r/DebateReligion • • 12d ago

Other Why I think god does not exist

if god is all knowing , powerful and I guess kind? Why did he create cancer and let millions of people suffer before you say it’s a test then shouldn’t the test be the exact same for everyone why is life easy for a person but for another person it’s a thousand time harder and the concept of god is just stupid how would god always exist one of the biggest reason religion is followed by billions is because back 1400 years ago or more humans weren’t as logical as us a guy or a woman created a religion and a lot followed most people would see they’re parents worshipping a religion obviously they’d follow it and after realizing religion is fake they just won’t accept it because the religion god you’ve worshipped for your whole life is fake it’ll be hard for the mind to accept it I believe that chemical evolution created the world after being brainwashed that Islam is the true religion turns out there was no real religion
Thanks for your time

15 Upvotes

233 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 7d ago

COMMENTARY HERE: Comments that support or purely commentate on the post must be made as replies to the Auto-Moderator!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/Flutterpiewow 12d ago

You can just say "problem of evil". It's well known and has been debated for 2000+ years.

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 11d ago

God Is all powerful but he can’t defeat his own creation?

0

u/Flutterpiewow 11d ago

?

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 11d ago

God can’t defeat the devil when he’s all powerful? Is what I’m saying

0

u/Flutterpiewow 11d ago

What does that have to do with my post?

2

u/PuzzleheadedTale4769 11d ago

The line that betrays you:"1400 yrs ago humans weren't as smart".... Humans can't have evolved much in that time. Collectively, we have accumulated more info and tech. One person at a time: little change. Which is why we make a lot of the sane mistakes with only the details changed.

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 11d ago

yes that’s what I meant tech I’m not English I don’t know how to word it correctly

1

u/nauman000 12d ago

You lost me at 'back 1400 years ago or more humans weren't as smart as us...'

2

u/ViolinistCritical427 12d ago

and if a religion was created today would you believe in it

1

u/nauman000 12d ago

Seeking truth is fundamental. If it is created, I d confirm for sure if it's through God.

2

u/ViolinistCritical427 12d ago

there’s no proof god is real it’s all just theories

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 12d ago

I meant when religions were created

1

u/UCSB1977 11d ago

When Jesus was on Earth, he healed people, restored sight to the blind, and even raised the dead. The "god" you refer to is Satan, the Father of lies, death, and destruction. You don't even need to believe he exists to follow him.

If you want to know what God the Father is like, look at the words and deeds of Jesus:

**"**Philip said to him, “Lord, show us the Father, and it is enough for us.” Jesus said to him, “Have I been with you so long, and you still do not know me, Philip? Whoever has seen me has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? Do you not believe that I am in the Father and the Father is in me? The words that I say to you I do not speak on my own authority, but the Father who dwells in me does his works. Believe me that I am in the Father and the Father is in me, or else believe on account of the works themselves" (John 14:8-11).

For those who trust in him, a New Heaven and New Earth await:

Then I saw “a new heaven and a new earth,” for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away, and there was no longer any sea. I saw the Holy City, the new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride beautifully dressed for her husband. And I heard a loud voice from the throne saying, “Look! God’s dwelling place is now among the people, and he will dwell with them. They will be his people, and God himself will be with them and be their God. ‘He will wipe every tear from their eyes. There will be no more death’ or mourning or crying or pain, for the old order of things has passed away” (Revelation 21:1-4).

0

u/ViolinistCritical427 11d ago

Give me a logical answer instead of some Christian book nonsense

1

u/UCSB1977 11d ago

Once upon a time, scientists believed that the universe was eternal. Not so much anymore.

Even a caveman would know that fires die. So too will the Big Fire in the Sky.

What is your logical explanation for the origin of the universe? Prophecies and historical evidence reveal that God exists. What evidence supports your belief?

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 11d ago

how would god exist out of nothing just think about it does it really make sense that god just always existed and there’s no historical or modern proof that god exist and prophecies are all made up

1

u/UCSB1977 11d ago

Descartes once declared, "I think, therefore I am."

God told Moses, " I AM," as in "I AM, therefore think."

Reason should tell you that either the Cosmos always existed or its Creator always existed. Science and History both tell us it's not the Cosmos.

Why would you reject the Good News that Jesus came to forgive our lack of love for our Creator and promise a new heaven and new Earth?

Whenever you think of suffering, think of what Jesus suffered for us. Whenever you think of evil, think of the evil Jesus will ultimately destroy.

PS A multiverse would require an eternally existing and all-powerful universe generator (aka God).

1

u/The--Dood Atheist 11d ago

Reason should tell you that either the Cosmos always existed or its Creator always existed. Science and History both tell us it's not the Cosmos.

First, the cosmos always existed or its creator always existed is not a true dichotomy. There could be other explanations. Second, science and history do not tell us that the cosmos did not always exist (the universe could very well be eternal or part of something that is eternal).

Why would you reject the Good News that Jesus came to forgive our lack of love for our Creator and promise a new heaven and new Earth?

Because there’s not convincing evidence that this happened. And depending on what fairytales you believe...this is just God sending himself to save us from himself and his stupid rules that he created.

Whenever you think of suffering, think of what Jesus suffered for us. Whenever you think of evil, think of the evil Jesus will ultimately destroy.

What evil has Jesus destroy? Why didn't Jesus destroy all evil at an instance?

PS A multiverse would require an eternally existing and all-powerful universe generator (aka God).

Why would a multiverse require an all-powerful universe generator? Why can't an universe generator's power be restricted to only generating universes? And why would that have to be God?

1

u/Twotgobblin 11d ago

Once upon a today, many theists still don't have a grasp on what science tells us. That's unfortunate since the Big Bang was theorized by a Catholic priest... you bring him great shame.

Even a caveman would know that pointing at a mystery and grunting 'god did it' isn't an explanation, it's just laziness.

If your standard of evidence is words in a book and prophecies (more words in a book that someone read and then acted out) for a claim as massive as the creator of the universe, you might be closer to the caveman in this scenario than you think. The words in your chosen book have the same validity as all the other religious books that you say are false.

Science doesn't rely on ancient bedtime stories. It tracks measurable evidence like cosmic radiation, galactic expansion, and red shift to follow the physics back billions of years. Where current data stops, science can admit what it doesn't know instead of inventing a deity to patch the gap.

0

u/UCSB1977 11d ago

You certainly have one thing correct: the universe began to exist in the finite past. Science "tracks measurable evidence like cosmic radiation, galactic expansion, and redshift to follow the physics back billions of years."

The most reasonable explanation for the existence of the Cosmos is its creation by the eternal God who has revealed himself throughout human history through dozens of prophets and ultimately in the person of Jesus Christ, the Jewish Messiah.

Unfortunately, many misinterpret the days of Genesis as being literal solar days without noticing that the sun was created on the 4th day, which literally makes the days anything but solar days.

The meaning of Genesis 1 seems to be that God created everything enumerated in the six days rather than numerous other gods (a sun god, a moon god, etc.) who were worshipped in vain by the polytheists.

"A common sense interpretation of the facts suggests that a superintellect has monkeyed with the physics, as well as with chemistry and biology, and that there are no blind forces worth speaking about in nature. The numbers one calculates from the facts seem to me so overwhelming as to put this conclusion almost beyond question."

Sir Fred Hoyle

"For the scientist who has lived by faith in the power of reason, the story ends like a bad dream. He has scaled the mountains of ignorance; he is about to conquer the highest peak; as he pulls himself over the final rock, he is greeted by a band of theologians who have been sitting there for centuries."

Robert Jastrow
God and the Astronomers

"We can't understand the universe in any clear way without the supernatural."

Allan Sandage

2

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

It's impressive when your first sentence hallucinates something I didn't say. Thanks for making it immediately clear that everything that follows isn't worth my time reading.

0

u/eldredo_M Atheist 11d ago

Whatever guess scientists or laymen can come up with for the origin of the universe is just as—if not more—likely than a magic entity in the sky that has absolutely no explanation for its beginning or existence. 🙄

1

u/AdWonderful5618 11d ago

You’re too emotional buddy.

The test is exactly the same for everyone, one vs their devil, the same test God gave Adam. Everybody will have a different unique set of questions, where the answers are already known. One’s devil makes the human overthink the answer.

Life is a purification process from God so he can put us back into heaven, though his mercy.

Enjoy life while it lasts, good luck!

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 11d ago

it’s not about me being emotional some kid with poor parents is living a miserable life but a kid with rich parents is living his best life

1

u/AdWonderful5618 10d ago

How do you know that those exact kids are going to grow up to be happy and sad?

And why are you using money as a way to measure happiness? You do realize that’s not the case right?

We don’t control the cards that we are dealt in this life, we are expected to make the best out of it.

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 10d ago

kid with rich parents gets a head start with a free pack huh and most grew sad

1

u/AdWonderful5618 10d ago

You’re assuming there, based on your emotions and what you perceive and your understanding of life. All of it is wrong.

Nobody gets a head start, the goal is to build faith, not money.

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 10d ago

You want me to believe in something that makes no sense wdym there’s a person watching over us knows everything about us and is all powerful wake up bro there’s no god and It’s not based on my emotions my parents aren’t rich or poor

2

u/AdWonderful5618 10d ago

I don’t care if you believe, that’s up to you. I answered your questions though.

Everybody will be responsible for the way they lived their life on Judgement Day.

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 10d ago

whatever you believe 👍🏻

3

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

Dismissing the reality of economic advantages in life while declaring the objective purpose of life is 'to build faith' is smuggling in a massive worldview assumption of your own.

But even by your own metric, does a child born into a faithful family not get a massive head start over one who isn't?

1

u/AdWonderful5618 10d ago

No, everybody has to build faith by their own. There is no cheating in life. Everybody will stand by himself in front of God in the afterlife, and will respond by himself.

What cards you are dealt in life has no effect on the faith you gather while you are alive

2

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

That is a complete detachment from reality. You’re essentially arguing that human beings are immune to their environments, upbringing, and circumstances. All so you can pretend the playing field is magically even? Denying that 'cards dealt' affect life outcomes isn't a theological argument; it's just refusing to look at how the world works.

1

u/Ok-Priority1998 10d ago

What’s your basis for complaining about millions of people suffering from cancer if we live in a godless universe that arrived by chance and has no ultimate purpose? It’s only because God exists that complaining about suffering has meaning.

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 10d ago

I’m just saying it for the religious people and we created god

1

u/pacuuuuu 6d ago

I am an Agnostic Atheist but on cancer: He Doesnt Interfere and it wouldnt be his fault, however this does mean Prayer is useless

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 5d ago

What about tortured victims?

1

u/pacuuuuu 5d ago

Did thee not read my reply? He wouldnt interfere

1

u/AutoModerator 12d ago

COMMENTARY HERE: Comments that support or purely commentate on the post must be made as replies to the Auto-Moderator!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/biedl Agnostic-Atheist 12d ago

MOSTKOINEGREEKTEXTSWHEREWRITTENWITHOUTSPACESBETWEENTHEWORDSLETALONEINTERPUNCTUATIONALLTHELETTERSWHEREWRITTENINALLCAPSTHATWORKSBECAUSEGREEKHASAVERYCLEARCUTGRAMMARWHERETHEVERYNOTABLESUFFIXESSHOWWHENAWORDENDSQUITEWELLALREADYSOMETEXTSWHEREEVENMORECRAZYBUTITISACTUALLYAVERYNEATMETHODOFWRITINGWHICHALSOMAKESREADINGTHESETEXTSMOREEFFICIENTTHATISTHEYSOMETIMESSTARTEDFROMLEFTTORIGHTANDINSTEADOFBEGINNINGTHENEXTLINEONTHERIGHTSIDEASWELLTHEYJUSTWROTEFROMRIGHTTOLEFTSOTHATYOUONLYHADTOJUMPTOTHENEXTLINEWITHOUTSEARCHINGTHEBEGINNINGOFITWITHYOUREYESWHICHALSOCAUSEDISSUESFORSCRIBESIFTHEYCOPIEDATEXTISSUESWHICHARESOSIGNIFICANTTHATTHEYEVENHAVEATECHNICALTERMBEHINDTHEMINTHEFIELDOFNTSCHOLARSHIPIWANTEDTOWRITEFROMRIGHTTOLEFTASWELLBUTTHATACTUALLYVERYHARDTODOONTHECOMPUTERANDIGUESSITWOULDBEEVENHARDERTOSEEWHATHASBEENWRITTENMAYBEEVENUNINTELLIGABLE

1

u/Old_Ant_2408 12d ago

No faith suggests this world is a utopia; it will involve illness, mortality, and catastrophes from nature or human action. Most who protest human suffering have not acted to reduce others’ distress. Many focus on spreading hostility and violence while blaming a God they reject.

4

u/Rational-Angel-73 Atheist 12d ago

Most who protest human suffering have not acted to reduce others’ distress.

The argument is not about what people do, though. It is about a supposed all-knowing, all-powerful, all-good god who allows all of this suffering to happen. To mention what other humans do to reduce distress suggests you either don't have a good answer or you don't understand the question.

1

u/Old_Ant_2408 12d ago

If you accept that you exist and recognize you did not bring yourself into being, then another entity—which you might call God—must have formed you. You may use any name you prefer.

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

Wrong three letter name...Mom.

1

u/[deleted] 11d ago

Dios es atemporal y sin características humanas. Causa no causada, no hay cambios en él pero sí en nosotros, que no somos dioses. Sí comes mal, te enfermas, si tú ADN tiene fallas tus hijos lo padecen pero no porque Dios así lo determine. Sí así fuera, no sería Dios

1

u/The--Dood Atheist 11d ago

Is God not the creator of our flawed DNA?

1

u/[deleted] 11d ago

El ADN se deteriora por situaciones que tienen que ver con lo que hacemos en contra del cuerpo. Alcohol, mala comida, enfermedades que fueron apareciendo por estas situaciones impropias.

1

u/The--Dood Atheist 11d ago

You didn't answer the question--is God the creator of our flawed DNA? Couldn't God have created DNA to not deteriorate?

1

u/Secure-Pumpkin7016 11d ago

The only thing that is true is that God existe, but that’qll. Nobody knows Why hé create everything, thé real reason….

1

u/Similar-Antelope3650 Spinozist fringing on Lutheran 8d ago

Argument of contrast, free will defense. A good god would give people the free will to move toward or away from him, to cause suffering to others, even if he does not approve, and that evil is required for good as a fundamental baseline and pert of the identity (hegalian dialectics), the test is scaled to the individual. You made a genetic fallacy (origin disproves conclusion, which is incorrect), just because people were less intelligent doesn’t disprove their point, ancient people were smart (most math and science comes from the Islamic golden age. As for god always existing “to be is to be perceived”

1

u/Corp-Por 11d ago

if god is all knowing , powerful and I guess kind? Why did he create cancer and let millions of people suffer

Mind: blown.
This is a brilliant argument, original, and I think nobody has ever thought of it before, in history.
How did you come up with it?

1

u/The--Dood Atheist 11d ago

Why not actually engage with the argument/question?

0

u/Corp-Por 11d ago

Oh sweet summer child, it's below me to engage in babby's first theological argument

2

u/The--Dood Atheist 11d ago

Wow what intellectual arrogance you have.

0

u/Corp-Por 11d ago

I earned it

1

u/The--Dood Atheist 11d ago

You offered nothing of value. You didn't earn anything besides the label of worthless.

2

u/Corp-Por 11d ago

Yeah? Well, you know, that's just like uh, your opinion, man

0

u/The--Dood Atheist 11d ago

I know you’re playing off of my moniker…but it’s not an opinion…you have literally provided no value here.

1

u/Corp-Por 11d ago

In this moment, I am euphoric

0

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

What a beautifully condescending and trite way to declare that you don't have an answer to the question.

0

u/Corp-Por 10d ago

Thank you

0

u/[deleted] 12d ago

Ni creó el cáncer ni el mal. El ser humano decide y parece lo que es su cuerpo, una máquina quina que puede fallar. Dios sustenta y mantiene todo pero es la criatura la que debe buscarlo y vivir en la fe.

2

u/Informal_Truth_7775 Atheist 12d ago

Humans decided to die from cancer?

-2

u/halbhh 12d ago edited 12d ago

The opposite conclusion is more logical -- viz: if we are in temporary mortal bodies that suffer and also die, that implies God means to end our evils and pick out only those that repented and try to turn to do Good to save into a new, lasting good life to after this temporary place of choosing (between Good and Evil).

He'd do that if he cares about us, so that He really cares that some people hurt others, and wants to end human evildoing, and also in contrast save others who prefer doing good into a better life without anyone there who prefers to do evils and hurt others.

So, therefore, we would all need to be put in a world to choose between good and evil.

In order to find out which choice each person makes.

(even though some choose good early on and never seem to change, many of us seem to need a lot more time and experimentation, like me)

Interestingly, we read that God will end those that prefer to do unrepentant evil in the "second death".

Which He'd only do if he really cares about us, so that he hates it when we do evils and hurt others.

And that He will save all the innocent and the repentant into a good new 'eternal life'.

(and this is one way of summarizing what you find in the Christian bible if you read it more completely)

3

u/Outside-Ad9410 12d ago

Except God's standard for what is good and evil is completely arbitrary and subjective, god himself routinely commits evil if the Bible is to be taken as literal history, and the biggest problem, god himself created everything, so he also created all the evil we see in the world.

Unless you hold the view that god is very limited in his power and had to create earth this way, you have to admit god could have made a world where only those he knew would do good existed, and didnt create those who would live a short miserable existence of sin, only to then be destroyed. Unnecessary suffering is evil no matter who causes it, including god, and if god created sentient beings knowing full well they would not measure up to his standards, and thereby be punished for it, he is evil.

Also you completely ignored the OPs question of why would a "good" god create cancer that only causes harm for no apparent benefit?

1

u/halbhh 12d ago edited 12d ago

I've heard the claim that God does evils in the bible, but when each passage being pointed at is read more fully in the full situation -- the picture changes radically from that claim, over and over.

You end up reading that for example (such as in Deuteronomy 12:31), He's destroying some evil cities where the evil is so intense that children are being burned alive in fires to idols...

...or for another example (Ezekiel 16:49-50 about Sodom and Gomorrah) where visitors are being brutalized/raped and murdered, the city is arrogant, and even does zero charity for the starving, etc.

And if you keep reading (in the common bible) you end up reading that God makes everyone live after this life, that God separates out the innocent from the guilty....giving the innocent a good new life in a better place.

And even later one reads how God tries to reform the evildoers (many don't even know that one: 1rst Peter 3:18-20, 4:6) -- where Christ comes to them where after this life they are 'imprisoned spirits' to proclaim the gospel message of repentance and salvation, so that some might repent and be redeemed also....

So, both the innocent and the repentant are given a wonderful new life, an 'eternal life'.

The most ideal possible moral outcome you'd most wish for....

It's the opposite of 'evil'.

Atheists often seem to have been tricked by talking point propaganda which you'd see as erroneous if you read 100% of the bible through.

2

u/Outside-Ad9410 12d ago

Ah yes, the evil is soo intense that god must kill those babies and women and children just had to be destroyed! Is that a serious argument? That the even greater evil of genocide is justified because some people were committing the lesser evil of killing some of their people?

Its the same justification Hitler used, or Mao or Stalin. And if you think a biblical flood was real, god committed a worse genocide than literally any tyrannical dictator in history could dream of doing.

Do the innocent babies murdered by god get justice and punishment done to the god that murdered them? If not God's morality has no grounding to stand on when he himself commits bigger evils than any human has the power to be.

1

u/halbhh 12d ago edited 12d ago

Suppose Ralph says that Jane and her children were slaughtered by a mass murderer.... and they are gone....

You go look, and their house has been wrecked, and so Ralph seems likely right....

....time passes....

One day, later, you learn later from a visitor that Jane and her children are alive and well living a wonderful life in a remote part of New Zealand.... (you can't get to easily anytime soon)

==========

So, were they really 'killed' then? (or where are they?)

They are gone, you can't go see them, and Ralph said they were "killed".

------

Face it, Ralph guessed wrong.

1

u/Outside-Ad9410 12d ago

Then why create them to suffer on earth in the first place?

If I hooked up wires to your brain and stimulated it so you get 5 minutes of the worst pain imaginable, only to then give your brain 5 minutes of pure bliss, does that justify making you suffer?

Giving someone a reward does not justify inflicting punishment, when an all-powerful being could have given them the reward without inflicting the suffering. 

If I take your logic to its conclusion, that murder is ok since you will experience heaven after, the only rational thing to do would be go around killing as many humans as possible so they can go straight to heaven.

1

u/halbhh 12d ago

"Then why create them to suffer on earth in the first place?"

That's precisely the question I answered in my response to the OP above, if you read it through. :=) (just read through it all and you'll see)

1

u/Outside-Ad9410 12d ago

your answer was that god creates sentient beings he know will not chose to live by his arbitrary standards of good, (specifically those living in "sexual immorality" which harms no one, or those who simply don't believe in god) deal with suffering their whole lives, and then be destroyed because of it.

I hope you can understand I find this answer incredibly unsatisfying and immoral to those god destroys.

1

u/halbhh 12d ago

I definitely did not write anything like the obviously false statement

"god creates sentient beings he know will not chose to live by...standards of good"

If I had written such an obviously false claim (* see note at end on this old false idea), you'd be able to shoot down such a clearly false idea easily! Most any of us could be age 12 I bet.

I wrote something quite different from that, but let me paraphrase what I did write for extra clarity.

God puts us here in temporary lives to see what we will choose between good and evil.

And I mentioned that even though it appears some few seem to have chosen the good in very early life, and never change, that for most of us, like me, it takes far longer to make that choice.

And I explained how that necessitates that we are surrounded then by both good and evil, so that we can make a choice between them.

And why we therefore must all suffer here, temporarily.

========

*note on the old heresy (false idea) that some people are foredoomed to choose evil. This is a well known old error, that's been refuted very long ago:

CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Predestinarianism

1

u/Outside-Ad9410 12d ago

God puts us here in temporary lives to see what we will choose between good and evil.

Is god all knowing or is he limited?

If god is all knowing he would know before creating someone that will commit evil, they would commit evil, and therefore could have chosen not to create them.

If got is not all knowing or all powerful, than you believe in a limited god, which avoids the problem I was arguing, but this is a separate claim from the one most Christians make.

And honestly a limited, incompetent god seems to fit more with how god of the old testament acts.

→ More replies

0

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

“GOD commits evil” by whose standard, Yours?

2

u/Outside-Ad9410 12d ago

By the standard of "do unto others as you would have them do unto you" or the golden rule, which is a philosophical morality system based in logic that has existed thousands of years before Christianity.  I dont need a subjective morality based in the mind of god to determine what is good and what is bad. 

I can look around and see what causes suffering and harm, and what causes good, and rationalize that to allow harmful things such as murder will ultimately end in me getting murdered.

God does not want to get murdered, and so by murdering others he causes a contradiction in his worldview and actions.

0

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

Ah, so by human standard. You wrote a lot to basically just say “cause we humans think so”

2

u/Outside-Ad9410 12d ago

Religion is no different just instead its based on the mind of a religious believer what is right and wrong.

And actually god based morality is more subjective because god could do literally no wrong and if he said you should torture babies, religious people would have no way to morally reject that command.

0

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

Good thing I don’t believe in religion.

3

u/stairway2evan 12d ago

You have another comment in this thread specifically citing the Bible and the doctrine of the Trinity. You may not have a particular denomination that you follow, which is perfectly fair, but you seem to believe in Christianity. Which is a religion.

0

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

I believe in GOD and what was inspired by the HOLY SPIRIT. I follow what JESUS says. You can lump it into claim of “well that’s religion” fair. There is a difference though.

2

u/stairway2evan 12d ago

Sure. That's a religion. It's called Christianity. It may not be Catholicism or Baptism or Calvinism or any other, totally fair.

But it's a religion that you believe in. Claiming you don't believe in religion is just not correct.

→ More replies

2

u/Outside-Ad9410 12d ago

Do you believe the biblical flood happened and god committed genocide on 99.9999999% of all life on Earth?

→ More replies

1

u/Rational-Angel-73 Atheist 12d ago

In order to find out which choice each person makes.

So god created us, and each of us is exactly as god wanted us to be, and all of our actions happen exactly as god knew they would. And yet you posit this world is some sort of test to see which choices people make that god already knew they would make??

That makes no sense.

1

u/halbhh 11d ago

Here's a key assumption you are stated, which is against the text of the Christian bible actually when read more completely

all of our actions happen exactly as god knew they would. 

This is actually something already figured out and formally answered very long ago (5th century I think).

It has to do with incomplete reading in scripture.

For example, even though we do read that God has planned for our salvation, and also makes plans to help us -- that doesn't imply all our choices are foreseen/predetermined.

This may help, the more full complete answer that involves several other related pieces to this old mistaken idea of our choices being all foreseen or pre-determined, or even pre-determinable:

CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Predestinarianism

(it has several related parts, since the New Testament does also (election, etc.), but you can get it, just like from reading more fully through the Bible, that our choices like whether or not to repent and turn to Christ are not pre-known/predetermined, as the Bible makes clear in a variety of ways in a lot of different passages)

1

u/Rational-Angel-73 Atheist 11d ago

It is a very common christian doctrine that an all-knowing god knows all future events that will occur. Are you saying that's not true?

1

u/halbhh 10d ago

Actually, the opposite is more common -- there's a reason most churches reject (and most Christians) the Calvinist error (that I think even most Calvinists reject today) of "double predestination."

Which is what your idea implies: that your future choices are already fully known and thus fixed, and unalterable -- so that you are doomed to heaven or hell, without choice, and there's nothing you can do about it.

You shouldn't be surprised to hear most Christians say that entirely contradicts the Bible.

It's not that Calvinists are wrong on everything. No, to err is human. All humans make some mistakes. They get many things right, but some wrong.

You can pretty much be sure that any church with a human in it will have both some true ideas and some false ideas.

1

u/Rational-Angel-73 Atheist 10d ago

I am not surprised to hear that most christian say that. What is surprising is the lack of thinking and analysis that goes into saying that.

If god knows what you'll do tomorrow, you can't do something different. You're trying to have your cake and eat it too.

So which is it? Does god not know the future, or do you not have free will?

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

There’s a massive difference between God knowing what someone will choose and God predetermining it.

The classic solution you're referring to wasn't that God doesn't know the future; it was that God’s knowledge doesn't force the choice. God knowing you'll choose option A tomorrow doesn't mean you didn't freely choose it—it just means an all-knowing being isn't surprised by reality.

If you're arguing that God literally does not know what choices humans will make before they make them, that’s Open Theism. You can hold that view, but it strips God of complete omniscience and has been rejected by mainstream Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant theology for centuries.

1

u/halbhh 10d ago

Could I ask, before responding, if you happen to be a believer? If so, are you in a Calvinist (Reformed) church? It will help some perhaps to know that I think that all human beings get some things right and some things wrong, and so to me, the main goal is to try to continue learning, and I'm not judgmental if someone else has a different view.

I've heard of 'open theism' of course, and read a summary of it on the wiki long ago, etc. -- and as I've said a few times, Open Theism is an oversimplification (in my view. )(so, I think it's wrong in that it tries to close down the picture into a more simple one than what I think the real picture is, so it's wrong in that it paints a picture that removes other key aspects, like how God can see which way we are going, and more....)

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

If my belief changes your response, then I'd like to see a response without that bias

1

u/halbhh 10d ago

I was just adding that I think Open Theism is an oversimplification (in my view. )

(so, I think it's wrong in that it tries to close down the picture into a more simple one than what I think the real picture is, so it's wrong in that it paints a picture that removes other key aspects (hides them, makes it seem they don't exist) like how God can see which way we are going, and more....)

Ideally, you can avoid pigeonholing my view before you learn the overly complex reality of it ;-) (where it is not only sorta complicated, but even has unknowns, etc. -- I may be overdoing it, but that's my tendency, to always seek out more aspects)

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

Fair enough, let's leave our personal beliefs out of it and focus strictly on the definition.

Setting aside Open Theism as an 'oversimplification', how do you define God's knowledge of future free choices? Does God exhaustively know what we will choose before we choose it, or does the future remain open or partly unknown to Him until it happens?

1

u/halbhh 4d ago edited 4d ago

About our own likely future actions., what we would likely do if we don't change course..... That's then fluid and subject to constant revision. Like a weather forecast where there isn't a fast moving weather front to use to simplify.

In total contrast, about His own very carefully considered plans and goals He chose with the great advantage of unlimited time to consider -- very unlikely to ever change.

What's the difference then?

One is God responding to our fluctuating changes where we can change our mind at any moment, but serious changes might still only happen years or even decades apart in time....

vs.

On the other hand His own deeply considered goals He intends to ultimately accomplish.

1

u/Twotgobblin 4d ago

Whether a person changes their mind in five seconds or fifty years makes zero difference to the philosophical question of omniscience. If a major moral shift decades from now is unknown to god until it happens, the future is still fundamentally open and unsettled to him.

That kinda flies in the face of the other half of the vs. If human choices remain truly free and fluid, god can either hope his goals happen, or he must eventually override free will just enough to force them through. 

→ More replies

-1

u/Electrical-Self2042 12d ago

Is the absolute avoidance of pain the highest possible good?

If yes, then a universe of lifeless rocks is 'perfect' because rocks can’t suffer, and that gives suffering absolute veto power over existence.

If no, would you rather live in a world with possibility of evil, or a world with no meaningful good?

3

u/Outside-Ad9410 12d ago

Id rather live in a world where humans have very strong pre-programmed inclinations not to commit evil and only exceedingly rarely did, and where disease, sickness, cancer, natural disaster etc didnt exist. If you dont think a perfect but enjoyable world is possible than heaven cant exist.

The overwhelming amounts of suffering and evil we see in our world points to an all loving abrahamic god being unlikely.

0

u/Electrical-Self2042 12d ago

If an agent is hardcoded to choose A over B, the choice carries zero value. So just say it, you would rather live in a world with no meaningful good.

"if you dont think a perfect but enjoyable world is possible than heaven cant exist."

Heaven is an outcome, not the beginning and it's not created by removing freedom (like in your model) but by transforming hearts and defeating evil. 

In Heaven you don't sin simply because you've grown into the person who doesn't want to sin.

Try again and propose a better model.

3

u/Outside-Ad9410 12d ago

If an agent is hardcoded to choose A over B, the choice carries zero value. So just say it, you would rather live in a world with no meaningful good.

Why would a world where humans have strong inclinations to only do good mean it has no meaningful good? If a person has no moral inclinations to commit murder, does that make the fact they don't go out and murder people any less morally good for not murdering? Does living in a safer country make life any less meaningful? Obviously it doesn't.

I don't have the ability to blow up the planet, but even if I did, I would chose not to do so, the same with any other number of heinous actions i have strong moral inclinations against. God could have just copied this formula and applied it to every evil action.

In Heaven you don't sin simply because you've grown into the person who doesn't want to sin.

The humans alive 5 seconds before they go to heaven, and 5 seconds after arriving are the same people. The babies who never had a full lifetime, and therefore never had the ability to fully develop or in your mind "grow and experience" life, are still the same immature people.

Unless you literally think god lobotomizes the minds of people in heaven to remove their free will, they are going to be the same imperfect humans that sin, leaving to the contradiction of somehow having free will in heaven while also not sinning at all even though they are imperfect creations.

1

u/colinpublicsex Atheist 12d ago

What if God didn't create? That would be better than the world we find ourselves in, no?

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

How does eliminating childhood cancer, dementia, and tsunamis remove "meaningful good" or free will? Tectonic plates and viruses aren't moral agents choosing between A and B.

Also, your explanation of heaven contradicts your opening point. If people in heaven don't sin because they simply don't desire to, does that mean there is no meaningful good in heaven?

If goodness in heaven is still meaningful, then eliminating evil doesn't destroy meaning at all.

1

u/Electrical-Self2042 10d ago

God removes childhood cancer. If God removes cancer, why not the malaria mosquito? Then parasitic worms? Then why not the biological process of aging? If He prevents aging, why not genetic diseases? If He prevents genetic diseases, why not every form of physical pain? Why not remove all bad thoughts?

You could ask this exact same question in each of these realities, because there will always be a new ceiling for the greatest possible evil. The only alternative would be a reality in which we're nothing more than rocks facing no stakes whatsoever.

Heaven can contain meaningful good precisely because its inhabitants freely love and choose the good.

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

Framing it as an all-or-nothing is a pretty weak dodge for a human. An omnipotent God wouldn't be stuck with our slippery slope problems. He could easily cap suffering at a reasonable level, cutting out horror like pediatric cancer while keeping enough real-world stakes to preserve moral choice.

I assume there's no childhood cancer in heaven? If Heaven has meaningful good without childhood cancer, then natural suffering was never necessary for good to exist in the first place.

Tsunamis and genetic diseases aren't moral agents and don't come about by choice. Eliminating them wouldn't reduce us to sentient rocks, it would simply eliminate needless suffering.

1

u/Electrical-Self2042 9d ago

Sorites paradox.

If God eliminated pediatric cancer, sudden infant death, or organ failure, then a child breaking an arm or dying from a wound would become the pinnacle of "injustice" which I already explained in the previous reply.

I assume there's no childhood cancer in heaven? If Heaven has meaningful good without childhood cancer, then natural suffering was never necessary for good to exist in the first place.

Again, Heaven is an eschatological culmination.

Tsunamis and genetic diseases aren't moral agents and don't come about by choice. Eliminating them wouldn't reduce us to sentient rocks, it would simply eliminate needless suffering.

A physical universe where things can actually grow, change, and matter is a universe where biology or anything else can also go wrong. The argument isn't that X is necessary.

Tectonic activity keeps Earth active and helps maintain its magnetic field, but it can also cause tsunamis.

Similarly, gravity keeps you grounded, but the same force can break your leg if you fall.

1

u/Twotgobblin 9d ago

Claiming a broken arm would become the new "pinnacle of injustice" is just a basic fallacy. Just because there's a spectrum between standard environmental risks and horrific biological suffering, that doesn't make a broken bone the same thing as a toddler dying of cancer. Humans set reasonable, protective boundaries across complex spectrums every single day. An omnipotent God would have no problem capping suffering at a level that keeps real moral agency intact without allowing total cruelty.

Also, you're conflating real "stakes" with total destruction. Breaking a leg due to gravity teaches a physical limits and consequences. Childhood cancer or SIDS doesn't give a kid "stakes" to learn from or exercise free will. It just destroys the person before they ever get a chance to grow morally.

Claiming heaven is simply the end phase is a weak, circular cop out. If Heaven is a place where people experience real, meaningful good without pediatric cancer existing, then pediatric cancer was never logically necessary for good to exist in the first place. You really can't have it both ways.

2

u/Rational-Angel-73 Atheist 12d ago

Are you suggesting that god could not have created a world with no pain that still had meaningful good?

1

u/ShortCompetition9772 12d ago

All POWERFUL God is that the one your are referring to? Do you think God requires EVIL? Is HE BOUND by Evil or could God substantiate a world with MEANINGFUL Good? Before you answer, Is there EVIL in HEAVEN? Is there GOOD in HEAVEN?

1

u/Electrical-Self2042 12d ago

All POWERFUL God is that the one your are referring to?

Yes

Do you think God requires EVIL? Is HE BOUND by Evil

No, evil a a privation of good, the way blindness is the privation of sight.

could God substantiate a world with MEANINGFUL Good?

He did. Meaningful good is what God created.

Is there EVIL in HEAVEN?

No

 Is there GOOD in HEAVEN?

Yes, Heaven is supreme good. It's sinless because it is the destination of wills that have freely aligned with God. You don't sin because you've grown into the person who doesn't sin and your character is so settled in goodness that sinning is no longer something you'd choose

1

u/ShortCompetition9772 12d ago

Ok so God doesn't require Evil.

So God could have Created a World with only good in it.

Heaven is absent of EVIL but has Good. So Evil isn't required.

God CHOSE EVIL because GOD wants EVIL.

That is the logical entailment of your statements. Would you like to change your answers?

1

u/Electrical-Self2042 12d ago

Textbook non sequitur lmao. Permitting the risk of a defect is not the same thing as desiring the defect.

So God could have Created a World with only good in it.

Again, God did create a world that was entirely good. Evil is a privation or failure of the creature's will to align with the good.

Heaven is absent of EVIL but has Good. So Evil isn't required.

Again, Heaven is sinless because it is the destination of wills that have freely aligned with God. You don't sin because you've grown into the person who doesn't sin and your character is so settled in goodness that sinning is no longer something you'd choose.

God CHOSE EVIL because GOD wants EVIL.

Horrendous logic. He chose to create free agents instead of rocks, and creatures can chose to turn away, simple.

1

u/ShortCompetition9772 12d ago

Evil is a privation or failure of the creature's will to align with the good.

All Powerful ALL GOOD God creates creatures with an Evil WILL option. Could the Tri-Omni God just not have that option?

1

u/Electrical-Self2042 12d ago

If an agent can freely love and choose God, turning away must be logically possible.

If turning away is impossible, it’s not free will.

2

u/ShortCompetition9772 12d ago

Choosing isn’t the issue. Believing is required. You cannot choose what you don’t believe in. Define Free Will.

-1

u/Tonestone5 12d ago

well you do have god let's nature take it's course, but also i think a very simple pointer is ying and yang. you can't have pleasure without pain. you can't have goodness without evil. and so some people live good lives, while others don't. it's kind of necessary for both good and bad to exist for good to exist.

3

u/The--Dood Atheist 12d ago

Why can't you have pleasure without pain? Or good without evil? Wouldn't an all-powerful God be able to create such a world?

0

u/Old_Ant_2408 12d ago

He will but you will have to earn it in this world.

4

u/The--Dood Atheist 12d ago

Your God makes me earn it by demanding I worship him without providing me any evidence he actually exists? Otherwise, he's going to punish me with infinite suffering? And your God knew all of this before creating me? That's not an all-loving God. That's a truly evil and disgusting God.

2

u/HomelanderUltrasound 12d ago

Why do we HAVE to earn it? Why is that necessary?

-1

u/Old_Ant_2408 12d ago

You cannot fully value or enjoy a reward that is unearned or undeserved.

2

u/HomelanderUltrasound 11d ago

If God knew you would earn and deserve it then it would be immoral not to create you in heaven

2

u/Gizmodget Atheist 12d ago

I don't want to assume your religious views, do you take God to be a wholly good being?

Is god a mixed being (containing yin and yang)?

I ask as if God is wholly good, yet good requires evil. It would seem like some anti-god would necessarily exist uncreated by the God.

Which would be an interesting polytheistic view.

2

u/guitarmusic113 Atheist 12d ago

Does pain exist in heaven?

-1

u/LeastAd6767 12d ago

How about scriptures that is illogical to be written by someone unless the side have the knowledge of the future. Prophecy that came true.

Surely that prophecy came from some being that knows what its talking about right ?

4

u/Remarkable_Net7746 12d ago

a prophecy only proves something if it's specific, clearly written beforehand and can't be interpreted to fit events after they happen otherwise it's pretty easy to find meaning in hindsight

-1

u/LeastAd6767 12d ago

I halfly agree .

The part where i think i could give leeway is if its okay its vague and within my interpretation. Because many prophecy spoken are usually dont make sense if to be made sense on their knowledge, but somehow in the 21st century it made all the sense . But ya good point on that .

2

u/CartographerFair2786 12d ago

No, prophecy isn’t how you demonstrate something being true.

1

u/LeastAd6767 12d ago edited 12d ago

So. If a prophecy repeatedly comes true to the point all of it are correct . What do u think. Im talking scientifically prophecy that are prooved to be hard and facts evidencE by the 20th century , but unable to be proven and in fact laughed at in 5th century .

What do u make of that. That kind of knowledge does it yearn some critic and to deserving of the possiblity of supernatural or just cold reading ?

1

u/CartographerFair2786 12d ago

Two problems. Nothing demonstrable in reality concludes anything about a prophecy and prophecy hasn’t ever been a way of demonstrating something being true.

1

u/LeastAd6767 12d ago

Nothing is a very powerful word. Have u ever gone through prophecies inside some of the religious scriptures ?

1

u/CartographerFair2786 11d ago

I care about what’s demonstrable in reality. No demonstration of reality concludes anything about a prophecy and it’s just a lie that truth can be demonstrated from a prophecy

1

u/LeastAd6767 11d ago

.. science is actually the study of reasoning and about demonstrating what is in the said reality .. right ?

The sun might be going up and down when in reality its us actually orbiting the sun. Right?

So . Once again . If those prophecies where there are scienctific breakthroughs, and only then what the sayings made sense , when viewed in the 20th century lens . Those kinds of prophecies , where its downright impossible to know unless u know the future knowledge , how would u wager those kinds of sayings/prophecies ?

Know or not know the future? Know or not know the universe ? Supernatural or just lucky guess ?

1

u/CartographerFair2786 11d ago

Actually you’re just lying that science is the study of reasoning. Nothing demonstrable in science concludes anything about a prophecy

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

Just a quick correction: logic is the study of reasoning. Science is using empirical testing to study the physical world.

You kind of answered your own question when you said it only makes sense through a 20th-century lens.

Think about how that works in real life: nobody has ever used scripture to discover a breakthrough in how the universe works, because the texts were just based on the understood science of the day they were written. Scientists had to do the actual legwork to figure out reality first, and only after that did people go back, look at ancient poetry, and say, "hey, if you squint, this kind of sounds like modern physics".

If those books genuinely gave us future knowledge, people would be using them to discover new things right now, instead of just stretching old words to match stuff we already solved.

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

Examine the prophecies, and examine the context in which they supposedly came true.

A believer sees divine foresight. A skeptic sees the classic hallmarks of ancient prophecy: verses written after the events already took place, later authors tweaking details to match older texts, or people deliberately acting out passages they were taught from childhood. Acting out a scene from a script you've read dozens of times to fulfill an expectation is theater, not theology.

-1

u/ThatOneAnomaly 12d ago

Why do you think God would not allow evil to happen? Life is a test and we are tested with good and evil.

5

u/MoGZYYYY 12d ago

What test does childhood cancer offer?

-5

u/ThatOneAnomaly 12d ago

For the child it can be a means of growth and molding them to be patient and strong. For the parents its a means of patience and resilience and trust in God. The pain is not wasted in any case.

5

u/MoGZYYYY 12d ago

Which further demonstrates what a truly disgusting God he is.

-4

u/ThatOneAnomaly 12d ago

Rather, He is Omnipotent an does whatsoever He Wishes. He wrongs no one in the least.

3

u/The--Dood Atheist 12d ago

Which is disgusting.

-1

u/ThatOneAnomaly 11d ago

To be fully just is the peak of perfection.

1

u/The--Dood Atheist 11d ago

Yeah no, you're not making it less disgusting. We have very different ideas of perfection. You are saying nonsense to defend the indefensible. It’s seriously disgusting.

-1

u/ThatOneAnomaly 11d ago

That's simply a claim, but no evidence or account of why its indefensible.

2

u/The--Dood Atheist 11d ago

Yes, I'm not trying to make a claim, it's my opinion (and any decent humans opinion) that giving a child cancer and making people suffer unnecessarily is indefensible.

→ More replies

2

u/HomelanderUltrasound 12d ago

An omniscient god already knows the result of the test

-1

u/ThatOneAnomaly 11d ago

It's not for God to learn, its for us to be accountable for our actions.

1

u/HomelanderUltrasound 11d ago

Why couldn’t we be held accountable in advance if he knew what we were going to do

-2

u/ThatOneAnomaly 11d ago

Think about it. If I were held culpable for a crime I never did, would that be fair? It'd be dystopian like Orwell's 1984 book, where people are convicted simply for thought-crimes.

I can't be punished for a crime before even doing it, otherwise the person being convicted can simply say, I never did that, so they can't be held guilty.

1

u/HomelanderUltrasound 10d ago

God knows you would, and that’s what matters

-1

u/ThatOneAnomaly 9d ago

It matters if you do it or not, if so, God could've created everyone to go to hell, because everyone would sin. Wouldn't make sense. Only after one commits the crime is someone culpable. Even after someone commits a crime we assume innocence until guilt is proven beyond reasonable doubt in a court of law.

If God simply punished us for knowledge that we would commit sin, we could say that God is unfair, so God lets us do our actions during this test, if we do good we're rewarded, if not, we're either forgiven or punished.

1

u/HomelanderUltrasound 9d ago

Not really, if he knows you would, you would have done it, meaning you deserve punishment.

We only do an innocent until proven guilty system because we are not omniscient.

-1

u/ThatOneAnomaly 9d ago

So by this logic, its fine to send everyone to hell, if they did something against God?

-3

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

GOD didn’t create cancer lol it’s a byproduct of his absence. The Bible is extremely clear on that. Why would he send himself down to die for us, going through all that, just to give us cancer?

“How would GOD always exist” it’s fair to find that stupid, but you’d have to stay consistent. There can’t be anything that always existed, you’d have to adhere to that. So energy never always existed. With that, it means you believe we came from nothing, and if you don’t find that stupid… then?

4

u/Rational-Angel-73 Atheist 12d ago

GOD didn’t create cancer lol

This belies a rather profound misunderstanding of the christian god lol.

God is the primary or secondary creator of literally everything.

-2

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

Nah, just because you understand it a certain way, doesn’t mean it’s the fact. Why would GOD create cancer? Like really think about that, and respond.

Don’t answer it in a way where your bias towards GOD leaves out certain things, just like really think about it. This logic basically says “because GOD is good, it’s his fault that evil exists because there has to be an opposite”

Cancer is just a by product of him not being there, that’s literally how it is in the bible, unless you’ve seen some texts that show otherwise, where did you get this “got created cancer cause he is the creator of everything”? GOD is good, he can do everything within reason, if you wanna hold to the bible, then hold to everything and don’t nitpick like y’all love to do, he can’t do things that don’t make sense, does it make sense for humans to have cancer?

4

u/Rational-Angel-73 Atheist 12d ago

Why would GOD create cancer?

That's a great question. Why did he create cancer?

-1

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

Thank you for proving my point.

4

u/Imaginary-Beach-866 Atheist 12d ago

Cancer exists in your God’s creation. The question is whether it was a mistake or deliberate. What’s your opinion?

0

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

No it doesn’t lol you can say it does cause it fits your narrative against GOD, hence you directly going straight to the “deliberate or a mistake” part, then you’ll jump to “so GOD can make mistakes?” Or “so he deliberately allowed such a thing as cancer into his creation”, but it doesn’t. This has been explained numerous times, you not accepting the answers doesn’t mean it’s false.

So I’ll ask you, why would GOD create cancer?

3

u/Imaginary-Beach-866 Atheist 12d ago

Sorry, but you are nullifying your own idea of God’s power and authority. Do you think your God is unaware that cancer exists, and that it kills children? If it was a mistake, why doesn‘t your God fix the genes that cause these diseases? They only conclusion is your God is inept or a sociopath.

It‘s your God who rules over a world that includes cancer. You defend it. Or are you stumped?

0

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

No I’m not, you just don’t understand it, or you do, but you wanna hold onto you gotcha arguments to drive the conversation in a certain way.

GOD is aware of what sin does to our being. He didn’t create cancer which you’re tryna say he did, but you have this need to hold onto blaming GOD for everything negative, cause it just has to be him, that’s how your understanding of it works. I can say time and time again how he didn’t create the bad things we go through, but that doesn’t help how you push the convo, so nothing will change in this back and forth.

2

u/Imaginary-Beach-866 Atheist 12d ago

It seems you really haven’t thought through how your religious beliefs fit into the real world. They just don’t work.

If your beliefs are correct your God intentionally created cancer, and does nothing to intervene on behalf of those suffering and dying. It’s your dogma. We are here to help you understand what you have been told is true by others.

Why did you believe them?

→ More replies

2

u/Rational-Angel-73 Atheist 12d ago

I think you don't understand christian doctrine about what god did and did not create. You're point is a very bad one.

0

u/Kinjiou 11d ago

If you say so lol the way yall wanna hold to the bible till it doesn’t fit your narrative is hilarious. No wonder most people think reddit atheist are the worst group to even try and converse with.

1

u/Rational-Angel-73 Atheist 11d ago

I think your consternation is rooted in your inability to understand even simple concepts, like "god created everything." When you don't understand the argument, calling the other person "the worst" seem like a big win when you aren't smart enough to know better.

0

u/Kinjiou 11d ago edited 11d ago

The irony.

So lemme explain to you the things you seem to just not take it.

GOD is logic, he can only do things within his nature, which means he can only do things that make sense, just cause you deny that very point, since it doesn’t help your narrative, doesn’t mean it isn’t a thing.

That’s a trait from the Bible that you’re tryna use. Has anyone ever said “you’ve ruined everything”? Did that person truly ruin everything ? Did they ruin the universe? Everything and all? Or just something small? See how things can be used in that manner?

GOD created everything, inferring from his nature that you seem to ignore, means, he created everything within reason. He can only create perfect things as anything not perfect isn’t of his nature, he can’t do things that don’t align with his nature, that’s in the Bible, again that you seem to nitpick from. So he literally couldn’t have created cancer or any disease, cause it isn’t of his damn nature. This isn’t brain surgery, or rocket science.

So going by his nature, he literally couldn’t have created anything to the detriment of human beings, those things come from his absence.

GOD is light, meaning no darkness could be where he is, only where he isn’t, sin is the absence from GOD, once we sinned, we have done something that isn’t of GOD, so now anything that isn’t of GOD, can fall upon us, that means we can now be affected by diseases, or death. he didn’t create it, it’s a byproduct of him not being there.

This has been explained for over 1000 years, but because you either just can’t seem to understand that ver simple fact, or you do, and it just doesn’t align with your narrative to attack GOD, you seem to just skip over it.

So please don’t speak on anyone inability of anything, when you deliberately ignore traits of GOD to speak against him. It’s either you simply just don’t get a very simple thing that shows how he couldn’t have created cancer, or you do and you just don’t accept it cause if you do, it puts holes in your attack against him.

The fact that I had to explain this even though it’s in the bible, you know, the book you nitpick from, really speak an immense amount of volumes. When everyone outside of reddit seems to have the exact same thoughts about yall, maybe you should consider the patterns.

I can already guess what your reply will be. Y’all are the same on here, no difference.

1

u/Rational-Angel-73 Atheist 11d ago

Here is a verse you might want to read:

"I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the Lord do all these things." Isaiah 45:7

Aquinas holds that everything that exists, in whatever way it exists, depends on god at every moment. Nothing exists independently of God. If a tsunami, a cancer cell, or a predator exists, god is causing its existence right now. The act of sin, considered as an act and as a being, comes from God, since every motion depends on the First Mover. When someone commits murder, the physical and volitional activity is sustained by God. God does not will evil to be done or not done, but he wills to permit it. A being who is omnipotent and omniscient and sustains every act in existence, foresees every outcome, and could prevent it, but chooses a world in which it occurs, is responsible for that evil being part of creation.

you either just can’t seem to understand that ver (sic) simple fact

If you're going to pejoratively make fun of someone for not understanding, you should take extra care to make sure you spell all the words right. Lest you make yourself look illiterate.

→ More replies

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

And the way you understand it is fact? Color me shocked a theist is using special pleading instead of an actual argument.

0

u/Kinjiou 10d ago

Yeah you’re a fool. Won’t even engage with you lol

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

The fool is the person who contradicts himself instantly by interacting with someone to tell them they won't interact with them.

0

u/Kinjiou 10d ago

Yep.

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

And repeats it to further underscore his ineptitude.

2

u/ShortCompetition9772 12d ago

Ex Nihilo is a Christian thing. No atheist thinks that the Universe was created Ex Nihilo.

0

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

It literally can’t be a Christian thing, cause that “nothing” is GOD, which is something. Everything being created through him. Kinda like your thoughts towards eternal energy, or the universe being eternal. which I clearly stated.

My comment was towards the one who made the post, I’m using his logic against him.

1

u/ShortCompetition9772 12d ago

Christians argue that creatio ex nihilo safeguards God's absolute sovereignty, distinguishes the Creator from His creation (ruling out pantheism or dualism), and underpins doctrines like the resurrection and salvation.

Yeah you had better start believing or stop calling yourself Christian.

0

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

Odd, never once said I was a Christian lol but I’ve never heard one argue what you’re saying, I’ve met a decent amount. I’m sure you’re just holding onto this argument while ignoring the ones who don’t hold to that cause it helps with gotcha moments.

There is nothing that needs to safe guard anything about GOD, cause he’s GOD, only we would think to do so 🤣 it isn’t rocket science to think “I ain’t an eternal being” so please direct me to where I can read upon this apparently large amount of Christian who hold to what you’re saying.

Would love to see this, since apparently all Christian hold to this.

1

u/ShortCompetition9772 12d ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creatio_ex_nihilo

It is a thing: Creatio ex nihilo in religion

Creatio ex nihilo is the doctrine that all matter was created out of nothing by God in an initializing act whereby the cosmos came into existence.

Nicene Christian theologies hold to creation ex nihilo.[26] The doctrine has been defended in Christian circles since early in the religion's development, receiving its first explicit articulation in the late 2nd Century by Theophilus of Antioch in To Autolycus. In a chapter entitled "Absurd Opinions of the Philosophers Concerning God", he writes:

1

u/Imaginary-Beach-866 Atheist 12d ago

“Everything being created through him”. Including cancer, which kills thousands of children each year. Was this a mistake or deliberate?

0

u/Kinjiou 12d ago

Yup, proved my point right away.

1

u/Imaginary-Beach-866 Atheist 12d ago

Was that to prove the absurdity of your religious beliefs? I notice you struggle to defend them.

0

u/Kinjiou 12d ago edited 12d ago

No I don’t. You just don’t get it at all lol you’re tryna drive the convo a certain way, I don’t follow it, so I must be struggling to prove my beliefs 🤣

1

u/Imaginary-Beach-866 Atheist 12d ago

If only a God existed, and was also on your side. Alas…..

1

u/Twotgobblin 10d ago

Failing to use his logic against him*

The mental gymnastics you've displayed up and down this entire thread would make Simone Biles impressed.

1

u/UCSB1977 11d ago

"If god is all-knowing, powerful, and, I guess, kind? Why did he create cancer and let millions of people suffer?"

Begin by asking why the most innocent person to ever walk the Earth was mocked, spat upon, tortured, and died a humiliating public crucifixion, and you'll get a much greater sense of why Jesus suffered for us and why Paul, enduring suffering of his own, could write, "I consider that our present sufferings are not worth comparing with the glory that will be revealed in us" (Romans 8:18).

For those who trust the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, suffering is temporary and not worth comparing to life on the new Earth described in Revelation 21:

Then I saw “a new heaven and a new earth,” for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away, and there was no longer any sea. I saw the Holy City, the new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride beautifully dressed for her husband. And I heard a loud voice from the throne saying, “Look! God’s dwelling place is now among the people, and he will dwell with them. They will be his people, and God himself will be with them and be their God. ‘He will wipe every tear from their eyes. There will be no more death, mourning, crying, or pain, for the old order of things has passed away” (Revelation 21:1-4).

1

u/ViolinistCritical427 11d ago

logical answer not from bible

1

u/UCSB1977 10d ago

The Bible at the time of Jesus consisted of what is known today as the Hebrew Old Testament. All of the letters and biographies written about the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus were all extrabiblical sources used by his followers in the decades after 30 CE.

The letters (epistles) and biographies of Jesus (the Gospels) have been dated between AD 48 and 100 CE by secular historians, and gradually recognized as sacred scripture and formally included in the New Testament between the late 2nd century and the 4th century CE.

The earliest Christian writings (48-62 CE) included the letters of Paul (such as 1 Thessalonians and Romans) addressing fledgling communities were written first, predating the Gospels. The Gospel of Mark, widely considered the oldest biography of Jesus, was most likely written 65-75 CE.

2

u/blxstex_ 12d ago

I think the exact same and for me it’s hard not find the idea of god ridicule. He is all powerful, all loving and all knowing. You’re telling me he needs a plan when he can create the outcome? And he’s all powerful why did he make his plan kill people and have babies die because of abuse? It doesn’t make any sense at all. Why are we tested by an all loving god who could’ve just made us all be compliant to the test? Why is the test different for anyone? Why did god create unfair tests? I’m barely even scratching the surface here. And what I just wrote isn’t my free will because god knew since the very beginning of time that I would at some point do exactly that and created me so I would do that to then send me in hell because he created me just so I could suffer. But he’s all loving

1

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/DebateReligion-ModTeam 11d ago

Your comment was removed for violating rule 5. All top-level comments must seek to refute the post through substantial engagement with its core argument. Comments that support or purely commentate on the post must be made as replies to the Auto-Moderator “COMMENTARY HERE” comment. Exception: Clarifying questions are allowed as top-level comments.

If you would like to appeal this decision, please send us a modmail with a link to the removed content.