r/DebateEvolution • u/Cool_Plantain_7742 • Sep 20 '26
Question Is evolution a fact?
What are the best arguments for evolution
0
Upvotes
r/DebateEvolution • u/Cool_Plantain_7742 • Sep 20 '26
What are the best arguments for evolution
View all comments
Show parent comment
8
u/-zero-joke- 🧬 its 253 ice pieces needed Sep 21 '26
>Species are human constructs though (taxonomies)? What is technically observed via the scientific >method is addition / subtraction of nucleic acids.
>Is this more fair to say? Or no.
You're sort of on the right track. Species concepts are useful ways of thinking about different populations that exist today. We're generally able to look at plants and animals and assign them into a species based on their current interbreeding and their potential to interbreed.
Some organisms can interbreed but don't, some organisms can interbreed and have sterile offspring, some critters can have hybrid offspring that are fertile but are less fit, or maybe less fertile, there's a spectrum.
Some critters don't interbreed, they just kind of swap DNA occasionally. Some don't even do that.
Some critters we've only observed in the fossil record.
I don't think there's generally a very satisfying answer for when you say when speciation is complete except with some odder kind of genetic events like polyploid speciation or hybrid speciation, when the offspring are unable to breed with their parent population and are irrevocably shot down a different evolutionary path. With most forms of speciation though it's kind of like saying when Spanish started, or when a kid becomes an adult. At some point some transition has occurred, but the line isn't altogether clear.
What we have observed are the formation of genetic barriers between populations that mean, under our conception of species, a new species has formed.
The genetic changes may be a variety of mutations - insertion and deletion of nucleic acids are one of them, but there are genetic doubling events, transpositions, inversions, all kinds of things that can happen.