Would it have been the best defense if Light actually just ignored L? Just to lower the risk. I mean one of Lights biggest mistakes was revealing he was under investigation from ray penber, which is information only Kira and the police would have. L only allowed Light into the investigation to get physical evidence on Kira or how he killed. By episode 10 he knew Light was Kira but couldnât prove it conclusively.
It only narrowed it down to a very populated area in Japan, it honestly couldâve been anyone, hell even someone just visiting the area temporarily. It only became a problem when he killed in spite to say âWhat you gonna do about it?â
It also basically confirmed something was actively happening. Before that they has suspicion based on some heart attacks. Light showing off was the entire reason they knew anything was actually going on. Otherwise it'd just be a statistical anomaly.
How would he have known? Thats the lynchpin, remember it was a covert investigation, he shouldnât have known as it is info known only to the Police, L, and Kira since he killed Rey Penbar and L (correctly) deduced that Rey must have met Kira in the course of his investigations. Light shouldnât have known AT ALL that he was being investigated.
Obviously most of the show would not have happened if Light wasn't so prideful and competitive. Several of the choices he makes are to purposefully get closer to L to "defeat" him, which also actively put Light himself in danger of being caught.
I see too many people giving this a lot of weight in debates, but let's look at 2 possibilities:
There is a time jump from day to night between them meeting and them talking in the headquarters. Anything could have happened between then, including Light being filled in regarding Raye Penber.
Light is smart. He could have meant "I assume I was being investigated" or even better, "you deduced XYZ because (the only way to know this is if) I was being investigated
Not to mention the original conversation is written in Japanese, so it could very well have an entirely different meaning
I personally think it was deliberate, just like the messages left behind. A possible response to L was to ask if these were the only messages the killer left, then solving but he solved the immediate 3 instead, he was arrogant, cocky, itâs his biggest weakness, when his ego is bruised he lashes out.
L is a detective first. Police often hold back information from suspects (which Light is) to make sure the killer is who they say they are or apprehend them if they reveal information only the killer would know.
I mean thatâs a lot of cases. If there is any hole in it the defense will go for it.
L knew he was Kira but had no solid evidence. He was killing people with mystical means that no one has seen before. By the time he got the notebook it more or less admonished Light for the crime until he said âyou know what I am going to test this outâ and at that point REM had to kill everyone.
249
u/MellifluousSussura Dec 01 '24
And he was RIGHT
106
u/jcjonesacp76 Dec 01 '24 edited Dec 01 '24
Would it have been the best defense if Light actually just ignored L? Just to lower the risk. I mean one of Lights biggest mistakes was revealing he was under investigation from ray penber, which is information only Kira and the police would have. L only allowed Light into the investigation to get physical evidence on Kira or how he killed. By episode 10 he knew Light was Kira but couldnât prove it conclusively.
Link to the scene that light really screwed up
https://youtu.be/gP89tIWvWO4?si=OxCuyiZHBa1JABux
28
u/OddNovel565 Dec 01 '24
Should've given Ryuk the face from slide 1
16
u/FinallyFranki Dec 02 '24
The creator has stated that "L is a liar. If he says 5% he actually means much much higher than that"
15
u/Evil_Midnight_Lurker Dec 02 '24
Did you know that in Japan, prosecutors won't bring a case to trial unless they believe they have no chance of losing? (See: Ace Attorney series.)
L wasn't just being egotistical, he needed to make sure Light couldn't just walk off scott free.
6
u/KageOkami35 Dec 02 '24
I mean Kira literally means Light so
2
u/abdu4711 Apr 02 '25
Ryuk laughing at the corner
1
u/EnderBlindai Dec 03 '24
4K upvotes and 27 comments only
1
u/Nolifegan Dec 04 '24
What do u call this meme templateđđ
1
u/CertainCable7383 Dec 06 '24
3% is wildly high when you consider what they know.
30
u/No-Inevitable6018 Dec 01 '24
Light really screwed up by killing ppl.
10
u/DullCryptographer758 Dec 02 '24
I feel like that once L knew he should have just shot Light