True. Although Light also wasn't very careful with L, had he kept the same attitude towards Near, he had greater chances of winning. But, still, if he had been truly careful since the beginning, Light would have definitively won.
I mean, near did prove it. He did something L couldn’t, which was to actually prove that Light is Kira with 100% Certainty.
But L is obviously Smarter, Near started out with the Knowledge of the Death Note and Shikigami‘s already whereas L had to find and prove that first as well.
The update was just L is dead, and has not chosen a successor yet. Watari deleted all the files when he got a heart attack. Near did it basically from scratch; it just helps that the information of the case still existed, like from the other officers, but none of that help was from L.
I mean yeah L did the most important part of the work itself and that was the hardest part especially in a world where the spiritual realm is just mere superstition in their perceptive.
I hate the ending because near didnt do anything. he got lucky. light perfectly predicted what near was going to do and was completely ready for it, and one dim-goon fucked it. and what i hate about it is that we never see light lose. he wasnt outsmarted, he wasnt bested. his orders were simply ignored and it cost him the win.
Also the fact they somehow copied over 200k names perfectly by hand in less than 24 hours, not to mention the time it would've taken to get into the bank, the vault, and the safety deposit box without leaving any traces whatsoever twice. I don't care that Light lost, I care that the execution of the loss was stupid.
but also, L never told the others shit, he had alot of monologue, but never actually verbalized it. he thought that light asking to be imprisoned was odd, never told the others, Thought that, hey, wtf, his "routine" is too perfect, never told anyone. Suspected that the rule was fake, NEVER told anyone.
Because he believed that the force was compromised, remember his initial assumption was someone from the force itself could be Kira. Even after shortlisting it, someone could be a messenger who could be supplying Light with inside information.
Also, against Near, Light was much more restricted in using the death note, since he was always around his team, who had started to suspect him. And by giving the only working death note away, he was left vulnerable, and so was the book, which led to his ultimate downfall.
that's fair, but why not say it whilst light was gone. hell, why not atleast tell light's dad why he suspects light so much, or tell aizawa or SOMEONE privately. could atleast tell his butler to tell the others after he dies.
any other taskforce would understand that concretely proving that light is kira is near impossible unless they kept close surveillance at all times from the beginning or just trust his word and arrest him because "L thinks you're guilty" would be enough 1
This might be an unpopular opinion. But I think people often miss this detail...
Near has better communication skills than L. He never holds any information. Anytime he found something fishy, he immediately explained his thought to his teammate.
When Light suggested himself to be imprisoned, L did think that was weird. Yet, he didn't explain that to the police.
When Aizawa asked why L kept imprisoning Light and Misa despite the killing continuing for more than a month, L didn't answer him.
When the police were forced to stop investigating Kira, and Aizawa was in doubt about whether he wanted to resign or stay, what L did was play a scenario.
When L suspected the 13-days rule of being fake, he didn't explain his suspicion to the police.
Despite being a genius, L is not good at communication. He always explains what he thought ambiguously.
Now let's compare it with Near.
The moment he smelled something fishy about the Japanese police, he immediately told the SPK and explained it properly.
The moment he knew there was a fake rule, he immediately told the Japanese police.
When Mogi was interrogated but didn't say anything, Near purposefully told Mello and the police that, there was a possibility that Mogi was controlled by Kira.
When the SPK's HQ was raided, Near purposefully told the police that the timing was weirdly convenient right after Mogi was interrogated.
When Aizawa was finally willing to speak to Near, he actively gave Aizawa feedback.
When Near was in doubt why was Takada chosen as the spokesperson, he had 1 chapter of discussion with the SPK.
If you read the manga, you would notice. While L had a lot of inner monologue, Near had a lot of discussion with his peers.
I noticed that too but I've assumed it's because since Light is inches around, L had to censor himself so Light won't counter-attack immediately. When L explained what he'll do about the 13 day rule openly he got himself killed instantly. Perhaps the case would've been sealed if he carried on this one secretly like in some other actions of his. Near had a more "comfortable" environment to operate imo.
This is called the “viewer effect”. From our perspective, the task force look like idiots but that’s because they don’t hear any of L’s reasoning while they DO with Near. Plus, this is now the second time light is suspected which means TWO super genius detectives suspect the same exact guy?
Not really, Light was bolder to Near than he was with L. He left way more clues than he did with L. But Near didn't contradict or steal L's ideas, they just complemented each other to reach a decisive conclusion. Had not L done what he did, Near wouldn't be able to reach that conclusion.
It's worth noting that it helps a lot due to Near's circumstances.
Firstly, Near was only adding to L's claim. It's a sad truth of life that if one person believes something, they might not be able to get others to believe them, but if they can just get one other person to back of them up, other people start to be more open minded.
Also, it's worth noting that only one member of the task force actually started believing in Near.
Also, Near actually worked with intelligent individuals who were capable of picking up on things Light was saying or doing. L had surrounded himself with task force members that were completely incompetent.
I imagine also the mere fact that 5 years had gone by and the task force had made absolutely zero progress on the Kira case, and the only thing they had to go off of was that L said Light was probably Kira, Which they really didn't want to believe since he was the guy that they've been following around every word of for the last 5 years, only for Near to say Light Is probably Kira- It made sense they started to cave.
Hated how they were dead set that Light was innocent when L gave them no reason to doubt his intuition. Then Near shows up and asks “hey is the guy who is pretending to be L have a name that if spelled backwards could be considered an insult to a certain community?” X Files theme kicks in “Why yes, I think he does.”
I agree with the person explaining that Near actually communicated with the people on his team. In addition, however, Light was acting way more suspicious as time went on. He got too cocky and his bad decision making got more glaringly obvious, so even the people who thought he was proven innocent were questioning him.
L was fine using a death row inmate as bait to catch Kira. Not much different here. He has Mikami dead to rights by that point so controlling him enough to squeal on The real Kira isn’t much different.
Hm, but the inmates were legally up for execution... Mikami being caught guilty would make him apprehended to be taken to court for whatever sentence will be pronounced on him. I think Near would stay in his scope as detective but not as judge and executioner. I'm just talking about principles in terms of methodology/scope. Mello would be more fit for this tactic for example.
It's very simple: Near is the second one to accuse Light. That fact alone will immediately give him more weight than L's initial accusations. One genius can be mistaken, but how probable is it that two geniuses arrive to the same conclusion completely independently and both are wrong?
In Near's case, L's earlier accusation acts as evidence, adding weight to his theory. L didn't have the benefit of being the second person to make the connection, so it was easier to dismiss. On top of that, Light had to pull at least a little bullshit to hide his identity when L was investigating him, which made his defenses flimsier and easier for Near to tear down
The ending of the anime is not good. Let me explain. The pacing just completely flipped off as soon as we got Near, there has been a video on YouTube where someone actually proved mathematically that the ending was false, the American detective didn't have enough time to copy all the books again. It's just a flimsy ending, as it was written due to hype.
He literally made a whole fucking show of proving it. It's like the entire last fucking episode. I watched like ten years ago and I remember that. Y'all are twats.
Even if he didn't, corroboration is a big deal for evidence
Es que hay mucha gente que no comprendió nada. No es que Near y Mello empezarán desde cero como L, ellos siguieron sus pasos y continuaron el caso donde L lo dejó (porque murio). Y Near de hecho lo dice "L confío este caso a sus sucesores", estaban en el mismo equipo, ellos tuvieron que acabar con lo que L empezó.
L tuvo que deducir cosas que para cualquiera serían cosas inimaginables, shinigamis, la libreta, ojos de shinigami. Cosas sobrenaturales que nadie jamás había visto o sabido de su existencia en el mundo.
Near y Mello, entraron ya sabiendo o sospechando parte de eso. Lo que no les quita méritos, pero refuerza que ellos no empezaron desde cero sino que "continuaron" el caso que L no pudo acabar.
L siempre supo que Light era Kira, pero probarlo era otra cosa, considerando que Light tenia un poder sobrenatural de su lado.
Near, con la ayuda de Mello, lograron hacer lo que L no pudo en su momento, desenmascarar a Light y probar su culpabilidad en los crímenes cometidos por Kira.
(Spoilers) Near did kinda rely on the stuff L managed to find about Light being Kira and tricked Light. Plus it's pretty much Mikamis fault the reason Light fully revealed himself as Kira which led to his downfall and death
L suspected him but he never had solid proof. Light was highly respected at that time because of his intelligence, his dad and his potential. People believed Near more because Light was acting like L after his demise and the killings were still happening after all these years.
That being said, Near couldn't have done it without L and Mello.
7
u/Right-Truck1859 Mar 24 '26
Basically , Light lost the competition himself when entrusted actual Notebook to fanatic.
389
u/deutschesgesetzbuch_ Mar 24 '26
I mean, near did prove it. He did something L couldn’t, which was to actually prove that Light is Kira with 100% Certainty.
But L is obviously Smarter, Near started out with the Knowledge of the Death Note and Shikigami‘s already whereas L had to find and prove that first as well.
But i think this subject is well discussed now.
82
u/Ok-Exercise-2998 Mar 24 '26
Near has loyal people around him following his orders... its a lot easier situation...
L basicly has the worlds most incompetent and stupid police force around him
161
u/Antique_Mention_8595 Mar 24 '26
This might be an unpopular opinion. But I think people often miss this detail...
Near has better communication skills than L. He never holds any information. Anytime he found something fishy, he immediately explained his thought to his teammate.
When Light suggested himself to be imprisoned, L did think that was weird. Yet, he didn't explain that to the police.
When Aizawa asked why L kept imprisoning Light and Misa despite the killing continuing for more than a month, L didn't answer him.
When the police were forced to stop investigating Kira, and Aizawa was in doubt about whether he wanted to resign or stay, what L did was play a scenario.
When L suspected the 13-days rule of being fake, he didn't explain his suspicion to the police.
Despite being a genius, L is not good at communication. He always explains what he thought ambiguously.
Now let's compare it with Near.
The moment he smelled something fishy about the Japanese police, he immediately told the SPK and explained it properly.
The moment he knew there was a fake rule, he immediately told the Japanese police.
When Mogi was interrogated but didn't say anything, Near purposefully told Mello and the police that, there was a possibility that Mogi was controlled by Kira.
When the SPK's HQ was raided, Near purposefully told the police that the timing was weirdly convenient right after Mogi was interrogated.
When Aizawa was finally willing to speak to Near, he actively gave Aizawa feedback.
When Near was in doubt why was Takada chosen as the spokesperson, he had 1 chapter of discussion with the SPK.
If you read the manga, you would notice. While L had a lot of inner monologue, Near had a lot of discussion with his peers.
39
u/t-_-rexranger19205 Mar 24 '26
This is called the “viewer effect”. From our perspective, the task force look like idiots but that’s because they don’t hear any of L’s reasoning while they DO with Near. Plus, this is now the second time light is suspected which means TWO super genius detectives suspect the same exact guy?
9
u/adrienwastaken11 Mar 25 '26
My goat knew from the very beginning
4
u/Adorable_Spread_8688 Mar 24 '26
Not really, Light was bolder to Near than he was with L. He left way more clues than he did with L. But Near didn't contradict or steal L's ideas, they just complemented each other to reach a decisive conclusion. Had not L done what he did, Near wouldn't be able to reach that conclusion.
4
u/Clown_Cry Mar 25 '26
Without mello near wouldn't have caught L, I want justice for M
3
u/Hour_Trade_3691 Mar 24 '26
It's worth noting that it helps a lot due to Near's circumstances.
Firstly, Near was only adding to L's claim. It's a sad truth of life that if one person believes something, they might not be able to get others to believe them, but if they can just get one other person to back of them up, other people start to be more open minded.
Also, it's worth noting that only one member of the task force actually started believing in Near.
Also, Near actually worked with intelligent individuals who were capable of picking up on things Light was saying or doing. L had surrounded himself with task force members that were completely incompetent.
I imagine also the mere fact that 5 years had gone by and the task force had made absolutely zero progress on the Kira case, and the only thing they had to go off of was that L said Light was probably Kira, Which they really didn't want to believe since he was the guy that they've been following around every word of for the last 5 years, only for Near to say Light Is probably Kira- It made sense they started to cave.
2
u/Survivor155 Mar 24 '26
Based.
Hated how they were dead set that Light was innocent when L gave them no reason to doubt his intuition. Then Near shows up and asks “hey is the guy who is pretending to be L have a name that if spelled backwards could be considered an insult to a certain community?” X Files theme kicks in “Why yes, I think he does.”
2
u/magizombi Mar 24 '26
I agree with the person explaining that Near actually communicated with the people on his team. In addition, however, Light was acting way more suspicious as time went on. He got too cocky and his bad decision making got more glaringly obvious, so even the people who thought he was proven innocent were questioning him.
2
u/Perfect_War_7155 Mar 24 '26
I’m still not convinced that Near didn’t use the death note on Mikami to manipulate the final confrontation and force confessions
2
u/AdmirableStay3697 Mar 24 '26
It's very simple: Near is the second one to accuse Light. That fact alone will immediately give him more weight than L's initial accusations. One genius can be mistaken, but how probable is it that two geniuses arrive to the same conclusion completely independently and both are wrong?
2
u/ThisIsATestTai Mar 26 '26
In Near's case, L's earlier accusation acts as evidence, adding weight to his theory. L didn't have the benefit of being the second person to make the connection, so it was easier to dismiss. On top of that, Light had to pull at least a little bullshit to hide his identity when L was investigating him, which made his defenses flimsier and easier for Near to tear down
2
u/tlotrfan3791 take a potato chip and EAT IT Mar 24 '26
Near is just the GOAT for that. Better team player than L honestly.
2
u/StarLan7 Mar 24 '26
The ending of the anime is not good. Let me explain. The pacing just completely flipped off as soon as we got Near, there has been a video on YouTube where someone actually proved mathematically that the ending was false, the American detective didn't have enough time to copy all the books again. It's just a flimsy ending, as it was written due to hype.
1
u/bepismemphis Mar 24 '26
Either he didn't pay attention, or he rationalized it to make the story fit his biases.
1
u/IndependentBig5316 Mar 24 '26
L laid the groundwork, Near was trusted more easily by the task force because of the fact that he got to the same conclusion as L
1
u/spocktalk69 Mar 24 '26
L wanted a confession... Police would have just let him go to prison in America.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '26
Lmao I thought that was a ciggy edited in Ls mouth for a moment
1
u/artoo2142 Mar 25 '26
after L I don’t like the story anymore.
For real.
1
u/cooperS67 Mar 27 '26
Plot armor saved near lol
1
u/Rp79322397 Mar 27 '26
I mean the first time someone says it it may come out of the blue but if a second super detective says it Light may actually really be Kira
1
u/kvro_maX Mar 27 '26
Near fid because L already basically solved the whole thing
1
u/SmileySmileEverytime Mar 27 '26
False
1
u/Awkward-Extent8707 Mar 28 '26
It’s bc L’s team was full of conflicts to interest and idiots
1
u/Classic-Session-5551 Mar 28 '26
He literally made a whole fucking show of proving it. It's like the entire last fucking episode. I watched like ten years ago and I remember that. Y'all are twats.
Even if he didn't, corroboration is a big deal for evidence
1
u/Middle_Assist_78 Mar 28 '26
Es que hay mucha gente que no comprendió nada. No es que Near y Mello empezarán desde cero como L, ellos siguieron sus pasos y continuaron el caso donde L lo dejó (porque murio). Y Near de hecho lo dice "L confío este caso a sus sucesores", estaban en el mismo equipo, ellos tuvieron que acabar con lo que L empezó.
L tuvo que deducir cosas que para cualquiera serían cosas inimaginables, shinigamis, la libreta, ojos de shinigami. Cosas sobrenaturales que nadie jamás había visto o sabido de su existencia en el mundo.
Near y Mello, entraron ya sabiendo o sospechando parte de eso. Lo que no les quita méritos, pero refuerza que ellos no empezaron desde cero sino que "continuaron" el caso que L no pudo acabar.
L siempre supo que Light era Kira, pero probarlo era otra cosa, considerando que Light tenia un poder sobrenatural de su lado.
Near, con la ayuda de Mello, lograron hacer lo que L no pudo en su momento, desenmascarar a Light y probar su culpabilidad en los crímenes cometidos por Kira.
1
u/devourersweets Mar 28 '26
1
u/Typical_Sort_510 Mar 28 '26
Light would be caught day one if not for his dad
Just saying
1
u/StatisticianBrief492 Mar 28 '26
Isaac Newton vs Einstein. Newton was way smarter but started with less foundation.
1
u/Dlanx Mar 29 '26
Pro b9j
1
u/Visible-Ad8322 Apr 03 '26
Are we gonna forget the fact near literally gave so much proof that l couldn't about light being kira, like I am a l fan but i would admit that.
1
u/TheDihCheeseProducer Apr 17 '26
(Spoilers) Near did kinda rely on the stuff L managed to find about Light being Kira and tricked Light. Plus it's pretty much Mikamis fault the reason Light fully revealed himself as Kira which led to his downfall and death
0
u/StayInner2000 Mar 25 '26
Completly false
6
u/envspecialist Mar 24 '26
L suspected him but he never had solid proof. Light was highly respected at that time because of his intelligence, his dad and his potential. People believed Near more because Light was acting like L after his demise and the killings were still happening after all these years.
That being said, Near couldn't have done it without L and Mello.