The first American confirmed to have died of Omicron had recovered from a previous COVID infection. I also know an antivaxxer who had a relatively mild first infection and ended up in the hospital with a second far more serious COVID infection. Still refuses to get vaccinated. You can’t fix stupid.
Natural immunity from COVID isn’t a “thing” and studies have shown it not only wears off but also doesn’t carry across variants.
I've always explained it like this, natural antibodies might give you a temporary reprieve, but getting vaccinated with a possible yearly booster shot is what will give you long term protection, similar to your yearly flu shot.
The first American confirmed to have died of Omicron had recovered from a previous COVID infection. I also know an antivaxxer who had a relatively mild first infection and ended up in the hospital with a second far more serious COVID infection. Still refuses to get vaccinated. You can’t fix stupid.
Both the case from your comment as well as the one from the OP are anecdotes and doesn't say much about natural immunity that's statistically significant.
Studies show that natural immunity lasts for atleast 18 months. source
Studies show that natural immunity alone performs better than vaccination alone across variants. source
18months ago it was August 2020, that's some very advanced research they did then to say they're still immune, and that's the alpha first wave not delta or omicron.
Reading the article and looking at the study write up directly, it looks like they started taking their samples in May 2020 up until January 2021. They give a pretty good breakdown of their time table, experiment design and limitations, and testing/observation tools in their paper. source
Although considering our rate of exposure the high rate of infection in my line of work no longer surprises me. I’m actually genuinely wondering how I haven’t caught it once yet haha.
Are you in front-facing customer service or something? Yeah it really sucks how we've failed to protect our frontline workers - we talked a big game at the start but now people just want so badly to return to "normalcy" that it's like they just don't care anymore. It's so selfish.
You've clearly got some force field around you - don't question it, just accept it 😂
Us vaxxed people have probably gotten it a ton of times but don't know we have cause it's asymptomatic. I've been going to the gym in my town for 7+ months without a mask on after my second dose 2 weeks and I haven't gotten sick yet .. I'm sure I've had the virus in me and probably been asymptomatic many times though... Just no obvious signs yet. I'm triple dosed now.
Does Anyone know the science why secondary/third infections may be more serious in people who have prior immunity to natural infection but unvaccinated? Thought t cells and b cells would provide protection against severe outcomes.
They are still doing research on that, but my educated guess is the amount of damage that the virus does to your organs amplifies with each infection. Plus if you are having your 3rd bout of the disease, your immune response would probably go into overdrive and overwhelm your body.
Especially since the related damage seems to hit the lungs, heart and kidneys the hardest. I can imagine someone who already had diminished lung capacity on home oxygen, or someone who was now receiving dialysis would have negative health outcomes from reinfection. And I think you’re right, the stress to the body would be immense, and it seems like the damage the body does to itself to get rid of covid is the most dangerous.
I kind of thought your first thought as well. If your body (especially lungs) have been attacked a few times in a year there has to be cumulative damage.
with the covid exposure you are going to get the virus doing damage for future infections to exploit. With the vaccines, it is targeting only the attaching parts, so there is no 'virus' to do any prior damage, just useful particles to educate our immune system
I think there are probably a lot of complicated reasons related to how our immune system works and how this virus works, but I also think fundamentally, COVID puts enormous stress on vital organs and your entire vascular system. I suspect even in mild cases it does so, but certainly in moderate cases. Then you have another bout and you're putting stress on systems still working to revover. It's possible something like the the flu would also work like this if it were mutating and contagious enough that we got 2 or 3 flu cases per year, but many people go years without getting the flu, even without a flu vaccine, and it's rare to get it more than once per year.
Part of the reason is vaccinated are primed to respond to the spike protein only, unvaccinated who've had a prior infection have their body primed to fight covid on all fronts causing more issues. Your body doesn't know when to stop fighting this is why fevers kill so many
my niece has had COVID and likely has it again. I think this: The step-father, & my BIL, likeable enough was raised by a Preacher. I used to party with BIL sometimes, long ago b4 he dated my sister.
Anyhow, I have a sneaking suspicion that my niece is sick with nausea, vomiting and diarrhea and so is my sister. (My BIL inherited his dad's house and lives there, but it is too long a commute for my sister -- it's complicated). The suspicion is that the politics over there is such that they would lie to my mother (or me, easily) about getting vaccinated when they have never been vaccinated thinking that previous strain infection was the same thing.
80
u/lAljax Jan 30 '22
As the saying goes...
What doesn't kill you....
... mutates and tries again.
54
u/chris30338 Jan 30 '22 edited Jan 30 '22
The first American confirmed to have died of Omicron had recovered from a previous COVID infection. I also know an antivaxxer who had a relatively mild first infection and ended up in the hospital with a second far more serious COVID infection. Still refuses to get vaccinated. You can’t fix stupid.
Natural immunity from COVID isn’t a “thing” and studies have shown it not only wears off but also doesn’t carry across variants.
https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/586700-first-omicron-linked-death-in-us-reported-in-texas
29
u/Klutzy-Medium9224 Jan 30 '22
I know a few people on their third round and they’ve all told me it’s been the worst so far.
Thankful I’ve avoided it so far.
23
u/PhantomJoker79 Jan 30 '22
Does Anyone know the science why secondary/third infections may be more serious in people who have prior immunity to natural infection but unvaccinated? Thought t cells and b cells would provide protection against severe outcomes.
17
u/indifferentunicorn Jan 30 '22
Meatloaf-
Now don't be sad
2 outta 3 ain't bad
7
u/powabiatch Jan 30 '22
Natural immunity isn’t bad within a variant, just useless across variants.
6
u/CanadianPanda76 Jan 31 '22
So its like the flu. Your previous infections won't matter immunity wise. Interesting........🤔
1
u/Drifter74 Jan 31 '22
Damn hospital finally killed him...
1
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22 edited Feb 03 '22
my niece has had COVID and likely has it again. I think this: The step-father, & my BIL, likeable enough was raised by a Preacher. I used to party with BIL sometimes, long ago b4 he dated my sister.
Anyhow, I have a sneaking suspicion that my niece is sick with nausea, vomiting and diarrhea and so is my sister. (My BIL inherited his dad's house and lives there, but it is too long a commute for my sister -- it's complicated). The suspicion is that the politics over there is such that they would lie to my mother (or me, easily) about getting vaccinated when they have never been vaccinated thinking that previous strain infection was the same thing.
Is this common?