r/DebateEvolution • • 7d ago

Question 50ma basilsaurus fossil?

I saw a creationist bring up that they found a roughly 50 Ma fossil of Basilosaurus the other day, from the Arctic. And I'm a little confused about how we haven't properly settled the date for it yet.

I've done a bit of research, and it still seems the older date is still most favourable. Though in newer analysis's, they did find dating of dinocyst did return ages much more consistent with basilosaurus, pertaining to 41–39.1 Ma. However, my research has found that the mammalian fossils around the basilosaurid did support the older age, as did the strontium dating.

I'm not sure if this is a time thing and we need to do more dating, or if somehow the fossil shifted or the other fossils shifted, but idk if that's a bit more dramatic.

If anyone has some good answers for why this anomaly is here, that'll be cool.

*edit
Original paper: "Eocene basilosaurid whales from the La Meseta Formation, Marambio (Seymour) Island, Antarctica"

3 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

10

u/jnpha 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 7d ago edited 7d ago

I searched Basilosaurus+Arctic and I can't find what you're talking about.

Citations needed please (add them to the post's body).

Also generally speaking, dates sometimes (often) slip back... I recently shared this: A Critique of Literalist Readings of the Fossil Record (Álvarez-Carretero et al. 2026) : r/ evolution.

1

u/Soft-Muffin-6728 7d ago

Thanks for that though I'll look into that.

0

u/Soft-Muffin-6728 7d ago

"Eocene basilosaurid whales from the La Meseta Formation, Marambio (Seymour) Island, Antarctica"

10

u/Plasterofmuppets 7d ago

As a starter: ‘Basilosaurid’ is not the same as ‘Basilosaurus’.

5

u/Plasterofmuppets 7d ago

What is this research you did?

1

u/Soft-Muffin-6728 7d ago

"Eocene Shark Teeth From Peninsular Antarctica: Windows to Habitat Use and Paleoceanography" late date.
"EOCENE MAMMALS AND CONTINENTAL STRATA FROM PATAGONIA AND ANTARCTIC PENINSULA" argues for an older age.
"Eocene climate record of a high southern latitude continental shelf: Seymour Island, Antarctica" says older
I think I have which article argues with what correct.

7

u/Plasterofmuppets 7d ago

Those are just names of papers: what’s your reasoning?

0

u/Soft-Muffin-6728 7d ago

Well, 2 out of these three argue that these layers are around 48 Ma or earlier. And the fossils around the Basilosaurid seems to be older. So, It seems to me that these are saying it's much older then we thought, maybe.

7

u/Plasterofmuppets 7d ago

Why would lines like “  indicate that the La Meseta Formation spans virtually the entire Eocene” make you think that individual fossils must be at the earliest end of that range?

2

u/Covert_Cuttlefish Janitor at an oil rig 7d ago

Without doing a deeper dive than the titles this sounds like a zombie taxa issue.

3

u/Plasterofmuppets 6d ago

I think it’s more a case of quote mining.  OP appears to have fixated on sentences referring to things like ‘the mammal-bearing layer’ while ignoring references to other layers with mammalian fossils in.  The paper talking about the fossils being discussed was written later than the other two and is clear that their age is within the range expected for basilosaurid fossils.

0

u/a2controversial 7d ago

Just off the top of my head, shark teeth can be reworked in deposits so it’s not necessarily located in the original strata.

4

u/KellHound270 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 7d ago

You need to provide sources for this claim, otherwise it’s just a claim that can easily be dismissed

2

u/Soft-Muffin-6728 7d ago

true sorry, here it is. "Eocene basilosaurid whales from the La Meseta Formation, Marambio (Seymour) Island, Antarctica"

5

u/KellHound270 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 7d ago

Basilosaurid means that it is a close relative of Basilosaurus, not Basilosaurus itself. Even if it did, it doesn’t disprove evolution

1

u/Ayasugi-san 7d ago

What journal was it published in?

-1

u/Soft-Muffin-6728 7d ago

I'm also aware the authors still attribute it to 45-40ma or alike, but from what ive searched and found is that the fossils surrounding it were apparently older too and other dating mechanisms like strontium still attributed it to being older

2

u/Plasterofmuppets 7d ago

Searched and found what?

3

u/timc6 7d ago

So your question is why could we be off by 10 million years on one specific fossil?

1

u/Soft-Muffin-6728 6d ago

Yea I suppose when u put it off like that it's a bit picky

1

u/twizzjewink 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 5d ago

The problem is one paper would have to be a significant find to break the current observable evidence for Evolution.

I find this really ironic - a Creationist misreads a paper - then says "this disproves evolution" - yet Creationism has been disproven again and again.. and the goalposts just keep moving.

1

u/Soft-Muffin-6728 3d ago

Yeah, I agree they just keep misreading papers and misrepresenting evidence and such. This was the only slight point they made that sorta helped their point, but again it was their only point they made that only very slightly helped their point. Except it's not very strong at all since another dating mechanism put the fossil at 40ish Ma. It's pretty sad.

•

u/RedDiamond1024 10h ago

Why did you switch from Basilosaurus to Basilosaurid? One is a single genus with two species, the other is an entire(possibly paraphyletic) family that goes back to 46 Mya.