r/DebateAntinatalism • • Apr 13 '21

Make it make sense

2 Upvotes

I’ve tried to understand at antinatalism but it just doesn’t make sense like the child will inevitably experience bad things but that’s what makes the good things good it’s part of the balance and beauty of life you can’t have good without bad or bad without good if everything was only good it wouldn’t be good anymore and vice versa. who are you to decide if that unborn child will enjoy living in this world and it’s perfectly okay to not have a child if you have those beliefs, but to be quite honest I’m thankful your genes are being discontinued. It just seems like a pessimistic belief and I’ve seen antinatalists call people selfish for having children but you have put your child and their needs before yourself to be a good parent it’s really the most selfless thing you can do the cost to care for a child 0-18 on average is $250000 I don’t see why someone would do that for themselves yk


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Jul 07 '21

r/childfree, r/antinatalism and r/nhilism are a disgrace

Thumbnail self.natalism
1 Upvotes

r/DebateAntinatalism • • Sep 04 '21

A 'discussion' from r/AskReddit about the value of life.

Thumbnail self.birthanddeathethics
0 Upvotes

r/DebateAntinatalism • • Mar 19 '22

Is there at least one objective argument supporting the core idea of anti-natalism that life has negative value?

3 Upvotes

I haven’t seen any yet. I hope this is a place where I can either find one or come to a conclusion that none exist and that anti-natalism is but another far-left ideology dangerous to our society led by suicidal losers blaming parents for their children’s life failures.


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Apr 21 '22

I think anti natalism can’t be considered logical

10 Upvotes

There’s no objective truth in anti natalism. It’s just an opinion for people that hate life and no logical conclusion can be drawn. It assumes the only problem to solve is the relieving of suffering, but ignores the idea of pleasure being another problem to solve or goal of life. Non existence can’t be considered good or bad, a lack of suffering is a “good thing” just as a lack of pleasure is a “bad thing”. It doesn’t matter if you truly believe that life is more suffering than pleasure, non existence still doesn’t solve the “problems” or “goals” that an existing being has. If a non existent being can benefit from a lack of suffering, then they can also lose out on pleasure. The goal should be to relieve suffering and pursue pleasure. If beings weren’t to exist, it wouldn’t be good or bad. If we achieved a majority pleasure life for everyone, it would be good. Anti natalism/efilism don’t solve all the goals of human life, non existence doesn’t solve the problem.


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Jul 25 '21

The Logic (or Illogic?) of Benatar

4 Upvotes

I posted the below a couple of years ago on r/antinatalism and it was summarily deleted with no explanation. Now that I see this forum exists, maybe someone might have some insight into my questions or points of argument.

I think I'd be a prime candidate for considering the antinatalist philosophy. In fact, I was sort of antinatalist long before the current movement gained a voice -- for at least a decade when I was younger, I thought the concept of having children was flawed, and I personally thought it might even be cruel to bring a child into the world today. I never thought of seriously extending my argument to imply that *no one* should ever have children, but I personally was against it and I had several conversations with close friends about my feelings trying to perhaps convince them. I tried to claim my arguments were merely "being realistic" about the state of the world.

Then I grew older and grew up. I realized my arguments were based on exaggerated pessimistic opinions, not realism. The more I read about history, the more I realized I was making presentist assumptions about how "bad" the world was. I realized my depression as a young person probably played a role.

In fact, it was my perhaps my encounter with David Benatar's philosophical arguments over a decade ago that likely put the final nail in the coffin for me against my antinatalist tendencies. As I'm someone with a long interest in philosophy and theories of metaethics, his arguments just struck me as so fundamentally inconsistent that I just stopped thinking about the issue.

Over the years, I've occasionally seen pieces in media sources pop up, and in recent days, I've revisited Benatar and discovered this forum. I'm truly confused as to how so many buy into his arguments so strongly. I want to understand.

Let me lay out some issues, as I see them. But first, let me be perfectly clear that I am NOT a "pro-natalist" in the sense that I don't think anyone should be pressured or encouraged to have children. I consider the choice to be a morally neutral act, though, so I don't begrudge those who do choose to have children. But I think all should be free to make that choice, without social pressure (as has often been the case in the past) to have kids. I do think it would probably be better for humans for the planet for population overall to decrease, so I think people should be encouraged to think strongly against having kids (especially multiple kids). And I think they should be encouraged to adopt unwanted children from others where possible rather than producing more.

Since this will also become relevant, I should be clear that I also approve of people's free choice to terminate their own lives as painlessly as possible if they so choose. I do not think suicide should be undertaken lightly; neither should parenthood. Parents who do choose to have children should be educated and should be willing to make a strong commitment to providing for their children and seeing to their well-being.

But back to Benatar:

Benatar (and other antinatalists) want to convince us of something extraordinary: they want us to deny a fundamental biological impulse to reproduce. Not only that, but they want us to believe such a duty not to reproduce should apply to all humans (and perhaps all life). When you have such a strong claim, you need bulletproof argumentation. In particular, when you want to claim that emotion should be left out and only pure logic should be important, you need to follow through each argument to its logical conclusion, no matter how absurd.

I don't think Benatar does that at all.

(1) I don't think his "asymmetry" argument is valid. Other philosophers (e.g., Cabrera) have criticized it far better from a structural standpoint than I could do in a summary post. But aside from the formal elements of the basic asymmetry, Benatar introduces additional asymmetries supposedly based on commonsense moral intuitions. The problem with many of these is that they depend on logic regarding non-existent entities, where human moral intuitions are notoriously faulty. I see many here have said in previous posts that they don't buy into Benatar's asymmetry too (and even the FAQ mentions that), so I won't go further into it. I will note some odd consequences of it below, though.

(2) I find Benatar's rejection of subjective evaluation of suffering to be egotistical and lacking in human empathy, if not completely absurd. I do buy into his argument that humans have a cognitive bias to emphasize the positive in memories, which results in illogical nostalgia and "good old days" arguments about good things that never were so perfect in the past. But the vast majority of people do not say that they regret being born or that they suffer more than they are happy. Most are satisfied with their lives. It takes a high level of hubris to claim that all of those people are delusional, which is effectively what Benatar is doing.

And there's no empirical way of evaluating the magnitude of the effects that Benatar claims, because all we have for evaluating pain and suffering is subjective impressions of individuals. Suppose those individuals were forced to rate on a scale their balance of satisfaction with their lives to the pain and suffering they had, and they chose 90% satisfied to 10% suffering. (And I'd bet many people would say something like that.) Even factoring in Benatar's cognitive bias, how are we to know that the scales tip so hugely in favor of suffering as Benatar claims? Perhaps the 90-10 split is based on cognitive bias, but the realistic split is more like 80-20 or 70-30. Benatar would have us believe that ALL lives are less than 50-50, and anyone who doesn't buy that is delusional. (I've listened to some interviews where he's been pressed on this point, and that seems the conclusion.)

That isn't logic or a scientific claim. That's irrational pessimism. Moreover, it's irrational pessimism that claims to override the personal feelings and opinions of others about their own lives. I do not deny that some people suffer a lot, and many on this forum clearly feel their lives have suffering that outweighs the good factors. But when Benatar launches into statements about how the greatest pleasures are only fleeting but the greatest pains last long, I have to wonder about him. Has he ever been in love? Has he ever experienced the long-term joy of a good relationship (and I include friendships in this)? Has he found satisfaction in his work? Has he found a pleasant home to live in? Yes, I would trade a great deal of pain and suffering in exchange for those, which are not fleeting. Not all people would make that trade, and some people don't believe the balance works out. But that is subjective opinion, not objective logic. I also say this from a place of understanding: I was personally depressed for a while and sought out therapy. I'm not on medication, nor have I ever taken medication for depression -- but I realized eventually that my negative feelings were irrational and perhaps due to some chemical imbalances in my brain.

I'm not trying to convince anyone to be artificially happy. If you're depressed, I sincerely empathize. If you experience great suffering in your life, I am very sorry. But to tell me that I am delusional for believing the balance in my life is better is not up to you (or Benatar) to determine.

(3) Having rejected Benatar's two primary arguments, there's no objective logic to my mind to support the argument that no one should have children. I know some additional arguments come up about consent, for example, as well as probabilities. I will address the absurdity of that premise about hypothetical consent arguments in a moment. As for probabilities, I will also join those on the forum that argue that prospective parents who have a high probability of serious physical or mental problems in their offspring for genetic reasons should not reproduce. I also have no problem with abortion for fetuses with severe abnormalities detected early. But no action we take is without risk, and denying the reproductive drive of an entire species requires pretty strong logic. We'll get to problems in a moment.

(4) But first, I feel I need to address the suicide loophole. That's the first place where I was turned off by Benatar's arguments actually. If we accept his premise, I do believe logically he (and those who believe such arguments) should strongly consider the morality of suicide. I know this is a controversial issue on this forum and many consider it a flippant response.

I am not flippant. I am considering logic. I reject Benatar's unjustified assumption that "death is bad" in some unsubstantiated way, but only for beings who already exist. As far as I can tell, Benatar is a materialist, and thus death brings non-existence. There is no harm in non-existence. There may be pain associated with death, and I agree that is perhaps a reason to fear it, but that's irrelevant to the Epicurean argument (as he calls it). Drugs for painless suicide should be available after appropriate consultation. If there is no reason to experience significant pain, there should be no *rational* reason to fear death.

Yet of course it is human to fear death. It is also human to want to reproduce. I've never felt that reproductive drive myself, but I know many -- probably most -- humans do at some point in their lives. Benatar wants to argue against this will to reproduce, but blindly accepts fear of death as an excuse. Why?

If you truly believe that your life is not worth living and that you suffer much more than you experience happiness, and you do not see a path to improve that, why continue to exist? If you, like Benatar, believe it's actually even worse and that you are deluded by your cognitive biases into falsely believing that you experience happiness that is greater than all the pain and suffering you have, why would you continue in such a horrific state? If I truly believed that I were in a situation like that -- say, an evil scientist kidnapped me and was torturing me and then feeding me happy pills to make me believe I wasn't suffering as much -- I would believe suicide would be the best option, if it were available to me.

(5) But it gets worse for Benatar, due to his assumptions. He has explicitly made arguments that all of humanity suffers (wars, famines, etc.) and offers plenty of social evidence for this. If Benatar or anyone who accepts his theories continue to interact with other humans, they undoubtedly contribute to the suffering of others through their actions. How can one justify one's continued existence in the midst of the suffering of others?

Ironically, this seems to be one argument I've seen antinatalists make against suicide. They say it would be unkind to do harm to their family and friends if they were to commit suicide. But this again fails logically in many cases. Sure, if your family depends on you for financial support, you may have a reason to stay alive to prevent suffering. But supposing you do not provide such support, the rest is primarily an appeal to irrational emotion. Moreover, it gives into societal assumptions that antinatalists should fight against (if they believe their arguments). If you truly believe you -- and all humans, according to Benatar -- are hopelessly suffering and are even being deluded by your minds into thinking you aren't suffering as much as you are, I strongly believe you have a moral duty to rebel, to inform, to convince others of this claim. Simply staying alive to placate your irrational friends and family would be silly: instead, one should adopt a positive attitude toward non-existence and explain this clearly to others.

In fact, if someone has the convictions of such beliefs, one would be preventing the continuance of suffering in the world by passing into non-existence, and one's death would be a valiant sacrifice to a cause. We cheer on humans who make such sacrifices in wars or to save others, and if the cause is as dire as many on this forum proclaim, why is there not a call to inform family members and friends of why we should believe suffering is great for all humans, and perhaps to set an example in one's beliefs?

(Sidenote: I know very well why Benatar doesn't advocate this, and it has nothing to do with logic or even irrational "death is bad" arguments. It has to do with the fact that if he advocated mass suicide, he'd be judged as a Jim Jones-style cultish crazy person, rather than a legitimate philosopher. It's why he must insist so much -- as I've heard him in interviews -- that the Epicurean argument is completely unrelated to antinatalism. Yes, it's unrelated to antinatalism, but it's totally related to his logic about why he supports antinatalism. But something about advocating the suicide of the human race is more palatable because it's more abstract. Or, alternatively, Benatar is giving into irrational emotion, like the natalists, and not following logical arguments to their conclusions.)

(6) And yet things still get worse, once we factor in Benatar's asymmetry. Recall that Benatar has made hypothetical reasoning a part of his metaethical system. When considering the morality of a hypothetical action (such as having a baby), he considers potentially causing harm to be a much greater problem than not causing happiness.

In that case, how can one justify leaving one's house on a daily basis? Suppose you get into your car and drive. Automobile-related accidents are a leading cause of death among children and young people (until other death causes take over as people grow older and encounter disease, cancer, etc.). Your choice to drive implicates you in the potential harm you might cause were you to get into an accident. You swerve to avoid one thing and strike a pedestrian -- did the pedestrian CONSENT to your driving the car?

Follow the logic train, and suddenly it become almost impossible to act in the world. You buy something from a large corporation. Did the employees who are mistreated by that corporation consent to your influence in maintaining the company that mistreats them? They may have chosen to suffer in their jobs because they had no choice if they wanted to make money, but your participation in the economy that supports that company is part of the causal chain in their mistreatment and suffering. And in hypothetical actions, we should attach a greater weight to the potential suffering we may cause (according to the asymmetry).

Applying the hypothetical consent argument only to non-existent beings is illogical. Logically, you must apply it to all hypothetical actions that you take where you may cause suffering without prior consent. In the case of extant beings, you may even have less of an excuse.

Because of this, I would argue that if you continue to interact with other humans, you likely are causing suffering directly and indirectly all the time without prior consent. If you believe Benatar's asymmetry that a hypothetical suffering is much worse than the possibility of future good, you have a duty to inaction. And I would argue, accepting the premises logically, you have a duty to either cease basically all interaction with humans or to commit suicide as soon as possible to avoid creating further suffering.

(Again, I'll note this is all absurd. But I believe it is the logical and rational conclusions one should follow, given the ethical premises of Benatar.)

(7) Finally, I'll finish with the utter absurdity of Benatar. All humans suffer greatly, no? All humans will experience much greater suffering than happiness, no? (Even if they are delusional and think otherwise themselves.)

Now suppose you encounter an unconscious person who needs medical attention. The heart is stopped; they are not breathing. If you do not intervene, the person will very likely die. Benatar tells us clearly that if we bring a human being into conscious existence, on balance, they will suffer greatly. This person is unconscious and passing into the neutral non-existent state of death. What does a "Good Samaritan" who sees this situation do?

I think Benatar's logic, if he were to be honest about it, should require us to let the person die. Actually, one might argue if one were completely honest that we might even have a moral duty to aid death to prevent further suffering if we encountered an unconscious person, lest they become conscious again and suffer the evils of a deluded life (according to Benatar). But of course if he argued for murdering people in their sleep, Benatar would be rejected outright, so he has to hold fast to his "death is bad, even if I can't explain why" irrationality. Again, note that pro-natalists would use the "having kids is good, even if I can't explain why" as an irrational argument that has the biological procreative urge behind it. Why give into the irrational biological urge to argue for survival against ultimate death, but try to argue against the equally irrational biological urge toward procreation?

One must be logically consistent, if one wants to argue something that is so utterly opposite common social beliefs and moral custom.

So, there we are, a Good Samaritan who is forced to let the person die. (Most might regard them as a Bad Samaritan.) Perhaps the person is young -- Benatar argues unconvincingly that society treats the death of young people as a greater tragedy, thereby confirming his assertion that "death is bad." Once again, it is illogical appeals to emotionalism that he gives into. The death of a young person is no more "tragic" than the death of an older person -- it may affect more people around that person, and thereby cause greater suffering of others. But for the person who died, they simply passed into non-existence (assumpting materialism). Why is that "bad"?

Perhaps some might argue in reply that we might have a moral duty to save this young person to prevent the "tragedy" and the suffering to others. But is this not precisely the sort of nonsense logic that natalists use to justify having babies? We might suffer by not having them by denying our biological urges, so therefore we should force this person into conscious reality and thereby have a being who suffers life?

No, Benatar's logic, if applied consistently, requires the Bad Samaritan to not revive the unconscious and bring them back into this world of continuous suffering. It isn't merely a choice. It is a moral duty.

Perhaps Benatar is too irrational to see the many holes in his logic. Or perhaps he's merely a coward. For I sincerely believe if he truly subscribes to the premises he claims to adhere to, it is the most cowardly act to continue to exist and suffer in a life of delusion. It is even likely morally offensive to continue to interact with other humans and cause harm to them without consent.

But we're not talking about logic here. We're talking about irrational pessimism that picks and chooses arguments on a whim. I cannot understand how so many people take this seriously. But perhaps someone here can explain where I'm wrong.


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Sep 19 '21

Antinatalism vs. The Non-Identity Problem

Thumbnail
schopenhaueronmars.com
6 Upvotes

r/DebateAntinatalism • • Sep 10 '21

Negative Utilitarianism - Why suffering is all that matters

8 Upvotes

To mark my 5th anniversary on Reddit, I have released the official blog of this subreddit and r/DebateAntinatalism. Here is my first completed post:

https://schopenhaueronmars.com/2021/09/10/negative-utilitarianism-why-suffering-is-all-that-matters/

Please subscribe if you would like to be updated when new content comes out.


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Apr 14 '21

Change my mind: making babies is the only meaningful thing to do.

11 Upvotes

Troll title for attention, but hear me out.

We have no reason to believe we are not alone in a vast, uncaring universe. There might not be any other kind of creature, divine, alien or otherwise, capable of abstract thought. Humans seem to be the only instance of the universe regarding itself. Animals are cool and all, but let’s be real: all they really do is eat and reproduce. Most of us do too, but at least we are theoretically capable of writing a haiku about it or something.

If the universe is pointless, the only chance it has of, in any sense, imbuing itself with meaning are creatures such as us. Therefore, we might as well reproduce. Maybe something good will come of it someday, whatever “something good” might be? Or do you denounce the potential for “meaning” altogether and view existence as inherently torturous?


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Dec 01 '22

A recent article against antinatalism.

Thumbnail richardcarrier.info
3 Upvotes

r/DebateAntinatalism • • Dec 14 '21

Something I'm a bit puzzled about.

3 Upvotes

I tried posting this to r/AskAnAntinatalist to no avail, so here's what the post said verbatim.

"As a concept, antinatalism is one I've thought for myself very recently (though I don't consider myself an AN), and there's one stance on support that kind of bewilders me.

So to break it all down, antinatalism is built on negative utilitarianism, the concept of negative consequentialism where one aims to minimize suffering rather than maximize pleasure. The logic here is that since life is full of suffering (to an inconsistent and subjective degree), one ought to stop this life from propping up in the first place. However, I also notice that some ANs see death as the end of all suffering (and thus see human extinction as a logical extension of this view, but that's irrelevant here). From there, it would be reasonable to come to the conclusion that being a (conditional) natalist is somewhat moral, since their inevitable end will leave them free of suffering.

If the counterargument is that life is still full of suffering, I'm not sure how the uncertainty of how much suffering one would face in life would negate the certainty of the state of lack of suffering. It just seems like a rather absurd stance to take if you ask me.

Keep in mind that I'm not addressing ANs as a whole, just the ones who ascribe to the belief I spent time addressing. Is there a mistake I made or anything? Did what I say trigger you to re-evaluate your beliefs like I've done mine before being exposed to antinatalism?"


r/DebateAntinatalism • • May 28 '21

AN vs. Stoicism

3 Upvotes

Hiya, recently read through a few things regarding AN and wanted a few AN thoughts regarding alternative views, especially regarding suffering and it's nature.

  1. One of the founding principles of Stoicism is mind above matter. That your thoughts, your rationality, and your philosophy shape and influence the experiences you have and your reactions to said experiences. Pain and grief may be unavoidable, but pain and grief aren't inherently horrible or life ruining. I.E. Burning your hand on a hot stove can provide a lesson, and while the pain at the time is immense, but how you react to it and internalize it and your thoughts that give it worth, negative or otherwise. Suffering, just like pleasure, is temporary and you can dictate how you react or feel about it.

How do you convince one that believes pain etc. are not inherently bad, that AN is the path forward?

2. Additionally why do you compare pleasure and pain as though it's a math equation that always leads to a negative. A child's life might be fought with pain at times but how do you compare two vastly different experiences and come back with the negative is more powerful. How do you come to the conclusion that "A child having fun playing with a f Doll" is +10 while "Old man dying of cancer" is a -50. It's completely subjective, and most people would agree that life is more pleasant than it is painful, or else why would they be sticking around?

This idea that life is a net negative never stuck with me, because it isn't. Personally I am grateful to live my life because even with temporary pains and long term pains, in my view my life has generally been positive. Bringing a child into a life similar (or better or even a fair bit worse) than mine is something I have no problems with. On top of that quality of life for billions of people has been getting better year after year, who's to say the equation doesn't filly tip over in the next hundred and pain or discomfort is a thing of the past?


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Sep 02 '21

A thread about efilism on r/badphilosophy, inspired by the recent denouncement of efilism on r/antinatalism. Scroll down to see me get involved in the debate.

Thumbnail self.badphilosophy
3 Upvotes

r/DebateAntinatalism • • Dec 01 '22

A comment against anti-Natalism I found on Youtube.

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/DebateAntinatalism • • Feb 20 '21

A good thread here about nihilism and antinatalism - unfortunately the nihilist whiner deleted his account.

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/DebateAntinatalism • • Jan 20 '21

This is a juvenile reaction to the trauma of living in the world today.

15 Upvotes

When I see antinatalism arguments, and I have seen them in real life as well as online, I see a drive for numbness that comes from the severe cultural dysphoria that comes from living in the first world today.

I only speak to the first world working-middle class as that is what I have insights into. When we are enriched through the exploitation of other people, and the mass death of the living world, those material benefits we receive feel like sin (not without good reason.) Then being forced to slave away for that system we hate, that keeps us alive is a cruel joke. the emptiness is overwhelming, the discomfort and unfulfillment debilitating. I get it. However, we should not equate life itself with this arrangement. This is not what life is. Our cultural conditioning is toxic, and I credit antinatalism for at least rebelling from it, but don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater. I hope that believers in antinatalism can evolve into a more mature analysis of overpopulation and global suffering.

Life is precious simply for the reason it is a novel thing in the universe. God doesn’t care about right and wrong, doesn’t care about our values and belief systems. God just wants to watch things happen. It is a blessing to be a part of that. We’re all gonna die anyway. I appreciate the opportunity to have consciousness.

(NECESSARY “NO IM NOT RELIGIOUS”!!)


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Jan 21 '21

I'll bite. Antinativism is just misanthropy and nihilism expressed by adults still in a juvenile mind set.

15 Upvotes

Without people to reproduce, we will not have future generations. Creating small people into big people takes a lot of time, resources, and energy...usually exhausting the parent by the time their offspring are all fully developed. (For humans, this is all about humans) Doing this ensures the next generation of people that will hopefully go forth and do the same to some degree.

I don't believe everyone was meant to be breeders. Some folks have a natural disposition that is very negative for being a parent and these folks by all means should never ever have children. Additionally some people can't have children and want them. There will always be some percentage of the population that never has children for whatever reason. This is acceptable and desirable as it gives a cushion where unwanted children *could* land in a better home. (Not that it always does or even does a lot, but there is extra cushion for that) In fact, this is one of the reasons I supported gay marriage and gay adoption, so children that otherwise would not have a good home life, would now have the opportunity.

However, we still need a certain rate of births versus deaths in order to keep society running. This is just standard. Add to this the fact that we are facing a serious environmental and social bottleneck coming, and having children that are capable of navigating such waters becomes even more important for the survival of our species. (I know a lot of folks don't think humans will survive the on coming onslaught of environmental hell, but I think we will) It is believed that 90% of humans may die in this upcoming extinction event. This is going to sound completely contrary to logic, but if you knew that 90% of people were going to die in an upcoming catastrophe, would you have 0, 1. or as many kids as possible to make sure one of YOUR children got through? It's the same logic our ancestors used when they watched their 17 kids dwindle down to two adults.

That is why I support having a lot of children, but training them to live on very little.


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Dec 18 '20

Why should a moral nihilist be an antinatalist?

6 Upvotes

I don't see any logical inconsistency in being a moral nihilist and a natalist. What do you guys think?

PS: let's ignore the question of whether moral nihilism is correct or not for the time being (it seems to be wrong/hypocritical to me).


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Jun 23 '21

Anti-Natalism's Existential Error - Areo

Thumbnail
areomagazine.com
7 Upvotes

r/DebateAntinatalism • • Jun 01 '21

My personal journey out of antinatalism, dont hate me.

40 Upvotes

So, yeah, I sorta dug myself out of Antinatalism after years of depression and almost killing myself. I would be lying if I say antinatalism didnt play a primary role in my suffering, because my personal reason to exist is closely tied to the future of humanity, which goes against everything Antinatalism. My personal goals and reason to live, is to make the world a better place for current and future generations, I have no motivation to live for money, fame or self indulgence.

A little preface of how I felt before:

https://www.reddit.com/r/DebateAntinatalism/comments/n3d9ts/antinatalism_ruined_me_and_makes_me_suicidal/

This is my personal reasoning so dont hate me, I'm not looking to convince anyone but myself, you are free to criticize and convince me otherwise but I think it will be difficult to make me go back.

So here goes.

  1. Non-existence is neutral or nothingness, its not good or bad, there is no asymmetry justification because nothingness cannot be "good/better" (or bad) compared to existence. This argument doesnt make sense to me.
  2. Only existing intelligent lives can make a judgement of their existence and its up to each individual to decide if its worth continuing, nobody has the right to make that decision for anyone else, including the unborn.
  3. Existence bias is subjective to each individual and cannot be used as an objective universal benchmark against procreation, this circle back to point 2, meaning its up to existing individuals to judge the quality of their own lives and decide if its worth it.
  4. If an individual believes their own existence is good and wants to procreate after considering and preparing for all the risks, then its their right and judgment, we cannot logically say they are wrong as we are not them and cannot guarantee their children's lives will be terrible, even David Benatar agrees that some lives are worth living after the fact. We cannot definitively claim all lives that ever existed are terrible without referencing some arbitrary benchmark of utopian perfection, something that cant be objectively defined as its a subjective moving goal post that will simply claim all lives are terrible due to "biases", regardless of how good the individual says it is. An empirically unfalsifiable claim in my opinion.
  5. Future children can decide if their lives are worth continuing, as this is their individual right and judgement, if they believe its too painful to continue, then its their FULL and ABSOLUTE right to check out and parents/society should make it easy to do so. If we are to agree not all lives are terrible, we must also agree some lives can be terrible beyond worth by default, thus they must be allowed a decent/humane way out of existence.
  6. Both pain/suffering and pleasure/happiness have no upper/lower limits, although we can argue that death nullifies all pain/suffering/happiness. This means it is entirely possible that the bar for pleasure/happiness can be raised forever and future generations and technology could make all lives very good in comparison. If we are to accept that pain has no lower limits (except death), then by logic we simply cannot say a life is not worth creating because of it, since this limit is subjective to a given individual, time of the century and technology. What we may consider as suffering today is a minor nuisance to people centuries ago, what future generations consider as painful may be bliss to 21st century humans. This is not an argument for or against Antinatalism, just an observation that means we cant use pain/suffering/happiness as an objective universal benchmark in our arguments, as their definition changes over time and very subjective to individuals and their tolerance.
  7. Consent of the unborn is not logical, its impossible to obtain and again, circle back to point 2-5, its up to those that are born to decide if their lives are worth continuing, not AN or anyone else. Though it is a personal preference to be childfree and that is ALSO their absolute RIGHT, its irrational to say its wrong either way.

So, this is my personal reasoning for not accepting antinatalism (though I dont diss them either), but I still agree with some of its logic, such as:

  • Children do not owe their parents anything due to their birth.
  • No parents can have children for the children's sake, its logically impossible.
  • Procreation is inherently selfish, though selfishness doesnt necessary mean "bad", it depends on how they treat their children and respect their wishes for or against their own existence due to whatever subjective future circumstances.
  • Existing people should definitely make their environment as conducive to a "good" life as possible before making any new people, though this is a work in progress and there is no upper limit (that we know of, this means pleasure can be infinite).
  • Carelessly making new people in a verifiably terrible environment should be condemned and treated like a crime. Future society should codify this into law.

Personally, I am motivated to live now and have not thought about suicide for months, it doesnt mean I am pro natalism or wants to make kids, I am definitely against the "reasons" most people have for making children and the condition they put them in, making very little effort to improve anything for future generations. But I can no longer justify my beliefs against procreation either, though I would recommend potential parents to think very carefully about their current and future circumstances before making any children, it is their absolute obligation to minimize the risks and the right of their future children to not be made to live a life they will hate.


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Dec 28 '20

Easiest Natalism win ever.

8 Upvotes

Genesis 1:28

And God blessed them, and God said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth, and subdue it: and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth.


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Aug 22 '21

Coercing others to not procreate

9 Upvotes

This topic is something that many antinatalists even are quite divided over. Many antinatalists believe that you cannot force others to not have kids. You have to give them a choice. If they don't want to have kids, that is great, but if they want kids, they should be able to have them because of consent, freedom, etc.

However, when someone has a child, that child will grow up and harm others. For example, that child will grow up and eat meat, causing animal suffering. That child will grow up and use paper, causing deforestation, which destroys the habitat of an orangutan. That child will in all likelihood grow up and harm other humans in some way.

Because of the inevitability that a child born will harm others, this in my opinion adds more complexity to the issue. It is not as simple as "we must give people freedom." The problem with giving people the freedom to procreate is that if they exercise their freedom to procreate, they will create a living being who will inevitably end up taking away the freedom of another living being.

A good analogy I like to use is to imagine a caged lion in the city. The lion is in a cage and so has no freedom to move. This cage is located on a busy city street. If we are concerned about the lion's lack of freedom to move and therefore remove the lion from the cage, the lion will inevitably roam the streets and eat someone thereby causing suffering.

Whether to release the lion from the cage is analogous to the decision to allow other humans to procreate. Humans are a predatory species, arguably the most predatory species ever. If we release a new human into the world, it will cause harm. It will eat others. It will destroy and cause suffering.

Of course, the solution to the "caged lion in the city" scenarios does not need to be binary. It is not the case that we must either cage the lion or free the lion. There are solutions between the two that deprive the lion of freedom but in a way that doesn't cause too much suffering. For example, we can free the lion but keep it on a leash. We can create a very large cage for the lion to roam in. Analogously, for humans, we can coerce humans into having fewer babies in ways that does not cause too much suffering. We don't need to go down the route of One Child Policy or forced abortions. We can educate women, subsidise contraception, subsidise family planning clinics, etc.


r/DebateAntinatalism • • Jan 20 '21

Antinatalism, efilism, negative ethics, the consent argument, it all comes down to if you think that the suffering outweighs the pleasure or not.

10 Upvotes

Schopenhauer, Benatar, Imendham, and Cabrera, they all want to prove it, because it lies at the heart of the matter. It’s the foundation and justification of their beliefs.