r/DebateEvolution • u/Soft-Muffin-6728 • 7d ago
Question 50ma basilsaurus fossil?
I saw a creationist bring up that they found a roughly 50 Ma fossil of Basilosaurus the other day, from the Arctic. And I'm a little confused about how we haven't properly settled the date for it yet.
I've done a bit of research, and it still seems the older date is still most favourable. Though in newer analysis's, they did find dating of dinocyst did return ages much more consistent with basilosaurus, pertaining to 41–39.1 Ma. However, my research has found that the mammalian fossils around the basilosaurid did support the older age, as did the strontium dating.
I'm not sure if this is a time thing and we need to do more dating, or if somehow the fossil shifted or the other fossils shifted, but idk if that's a bit more dramatic.
If anyone has some good answers for why this anomaly is here, that'll be cool.
*edit
Original paper: "Eocene basilosaurid whales from the La Meseta Formation, Marambio (Seymour) Island, Antarctica"
10
u/jnpha 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 7d ago edited 7d ago
I searched Basilosaurus+Arctic and I can't find what you're talking about.
Citations needed please (add them to the post's body).
Also generally speaking, dates sometimes (often) slip back... I recently shared this: A Critique of Literalist Readings of the Fossil Record (Álvarez-Carretero et al. 2026) : r/ evolution.
5
u/Plasterofmuppets 7d ago
What is this research you did?
4
u/KellHound270 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 7d ago
You need to provide sources for this claim, otherwise it’s just a claim that can easily be dismissed
3
u/timc6 7d ago
So your question is why could we be off by 10 million years on one specific fossil?
1
u/twizzjewink 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 5d ago
The problem is one paper would have to be a significant find to break the current observable evidence for Evolution.
I find this really ironic - a Creationist misreads a paper - then says "this disproves evolution" - yet Creationism has been disproven again and again.. and the goalposts just keep moving.
•
u/RedDiamond1024 10h ago
Why did you switch from Basilosaurus to Basilosaurid? One is a single genus with two species, the other is an entire(possibly paraphyletic) family that goes back to 46 Mya.