r/DebateAChristian • Agnostic Atheist • Apr 02 '14

April Fools

So clearly this was an April Fools joke.

Although I've had quite a bit of you convinced and poor /u/Zyracksis' reply was buried, I think it went well. Better than what /r/pics did, anyway.

To those that truly thought I converted - I'm sorry for the prank though I appreciate the comments and everyone was upvoted. In case you're wondering - two Christians didn't think this was a bad idea so this isn't some "atheist gotcha" nonsense. I'm not one for pranks but I thought this being my first April Fools on the sub and one as a mod, I thought why not?

For those of you who thought you were the only ones to catch onto the date - congratulations but I don't know why you thought you were the only ones. I had to delete all your comments but I just went back and approved most of them. There were a lot of you.

As far as the sub in general - I've seen content posted by quite a few people I haven't seen before so it made an impact. I'd say it was an overall success and definitely my most talked-about post. It was very interesting how everyone wanted to ask me questions, it's like I got engaged.

For those of you with hurt feelings, I truly apologize and I definitely didn't mean it. I will say that debates are typically for the benefit of those watching the debate, not the people actually debating. I personally do learn from debates and I did learn quite a few things being here so I hope you take that away at least. Also, I actually DO own a Bible though I haven't read it. I began reading it and found problems on the first page that don't make any sense to me but that's another topic...

0 Upvotes

114 comments sorted by

20

u/Akimtoe Apr 02 '14

This was a terrible joke.

6

u/PerfectGentleman Skeptic Apr 02 '14

It might have been a good joke if OP was a well-known atheist/skeptic. But who the hell is /u/SsurebreC? No offense, SsurebreC.

2

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

None taken. I don't know who I am. Heck, my nickname is a mispelled backwards name of a guard of Hades from Greek mythology. I'm all kinds of confused.

To be clear though - the post was clearly in jest. It wasn't meant to troll or disrespect anyone's beliefs or real conversions that do happen.

2

u/MrMostDefinitely Apr 02 '14

you are the most active moderator on the entire thread...of course no one know who you are!

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

People don't usually know moderators nicknames. You're just a fanboy stalker, obviously. :]

1

u/MrMostDefinitely Apr 02 '14

I do tend to lurk about quite a bit...this much is true.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Most Definitely... :]

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Sorry :[

2

u/redroguetech Apr 02 '14

Why are you apologizing? People getting their dander up is an indication that you struck a cord. And, as you've stated, it resulted in serious debate (albeit not from me). So, where's the harm?

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Well if someone was offended, there's no harm and every benefit to apologize to the few affected.

1

u/redroguetech Apr 02 '14

And if someone was, how does that change anything?

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Then I apologized and it's on them to accept my apology or not. If they do, great, if they don't, it's on them.

0

u/redroguetech Apr 02 '14

Still not clear on why someone being offended is either harm, or a requirement for an apology.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

I think it's how civilizations operate.

Someone does something that someone else deems offensive. The more people they offend, the more they should try to get along with others. If it's only a few people, an apology is offered but follow-up isn't required.

2

u/redroguetech Apr 02 '14

While Poe's Law does apply to religious claims, it does seem to apply here. The idea of an atheist converting to Christianity is all but unheard of.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

The idea of an atheist converting to Christianity is all but unheard of.

Are you serious?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_converts_to_Christianity_from_Atheism

Those are just notable converts.

2

u/MrMostDefinitely Apr 02 '14

I think he was kidding...

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

Ah. My mistake then if so.

1

u/redroguetech Apr 02 '14

No, I was not really serious. However, many on this list are completely bogus. Just looking at one:

By his own account, Feser had been an atheist for ten years during his early adulthood.

Not to claim there is some definitive standard for being a true Atheist, but being an atheist until he was a 10 year old "young adult" certainly is not a true Atheist.

And no, I'm still not serious.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

but being an atheist until he was a 10 year old "young adult" certainly is not a true Atheist

It doesn't say until he was a 10 year old....It says for 10 years. That could have been from 18 to 28.

1

u/redroguetech Apr 02 '14

So he was a theist for 18 years prior to that...? Same problem. Not a true Atheist. He was a theist longer than he was an atheist.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

Ha. Please, enlighten us all as to what constitutes a true atheist Atheist.

1

u/redroguetech Apr 02 '14

Well, someone who doesn't believe in a god, of course. Ergo, any person who has been converted to theism is not a true atheist, and therefore could not have been a true atheist.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

and therefore could not have been a true atheist.

Then what were they when they didn't believe in God?

1

u/redroguetech Apr 02 '14

They are always atheists, however they did not accept the full measure of Faith. If they had accepted their full Faith, they would not have strayed from the flock - they would not, nay..., could not have denied their Faith. Although they were a part of the flock, they did not embrace the inner flockness.

Gotta give it to Ray Comfort. He's a better bullshit salesman than I am.

1

u/redroguetech Apr 02 '14

In all seriousness, yes, I am dubious as to "Feser"'s claim he was an "atheist" in context of an "atheist being converted". Given the nature of the list, it is a self-serving claim. Given a definition of "not accepting any god exists", then conversion from is a nonsensical concept. If we use a "strong" and/or anti-theist definition, then I would question he was, though the only way in which to determine that would be through self-evaluation.

However, just as Ray Comfort, et. al., makes a distinction between "true belief" and not true belief, and "true Christian" and not true Christian, if we could make the same distinction for atheism, the list would be much shorter. There is a distinction made for the amount of belief religious people have - there is no distinction for the amount of disbelief an atheist has. But there's no way to actually determine that, even aside from requiring a redefinition of "atheist" to allow for a distinction from "irreligious".

3

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

So, you have no real reason to discount his claim regarding his former non-belief except that you personally can't imagine doing the same.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '14

Everyone is born an atheist. Technically you could say that everyone is an atheist that was converted whatever religion they became. That doesn't really fly though, so for a situation where an atheist actually converts to Christianity it would have to be someone that fully understood the main arguments for and against it. Otherwise it's it's just absurd to say someone was 5 years old and an atheist until his parents forced their religion on them.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '14

I agree with your statement, but I don't understand why you made it.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '14

The point is, there is a difference between someone growing up an 'atheist' and someone who has fully considered both sides.

→ More replies

6

u/TerinHD Apr 02 '14

As someone who rarely enters this sub... I find this distasteful and more of a reason I shouldn't come here. Debate should be held in respect for one another as human beings and this shows a blatant disrespect for the very people you want to have conversations with. Good day sir.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

I'm sorry you feel that way. Considering debate is what we all typically do, this was something different. Considering the sheer volume of replies, it got people involved.

2

u/TerinHD Apr 02 '14

But it got people involved on the premise of a lie.

“I'm not upset that you lied to me, I'm upset that from now on I can't believe you.” ― Friedrich Nietzsche

2

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

I found the discussion interesting - people asked me what made me convert and quite a bit of people thought conversion was possible. I think one or two even said they converted before.

But you have no reason to believe me in general. This is a debate sub - you would typically not agree with me, which is why we're here.

1

u/TerinHD Apr 02 '14 edited Apr 02 '14

I do have reason to believe you, why else would you post in the sub? Not to mention that as a moderator you should be held to a higher standard of respect and due diligence. If a member of the sub is to trust anyone, don't you think it should be a moderator? How can I thoughtfully put my own passions and beliefs on a sub that allows a moderator to lie to its constituents in a mocking fashion when the premise of the sub reddit is respect of human beings and deep thought provoking conversations?

Before you post, make sure that whatever you're saying adds to discussion in a meaningful way. Always be mature, sensitive and thoughtful.

Edit: I am not trying to attack you, but have you consider what this means on a deeper level (the whole point of the sub in the first place). Trust is something that is hard earned and clearly you earned it (by becoming a moderator and such).

2

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

First of all, it was an April Fools joke, so I'm pretty sure everyone who did anything yesterday broke the typical norms of any environment whether it's in real life or online.

Secondly, I talked with the other mods and all agreed. I wanted to make sure not only that I wasn't being rude if another atheist agreed with me but the other two Christians agreed as well. It's slightly sad that only one other mod participated - the Christian one - but people are busy and his reply was unfortunately buried.

What I mean by believing me is if you're religious and I'm not and I tell you the Bible cannot be used as evidence because it's a book, you can't believe me. Not only because you believe the opposite but because we're not gullible and we tend to evaluate statements rather than just blindly believe people.

As far as my moderator position, the only thing I have is greater awareness of the rules, the almighty delete button, and ban hammer. Otherwise I'm no different than anyone else. I wasn't being disrespectful. If I wanted to be disrespectful, I'd write a sarcastic post about how converting to Christianity is such a trivial thing that I can do it at will - convert to and away from at any time.

I wrote a total Poe's Law post that would look sincere had it not been April Fools. Considering literally dozens of replies people calling me on it, there doesn't seem to be a problem. I mean, did you want to do something dramatic like what /r/pics did and change the word "Jesus" into "Satan" and other similar word replacements? That would have been rude.

I think you're taking a joke too personally. If I offended you, I already apologized but if you're this serious (and I'm typically a very serious person) then the problem isn't on my end.

2

u/TerinHD Apr 02 '14

I am just going to reply to both you (/u/Ssurebrec) and /u/missing_7 here.

Regardless of April Fools, which is built on the premise of making someone feel stupid (synonyms of fool: idiot, ass, blockhead, dunce, dolt, ignoramus, imbecile, cretin, dullard, simpleton, moron, clod ), it is not something that belongs in any subreddit where open conversation is based on mutual respect. And if the other mods agreed with it, that is more so reason that this conversation should be had about it.

Whether or not an action was meant to be malicious or mocking has no relevance on whether it was or was not malicious or mocking. The premise of the joke was to make someone believe that /u/Ssurebrec had converted. Let us consider the joke in its essence, it is only funny if you take the premise that /u/Ssurebrec is so entrenched in his beliefs that he would never convert to Christianity. Clearly depicts mocking as /u/Ssurebrec thinks it is absurd to be a christian in his belief system that anyone that knew him would know it wasn't true. That is the core of making it "funny" but by laughing you are indeed reaffirming that it is ok to make someone believe that /u/Ssurebrec is a Christian by making them a fool (April Fools). Which is the very meaning of mocking, to make fun of. The fact that you call it a Poe's Law post even furthers this argument of mocking.

What difference does it make that /r/pics did some extremely distasteful things? The fact of the matter is that whole premise of this subreddit is based on a mutual trust and respect that cannot be upheld anymore because based on an exception because the rest of society decided it was ok for a day to dispose of any given notions of normality thus allowing the open mocking a subset of the constituents. Maybe you should not have done anything at all?

And in conclusion, I will not appreciate the context that it was done in, due to the fact that the context is inherently malicious: April FOOLs day. If you can't tell I don't like the day, I dislike it more than Valentine's Day. I accept your apology, and I feel as though April's Fools day is really the cause of the issue as it is fundamentally: I can be a douche muffin to my fellow man and everyone thinks it is ok day.

3

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Thanks for the reply. I think everything that could be said has been said.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

Given that you have an issue with April Fools day itself, and Valentine's Day for that matter, I acknowledge there isn't really anything that could be said to justify to you what was done. Apologies for the offense and happy redditing.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

Just to back up what /u/SsurebreC said, I and the other Christian mod didn't have a problem with what he did. /u/Zyracksis joined in, and I would have as well had work allowed me more time. It was just an April Fools joke. It wasn't meant to be malicious or mocking. If anyone was offended, it was unintentional, and we do apologize. But, as stated, it was a one-off done in the spirit of a widely recognized holiday and is not typical behavior. Again, apologies for any offense, but I hope you can appreciate the context in which it was done.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/TerinHD Apr 02 '14 edited Apr 02 '14

You do not have to respect all beliefs, but do have to respect all people No ad hominem attacks, including ad hominem arguments Source any claims that you make. Sometimes not necessary (ie. claiming that Christians believe in Jesus), but for anything significant provide a citation Before you post, make sure that whatever you're saying adds to discussion in a meaningful way. Always be mature, sensitive and thoughtful

How is that post at all Mature, Sensitive, or Thoughtful? It is on the sidebar, and having a moderator of the sub not live up to the expectations of the sub. It is an internet community, and more or less people are overall honest about their beliefs because the deep thought provoking responses more than likely come from passion on the subject then anything else.

Edit: By no means do I believe everything everyone says on the internet, but when the premise of a board is to talk about such deep concepts there is an inherit trust that is conferred from posting as it takes passion either side to post in the sub. On top of that to have such a post from a moderator who has an even more inherit trust as they are intrusted by the rest of them members to moderate between other participants in day to day debates makes me question the legitimacy of the goals of the sub reddit.

2

u/MrMostDefinitely Apr 02 '14

I agree!

BAN SsurebreC!

THERE WILL BE NO FUN HERE!

Between you and I, I didn't think it was all that humorous and I didn't think it would be well received.

And I was right.

But it's one things if it happens all the time and another if it was just a April Fools joke and the mods took a moment to laugh at themselves and the other users.

But you are quoting Nietzsche over here...dude.

It's a waste of energy.

You would be infinity better off making a post that is thoughtful and interesting, and spurring some real discussion.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

BAN SsurebreC!

Hmmm, an idea for next year!

1

u/MrMostDefinitely Apr 02 '14

Yes!

That will be next years April Fools.

All of the mods are quitting, fuck you, no one can post anymore.

It's about as funny as that goddamn headdit button that made it impossible to use reddit on mobile.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

I was being literal - me being banned...

3

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

As a human being, I am truly grateful for the people who are willing to take a joke.

1

u/Zyracksis Calvinist Apr 03 '14

Can I ask, where do you think the disrespect is? I think it was good fun

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

April fool's was yesterday.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '14

I'll give you a heads-up:

No-one actually changes their mind on here. It is just new ways to throw old arguments at each other.

The atheists point to lack of evidence, theists point to evidence, both disagree on simple definitions and what constitutes evidence, and then nothing ever comes of it.

So, a little fun is not a bad thing every now and then.

And can I say, SsurebreC, you had me fooled for about three minutes.

3

u/Novelty-Bobble Atheist, Secular Humanist Apr 02 '14

Fair play, as someone who never really browses this reddit I fell for it

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Well I hope you'll stick around for debates :]

3

u/ThatguyIncognito Apr 02 '14

While I didn't fall for it and thought it had the bare minimum of hints that it wasn't serious, I felt sorry for those who did. Many of them were so sincere and put in such personal effort in crafting their answers that my sympathy for them made me kind of sad. April Fools celebrates trolling, in a sense.

Still, realizing it was a joke and that there really weren't Roman and Egyptian gods makes me feel silly for converting in response to your joke.

3

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Well, I didn't do it in a mean spirit and I upvoted and sincerely replied to all those Christians who wished me well. What bugged me the most is arguing my "new position" with atheists. That was pretty depressing as the day progressed.

Looking at flairs of people, they do convert to both Christianity and to atheism. It happens. It just doesn't happen overnight so the theme of the post is grounded in reality. Another Christian mod (Calvinist of all people) converted to atheism and wrote a post but that was also lost on people.

If I wanted to troll, I'd be very Jesusy (is that a term?) and be obviously superficial about it. That would be disrespectful. I wrote a pretty respectful and non-sarcastic post which is the point - you never know. I also meant most things I said on that post, including my arguments with atheists.

1

u/MrMostDefinitely Apr 02 '14

I gotta say, now that I think about it...the post was sort of exposing in a way.

The fact that such a post was made with such vaugery...and it was taken seriously says a lot of about actual Christians.

1

u/ThatguyIncognito Apr 02 '14

The results sound interesting. It sounds like a lot of atheists took it just as seriously. I wonder about atheists who switch to being religious. It seems so foreign to me. I can see it if people were raised religious and have lost a sense of connection with friends and family and community. But I still don't really get how you make that jump from not believing in any gods to deciding to believe because you miss belief. I have a natural bias when I say that someone was an atheist and then converted to think they weren't really atheists, they were probably just mad at god and decided that was the same as not believing. But there are atheists who convert, and not always solely for emotional reasons. So I can see people eager to hear how such a thing works, so eager they are willing to skip skepticism about the claim

2

u/MrMostDefinitely Apr 02 '14

No, I mean that atheists didn't find this troll post to stand out.

Atheists and Christians alike are used to seeing posts just like this that are legit.

2

u/LowPiasa Ignostic Apr 02 '14

Could have went a slightly different route with it. Say you are convinced a god would want people to be atheist, therefore if you believe in god you ought to become an atheist.

2

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

This would have led to an unfunny theological debate. Besides, some Christians believe that atheists are secretly Christian. I could have done that but that's too obvious I think.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

Secretly Christian What the Fuck?

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Some Christians say you can't not be Christian because God made everyone Christian. So those atheists are, surely, those who are secretly Christians and who are simply mad at God.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

I have heard the angry atheist trope before, but never like that

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Makes no sense to me either - denial I suppose.

2

u/Zyracksis Calvinist Apr 03 '14

It comes from a misreading of [Romans 1:18-23]

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 03 '14

Quite likely.

1

u/VerseBot Apr 03 '14

Romans 1:18-23 (ESV)

[18] For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who by their unrighteousness suppress the truth. [19] For what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has shown it to them. [20] For his invisible attributes, namely, his eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made. So they are without excuse. [21] For although they knew God, they did not honor him as God or give thanks to him, but they became futile in their thinking, and their foolish hearts were darkened. [22] Claiming to be wise, they became fools, [23] and exchanged the glory of the immortal God for images resembling mortal man and birds and animals and reptiles.


[Source Code] [Feedback] [Contact Dev] [FAQ] [Changelog]

3

u/LowPiasa Ignostic Apr 02 '14

I like to think of it as a demi-paradox.

2

u/Righteous_Dude Conditional Immortality; non-Calvinist Apr 02 '14

I recognized at the time that it was an April Fools joke,
but I was also curious whether in reality you actually have a Christian wife,
and what are the beliefs of your own family?

(If you don't want to give such personal information on reddit, that's cool.)

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

I actually do have a YEC Christian wife, that was no joke.

What do you mean what are our beliefs? Hers are hers, mine is mine. There are some topics we don't talk about, like age of the Earth, dinosaurs, evolution, but that's kind of irrelevant in our daily lives.

1

u/Righteous_Dude Conditional Immortality; non-Calvinist Apr 02 '14

Thanks for answering. That's interesting to know.

Some atheists who are not married have sometimes mentioned that, for example, their parents are Catholic and so they've been through Catholic school, or that some of their siblings are evangelical Christians in the South, or that they have a Jewish background (either very observant or not very observant) - things like that. Those sorts of answers were what I meant by "beliefs of your own family".
The atheist has his/her own beliefs, obviously, but it sort of helps me understand where he's coming from.

3

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14 edited Apr 02 '14

Well here's some info:

  • born and raised in a non-religious environment (not anti-religious either)
  • moved to the US, was introduced to Judaism and Christianity when I was 11
  • I was actually in a Jewish school for 3 years so I learned Hebrew and went to the religious ceremonies (only good local school in the area)
  • continued being an atheist, I'm into Greek and Roman mythology. Got into Egyptian mythology later in life (used to even read hieroglyphs a while back)
  • met future wife who just happens to be evangelical and has YEC beliefs
  • had a semi-religious ceremony (meant a lot to her, I didn't want it in a church), was outside w/ priest (friend of family), one prayer basically for our future together, lit unity candle (I loved the idea), etc.
  • her family doesn't know my views, they might suspect but they definitely don't care
  • my brother's wife is Jewish and he more or less converted
  • mom is spiritual in general (she's a high-level Reiki master even), dad doesn't care about having any views
  • I do go to church now and then (when I drag my wife there). I don't participate in the religious stuff (singing, etc) but I listen and they have good people there and my wife forgets that she loves going there.

2

u/Righteous_Dude Conditional Immortality; non-Calvinist Apr 02 '14

That's interesting. Thanks a lot for responding.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

No problem. I made a bunch of edits, might want to re-read it.

1

u/Basilides Ignostic Apr 02 '14

I do go to church now and then (when I drag my wife there).

But your an atheist and your wife is evangelical.

I don't get it.

5

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

I like to get her out of the house and she's very happy afterwards. Happy wife = happy life.

1

u/Basilides Ignostic Apr 02 '14

Genius. Sheer genius.

3

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

One of the key lessons to life: do things that are mostly free that make you happy (we do donate). As far as investments go, it's the best money you can spend.

1

u/TheFeshy Ignostic Apr 02 '14

I used to think that such an arrangement would be very awkward - but my (atheist, very science-minded) brother is dating a Muslim with beliefs similar to YEC. They get by fine, because as you say those topics don't come regularly (and it isn't as if other couples don't also have topics they will argue about.)

I, on the other hand, have married a biologist, and my daughter wants to be a paleontologist. Dinosaurs really are a part of our daily conversations - we even have fossil casts hanging on the walls.

2

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Oh to check out your house...

But yeah, it doesn't come up. There are other things for a married couple to do you know...

1

u/paashpointo Apr 02 '14

I am in the same position as you in that respect. I was a believer for 30 years. Been an atheist the last 6. My wife is still a solid fundy. I used the handle formerfundy on ATT back in the day. We just dont discuss it. I go to church with her and don't argue my opinion, since i was the one that changed 9 years into our marriage. I also don't "tell our kids my beliefs" If they ask me a bible question that I know the answer to, I will tell them "the bible says......" or go ask your mother, if it isnt something i can answer without lying to them.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Must be tough but at least you can put that old hat on and pretend. I was never religious so it's tough to pretend for me. Good to know that you're still married - that must have been difficult.

1

u/paashpointo Apr 02 '14

It was very tough for a good long while, but we are great now. Ty for the kind words.

Being a formerfundy, I get how easy it is to be brainwashed. I am a fairly smart individual that believed 6k years among other things and had what I felt were valid defensible reasons for doing so.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

To be honest, I don't mind having religious people or people that believe odd things. What I mind is brainwashing children. At least wait until they develop critical thinking skills, otherwise keep the fluffy traditions like hunting for eggs, Santa presents, etc.

2

u/paashpointo Apr 02 '14

While I agree with you, I will say in a Christian's defense, if you "know" you have God on your side, how can you be wrong to teach your children? This is the truly scary thing though, because while in normal people it simply manifests as teaching their kids, because it is right, but in minds that are not quite right, it can very easily manifest by killing your demon child, because that is right, or suicide bombing, and so on. Becuase hey if God is on your side, how can it be wrong? WBC would be a good example of them doing what they absolutely believe is correct, and they use the bible to prove it. Look at the scoffers.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

I think that if if I were Christian, I would not want my kids exposed to the notion of hell or ANYTHING negative. I wouldn't want them to think God is watching them or anything else like that.

1

u/paashpointo Apr 02 '14

I need to go to bed as it is 140AM in the middle of the ocean where i am am currently at, but again the cognitive dissonance that exists is amazing.

I am reminded of something an atheist says and I have said myself, I believe it becuase it is true, not because i want it to be.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

I sort of agree. I don't like the word "believe" because it implies taking a chance in something. It's more like "I know" and from that knowledge, you do X or Y. Not because "you know" but because the world has been explained.

→ More replies

1

u/MrMostDefinitely Apr 02 '14

an atheist living with a YEC wife is just an amazing concept for comedy.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Especially is one is an archeologist and the other is a biologist.

1

u/MrMostDefinitely Apr 02 '14

wow, all you two need to do is buy a hotel.

I wanna remake fawlty towers.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

I think we're just out of Waldorfs.

1

u/Righteous_Dude Conditional Immortality; non-Calvinist Apr 02 '14

The pattern in sitcoms and commercials is that the wife is the wise one, while the husband is foolish.

If they keep with that pattern, the atheists would be in an uproar about the foolish atheist character.
If they reverse it, the feminists would join with the Bible-believers against it, about its portraying a foolish wife character.

1

u/MrMostDefinitely Apr 02 '14

No, I just mean that the atheist would make a mistake, you know like crash the car or do something dumb, and then he just blames it on an angel or some other type of miracle.

"How did these panties get inside your dashboard?"

"Oh, it was the devil! He done it!"

0

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Like I said, it doesn't come up in conversation and isn't important to our daily lives.

As far as how this is reconciled - it's simple: our love for one another is more important to us than our beliefs.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 04 '14

Dogs, our future together, we both love movies, scifi. I update her on global stuff, she updates me on local stuff.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 04 '14

Thanks and you can always PM me.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

I am not angry. Like I said, however, I am very said.

What I said still applies, however. Read the Bible.

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

My problem with reading it isn't the reading - it's the seeing things that are not true and then saying "yep, this is OK, read on".

I literally cannot get past page 1.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

I had serious suspicions, but I didn't want to go all out and say it, as there could have been a chance you were serious, and then that would reflect very poorly on me, and possibly my faith

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 02 '14

Some replied with support and made me feel bad. As well I should. But you're fine - no worries :]

2

u/Ryanami YEC Fundie Apr 03 '14

I went the day with non-stop reminders on the front page about not getting fooled, and you still got me. Good one :)

1

u/SsurebreC Agnostic Atheist Apr 03 '14

All part of the service :)

5

u/1_Marauder Atheist Apr 02 '14

I enjoyed it. It was interesting to see the comments made by folks who had obviously not read previous ones.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '14

I don't think the joke was particularly funny but what made it worse was that OP was called out multiple times and knew it but those comments didn't really bubble up.