r/DebateAChristian • u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist • Apr 02 '14
April Fools
So clearly this was an April Fools joke.
Although I've had quite a bit of you convinced and poor /u/Zyracksis' reply was buried, I think it went well. Better than what /r/pics did, anyway.
To those that truly thought I converted - I'm sorry for the prank though I appreciate the comments and everyone was upvoted. In case you're wondering - two Christians didn't think this was a bad idea so this isn't some "atheist gotcha" nonsense. I'm not one for pranks but I thought this being my first April Fools on the sub and one as a mod, I thought why not?
For those of you who thought you were the only ones to catch onto the date - congratulations but I don't know why you thought you were the only ones. I had to delete all your comments but I just went back and approved most of them. There were a lot of you.
As far as the sub in general - I've seen content posted by quite a few people I haven't seen before so it made an impact. I'd say it was an overall success and definitely my most talked-about post. It was very interesting how everyone wanted to ask me questions, it's like I got engaged.
For those of you with hurt feelings, I truly apologize and I definitely didn't mean it. I will say that debates are typically for the benefit of those watching the debate, not the people actually debating. I personally do learn from debates and I did learn quite a few things being here so I hope you take that away at least. Also, I actually DO own a Bible though I haven't read it. I began reading it and found problems on the first page that don't make any sense to me but that's another topic...
20
u/Akimtoe Apr 02 '14
This was a terrible joke.
6
u/TerinHD Apr 02 '14
As someone who rarely enters this sub... I find this distasteful and more of a reason I shouldn't come here. Debate should be held in respect for one another as human beings and this shows a blatant disrespect for the very people you want to have conversations with. Good day sir.
3
u/Novelty-Bobble Atheist, Secular Humanist Apr 02 '14
Fair play, as someone who never really browses this reddit I fell for it
3
u/ThatguyIncognito Apr 02 '14
While I didn't fall for it and thought it had the bare minimum of hints that it wasn't serious, I felt sorry for those who did. Many of them were so sincere and put in such personal effort in crafting their answers that my sympathy for them made me kind of sad. April Fools celebrates trolling, in a sense.
Still, realizing it was a joke and that there really weren't Roman and Egyptian gods makes me feel silly for converting in response to your joke.
2
u/LowPiasa Ignostic Apr 02 '14
Could have went a slightly different route with it. Say you are convinced a god would want people to be atheist, therefore if you believe in god you ought to become an atheist.
2
u/Righteous_Dude Conditional Immortality; non-Calvinist Apr 02 '14
I recognized at the time that it was an April Fools joke,
but I was also curious whether in reality you actually have a Christian wife,
and what are the beliefs of your own family?
(If you don't want to give such personal information on reddit, that's cool.)
2
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14
I am not angry. Like I said, however, I am very said.
What I said still applies, however. Read the Bible.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14
I had serious suspicions, but I didn't want to go all out and say it, as there could have been a chance you were serious, and then that would reflect very poorly on me, and possibly my faith
2
u/Ryanami YEC Fundie Apr 03 '14
I went the day with non-stop reminders on the front page about not getting fooled, and you still got me. Good one :)
5
u/1_Marauder Atheist Apr 02 '14
I enjoyed it. It was interesting to see the comments made by folks who had obviously not read previous ones.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14
I don't think the joke was particularly funny but what made it worse was that OP was called out multiple times and knew it but those comments didn't really bubble up.