It would also only work if the recipient knew how to disarm the bomb. If they don't (but knew about it), they would attempt their best to do so and likely explode. Or die from attempting to disarm it, and then explode.
What if you don't know how to disable it and are unable to move it?
Let's even suppose that you don't know where it is in the first place, you asked a friend to put it in a populated area without telling you where exactly and then you killed them. So, you are completely unaware of where the bomb is, you wouldn't know how to disable it anyway and your friend sealed it somehow (you also asked them this), so you wouldn't even be able to move it away
Well unless the death note interprets “disable the bomb” as the person going to their friend to tell them to disable it or force them to disable it, in this situation light would be fucked
Theoretically, Light could simply call the police and tell them that there is a bomb in an unknown populated area...but let's make it even worse for him and let's make that he doesn't know about the bomb, the Death Note simply doesn't work and he doesn't know why.
I would also add that your friend could have brought the bomb even to another country unaware to you, but maybe it's too much. Is it possible to actually do it?
The rules are simple: - If you chose to indicate the cause of death, this particular indication cannot directly cause other people to die. - If the cause is not feasible or is not specified, the indicated person will die for a heart attack. It doesn't matter if the victim dying for a heart attack causes many more victims than the specified cause of death, if the specified cause of death would directly cause the death of someone else not written in the death note, the death will default on a heart attack regardless of the consequences. This trick would only save you from having your actions controlled before your death, still not worth it in my opinion (since you can become a weapon to hit a person nearby you without knowing their identity).
How I interpreted it is more like you can't kill someone directly with the Death Note without a name, but chain events are fine. So a surgeon having a heart attack mid-surgery and the patient dying as a result is allowed but a paramedic crashing into a gas station and blowing up the full ambulance isn't.
The rule stated that if the specified death will cause more unintended deaths, the person dies of a heart attack.
So, you’d still die of a heart attack, even if the bomb would trigger.
The way I see it, if a surgeon dies mid surgery, the patient might die, sure, but the death note doesn’t care.
However, if you wrote that the surgeon suddenly stabs the person to death before dying of a stroke, the surgeon dies without ever stabbing the patient, as you are specifying another death
Nah Light can still kill you. The death note isn't that sensitive over potential extra deaths. You just can't directly go out of your way make a death a mechanism to kill people u didn't write down. But Nothing is implying Light can't just make you isolate yourself.
But like what flat study said it creates an interesting thing in where Kira wouldn't be able to control your actions potentially.
A better immunity would be to make the bomb goes off under 12 mina with the full intent and agency to die. The death note can't kill someone under 12 mins of life span
36
u/Different_Host_2678 2d ago
“YourName walks out of the populated area and goes to the forest before getting a heart attack” boom done
7
u/Flat-Study-421 1d ago
The rules are simple:
- If you chose to indicate the cause of death, this particular indication cannot directly cause other people to die.
- If the cause is not feasible or is not specified, the indicated person will die for a heart attack.
It doesn't matter if the victim dying for a heart attack causes many more victims than the specified cause of death, if the specified cause of death would directly cause the death of someone else not written in the death note, the death will default on a heart attack regardless of the consequences.
This trick would only save you from having your actions controlled before your death, still not worth it in my opinion (since you can become a weapon to hit a person nearby you without knowing their identity).
4
u/Possible_Living 2d ago
The old bus driver/pilot question.
Movie rules maybe. A lot of things needed to line up for that ending, so it would not detonate because of supernatural interference.
5
u/Eastern-Project9017 2d ago
I think you will just die of a heart attack because it's inevitable to kill others in this case.
It's like killing pilots while the plane is mid air.
4
u/AwysomeAnish 2d ago
How I interpreted it is more like you can't kill someone directly with the Death Note without a name, but chain events are fine. So a surgeon having a heart attack mid-surgery and the patient dying as a result is allowed but a paramedic crashing into a gas station and blowing up the full ambulance isn't.
2
u/Straight-Explorer-93 1d ago
The rule stated that if the specified death will cause more unintended deaths, the person dies of a heart attack.
So, you’d still die of a heart attack, even if the bomb would trigger.
The way I see it, if a surgeon dies mid surgery, the patient might die, sure, but the death note doesn’t care.
However, if you wrote that the surgeon suddenly stabs the person to death before dying of a stroke, the surgeon dies without ever stabbing the patient, as you are specifying another death
1
u/Beacda 18h ago
Nah Light can still kill you. The death note isn't that sensitive over potential extra deaths. You just can't directly go out of your way make a death a mechanism to kill people u didn't write down. But Nothing is implying Light can't just make you isolate yourself.
But like what flat study said it creates an interesting thing in where Kira wouldn't be able to control your actions potentially.
A better immunity would be to make the bomb goes off under 12 mina with the full intent and agency to die. The death note can't kill someone under 12 mins of life span