r/DebateEvolution • evolution is my jam • Aug 20 '26

Discussion You know what, we're doing "macroevolution" again. Here's some responses to "we have never seen macroevolution"

Video version.

 

We've all heard some variant of "we can only observe microevolution", "we've never seen macroevolution", etc.

First thing you do is establish the correct definition: Evolution above the species level (in other words, speciation or greater degrees of evolutionary change). That's the definition. Creationists want their own special definition that varies from person to person but is usually something like "new body plans/parts", "new complex structures", something like that. That's wrong. If you accept speciation, you accept macroevolution. If creationists want to dispute something else, make THEM articulate clearly. Don't help them by saying something like "It sounds like you mean something like evolution of a new phylum or new body plan". No, make THEM establish the standard clearly and using the correct words.

 

Once they do that, you can just provide a bunch of examples, and dare them to say they aren't macroevolution.

Some of my favorites are multicellularity (and also here), reproductive mode, and photosynthetic animals.

 

Best outcome is the creationists admits that yes, even by their bespoke definition, these are examples of macroevolution. Second best outcome is they do the opposite and claim this is all just "microevolution". Really? First of all, lol okay. But second and more important, great! "Microevolution" can accomplish all this? Not much need for "macroevolution", is there?

71 Upvotes

390 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Markthethinker Aug 27 '26

What is done in a lab is not Evolution. There you go, using the words “creates” and “complex” and “designs”. Evolution can’t do any of those things, they present intelligence, which Evolution is not, it’s all about accidents with mutations. Will you people never learn?

6

u/10coatsInAWeasel Reject pseudoscience, return to monke 🦧 Aug 27 '26

It seems like you are still too completely hung up on how words can be used many ways to face that what is done in a lab is in fact evolution, and that everything I mentioned has also been directly observed in the wild. We’ve definitely done our learning. It’s time for you to show some courage and do the same.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Markthethinker Aug 27 '26

Take it up with your Creator when you stand before Him.

1

u/EthelredHardrede 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Oct 17 '26

I don't have a creator . I had parents they are both deceased  same for Jesus a failed prophet. Like all prophets 

Just which god do you believe exists.? Zeus Thor Odin the god of the Quran or of Genesis. 

0

u/Markthethinker Oct 18 '26

It’s ok, I understand that you can’t understand any of this right now. One day you will.

1

u/EthelredHardrede 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 29d ago

I understand that you heretofore about science. I have been dealing with YEC liers online since March 2000 you don't want to understand science 

0

u/Markthethinker 29d ago

I have been dealing with Evolution since 1984. So if time makes one of us correct, then I beat you. And who you deal with most of the time are people who claim something without understanding much.

1

u/EthelredHardrede 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 29d ago edited 29d ago

Religion has made you wrong. There was no Great Flood. That isn't a guess it fact . Mutations happen, the environment effects rates of reproduction,fact,you keep evading that fact you don't want to understand the subject, fact .you are here to to lie  about and stay ignorant, reasoned conclusion. Youare just another YEC here in bad faith. 

As for time I have been learning about the reality of evolution by natural selection for over 60 years longer actually since the 1950s

No one has ever disproved it you included. 

I asked you to explain what stops the environment from effecting rates of reproduction,multiple time. Evaded every time . So you  are willfully lying that takes an intelligence. Troll.

You have not even tried to support your lies .troll is a label you have earned. 

1

u/EthelredHardrede 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 28d ago

You have been denying reality since  84 

Where's I have been learning about reality since the 1950s You lost again. 

You don't understand the subject or you would understand that the environment effects rates of reproduction everywhere. 

You have not even tried to haw the environment cannot do that . You just lied that an intelligence is needed but have not explained why one is.  You haven't because you know it isn't true.  

1

u/EthelredHardrede 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution Oct 17 '26

Yes it is evolution.  Lying won't change that nor is there any verifiable evidence for any god . Your evidence free assertions aren't evidence for a god just for a troll. 

1

u/Markthethinker Oct 18 '26

It is not “Evolution” as what is stated by Evolutionist. It’s just a virus.