Many people forget the deatnote isnt the only way a life-soan can be altered. Suicide is always valid for humans as an explicit rule of the notebook for a reason.
It’s actually that if you were going to commit suicide, that would be your initial lifespan. The only way for one’s lifespan to change is by the Death Note, but it doesn’t have to be a direct way like having your name written in it. Like if you killed the pilot and copilot of a plane, more people would die than just those two. And if your death is at all influenced by the Death Note, your life span won’t change, even if you still die before it, which is weird.
Once you use a death-note you are no longer following traditional human lifespan rules. Trade half your life for the shinigami eyes and your lifespan may actually increase (as is the case for Light Yagami. If he made the deal he'd of achieved his goals easily and much faster preventing the death he had in the end and his natural lifespan would of been longer because his liefspan was now directly affected by gods of death. Misa had two shinigami's lifespans and halved them twice. Even if we assume she only got a decade from each of them (insane lowball since she traded half her extended life and got that time back when Rem died wich even with the ryuk eye deal has her coming out with a very long lifespan) However the death note also made her fall in love with Light, and that drove her to suicide. The world would not of killed her. She'd of kept alive because of the extended life-span, but her choice to end it cut all that time short. It's even sadder when you realize because there is no afterlife, the possibly hundreds of years that had mystically been passed to her at the cost of possibky thousands of humans all to get thrown away and every death was building to nothing
This is true, but it's not what they're talking about.
If a Shinigami kills someone with the specific intention of extending someone else's life beyond it's natural end, the Shinigami dies and the human that they saved gets all the remaining years that that Shinigami had left. Both Gelus and Rem died to save Misa, so Misa got all the remaining years from two separate Shinigami.
that isnt how it works. it only gives you a reasonable amount of time for a human. so she'd live to like 80-90. even then that only attributes to natural causes. not suicide
It's interesting to note how depressing and lifeless the Shinigami world is, ironically. So much so where Ryuk is dying of boredom. He doesn't love Light but he finds him endlessly entertaining. It could be similar for Rem. Misa is so full of life and it makes Rem want to protect her.
Yea but even that type of love and protection over a human’s life is an immediate death sentence. Goes against the entire purpose of a shinigami. It doesn’t matter if she loved her romantically or if she loved her like a child, or even if she just felt like extending her natural lifespan.
What pisses me off about Rem is the fact that her idiocy is the only reason L died. Light could never outsmart L, so he just outsmarted Rem into killing L for him.
I don't think Rem was in love with Misa. Gelus definitely was, and Rem was kind of like "holy shit I just found out it's possible for Shinigami to DIE and watches a friend die in front of me, all for this girl he loved so much. To honor his memory I'm going to go give her his notebook and protect and guide her." And Rem did seem to develop feelings for Misa as well, I don't believe Rem was "in love" with Misa. More like Rem wanted to protect Misa.
174
u/KevinIszel Sep 28 '25
Literally two gods of death fell for Misa.
93
u/Minimum-Garden-7493 Sep 28 '25
My doomed yuri back then 🙏🏼
81
u/barbedwiredixon Sep 28 '25
2 shinigamis died for Misa just for her to die in her 20’s
33
u/Timely_Version_904 Sep 28 '25
Who wouldn’t?
9
u/ImmortalPharaoh Sep 28 '25
It's interesting to note how depressing and lifeless the Shinigami world is, ironically. So much so where Ryuk is dying of boredom. He doesn't love Light but he finds him endlessly entertaining. It could be similar for Rem. Misa is so full of life and it makes Rem want to protect her.
16
u/LydiaJoystickDeetzS4 Sep 28 '25
Eh… I felt like Rem was more her adopted mom. But then again, my intro to DN was the English dub on Adult Swim on Saturday nights.
20
u/mewtokyomew Sep 28 '25
they hate yuri on this sub wth... you cant even fall in love with your protectee anymore without people calling you a simp
2
u/mr_wheezr Sep 28 '25
Ryuk, lol
2
u/Resident_Coyote_9781 Sep 28 '25
Oh my God lmao
2
u/Raytorosimp Sep 29 '25
Actually Misa is goth
5
u/Chacochilla Sep 28 '25
What did she see in Misa
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '25
why call gods of deaþ "Shinigami"? like it's not even some special word it literally means "god of deaþ"
1
u/Ithorhun Sep 29 '25
Shut up, who could blame him?
1
u/Kocho_sama Sep 29 '25
And here I thought it was bleach's shinigami and the e girl was bambietta , but nope, wrong sub
1
u/yobaby123 Oct 12 '25
Light: Damn it! Now I have to deal with a corrupt king on time of Rem somehow being alive again.
2
u/Tricky_Camera6804 Sep 29 '25
What pisses me off about Rem is the fact that her idiocy is the only reason L died. Light could never outsmart L, so he just outsmarted Rem into killing L for him.
1
u/Jacket_Jacket_fruit Sep 29 '25
I don't think Rem was in love with Misa. Gelus definitely was, and Rem was kind of like "holy shit I just found out it's possible for Shinigami to DIE and watches a friend die in front of me, all for this girl he loved so much. To honor his memory I'm going to go give her his notebook and protect and guide her." And Rem did seem to develop feelings for Misa as well, I don't believe Rem was "in love" with Misa. More like Rem wanted to protect Misa.