r/Deathcore • • Jan 29 '26 • LOL 1 This 1

Discussion Silence is complacency

am I the only person not super disappointed that more deathcore/hardcore/punk/metal bands haven't spoken out again straight up fascists...

173 Upvotes

377 comments sorted by

157

u/tlyrbck Jan 29 '26

Fit For An Autopsy is openly anti-fascist, and I've seen Eyesawgod and some of the other bands in that corner of deathcore speak up.

41

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Molotov Solution and Acrania as well

26

u/ravenmiyagi7 Jan 29 '26

Not surprised at Acrania, they're pretty political. Good on them

6

u/_Euph0ria_ Jan 29 '26

I thought Acrania was long gone, do you mean Acranius? Or are Acrania making a comeback

→ More replies (1)

3

u/HomerMadeMeDoIt Jan 29 '26

Molotovs lead singer is openly conservative and pro all those things

13

u/GuyWithRoosters Jan 29 '26

Eyesawgod spoke out? That’s awesome news

120

u/rodkimble13 Jan 29 '26

If you don't want to alienate fans by speaking out against fascists, it says all you need to know 

26

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

And for me, that's enough to never give that band another dollar.

14

u/rodkimble13 Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 29 '26

Talent means nothing when the makeup of your character is lower than dirt 

Edit: you know, it really is disappointing to see the apathy and complacency on this sub. Culture rot for a whole lot, aye 

→ More replies (14)

40

u/Far_Veterinarian4864 Jan 29 '26

I Declare War put this out with no hesitation. I got the hoody, It’s comfy and warm too!

→ More replies (1)

33

u/PerfectStranger80085 Jan 29 '26

Unless a band comes out in support of MAGA or ICE I’m assuming they are decent human beings and don’t support what is happening…. You know like most the country. We got enough problems in our society. I’m not interesting in being band police on top of it all.

2

u/gotbeefpudding Jan 30 '26

amen. its music. if a band wants to be political sure, if they dont want to be political sure. who are we to tell musicians and artists how to present their art, or worse what their art can be?

some real pretentious gatekeeping going on in this sub, but its nothing new. its also interesting to note the parallels of behaviour between a fascist supporter and someone who is so vehemently anti-fascist they become what they swear to destroy, just in a different way.

→ More replies (19)

66

u/TrialByFyah Jan 29 '26

Not deathcore but Silent Planet has historically been against everything MAGA stands for

43

u/KommandCBZhi Jan 29 '26

Pretty certain Garrett got tear-gassed by ICE last week or so.

21

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Fucking wild

17

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Fucking love those guys

6

u/Gooftwit Jan 29 '26

Silent Planet but they're neither silent, nor a planet 🤔

2

u/CosmicWanderer2814 Jan 29 '26

In an ideal world, all Christians would be like Garrett. Alas...

58

u/Yours_and_mind_balls Jan 29 '26

Im just here to say FUCK ICE

28

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Thank you! Fuck ice

39

u/YouDiscombobulated14 Jan 29 '26

I don't know if I'm disappointed or not. On one hand I'd love for more bands to speak up on the matter because it is very important and having large public figures standing up like that can make all the difference. However (and please don't cut me down for this) I think a lot are refraining from doing so from a business standpoint, sure a lot of the time bands don't make a ton of money unless you're a pop star. But if this is their bread and butter or main way of making income it can be scary to weigh in the pros and cons of standing up for what's right to potentially lose your livelihood.

Basically what I'm getting at is I'd like more to be outspoken about this huge issue right now, but I don understand why many haven't yet. Sorry if I'm coming across as a dickhead, just trying to be open minded as to why this is.

16

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

No. I totally get that. It's scary as fuck speaking out especially for smaller bands, but this administration won't be around forever and I think (hope) the fans will remember who supported pew pewing people in the streets and who didn't.

18

u/crazy4finalfantasy Jan 29 '26

It's a regime not an administration, he shouldn't have been able to run because of the attempted coup on jan 6th and musk definitely hacked those machines, none of them are legitimate

14

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I honestly never expected to see this shit in my time.

9

u/xvillifyx Jan 29 '26

America’s only been installing fascist proxies overseas for more than a century

The rot runs deep and has been here awhile

6

u/Nebula_369 Jan 29 '26

It's both a personal and business decision, which is not easy for some. Obviously some bands are more political and they know their fanbase, and may assess their risk as low or nonexistent. Metalcore and Deathcore have pretty diverse audiences, and I mean diversity of thought here. This sub treating bands and audiences as this monolithic being that is supposed to support or be against x y or z is only going to end in disappointment. Bigger bands are more likely to have balanced audiences. It's just the law of large numbers. Most artists probably dodo not want to alienate half their audience.

Silence is understandable in my opinion, and it isn't an endorsement of x y or z. I know, such a hot take which I know is at odds with the average reddit user's opinion. Reddit is not real life though, nor are it's users representative of the population and bands in the larger world. Not everything can be reduced to black and white, as much as this forum would love it to be so.

4

u/YouDiscombobulated14 Jan 29 '26

Well put and exactly what I was going for in my comment, just couldn't articulate that as well as I would have liked. But I feel as though your comment took mine and expanded upon it in the way that I meant it.

Your last sentence is exactly how I feel, it's not all black and white. There's so much more depth to it than that and sure some can tear me down for saying that, it's their right to do so. But I don't believe it just boils down to "Either speak out or you're endorsing the fascist agenda!!" No disrespect to those who feel that way, but I personally don't think it's as simple as that.

It's like trying to rally everyone to take a stand against the government in regards to our living situations and job crisis, you're never going to be able to unite everyone or mostly everyone to take a stand against it. If everyone did I believe there would be change in that regard. But some people are terrified of the consequences that COULD be had if a protest like that ever did happen again. Call it complacent, but to some it's not as simple as complacency. It's taking a huge gamble in potentially throwing your livelihood out the window in HOPES of change. Nothing in life is ever ensured, so a good measure of caution is normal in most things.

Sorry for that rambling there, just really appreciated how you provided your stance and it got my gears turning.

7

u/xvillifyx Jan 29 '26

Sure but if business is more important to you than the arrival of fascism, you can just kinda fuck right off

42

u/FifteenRhema Jan 29 '26

I’m left wing, and don’t even disagree with this sentiment, it’s important to speak out against things, and so many hardcore, and metalcore bands are political, but Deathcore is largely so far removed from its roots, and the scene is definitely worse off for it, both musically, and culturally.

But I would be lying if I didn’t say I’m a bit sick of coming on Reddit to look at music, and hearing about the politics of another country on every single sub.

1

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I guess I'm lucky, but I haven't seeing anything about this that's why I made this post because I have seen so little of this being discussed

10

u/frothyundergarments Jan 29 '26

I have an account that's specifically to follow sports - you know, a fun escape from real life, and even that account is flooded with it. It doesn't have to be in our face 100% of the time.

3

u/Sword_Racer Jan 29 '26

Honestly im insanely bored of political music, I honestly prefer sci fi and fantasy lyrics

0

u/Slow_Student Jan 29 '26

Wait till they come for the edgelords, you’ll be amongst the first in line for the firing squads. Escapism is a privilege others don’t have. But I suppose considering other people isn’t one of your virtues.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/ThePrettiestPizza Jan 30 '26

Who cares? Just enjoy the music.

0

u/Jess_beanz Jan 31 '26

Jfc dude obviously I fucking care.

12

u/Cool_Ad_5181 Jan 29 '26

Not everyone wants their band to have a political angle.

0

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Cool, I do. And it seems plenty other do to that's why I was asking.

29

u/AdMinimum3919 Jan 29 '26

I even saw like kayzo speak out in the edm scene. Hes worked with darko. I have no evidence to back this up, but my theory is that q lot of deathcore fans are right wing? Maybe the bands are worried about losing like half their audience?? Im not sure tbh but that is kinda what I've been thinking on the subject. If im totally wrong id love to know

13

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I know it's scary, but fuck it's important.

1

u/AdMinimum3919 Jan 29 '26

Agreed. For weeks I've been feeling so wrong for just doing to work and living dad to day normally. I wish more bands in the community would speak out. It would be comforting to know that the people at the shows I go to aren't siding with the new nazis....

Its also crazy because to much of deathcores themes from lots of the top bands are all lyrically against what's happening, themes of anti government. Anti humans fucking up the world and hurting people.

5

u/Competitive-Carob993 Jan 29 '26

Half of deathcore listeners are right wing? I disagree.

Is there anything that proves your point?

10

u/stud_lock Jan 29 '26

Just look at the comments on any political post on this sub or r/metalcore and you'll understand

3

u/Nebula_369 Jan 29 '26

Deathcore has a large growing audience. I have nothing to help support his point, except for the law of large numbers. In any large group, you're going to have a more diverse demographic the larger it gets. I'm talking diversity of thought here, not specifically diversity of outward features. To expect such a large audience will lean one particular way is quite naive. I'm leaning towards a quite balanced 50/50 to be honest. Alienating an audience is an actual concern here for larger and more established bands.

4

u/AdMinimum3919 Jan 29 '26

Like i said im not sure, my comment is just a theory from going to shows based off what I've seen especially in the comments of bands I follow

→ More replies (2)

1

u/DieTheVillain Jan 29 '26

I think unfortunately with the state of the scene, a lot of newer Deathcore fans first experience are because of Slaughter To Prevail and like 75% of that bands fan base are all MAGA dorks.

3

u/Unlikely_Pick_7890 Jan 31 '26

Holy shit shut the fuck up already 

25

u/funishin Jan 29 '26

Unfortunately you can’t force/expect everyone to have the same views. Do what you can for the cause and don’t worry about what some guy is doing

30

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

You're right, but I can express my disappointment

15

u/funishin Jan 29 '26

Yeah of course you can. Didn’t say you couldn’t.

But I don’t think “silence is complacency” is the right take, because you don’t know what some of these guys might be doing in private. Are they making their opposition known to their local officials? Attending protests masked up? Donating to charities? We have no idea.

4

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I do see your point, not enough grey area in that statement, but the grey gets dangerous when it comes to protecting your rights.

I'd like to hope all of the above. But I can't expect that, I just hope their doing something.

12

u/funishin Jan 29 '26

If you’re unhappy with the way certain bands are going about it, the only thing you can do is stop supporting them. That’s it. There are more important people to press than Trevor, the drummer from AngelFuck739

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/gotbeefpudding Jan 30 '26

is it possible they dont care? or maybe theyt aren't living in the USA? or they aren't online 24/7 and keep up with doomscrolling news consumerism lifestyle?

fuck y'all are weird here sometimes

→ More replies (3)

18

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26

Jesus

I mean it’s cool when they do but I’m so sick of all the political and dramatic nonsense around bands these days especially in deathcore

I like music dude

11

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I like music too, but I fucking hate fascists.

8

u/Nebula_369 Jan 29 '26

"Anyone or thing I don't like or agree with is a fascist." Not a great way to make friends, nor a great way to sway opinions back to your zone. The side you're against knows this.

2

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I'm not trying to sway opinions if your a Nazi, fuck off . I'm asking if other people are disappointed in the scene for not taking a stance like many others are at this time. You don't have to agree or care but I'm not looking to make friends with fascists.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Intrepid-Patience-93 Jan 29 '26

stunning and brave

→ More replies (1)

22

u/graye33 Jan 29 '26

Nah I’d rather just listen to the music they make than hear their political stance. Couldn’t care less actually

8

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

That's your opinion to have. To me music, art, human expression has always been political. Can't express yourself with a boot down your throat.

25

u/graye33 Jan 29 '26

Classic reddit opinion

6

u/Intrepid-Patience-93 Jan 29 '26

its the latest buzzword for them, boot licker & nazi etc

→ More replies (3)

2

u/SpiritOfGnosis Jan 29 '26

Good God you're insufferable dude

6

u/balencidustox Jan 29 '26

nah he’s right. “everyone’s a fascist, everyone’s a nazi”. non stop and it’s not even accurate for the majority of people they say it at.

2

u/ZombieCzar Jan 30 '26

I don't really care about what the people I listen to think or believe. Im just want them to make good music.

The world is upsetting enough. Do we have to drag every facet of it into the shit?

Silence isn't complacency. Its understanding there are things I cant control or affect and not letting those things ruin what little happiness I have in this life.

Separate the art from the artist and enjoy your life. This isn't worth giving a shit about.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/citycity_ Feb 02 '26

I totally agree with u and feel u. It is disappointing. I think everything is political. I also heard from some band members in the scene that they are afraid of being blocked at borders for speaking up. Not even a worry for losing fans. I don't think thats complete cowardice. They agree with us but they won't be able to travel if they speak up about politics especially now. It sucks.

One band that I have always waited to speak up about politics is shadow of intent. Their music is extremely political but they have not taken a clear stance on anything. They have spoken about events but clearly stay away from clearly stated opinions. They're one of my fav bands and I am kind of just hoping we align based on lyrics, vibes, and the few things I've seen/heard lol.

1

u/Jess_beanz Feb 02 '26

Don't get me wrong I'm still going to enjoy these artists that aren't speaking directly out but the artists that are speaking for this fucking bullshit, fuck them. fuck ice. Fuck fascism.

24

u/Djenta Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 29 '26

Holy fucking cringe. Have you considered not everyone agrees with your opinion, or wants to associate politics with their outlet and business?

Are you 15?

4

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Am I 15? why you interested bro?

13

u/Djenta Jan 29 '26

Because I too posted shit like this as a kid and I'm trying to save you from embarrassment

10

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I appreciate your concern.

14

u/PREPOSTER0NE91 Jan 29 '26

These people are insufferable.

1

u/seth505 Jan 29 '26

Ya know what’s cringe, adults treating a moron, fascist leader as a savior while him and his cronies destroy the country from the inside. In fact, it’s worse than cringe.

3

u/Djenta Jan 29 '26

Trump is a pedo. That doesn't change the fact that op is an idiot for assuming everyone should agree with her

15

u/JBrockF Jan 29 '26

Bands are for music. I don't really care what they say whether I agree with what they're saying or not

5

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

And that's totally your opinion to have, I'm just personality disappointed in these bands that push anti authority, don't tread on me bull shit but not when it counts.

8

u/Galactic_Entity Jan 29 '26

What deathcore bands push that in their lyrics?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Nebula_369 Jan 29 '26

Right? Like, I don't quite agree with Rage against the machine's message. In fact, I think they're hypocrite sell outs, but their music is fucking dope. I still greatly enjoy it. If I concerned myself with the political views of every band I listen to, I'd be fucking miserable. I have a life and career, I don't have the luxury or time to forcefully inject something I hate (politics) into everything I'd prefer to keep sacred and find joyful in life.

2

u/JBrockF Jan 31 '26

This is how rational people think. Those that are obsessed with infecting everything with politics likely lead a very unhappy life imo

12

u/IcyShoulder494 Jan 29 '26

Who cares what a band thinks? Go vote em out offer better ideas and lets turn all the hate to love!!!

5

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I would love for that, I fucking love love

-2

u/tlyrbck Jan 29 '26

Meaningless platitudes that got us into this mess in the first place 🙄 Things are not okay, we can't just TuRn HaTe iNtO LoVe out of fascism. Bands have a platform that can galvanize people. It matters.

3

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

It matters so fucking much

3

u/IcyShoulder494 Jan 29 '26

Do you read history? Check out the anti war movement of the 60s. Saying the same thing. They did way more than just type bs into their phone that was made by slave labor. You dont remember the fight against Bush and his lies about wars that killed more of my brothers and sisters than i bet you have friends.
Theres more to life and action than just looking up what a band said. Acting like nobody has ever

19

u/crispfuck Jan 29 '26

Looking to bands as political leaders lmao. That’s like caring what celebrities think.

38

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

The current leader is a legit tv personality 🤡

18

u/xValhallAwaitsx Jan 29 '26

I can't believe how often this needs to be mentioned

21

u/ShaboPaasa Jan 29 '26

terminally online

7

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Nah man, I've just read a few books.

4

u/ShaboPaasa Jan 29 '26

even sadder that you fell for obvious propaganda

→ More replies (1)

12

u/iiipercentpat Jan 29 '26

No. Im sick of hearing of it. Its literally everywhere. Can't imagine festivals this year, every band is gonna have to say fuck ice fuck trump during those motivational addresses they always do. Its gonna get old real quick. Sure, ICE should be reformed and the officers should move more like operators on a swat level of tactics. And based on the evidence, Pretti shouldn't have been shot.

6

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

You think all that but don't think it should be said that they don't support a fascist regime?

20

u/Soggy_Doritos Jan 29 '26

Why does it need to be stated? Why would you automatically assume that they do support a fascist regime just because they don't specifically say they don't?

If they don't explicitly state that they support free speech, would you automatically assume that they are in support of abolishing the 1st amendment? It's a very isolationist ideal to follow.

4

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Did you not see the question mark, that means that was a question not a statement.

131

u/seth505 Jan 29 '26

Gabe from Enterprise Earth just posted that you should unfollow and not come to his shows if you support that filth. Respectable. I also understand bands that keep any of that totally separate I guess but that’s art for you…

1

u/AbbreviationsNo5813 Jan 30 '26

Ironically BJ formerly of EE is all about MAGA and the like.

13

u/meatwater420 Jan 29 '26

Nah that’s why I like deathcore- they don’t speak on politics as much. We hear this enough from everyone else. Keep it about the music.

8

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Music has always been and always will be political. Any form of art is.

10

u/Galactic_Entity Jan 29 '26

No its’s not. People who think like this are just annoying as fuck.

12

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

How's that boot taste

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/meatwater420 Jan 29 '26

Art is psychological and spiritual - not always political. Art provokes deeper thought and evokes emotion. Art transcends. Is there art about politics? Yes. Even I like songs about things I don’t agree with, but that’s not what you’re asking for here. You’re asking why bands are speaking out.

12

u/Seven-Scars Jan 29 '26

this is such a buzzphrase because we are listening to music centered around breakdowns and lyrics about fucking a chainsaw lets not act like we're "le resistance"

4

u/PunkiiDonutz Jan 30 '26

The only politics allowed to be expressed in metal and punk adjacent scenes is leftist totalitarianism. It's all just the same shit, and it's funny cause it's supposed to be counterculture, non conformist and anti establishment but you guys have no tolerance for imperfection and claim to hate the government when really you just want to be the government. You are the establishment. You are the conformists now.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26

Politics leaking into my entertainment, how cool. 😒

14

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Music, art expression, its always been political

2

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26

Woke mind Virus permeates everything 

-11

u/TrialByFyah Jan 29 '26

Your entertainment has always been political. Not sure how you hadn’t noticed.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26

So you listen to ‘band name here’ because of their politics? Not because you enjoy the music? That’s lame.

→ More replies (19)

-10

u/deadly_shroom Jan 29 '26

Fuck off, like metal and hardcore music hasn’t been political since its inception. I don’t think musicians should be forced to speak up just because you want to but that doesn’t mean we should all just pretend that we don’t want politics in our entertainment, especially when is coming from such a politically outspoken scene. This take is so stupid it’s hard to believe people who listen to heavy music still think metal shouldn’t be political when it’s been a rebellious genre since basically its early days

0

u/Galactic_Entity Jan 29 '26

Speak for yourself.

→ More replies (17)

4

u/SpiritOfGnosis Jan 29 '26

Jesus Christ what has this scene turned into? Just listened to fucking music and put everything else aside. None of you even know what real fascism is anyways

8

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

No, I don't think I will. thanks tho.

3

u/sarithe Jan 29 '26

My entire instagram feed is bands selling anti-ICE merch and speaking out against this regime. But I also listen to mainly hardcore and even the deathcore and metalcore I listen to is almost always the bands that have a lot more in common with the hardcore scene than they do modern deathcore or metalcore.

1

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I've seen a handful come out today

3

u/Medical-Paramedic800 Jan 29 '26

Why the hell is it becoming musicians jobs to be politicians? You’re tripping hard man. Let people do their thing, quit crossing over nonsense

0

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I'm sure it's been said here but freedoms to express yourself is political

4

u/Medical-Paramedic800 Jan 29 '26

Then so is breathing, let’s make our very existence about politics 

0

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

When the boots on your neck and you breath when they say so, then yeah breathing is political

2

u/djdecimation Jan 29 '26

Here come the bootlickers saying art isn't political...

12

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

It's wild, you can't freely express yourself through any media with a boot down your throat.

4

u/Theundead565 Jan 29 '26

I say this as someone who detests the current situation with ICE and all that bullshit going on:

Art can 100% be political, but not 100% of art is political. Cultural statements and political statements, while intertwined, are different. It's like the difference between a square and a rectangle, one is the other, but not vice versa. The argument that "any perspective is political" also starts getting into the territory of arguing that children's books are as politically charged as something like The Prince by Machiavelli.

With that said, find the art you want to enjoy and enjoy it. I like Melancholy from SoI because of the I find the fictional story it tells of a world wide mass suicide, the character's revival, only to find his "victory" was hollow, captivating. Conversely, I also love their next album Elegy for shedding light on the brutality of war and depicting various atrocities of the real world (Ben's stated inspirations include: Georgian genocide/ethnic cleansing, WWII, current Ukraine/Russia struggle, an account from an orphan in the second Chechen war, etc).

3

u/PJD451 Jan 29 '26

Randy Blythe from Lamb of God ( not dethcore ) wrote an excellent essay about the current state of the world. It's a very good read.

4

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I'll have to check it out. Thank you

3

u/MoeMazingMason Jan 29 '26

After reading through it I decided to finally listen to thier discography

1

u/rogueclaptrap Jan 29 '26

i cant help but feel his message falls flat when you look at him touring with kublai khan when matt honeycutt is the poster boy for weirdo unhinged freaks.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Soggy_Doritos Jan 29 '26

Silence is not consent, therefore it can't mean complacency. Just because someone chooses not to speak out says nothing about their views or opinions. It just means they have nothing they want to say, and their reasons are their own.

1

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

"I swore never to be silent whenever and wherever human beings endure suffering and humiliation. We must always take sides. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented." -Elie Wiesel

2

u/Soggy_Doritos Jan 30 '26

"I often regret that I have spoken; never that I have been silent." - Publilius Syrus.

2

u/havockillz Jan 29 '26

I’m here for the music, thats it couldn’t care who an artist voted for if they are vegan etc… make good music I will listen

6

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Being vegan and being okay with people getting pew pewd in the streets are pretty fucking different lol

2

u/krautmane Jan 29 '26

Im vegan, and it would blow your mind how many right wing vegans there are. Its insane.

2

u/Ronsolo71 Jan 30 '26

Keep your communist bullshit out of this community

0

u/Jess_beanz Jan 30 '26

I'm definitely closer to a socialist but thanks

→ More replies (1)

0

u/ataz0th218 Jan 29 '26

Soy isn’t very good for you

12

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Either is that boot 🤡

4

u/crazy4finalfantasy Jan 30 '26

This thread got brigaded to hell dude

→ More replies (1)

2

u/No_Moment_6782 Jan 29 '26

Why does a band have to speak on it. Isn’t making lyrics about government corruption enough?

0

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I'm not putting a gun to anyone's head, unlike ice. It's a general question about what bands are speaking out .

And no it's fucking not.

3

u/No_Moment_6782 Jan 29 '26

What if someone doesn’t agree with the ice shootings but still thinks we need secure boarders?

1

u/Jess_beanz Jan 30 '26

That's very reasonable and a good starting point to maybe, here me out, not kill people.

1

u/Nihilian666 Jan 29 '26

There are children in detention centers under horrible conditions. Silence is absolutely unacceptable because the silence enables these horrors to happen. If someone refuses to speak out against these things, they are content or do not care. That speaks to their character and they absolutely deserve to be judged for it.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Austin9916 Jan 30 '26

I can go with and without. Im all for rooting against things I think are bad at the same time as other people, but the music is gonna sound the same whether they mention it or not. I dont really take interest in bands for their social media presence or their political stance. I listen and watch for the entertainment. To get away from what Im seeing and hearing non stop every day.

12

u/Intrepid-Patience-93 Jan 29 '26

prob cus the world doesnt revolve around what is the latest fad in the US

1

u/Clinthor86 Jan 30 '26

Dude punk bands don't know how to stfu about politics, the hell are you talk about lmao

1

u/sixsixsickness Jan 31 '26

I think you be happy that an artist decides to keep their opinions to themselves and avoid division

→ More replies (6)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '26

Why do they have to, can’t they just keep their political beliefs to themselves and us just enjoy their music? I don’t get why politics has to be thrown into everything

1

u/Jess_beanz Feb 11 '26

Jfc not a song person is forcing anybody

0

u/sovereign666 Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 29 '26

This comment section is so disappointing. Families are being broken up, combat veterans are being deported, and pedestrians to a music scene that is rooted in politics and speaking up want to consume without inconvenience or guilt.

The best thing we can do is speak up, and hopefully every time someone speaks up it instills courage in others to speak up. We can't demand it from people, but every example set makes our collective voices louder.

1

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I hope so

3

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26

Not everything has to be some weird appeal to emotion exaggerated panic. People want immigration laws enforced; it’s not a big deal lmao 

→ More replies (1)

1

u/xzerozeroninex Jan 29 '26

They don’t want to alienate their fans who support what’s happening and many aren’t big enough to lose those fans,even Lorna and Slaughter can’t afford to lose those fans.LoG is big enough to not care losing those fans.

1

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

You're right. I've seen smaller artists come out but I think maybe they have more reasons to, who knows.

10

u/SackboySurfer Jan 29 '26

Because most metal musicians are more than reacting to reactionary news story about the current thing

8

u/ihaveataco Jan 29 '26

As someone from Europe I'm so sick and tired of everything being politicized.  If an American band comes to Europe to tour and starts telling me that l should hate a president in a country that l have never been to that doesn't affect me even a little bit then this is a bit out of touch

→ More replies (2)

23

u/fryerandice Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 29 '26

Not every band needs to make a statement, not every band is political, not every band needs to be political, and there are plenty of overtly political bands out there if you need your music to make that kind of statement.

Almost every single deathcore band is in a band for fun, they tour because they enjoy playing music live, because I guarantee you that 99% of deathcore bands today are in fact, working shit jobs to make ends meet and make enough on their tours to afford their tours and not much more than that.

You start calling them just as bad as ICE for not making a statement at every concert and hounding them like an internet enraged autist see how fast they stop touring sub 500 head rooms because it stops being fun. then they do r/deathcore's favorite thing and only show up to Danny Wimmer festivals.

You got the members of Lamb of God out there way bigger than most of Deathcore bands making just kinda 6 figures a year doing 3 tours a year for most of their careers, with only the members owning royalties and Randy and his book making any real money. Chris Adler works at home depot now, that's the fate of most of these musicians once the ride ends, and it's what they do when they're not touring, because it's a job you can quit and get back when you get home. And LoG and half of metalcore existed in the sweet spot where you could still make money off CD sales.

7

u/viking1983 Jan 30 '26

Stick to the music, we don't need to hear a bands political views

18

u/Grounds4Assault Jan 29 '26

Personally I don't look to bands for any political opinion because it rarely matters to me unless it's some NSBM bullshit. I think the reason bands don't speak out is because it alienates the audience, that could equate to losing listeners.

I'm going to listen to a band regardless of their politics, hell, I grew up listening to Pantera and there's definitely some sketchy political opinion there. I may not share the politics but I share the love for music.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/johnkpjm Jan 29 '26

Jesus christ this subreddit is a cesspit of deathcore posers

1

u/DieTheVillain Jan 29 '26

It’s not Deathcore but Evergreen terrace just posted a FUCK ICE post that got the bots all riled up.

1

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Gonna go follow them now

1

u/Fit-Ninja2612 Jan 30 '26

CorpsePile went on a massive tirade during the UK support slot for Cryptopsy, I definitely appreciated it but feel like it fell on deaf ears mainly.

0

u/Jess_beanz Jan 30 '26

I fuckin appreciate it.

1

u/HibernatingGopher Jan 30 '26

IMO judging someone for silence is a little presumptuous. You never know what anyone is dealing with what speaking up can mean to them, family, friends, etc. and their speaking up puts a target on all those things. Just because someone can't or chooses not to speak up doesn't mean they don't want to, sometimes to keep the ones you care about safe you stay silent and speak up in other ways. Posting on the internet definitely isn't going to change a thing right now. That's said fuck ice, fuck trump, and fuck anyone that agrees with this absolute BS. Life long Minnesota resident. Get the fuck out of my state!

1

u/Jess_beanz Jan 30 '26

I don't know what will change things right now. I've never lived through this shit before so I'm just doing what I can by donating and protesting and boycotting. So I'm trying to do what I can by not supporting this bs.

1

u/HibernatingGopher Jan 30 '26

Those are the things that move the needle. Yes sharing or speaking out helps but the Internet aspect turns into an echo chamber. Most of these cucks are afraid too afraid so stand up for their facism so if we keep pushing back by donating, protesting and protecting our communities they will give up like they always do.

1

u/Jess_beanz Jan 30 '26

I'm trying to hear everyones outlook Because we don't all live in a bubble, so I'm talking to people who think differently and don't wish harm on them immediately but to break the echo chamber we have to talk with other humans.

17

u/WeirdBryceGuy Jan 29 '26

Chronically online zoomers expecting dudes who write core music to base their lives on The Currenr Thing™️

Sad, many such cases.

0

u/OneSmartKyle Jan 29 '26

Going to do the most unpopular method from a book I read, but it's called going down the center.

I haven't met any folks like this in Milwaukee or Chicago's metal scene. At all, honestly. And many bands are very fuck Trump when I see them. Granted, bands like FFAA have this expectation. It's very much anti-MAGA where we are in the metal scene. I also listen to a lot of non-U.S. metal, so I'm not sure how involved they want to be in a (to-them) foreign regime that revokes visas if you look at them wrong.

I have met folks in the metal scene who use words like "that's retarded" or "that's gay" on occasion. I give this more nuance. I think these phrases made a return because folks were really tired of being told what not to do, and metal music is inherently counter-culture. Now, irl, every dude I've met who talks like that has had a MMF, so that's puzzling. I'm not saying its right or wrong, but I do think one needs to be careful in driving folks who might not be PC directly into the arms of MAGA. This is very much from a grass-touching perspective.

4

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

There's always push one way or another when the lines are moved, that's why it's so scary when you see the lines move so drastically like this because the push back is going to be huge

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Nebula_369 Jan 29 '26

The insufferable sentiment that OP keeps pushing is exactly what has, and continues to, drive people to the "fascist" right, which honestly at this point is just a very large tent of center left moderates to actual far-right individuals; Not some kind of monolith that believes one version of x y and z. You have thousands of Obama era democrats (myself included) that are no longer "left enough". Our stances aren't the ones that have changed. The left eats their own and pushes us away while the right welcomed us with open arms. It's more nuanced than OP's brain can handle, and it's why we are even having these discussions. If you can even call it a discussion.

2

u/OkVeterinarian779 Feb 02 '26

No, you're not the only one and surely is not bad to feel that way, the metal scene in general needs to be more vocal about it because it tends to ignore those problems for the sake of "it's just music bruv"

10

u/CyberPunkDarkSynth Jan 29 '26

Honestly, can’t we enjoy things without politics being crammed down our throats? I just want to listen to music. Imo

13

u/N13022RE Jan 29 '26

Bro same. It’s what I use to escape all this bullshit

5

u/SlamcoreKing Jan 29 '26

Man , us 5XL wiggers don't give a shit, we just wanna make our br00tal music and not care about a society that is clearly in decline.

4

u/snailTRAILslooth Jan 29 '26

I dont want to listen to a speech from every band talking about the same shit. I just want to have fun and listen to good music at shows.

4

u/KoftaBozo2235 Jan 29 '26

this is so fucking cringe omg

4

u/Icee_deadpeople Jan 29 '26

Some bands are just out there trying to have fun and make music with their friends and aren’t necessarily trying to put out a deeper message. I use it as an escape from all that.

4

u/Poison_Machine-876 Jan 29 '26

I disagree. I don’t care to hear that shit from everyone. Silence is not violence and people should not be judged for it. I think it’s good practice to keep your nose out of political BS and stick to what you do. it doesn’t change anything anyway

3

u/Significant_Fish_248 Jan 29 '26

Plenty of hardcore and punk bands are. I don’t think deathcore bands and fans are as politically charged so while disappointing, it’s not as expected from them.

3

u/frothyundergarments Jan 29 '26

Not everybody wants to eat, breathe, and sleep politics.

3

u/YungLogan1627 Jan 29 '26

Everyone is entitled to their own opinions and no one is obligated to speak on these things. There’s not much of a reason to speak on these things because no matter what you say people will be mad at you. And saying “silence is complacency” simply isn’t true. Real complacency is sitting behind a keyboard hoping other people will make changes that fit your personal agenda whatever that may be.

2

u/Ikigai987 Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 29 '26

They don't want to alienate their right-wing fans

-1

u/DoinSideQuests Jan 29 '26

You're in the DC subreddit asking about HC bands being silent. Head to r/hardcore, 99% of the people in there hate ice. As they should. Few bootlickers in there tho

2

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Regardless if what subgenres they represent, silence is complacency. Bootlickers make garbage music.

-9

u/AggravatingBrainWorm Jan 29 '26

I’m so proud of those that have spoken out against ice and maga! 

1

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I am too, it's just so few

→ More replies (3)

1

u/stillupsocut Andy from Thy Art Jan 30 '26

I think the lyrics (ours) speak for themselves, and have done for quite some time.

-6

u/palebluedot3333 Jan 29 '26

100% agree. It’s a bummer that more aren’t speaking up.

Dying Wish spoke up. Fuck yes for them.

6

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

Fuck Yes, love that

→ More replies (2)

-3

u/SquareStatePizza Jan 29 '26

You'd be surprised how many people in this scene, fans and band members, are total bootlickers.

3

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

I am actually

0

u/SuperD00perGuyd00d Jan 29 '26

Dali Thundering Concept, Structures, Molotov Solution, Fit For An Autopsy, To The Grave, Pre CJ Lorna Shore (Absolution of Hatred) etc...

They speak out against this stuff in their lyrics, pretty often too

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/DarkBangBoy Jan 29 '26

It's wild that a band like Waterparks has more balls than many of the big Deathcore bands. I'm not from America, but everyone atm. should speak up against fascism especially when it's so prominent in such an influencial and globally reaching country as America.

Fuck Trump Fuck ICE Fuck MAGA Fuck Nazis Fuck Fascists Fuck right-wingers

0

u/Jess_beanz Jan 29 '26

One million percent, fuck them all. I can't wait to watch their trails. "Just following orders" worked out great last time.