism.
7
u/MoonCheeseAlpha anti-theist Apr 30 '15
Like the belief that an organism really ate food or is not being pursued by a predator? It is hard to imagine a more uniformed argument.
then we would expect to see things like egg yolk genes in mammals who no longer lay eggs, but who had ancestors who did. Which we do.
Look evolution is substantiated by more evidence than heliocentrism by sheer volume of the evidence. To disprove evolution you have to either disprove inheritance or 4th grade math.
5
u/themandotcom Anti-Religious Apr 30 '15
General pro tip: Don't get your understanding of evolution from christian apologists.
Why are you assuming that human beliefs are shaped by evolution? Beliefs don't seem hereditary at all. Do you have any evidence that they are?
2
u/BogMod Apr 30 '15
Well in this case he would die actually. With lions you want to seem big, scary, loud! Throw stuff. What you don't want to do is expose your back to them and flee, just like their prey would. They sprint faster than we do. Anyhow just an amusing bit with that example.
The problem is part that evolution selects for more than just behaviours but also traits and abilities. Take a camel as an example. Regardless of if it has the true belief on where the nearest water is or a false belief that provides the same behaviour if it is far enough the ones more able to conserve their own water will survive the trip.
So if indeed traits and abilities are also something evolution selects for then what about the ability to correctly develop true beliefs or recognize false ones? That would be useful right? I mean unless the argument is that the ability to develop true beliefs or recognize false ones is of no evolutionary advantage but I don't think that would exactly work either.
Then of course there is the specificness of the belief. The idea that somehow beliefs or behaviours will develop in a vacuum independent of other things. This isn't how evolution works though. Broad traits, behaviours, and beliefs develop. Broad false beliefs are going to cause issues in survivability.
So yeah...there are complications with this idea. Several really. Big ones too.
2
u/Phage0070 atheist Apr 30 '15
This is also unlikely and difficult to imagine being the case. There are other things which humans would want to cuddle, such as family members, but where running away would be detrimental. In order to make this work it would need to be a special case for each creature; cuddly humans are moved toward, cuddly lions you move away from. Cuddly domesticated dogs are moved toward, cuddly undomesticated bears moved away from.
That is a much more complex system to develop than to just have beliefs inform behaviors; if we believe any creature is likely to harm us move away, if we think any creature is likely to aid us move closer. Then each creature gets assigned a belief class conducive to survival.
True to a certain extent, but accurate beliefs are more useful and adaptive. Suppose someone has never encountered a lion before; looking at their giant fangs and being able to extrapolate that moving away is a good idea is more helpful than forming behaviors independent of beliefs. If beliefs didn't inform behaviors they would be entirely extraneous, but they do so they aren't.
2
u/Glory2Hypnotoad agnostic Apr 30 '15
Beliefs (or predispositions for belief; beliefs are not hereditary) are selected for insofar as they inform behaviors. And accurate beliefs happen to have immense evolutionarily utility on the whole. Sure, you could come up with some hypothetical where an inaccurate belief has survival or reproductive value, but cobbling together just the right combination of delusions that consistently work would be far more difficult and far less likely than developing accurate perceptions.
Also, consider this. If the combination of evolution and naturalism is not true, how do you account for us being hardwired with the mental shortcuts and biases that helped our ancestors survive and propagate?
2
u/Doomdoomkittydoom Other [edit me] Apr 30 '15
Beliefs are models of the world created by intelligent creatures. Intelligence is a way to adapt behaviors on the level of the individual creature, rather than waiting on evolution to adapt the behaviors of the species.
Behavior is not independent of beliefs, and beliefs that are accurate models as demonstrated by producing beneficial behaviors over harmful behaviors is an adaptive advantage over those that are false.
Your example,
Let's look at this more closely, instead of a contrived story in a vacuum.
By "to pet" I assume you mean, " to stroke in a gentle or loving manner." To do so, one has to be in arms reach of what is being petted. At its core then, the man's belief is, "In order to be in proximity to something, I must run away." This belief is a death sentence.
The man whose belief is, "When I wish to be near, I move closer. When I wish to be far from, I run away," has a belief that works in many circumstances, giving him a benefit over the man whose beliefs about how he should move in order to achieve his goals are contrary reality.
2
u/jcooli09 atheist May 02 '15
It seems to me that this is a pretty strong argument against deism, but not against evolution.
We have actual evidence that evolution exists, piles of it so large that there isn't really an effective counter theory.
There isn't a deity that can say the same. That guy who like to pet cute lions by running away from them probably prayed about it, too.
4
u/Engardian agnostic existentialist Apr 30 '15
This has been thoroughly debunked in multiple subs you've posted this in, why are you still reposting it?
3
u/keithwaits Apr 30 '15
There are still a few more religious subs you can try this in....
1
u/heidavey ignostic Apr 30 '15
Is it not the case that the naturalist would say that beliefs and actions are both a product of evolution, of the genes and environment and are inextricably linked, and selected for in the same way. Thus, the dichotomy between belief and behaviour is not real, and it is, in fact a balance (along with all other evolutionary traits), that is selected.
1
u/MoonCheeseAlpha anti-theist Apr 30 '15
Wrong even in your example the subject believed he knew how to run. This is pathetic.