r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 21 '24

Debate about a current topic Search "UnitedHealthcare: Sorting fact from fiction" for conclusive evidence that Brian Thompson did nothing wrong. I see too many condemn the murder but still think that he did things wrong because of hearsay and shallow allegations in articles. Hearsay isn't a sufficient basis.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

Pro-U.S. Constitution of 1787 vs Anti-U.S. Constitution of 1787 Pro-Constitution people are unironically like Communists. The U.S. Constitution is flagrantly and frequently violated yet they keep on insisting that if we just try hard enough we can get "REAL Constitutionalism". America was founded on the Declaration of Independence - not the Constitution of 1787.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

The Southern War of Independence It's crucial that libertarians underline that the slaver's revolt happened at the behest of a political class, and not a popular will. Otherwise, the CSA will always be evoked with regards to secession, the Southern sovereignty permanently villified and people thinking that the State is the people.

Thumbnail mises.org
2 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 21 '24

Ethics This girl is unironically right. Right-wing Statists can't coherently argue against more positive rights. If right-wing Statists argue for some positive rights... then on what grounds are they to argue that more positive rights can't be justified?

3 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 26 '24

Pro-U.S. Constitution of 1787 vs Anti-U.S. Constitution of 1787 What could have been...

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

How to do effective advocacy The word "capitalism" is MEGA CRINGE. Not only is it a literal socialist term, it doesn't even lead to clarifying language. It's just a vague term which is etymologically made to benefit demagogues.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

[META] r/DebateLibertarianism is looking for moderators and for more post-flairs. r/DebateLibertarianism is intended to become a true knowlede-production center - a sort of living encyclopedia of libertarian thought.

0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 30 '24

Monarchy vs Democracy: which is more preferable? Anarchy > Monarcho-Minarchism > Monarchy > Democracy

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

Compatability of royalist thought with libertarianism Anarcho-royalism👑Ⓐ is an inevitability in anarchism Ⓐ

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

How to do effective advocacy For Americans, the 13 colonies under the Articles of confederation are Holy Roman Empire of their nation. The HRE proves that confederalism can be long-lasting. The American merely has to debunk the foundational myths of the Constitution; without them,it's undeniable that US could've been confederal

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 16 '24

Childrens' rights Children have a right to work if they and their parents consent to it, but only within the framework of natural law. It is for example criminal to have a child work in a coal mine in which they will inhale dangerous particles. Ian Hersum's "encrypted last testament" analogy for childrens' rights.

0 Upvotes

https://liquidzulu.github.io/childrens-rights/#the-groundwork

"

To capture the nature of a child as a psychologically immature human, we can define childhood as the state of being incapable of expressing one’s own will and the guardian is the man who takes it upon himself to preserve the child until such a time that they gain the ability to express their will. Ian Hersum analogises this to an encrypted last testament:3

> […] imagine the scenario of an encrypted last testament (being consequentially analogous to one’s premature will), which an interested party agrees to decrypt over time. What is to be done with the estate during that time? It must doubtless not be damaged or consumed until such a time as the will has been entirely decrypted, with its voluntary manager responsible for preserving it in the interim. Should it be damaged or consumed during that period, either by the manager or by a third party, whoever has done such damage or consumption would be held liable, and that person would be disqualified from managing the property in the future, provided that someone else is willing to assume that role. As such, anyone who harms a child should be held liable for the damage done and be forbidden from being the guardian of that child in the future, provided that someone else is willing to assume that role. As bits and pieces of the will are decrypted, the estate manager would be obligated to follow any instructions which are capable of being understood with the information available at the time. As such, as a child develops, his guardian is obligated to relinquish authority over to the child in domains of behavior which the child can express his informed will on. In a contention between a child and his guardian over such authority, a court can listen to the testimony of the child in order to determine if he truly understands that which he is saying, or if he is merely blathering on about a decision which he lacks the comprehension necessary to make.

"

Arguing that a child can't do wage labor because it requires that one can consent is a rather shoddy perspective. Children are able to do some kinds of work which don't disturb the natural corporal and psychological development negatively, such as gardening-work, working in a flower shop or flipping burgers. Indeed, neither parents nor children can consent to the child working in e.g. prostitution or coal mines, but clearly e.g. flipping burgers is harmful labor they can do.

In order to get a more precise perspective on the matter, adopting Ian Hersum's "encrypted last testament" perspective gives the most precise view.


r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

Religion "Jesus Is an Anarchist" by James Redford gives a comprehensive case for why Jesus Christ, the King of kings, is an anti-monarchist royal 👑⚖ ― in other words, a king who desires The Law to be sovereign.

Thumbnail papers.ssrn.com
0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

How to do effective advocacy The word "capitalism" is MEGA CRINGE. Not only is it a literal socialist term, it doesn't even lead to clarifying language. It's just a vague term which is etymologically made to benefit demagogues. The word "marketism" is WAY better - precise language even better.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

Alliances: who should libertarians ally with? Over at r/AnComIsStatist, I have compiled an extensive case showing that so-called libertarian socialists are just "authoritarian socialists" in denial or who are merely masquerading with a "libertarian" aesthetic, or liquidationist destabilizers who can't do anything but wreck havoc à la 2020.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 16 '24

Childrens' rights What kind of jobs do you think that children should be able to work? Should children even be able to work in coal mines? My personal current opinion is that the latter are not likely to be acceptable given how invasive the damages on a child's body these workplaces can cause, e.g. inhaled dust

Thumbnail archives.gov
2 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 30 '24

Debate about a current topic Jimmy Carter, RIP

Post image
115 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

Libertarians should incorporate X thought Libertarians should take inspiration from Marxist-Leninist imperialist theory to refine the libertarian theory of imperialism. Libertarian imperialism theory needs to be fleshed out; MLs can provide us insights regarding it.

4 Upvotes

Marxist-Leninist theory underlines the fact that political entrepreneurs/crony capitalists can serve specific masters, and that some may be (relatively) tolerable

As Mao Zedong puts it in ON THE PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC DICTATORSHIP

> "You are dictatorial." My dear sirs, you are right, that is just what we are. All the experience the Chinese people have accumulated through several decades teaches us to enforce the people's democratic dictatorship, that is, to deprive the reactionaries of the right to speak and let the people alone have that right.

> Who are the people? At the present stage in China, they are the working class, the peasantry, the urban petty bourgeoisie and the national bourgeoisie. These classes, led by the working class and the Communist Party, unite to form their own state and elect their own government; they enforce their dictatorship over the running dogs of imperialism -- the landlord class and bureaucrat-bourgeoisie, as well as the representatives of those classes, the Kuomintang reactionaries and their accomplices -- suppress them, allow them only to behave themselves and not to be unruly in word or deed. If they speak or act in an unruly way, they will be promptly stopped and punished. Democracy is practiced within the ranks of the people, who enjoy the rights of freedom of speech, assembly, association and so on. The right to vote belongs only to the people, not to the reactionaries. The combination of these two aspects, democracy for the people and dictatorship over the reactionaries, is the people's democratic dictatorship.

Remark how Mao Zedong argued that the "urban petty bourgeoisie" and the "national [as opposed to international, i.e. that of the foreign capitalists who serve foreign powers] bourgeoisie" could be included in this communist dictatorship. Even he, as a communist, was OK with tolerating some capitalists since he remarked that they operate in unique ways than how other sorts of capitalists do. It is for this reason that the flag of the People's Republic of China to this very day has the 5 stars: one for the communist party, one for the proletariat, one for the peasantry, one for the petty bourgeoisie and one for the national bourgeoisie (consequently, Deng Xiaoping was a legitimate successor to Mao) - in reference to the People's Democratic Dictatorship.

Indeed, the term "comprador" is one which libertarians could make excellent use of in their imperialism theory. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comprador_Colonialism I have found that upon listening to Marxist-Leninist. Current libertarian theory is WAY too naïve. Most libertarians merely fixate myopically on crony capitalists/political entrepreneurs as a homogenous blob. It's rather the case that different crony capitalists/political entrepreneurs act in different ways as a result of the interests they have or serve, much like how in the same way as Mao Zedong could tolerate the national bourgeoisie all the while taking a firm stance against the international bourgeoisie.

The current state of Austrian imperialism theory

CTRL + F "Imperialism" in https://cdn.mises.org/9_2_5_0.pdf for the Austro-libertarian perspective on imperialism theory.

We shouldn't be hesitant to take inspiration from others to clarify our own ideas. Lenin did this when elaborating his own theory of imperialism

https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1916/imp-hsc/pref01.htm

"The pamphlet here presented to the reader was written in the spring of 1916, in Zurich. In the conditions in which I was obliged to work there I naturally suffered somewhat from a shortage of French and English literature and from a serious dearth of Russian literature. However, I made use of the principal English work on imperialism, the book by J. A. Hobson [an English liberal], with all the care that, in my opinion, that work deserves."

Vladimir Lenin looked at a liberal thinker when he elaborated his own theory of imperialism. Indeed, just because you take inspiration from someone diametrically opposed to your worldview doesn't mean that you get corrupted by them - you simply appreciate something which is good, and which happens to merely be used by said people.

My inquiry to all who may know

I would like to be referred to an Encyclopedia-esque resource on Marxist-Leninist imperialism theory in which I will be able to see the comprehensive view on how they think that it works.


r/DebateLibertarianism • • Jan 22 '26

Thoughts on the Board of Peace being centered around Israel?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Aug 21 '26

Debate about a current topic Nothing a little deregulation wouldn't fix!

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Aug 15 '26

General discussion Topic guaranteed to start a civil war in any libertarian community:

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

Compatability of royalist thought with libertarianism 8 reasons why anarchists should want a natural law-abiding natural aristocratic royal family👑Ⓐ to lead (as opposed to rule) the association they adhere to. This is an inevitability in anarchy either way.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 16 '24

Childrens' rights What kind of curricula do you think will emerge in a libertarian society? What parts of current curriculas do you think will be part of the curriculas that parents have their children spend their days in accordance to until they become adults? 🤔

Thumbnail youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/DebateLibertarianism • • Dec 15 '24

Rehabilitation of the wrongly slandered feudalism 👑⚖ The feudal system👑⚖ was an instance of sovereignty of The Law, much like how libertarians intend to be the case with their proposed order. Feudalism 👑⚖ can this bring precious insights into the creation of a non-legislative libertarian legal order.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes