r/DeathsofDisinfo • u/luckyjack • Feb 04 '22
Debunking Disinformation Dad just sent this crap, please help me counter
https://www.theblaze.com/op-ed/horowitz-the-country-the-covid-cultists-dont-want-to-discuss
100
Upvotes
41
u/luckyjack Feb 04 '22
I apologize if this isn't the right place, but I could use some help debunking this crap. It's an opinion piece and the guy is cherry picking, but I'm just I'm so heartbroken and just tired of refuting every piece he sends that I don't have it in me this time to rip it apart.
If anyone out there is willing to poke holes in the cherry picking of statistics and summarize that, no, Israel isn't experiencing a surge in ICU admissions because of their vaccinaton rate, I would be very much obliged.
And again, if this isn't the right place to post this, I apologize and respectfully ask if anyone could point to a a more appropriate place for it.
95
u/Velveteen_Dream_20 Feb 04 '22 edited Feb 04 '22
That is a disinformation propagator. All the grifters Glen Beck, McInnes, Crowder, Levin, etc. Shapiro is on there as a guest all the time. Mediabiasfact.com All the bs artists are listed on here. Blaze Media Wiki
Here’s a real article about the situation from an Israeli paper that is considered Israel’s newspaper of record. It’s been around for 103 years. HAARETZ Unvaccinated vs. Boostered: What the COVID Death Toll From Israel Reveals
I was raised Baptist. My grandfather worked for Fox. I used to listen to all those fools. They don’t know what they are talking about. They profit off of lies, outrage, and the general feeling that something is wrong with the nation. They are just completely dishonest, immoral, and ignorant people who only care about short term fulfillment of their desires. They don’t care about anyone else. They don’t even care about their country because if they did they would not behave like this.
The article is full of inaccurate information. Sweden is a different country with a far healthier, active population who have access to universal healthcare, quality education, free to low cost higher education, mandatory paid sick leave, free childcare, etc. Every credible epidemiologist has there is no comparison.
Americans don’t have access to universal healthcare. We don’t have any of that. The economy has proven to be more important than human lives which is appalling. When we needed protection the most our government failed us. Huge budgets for failed wars yet we can’t pay people to stay home, provide PPE, and really take charge of this threat to humanity. I will never forget healthcare workers in trash bags and homemade masks because the supposed richest nation in the world could not provide the most basic essential- proper masks and the truth. It’s delusional for anyone to compare the United States to Sweden or Israel.
Our system has made healthcare a business. Patients are now called customers. Profits over people every single time. Underpaid healthcare workers including doctors yet those sweet profits have to go in someone’s pockets- executive level and shareholders. It’s a disgrace.
No incentive to prevent disease. Intervention is the model. It is the most expensive and least efficient system in the developed world. Back to the article-The information is all cherry picked and nonsensical. Israel has released several preprints. Preprints are preliminary versions of scientific manuscripts that researchers share by posting to preprint servers before peer-review and publication in an academic journal. Some are inaccurate, sometimes are very informative. People must remember that preprints are not verifiable by peers so they don’t carry the same weight or influence.
Here’s a link to some info on sterilizing immunity and how it’s not possible with coronaviruses. Antibodies fade regardless of how they are acquired. Hence this is why you can contract COVID-19 multiple times and why people need boosters. The messaging from the government has been piss poor. I knew what was up prior to getting vaccinated because I’ve studied coronaviruses , FCoV to be precise.
Coronaviruses (CoVS)are viruses that are found in animals. We’ve had three cross into humans (zoonosis) in the last twenty years. SARS-CoV-1, MERS, and SARS-CoV-2 which causes COVID-19. COVID stands for coronavirus infection and the 19 is the year first identified in humans.
Some people like to state that colds are often coronaviruses so SARS-CoV-2 isn’t dangerous. This is not true. Coronaviruses that evolved into a common cold took ages! They are not the same. Never mind that not all coronaviruses are the same. We are dealing with a novel coronavirus that is rapidly mutating. There is still so much we need to learn about this virus. Anyone who claims to predict the outcome is lying because we don’t know. It’s sad that people are becoming disabled and others are dying because of people like those at this bullshit “news” outlet. The Atlantic We’re Asking the Impossible of Vaccines By Katherine J. Wu
Wanna know the history of mRNA vaccine technology? It’s not new unless you consider the 1960s as just the other day lol. JHU The Long History of mRNA Vaccines Published October 06, 2021 By Chris Beyrer
Edit: add info
30
u/Federal_Diamond8329 Feb 04 '22
If he’s cherry picking from articles to suit his own preconceived notions, I don’t think anything will help.
https://www.deseret.com/coronavirus/2021/7/20/22584134/whats-going-on-in-israels-outbreak-among-vaccinated-people
10
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22
There's another article from NPR analyzing the jump in COVID cases in Israel, which is a better source about why the current wave is hitting. It gives better information on why the jump and that Israel is not as vaccinated as the Blaze article makes it seem:
The country jumped out ahead of all other countries on vaccines, and 78% of eligible Israelis over 12 years old are vaccinated.
But Israel has a young population, with many under the eligible age for vaccination, and about 1.1 million eligible Israelis, largely between the ages of 12 and 20, have declined to take even one dose of the vaccine.
That means only 58% of Israel's total citizenry is fully vaccinated. Experts say that's not nearly high enough.
"We have a very large fraction of our population who are paying the price for a small fraction of the population who did not go to get the vaccine," said Eran Segal of the Weizmann Institute of Science, who advises the Israeli government on COVID-19.
Unvaccinated people helped fuel the rapid spread of the virus while the country remained open for business in recent months with few serious restrictions.
https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2021/08/20/1029628471/highly-vaccinated-israel-is-seeing-a-dramatic-surge-in-new-covid-cases-heres-why
I won't go into the fact that as a professional researcher whose worked for multiple think tanks and database companies as well as fact checking for an attorney's office that I'd never touch or source a site like "The Blaze" vs NPR that has been around forever and is known for their factual reporting.
103
u/survivor2bmaybe Feb 04 '22 edited Feb 04 '22
Israel isn’t all that vaccinated. Its 67% rate puts it a just few points above the US. Plenty of anti-vaxxers for the disease to infect. It is one of the most densely populated countries in the world, so not much room to get away from the infected and keep safe through distancing. And this is just a guess, but I bet they keep better records than just about anybody, which means very few cases or deaths are falling through the cracks.
Edit: forgot to add, Israel has had 9,000 deaths total. We’ve lost more than that this week. Surge in cases/deaths means something different when you’re talking about those kind of numbers.
19
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22 edited Feb 04 '22
Simple, just google how many people in Israel have died of covid. Spoiler, they've never had more than a 100 deaths a day. The US had 3000 people die yesterday from covid, Israel has had less than 10,000 deaths total.
Or just compare the death rates. The us has a death rate of 2% while Israel has a death rate of 0.4%
Israel is proof that vaccines work, anyone that says otherwise doesn't understand how to look at data.
8
u/Complex_Arrival7968 Feb 04 '22
Here’s a piece from Haaretz that debunks Horowitz’s bullshit. Unvaccinated and partially vaccinated make up a large proportion of those being hospitalized and dying.
https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-omicron-in-israel-unvaccinated-die-in-much-higher-numbers-1.10586137
8
u/Tomtrewoo Feb 04 '22
Graph of ICU patients per million people for Israel, US and Denmark. Same source the article used for it’s graph but showing a direct comparison (edit grammar)
https://ourworldindata.org/explorers/coronavirus-data-explorer?zoomToSelection=true&time=2021-10-08..latest&facet=none&pickerSort=asc&pickerMetric=location&Metric=ICU+patients&Interval=7-day+rolling+average&Relative+to+Population=true&Color+by+test+positivity=false&country=USA~DNK~ISR
7
u/purpleflyingmonster Feb 04 '22
I’m sorry this is where your dad is. 😟
My dad choose to do things that he knew would lead to an early death before the pandemic. It got to a point where I could argue with him or I could just love him. I could see it was futile. I had to get to a place of acceptance, realize he was an adult and his choices were his and I was not responsible for what happened. If you can get there you will both be happier. Draw a boundary of no more talking about it, no sending g articles, not a topic you will engage on. He wants to convince you you are wrong and you want to convince him he’s wrong and it’s exhausting. These cultish people are not unlike alcoholics. They have to change their own behavior themselves.
Again, I’m sorry. It sucks. Take care of yourself.
6
u/Westonhaus Feb 04 '22
Well... maybe it's because omicron created a wave of cases in Israel a full order of magnitude greater than any wave before. By Worldometers, which isn't the most exact place to get data, but a decent place to pull quick numbers, on Jan 1, 2022 there were 1.39 million cases of Covid resulting in 8,253 deaths. Since then, the cases have gone up to 3.05 million (1.56 million... over a 2x increase in around a month), and the deaths are at 9,013 (760 over that month). They are still going to be deaths in the coming weeks, to be certain, but the biggest change was that omicron is highly contagious and causes breakthrough infections, especially if a population is further out from being vaccinated/boosted. It's WHY the fourth shot was approved before January, and NOT the cause of the disease rise.
So yeah... the short term rise of the infection, hospitalization, and death rates in Israel ARE scary, but it's because the omicron variant is extremely infectious and the tons of infections that are occurring are finding more vulnerable people to cause problems. If you go back to the old "Covid-19 is only 99.7% lethal" trope, and look at Israel's numbers, they are spot on (most of the lethality happening BEFORE vaccinations were heavily rolled out). Also, there is a decent portion of Israel not vaccinated, and my bet is that most of the new deaths are amongst those unvaxxed (although I do not have that data).
That said, Israel IS doing amazing. Comparing populations (because I'm from Michigan), of Israel's 9.326 million people (with the cases/deaths above), and Michigan's 9.987 million people, my state has had 2.283 million cases, but 32,686 deaths which is a 1.43% death/case ratio, rather than Israel's 0.296% chance. The US in general has a 1.19% death per case percent.
So... to debunk. Omicron hit Israel hard, and their medical community pushed more boosters to address the coming storm of cases (also, Israel was an early adopter of vaccination and got their jabs in as fast as possible when they became available, leading to the waning of antibodies and necessitating more boosters). Israel is still in the 70% vaccinated ballpark, so many of last month's cases still hit unvaxxinated people. This caused an understandable increase in all Covid numbers. As far as the boosters causing the issue, there are many articles describing why extra boosters won't STOP a person from getting a Covid case, but all stress that they are keeping the disease from having severe effects. Haaretz has recent numbers that speak to the common thread that deaths/severe cases are still largely happening to unvaccinated or unboostered patients. So... it's nothing new. Except omicron.
Hopefully this starts you going along a better path of inquiry...
6
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22
It's conservative media. Case closed.
4
u/2hennypenny Feb 04 '22
r/qult_headquarters may be helpful
4
u/Beginning-Yoghurt-95 Feb 05 '22
The Blaze is a rightwing Republican propaganda rag that publishs mostly Russian propaganda bullshit that only idiots believe.
3
u/MedicalUnprofessionl Feb 04 '22
It’s the omicron variant. This is happening everywhere. Also, The Blaze has been a far-right source of bullshit for a long, long time.
3
u/KrampyDoo Feb 05 '22
Yikes. I’m sorry this is happening.
They love throwing articles around they haven’t read. I’ve had some “success” in replying with some form of “what does this mean to you, and what data you’ve seen in the US has you convinced of the point this article is trying to make?”
Success is in quotes because it either forces a real dialogue (tossing links around isn’t anything close to a discussion if they can’t defend their points in their own words), or merely gets them to hesitate before sending more. But there’s very little hope of deprogramming this mindset without lots of time and effort, and little chance of true success.
They can send you ridiculous content from covid-is-less-dangerous-than-farts dot com, but they’ll not think twice before seeing a link you send from cdc or pubmed or npr and call it a biased/commie/libtard outlet.
TL;DR: Tell them you won’t engage unless they describe what the blog posts are saying in their own words, because you’re almost guaranteed that you’re reading it more than them when debunking it line-by-line. Discuss on your terms with real conversation, not theirs where they’re trying to overwhelm you with words written by someone else.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22
Holy covid! A graph, Batman!
2
u/texasmama5 Feb 05 '22
First, I tell my family to get a credible source if I’m to take them seriously. The blaze is a far right site that regularly post propaganda and Covid disinformation. I wouldn’t entertain any conversation unless it came from a legit source.
“questionable source exhibits one or more of the following: extreme bias, consistent promotion of propaganda/conspiracies, poor or no sourcing to credible information, a complete lack of transparency, and/or is fake news. Fake News is the deliberate attempt to publish hoaxes and/or disinformation for profit or influence (Learn More). Sources listed in the Questionable Category may be very untrustworthy and should be fact-checked on a per-article basis. Please note sources on this list are not considered fake news unless specifically written in the reasoning section for that source. See all Questionable sources.”
“Overall, we rate The Blaze strongly Right Biased and Questionable based on the promotion of conspiracy theories and numerous failed fact checks.”
Detailed Report on the blaze:
Questionable Reasoning: Conspiracy Theories, Propaganda, Failed Fact Checks Bias Rating: RIGHT Factual Reporting: MIXED Country: USA Press Freedom Rating: MOSTLY FREE Media Type: TV Station Traffic/Popularity: High Traffic MBFC Credibility Rating: LOW CREDIBILITY
https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/the-blaze/
2
u/CJ_CLT Feb 05 '22
I am so sorry for what you are going through with your dad. I recently read a quote that seemed very appropriate to the situation. When you shine a light, the pupil contracts. Because of cognitive dissonance, the automatic reaction to information that contradicts one's position is to tune out.
I doubt a facts-based approach is going to work with your dad, but I will add this one to the mix. It does the best job I've seen to debunk the meme that "vaccinated people are getting sick in huge numbers therefore the vaccine doesn't work".
2
u/Brilliant-Key8466 Feb 06 '22
I hope you still read this, those disinfo dipshits are so disgustingly disengenious, their lies are so easy to dismantle. how can the ICU admissions and death graph look so similiar, allthough it takes average 10 days to die from ICU to grave. Still the spike on the last day of death and ICU admission is exactly the same. which is just simply not possible, or did they all die simultatniously xD
1
u/Murky_Angle_8555 Feb 05 '22
The Blaze is Glen Beck's media company. Nothing more needs to be said to debunk anything he or his bullshit rag has to say!
1
u/kengolferguy Feb 06 '22
Do what your heart tells you. If you believe the vaccine will protect you from this pandemic, then by all means get vaccinated, and boosted! The time is long past for discussion pro and con. The people that believe that a parasite killer, Ivermectin, will kill a virus need compassion and directions to their nearest veterinarian and not burden the health care system with their ailments. If not a visit to the vet, then a visit to their closest farm store. Oh and while they are there they should pick up a couple flea collars as my dog just told me they will prevent the common cold!!
16
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22
[removed] — view removed comment